High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1384/2018dismissed

M/S Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd v. Surjit Singh And ORS

2018-09-11Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh11 pages

!"#$ % $ $ &''())* +

),& '&-.',/ -0- &))/)&' 100'..

& 2'-, 3,-4)&3)56 &6'- 1 '0'&

),& '&-.',/ -0- &))/)&' 100'..

& 2'-, 768)-3)56 &6'- 1 '0'& * 9# "3

: 3 ;

!"3

9# "3

;"$

# $# %& '& %'()*+ # ,# - - *+

- * -

/ *

%1 '2 (332 4 "

/ ()3455 #(6

47 %

8 , - # * / 97 : # * *+;

;

" - .

+ / < 2 - (& - * & ( (33& <#+ - 7

)'=

/ > (2 - *+ *

/ *8 #

/ , ( (333

7 / %&

- + *

* -

- ## *+ *+ # () * (& '( %''6

## *+ - -

*+ ?@ (2&1'

(333

6 (333 + *

*+ (2

9 +

- *

- @ A9 7 ;- +

*+ #,# $# 2 %''2 /

- -

(3 %''2 + (& (( %'(1

*+ #

*+ *

9 - 7 * # * 8 B

/ ,

* 64 - #

- + <=-)&)&6'

&,-'/ /,)-'(&)5-'0'& &5- &)&'-'& && . /,& (/0' &) ))&) . (/0' &) = 0 ) +++)&'

+++&6' &' = - -5- & )&'-'& &&6'- &' >?0'- ,/) ((- ('=)&6 = -&6'

&& . (/0' &) - &6' 0'-) &6' = - &' +++ '@,-' A B'C ( 0'- (-' = & C' ) D E> +++ ).' BC -'0'& +++ &).. )& -'

.)F &)G ;-

- # )'=

1 (33& */+ ( (333*+

> %& - (2 (( (333 <&6' ='-)5 -'0'& 6 6='8'-(6 ..'5''&'-/) &)(/0' &)BC&6' ..'(&- & &6'- &' E.

(0'- (-'BC).)5 D E> +++ 8)'

-'- &' +++; $)8))#'(6&6)HB.' ,-&= 0.'

'&&)('&6' (&&6 &'&)-' = -' /,&(/0' &) & '0)&' =)&6 &6' (I,))&) ..'(&- ='8'-;

)B,-'/'&(/0' &)B'C&6'- &' .

(0'- (-'

= & C'=)&6 ,-&6'-)-'(&)&6 &&6' /,&'0)&'BC&6'

='-)5-'0'&6 ..B'0,&) A0'- &)8' ((,&=)&6

&) .)F'B 7 &'

-/ @)/,/- &')&'-'&&6 &&6'

-&C,'&)&.'&&6' /'( -'(8'-;&6' ) /,& 6 & '8'&6,56 D E> +++= )/)'BC&6)HB.'

,-&+J)/)' + ) ..C3K +>E)=6)(6))&) ..C& &,I,-'-= ' + E = ) ..C )/)' E > C'& ,(6 )&'-)/-'-0 'BC&6)HB.' ,-& BC&6'HB.'0'@

,-&.C'.

C'&6'-'.'

' /,& .-'

C'0)&'BC&6'

='-)5-'0'&)&6'C'

- +++)&'. 6,;&6'I,'&) (.

)/)5)&'-'&= &&6)& 5''& -)'G

/ - / *

*+ #,#- - #

6 (333

-- + * 9 7

* - *- #

+ # *+ - 64

#,# C6'),' & =6'&6'-&6' /,& =6)(6 = '0)&' BC &6'-'0'& A

-0- &) =)&6 &6' &) .)F' B 7 &6' / @)/,/ - &' )&'-'&&6 &0 -&C,'&)&.'&&6' /'(,.-'(8'-)&;)&B'

'()' )&-'0'& A -0- &) )&.C0-&'(&'&6'

)&'-'& -0- &)&6 &&6'C6 8'B'' 8'-/0 C)5&6',..

