High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2389/2016dismissed

Amar Singh v. Raghbir Singh And ORS

2018-09-20Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu15 pages

"#$ $%&'&()

*++$,,"(# -. *$'+(/$(#' ) 01 21

213 3

!" #$ #% &# ' ( )* + " !" &&

( , * - ). + ( & /

0 1 - .+ + " 2

-. -,. (" 2 &

+ ! 34 "( (

# &##& ( 2

(

8 (9 2

9 + " /

7 ( "

; " <

+ + 8 0'

-. -,.

+ ! 8 0'

( 2 & "

! " "" ( 2

-. -,. 2 & "

" ;

+ 8 05

+ ( %

( 2

-. -,. 2 & + !34 "( (

+ ( /

" + ( /,) ) "

( 2

-,. +

( /

+ "" +" ( /

) = (

8 9 9 " + ( 2

6 > "

(+ ( ( 2 & 6 >

+ + "

"#$$ !

"#$$ &

(

"#$$ )

" #$+

"#$+ ,

"#$+ - .

> , + ! +

+ ! 3 ( <

( " ( /

( 2

-. -/. " > ,

+ (

- .+ *3 (

( " ( 2

-. -/. + 7 /

( " 2

-,. ,

( ( +

( /

- . ?

< 2 &6 $

$ #5

@56" , ) " "(" 2

#::5-A8 '.

" " /

+ + 7 *

( @@:@$-A8 :.

( " 2

-,. + 7 (/

- .

> ,

(

(" 2

-,. +

( /

+ ! "( "" "(

(

+ " /

" &#&'( + ( " /

> ,

96 8 " "

" " &#&'(

+ +< ( / &#&' ( $ ; " ,

" " " +

! " " /

" ( ( B(

=$0.1--2,3 ,

+ +

+ " + ! 3 "( + + "

(

+ !34 "(( 5 7 + "(/

- .

8 9 " ,

( 8 " 9 "

" ( "

-A8 ) .

+ 9 2

9 + " * + " " 8 /

+ + "(,

! 1 " > ,

!1 "

8 " 8 " ++ 7 +78 " + 9

+ 9 "( ,

)9& " " 2

6 $

8 9 (/

8 "

++ 8 9 ,7( + 8 " + 9 / 7":5 ; A 5$&- B =.

" + (8 " + 9 @

8 " 9 "

+ " + " ,

" (

(

+ "

/ 9 + " + "

" " +

9 > ,

" " /

" 9

" " "/

" ++ " " "") ( ) + + C 4 A8 8 " + 4A8+ )9'

A8 )9'0/ A8 )9'0, )9'0* > ,

A8 )9'0/)9' ) ( ) +

7 " " "

<D D6 " " ""

< 6/

+ + + ( 8 " ( " "

/ 8 + ( )9' 3 + 4 A8 > ,

" (

" " "9+ /

8 "9+

* +

8 9 + " "

" "

< " +

" " -A8 )&. 9 >

+ " "8

9 > ,

" + (

+ " #

" <+ "9 8 (/

( &##' ,

" 2 ::5-A8 5.+ "

" / (" 2

-,. + 2

6 + " / " 45

%&% 6

@0 -6 %. + 2

6 $ > " 2 ::5+ / +/

+ 9 ( + 2

6 $ > "

(<+ 9

"<+ 9 ( &##'

> ,

+ 96 8 "

+ 2

6 $

" 6

:&'##0

( 7 &#5# #% &##' A8 )960

6 $

" 6

% 45

%&%6

@0 -6 %. )

1 + ( + 2

6 $ " /

+ 9

> " + " (

8 "9 " 9" 2 ::5-A8 5.+ > ,

"9-A8 60) ./

7 " 2

-,. 2

6 7 "

" "" + 2

+ " ) - 2 $.

> " 9 2

6 $ (" 2

-. -/. & 8 0:

" (" 2

-,. + +

" ( < " 8 9 + 3= " , 4 ", "(/ #5$6' 7$6'8' 6' 89"(:," ", "(/ "(#5$6;3

+$< 86# 8/:9$(#'

> ,

(" " ("

-,. + 2

%+ (

+ ;2 6:+ " ; " <

+ ( ( " + 8 0:

( 2

-. -/. ! 8 0:

( 2 & + " " " 2

-. -/. 2 &

" 0:

0 ( + " ( ) * + !" #$ #% &# '

( /

+ (

( + +

( /

" ! 3 "( " ( /

+ < ! "( , +

" "

(

9 (8 ( /

+ ( " , + + ( ( 2 +

& ;

(+ (

( +

( 7 +

( ; ( " ( , +

" 7( /

( ( +

( /

< 2 &6 $ $ #5

@56+ " , ) " + " 2

#::5+ "/

7( "+

( @@:@$ " A8 :

> ( 7 ( /

+ (

7 ( "

( +

( ! 3 "( +

" + (

+ ! "( " "

( &#0&'( "/

" 8 "

+< ( / "

&#0&'( > " +

! " "

2 ,"(# "97' "69"("(/"(/#5$6' == 1 >3 + " + ! 3 "( ( + "

(

+ !3 "((

( +

0 8 "

< "

+ )9 + (

( 9 "+ 8 /

" " " " " / + 9 "(,

)9& 9 "

9+ 8 (/

9 + + (

" 0 2 & 9 &#

" " * + " " " 8 + + "( ,

! 1 "

> 7" 8 " + 9 "

:5 "+

2 (

( 1

+ "

+ 9 + 8 ; " " 9 " +

" "+ 8 9 " "/

+("

0 ) ( + 3 + 4 A8 + ( A8 )9'0/ A8 )9'0; A8 )9'0*+

7 " " <D D6

" " " < 6/

+ 2 8 (8 " + (

0 /

0 8 " ( 4 A8 ) ( + ( E 9 /

+ ( (8 " + + 9 /

8 9 "

( " " 8 9

" + 8 ( " + (" (7 '

9 " ( 2 ::5+ / ( 4 , "

" ( 7 (

" 2

-,. + 0 2

6 + " 7 " "<2 %&% 2 @0 -6 %.+ 0 2

6 $ > " ( 2 ::5+ + /

+ 9

( + 0 2

6 $ > "

<+ 9

" <+ " ( &##'

; 96 "

0 2

" 6 %

:&'##0

< 2 &#5# #% &##'

8 " +

+ 0 2

6 $

" 6 % "< 2 %&% < 2 @0 -6 %. ) 1 ; "

0 2

6 $ ("/

+9 < ( + (" + ( ! ( , + F " < " 8 9 + 3= " , = - .

(

(+ !34 "((

( " 2

-,. +

!3 "(

9 8 + "(/

" ; "

8+ + + !"

( , !" , :

2 7 +

> " ( "

" @5 ( 21 $+#$9?$6 3

<0 G02 G02