/,&(/0' &) .5=)&6& &,&-C)&'-'& &&6 &0)&

&)/'=6)(6)&=,.6 8'B''.) B.'&0 C,'-&6'3& &,&'6'

)&'-)/-'- &' +++=,.'(' -).C(/'& '&6'

=-)&0'&)&)= '()'+ &6'-'-';&6' -0- &) ( &6)'B'6)&6' )-'-&(&'&6 &&6'$)8))#'(6 0-&'(&')&)&'-'& )&)&.) B.'&0 C)&'-'&8'-

B8'&6' /,&&6'-'

&'-)('&6'C6 '0)&'&6' /,&=)&6 &6' &) .)F'B 7 '0'& A -0- &)(&),'&5'& &6'B'')&)&'-)/-'-&6'-'

&'-BC 00- (6)5&6'0'@ ,-& + E .=6'& &,I,-'-)&6'3= 0 ' &6'-'-';.

='-='-'')'&6'B'')&, 5'&6' /,& =6)(6&6' -0- &)6 '0)&'B,&&0 )&&6'0'&)&)'- @@@ @@@ @@@ 6' 0') 6 8)5 B'' & 7' > ++E; &6' ..'(&- 6 . -)56&.C 5- &' +?

)&'-'&-/&6')-&C'

- 0'-&6' = -)&'. &6'-'-';)&'-'& ,(6=,.(&),'&-, )&= &0 ) 0'-0-8))3'(&)

&6'(&G @@@ @@@ @@@ < ',.& &.C;),' )'()') 8,- &6'0'&)&)'-3)/).

-.C&6'),'0-)()0.'&6 &

(&&6' ,-&=,.6 -/ C0 -&C;&6'-'- &'

+++ = .C / &' &6 & &6' /,& = '0)&' &6'-)&))&6')&'-'&&6' -0- &) )&=,.5'&&6'B'')&&6' (&&6 &-/&6' &' '0)&&6' /,&&)..&6' &'0 C/'&;)&=)...C 8'&0 C&6')'-'('&6')&'-'& =,.B'

8'&6'6)56'-- &')&'-'& &6'-'-';)&( & B' )&6 &&6'-'- ,(6=,.0-&'(&&6'/&&6'

'@&'& &6 & &6'C -' & .) B.' & 0 C &6' )&'-'& & &,&-C- &'&)'&&.'0-)()0.'&6 & (& ,-& =,.6 -/ C.)&)5 & '.) ('( .B'0.

(',0 3,&6

&'- .)'.&23& &'

6 //'

F)23& &'

-&-/&6'('.'B- &'4,5/'&&6'0'@

,-&) :

- & -'

-&6 &6'-23')-

'.5)&;$'0 -&/'&)' '.5C &6'- 3,0-'/' ,-&

6'-'.'8 &0-&) -'

,'-*A < 3,&6

&'- .)'.&3,0- ;

&6) ,-&'

.&=)&6&6'''(&&6'-)56&&6'0 -&)' =66 8' (&'B )';0-&'(&'BC)&'-)/-'- &6' ,-& )(,--'-)56& B.)5 &)=6).'&6'

)&'-)/-'-&8 ( &'--'8'-' &&6''6'

,-&-''--'&&6'(&-)' (&,(,-) ''/)'/ 5B)& 6'.&6 &&6'(&-)'= &()'))&

00.)( &) .C & ,(6 (& &6' ,-& =6)(6 ='-'

'--',J&6'(&-)') 00.)( B.'& ..,(6 (& & =6)(6)& B'6'.&6 &&6' ,-&=,.&6 8' (&' )&B''(--'(&.C 00-)'&6' (& &6'.

=&) &6'0-)()0.'-'&)&,&)=6)(6) &&- (&'D6'

((,& (&&6'0 -&C;0'-, )5&6' ,-&&0

-'-;=6)(6 &&6'')6'. &,& ) B.';6

-',.&')'0 -&C5 ))5 8 & 5'=6)(6)&=,.& 8'&6'-=)''

-';-&6'&6'-0 -&C6 ,'-' )/08'-)6/'&=6)(6)&=,.&6 8','-'B,&- &6'-'-&6' ,-& &6' (&,(60 -&C;&6'&6'

,((',.0 -&C) ..C6'.'&)&.'& -'.)'; ' B.') &'-//'C &&6''&6'.)&)5 &);)'&)&.'&B'

(/0' &' ) &6' /' / '- ) =6)(6 &6' 0 -&)' =,.6 8'B'')&6')&'-)/-'-&6' ,-&=,.& 8'B''0 '6',((',.0 -&C( '/ &6'

'.)8'-CB'')&'

-'BC&6'00)&'0 -&C,'-&6'

)&'-)/-'-&6' ,-&;-B&/ 7'-'&)&,&)- =6 &)&6 .&G ',.& &.C;&6' -5,/'&- )'BC- / -/ ;(,'.--'0'& )-'4'(&'G "

+7 *

- * #,# - + : # - - "

/ - *

* + 64 +

(333*

8 9 *+(2 * - * 7 +

--.

9 7

64 "

+ *

-- *- - A +- - # + '6 (333+ - +

? 9- -* 64-

C/'&&'-'&*AD6'&6' /,& ,(6(/0' &))&0 )-'0)&'-B'-'

& 7)50')&6'.

;&6' ..'(&-6 ..0 C&6'

/,& = -'=)&6)&'-'&&6'-' &&6'- &'L)'

0'- ('&,/M 0'- ,/ -/ &6' &)/' & 7)5 0'),&).)&6 ..6 8'B''0 )-'0)&'* -8)'&6 &),(6(/0' &)- C0 -& &6'-')&0 )-'0)&'=)&6) 0'-)'C'

-/&6' &'=6)(60'))& 7';)&'-'& &&6'

&')&''0'-('&,/0'- ,/6 ..B'0 B.'-/ &6' &''@0)-C&6' )0'-)'C'

-&6'

/,&(/0' &)-0 -&&6'-'=6)(66 &B'' )-'0)&'B'-'&6' &',(6'@0)-CG DE * # 64 * *+

/ - *

/ +

- > 3= *

- + *

>(1= * + * E + + - *

* E +

* * # / - *

'1 (33& #

>3= +

%( '1 (33&%'

'1 (33) >(1= %( '1 (33)

2 ( (333

F*+ - %) '( (333> %& 9

/ +

?@ (2&1'(333 + + *

- 8 9# + 6 (333 + * *+ (2

< ..='

&'&6 &&6' (I,))&) ..'(&- )& 6. )I,)-C '4)'BC 3'(&) '&'-/)'&6'(/0' &)/'-'.C&6'B )&6'

0-)(')@'BC&6'$)&-)(& -)('!)@ &) //)&&'' &)('/&)->

'&)&)'- 6 '0)&' &6' '&)-' = -'

/,&=)&6&6' (I,))&) ..'(&-;$)B,-'/'& (/0' &) B'C 3)@&'' .

( 0'- (-' =)..

-'/ )& C' '

=6).';&6' /,&'0)&'BC&6'

0'&)&)'-6 ..B'0,&) A0'- &)8' ((,&=)&6 &) .)F'# 7 &'

-/ @)/,/- &')&'-'& &6 &&6'0 -&C,'&)&.'&&6' /'( -'(8'- $ &)G :- 7 * * + - # 6 (333#

-- *

# 64 *

7 * # + # - #

- - - < 8 9 *7 * 7 G +*

6 (333- < - - -

- - -

# + -

- - +/ + + -

--.

64 : -

7- #

- / 6 (333+-**+

64 / +

* - + -

- #

+ + * 8 9 # + * *+ (2 +

* + 64 - +

* *$- #

+* 7 # 9 #

- + #

64 +- +- <- # 6 (333 #

64*

B* # + 7 + #- *+ #,#- +

# + * #- -

# $#

* # #+

: 3 !"3

? #. HD ? * HD