← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/615/2017dismissed

Naveen Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-04-20Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

  



          !" #$%  &'( )(*!+!", - . &/(("012&3&")'4(3+ 566(77&"'+ 8(3+1+ 9'&'( &3:&"&&")'4(3+ 5(+6")("'+

 , ;  9 

 

;  9 

9# 3(+("', 33(2 (('"&")<)/*&'( 3'4(&66(77&"'+ ===    >? "'3&@*13'&66(&7!+&A&!"+'B1)A2("' '4(7(&3"()C3!'*13' )&'()  )!+2!++!"A*4&77("A(''4(C!'4)3&C&7 3(/!+!" 6&: +*&7(A3&"'()/!)(3)(3)&'() $7"AC!'4'4(&66(&7<&667!*&'!" +((D!"A*")"&'!" )&:+;)(7&:!" !7!"A'4(3( <4&+&7+E((" !7() > ? (&3"() C3!' *13' C4!7( &*D"C7()A!"A 3!A4'   '4( 9'&'( ' 3(*'!

: & 2!+'&D(< +1+'&!"() '4( 3)(3 )&'()  $ C!'4)3&C!"A '4( 3(/!+()6&:+*&7(A3&"'()''4(C3!'6('!'!"(3+E1'"(A&'()'4(3!A4' '4( 3(+6")("'+'3(*/(3'4(&21"'6&!)''4(C3!'6('!'!"(3+613+1&"'''4( A3&"' '4(3(/!+()6&:+*&7(!"/!(C '4()(*!+!" '4( "FE7(9163(2(

13'!"     /(3+1+    <"'4(A31")'4&''4(C3!'6('!'!"(3+C(3(7C+&7&3!()(267:((+&") 3(*/(3: 32'4(2C17)"'E(+1+'&!"&E7(!"/!(C '4(7&C7&!))C"!" '4(& 3(2("'!"())(*!+!"

 >$? 13+1&"''3)(3)&'()  !" # - < C4(3(!" 63&:(3 C&+ 3 A3&"'   '(*4"!*&7 6&: +*&7(      @ -< '4( 6('!'!"(3+/!)(3)(3)&'()-- $!(""(G13(@ <C(3(A3&"'()'4( '(*4"!*&7 6&: +*&7(      @ - 3(/!+() '  - H  C(  %%< 13'4(33(/!+()' @ I 3&)(&: -J@C(    A3&"'() /!)( 

!*( 3)(3 )&'() -- $ !( ""(G13( @  9!"*(<'4(6('!'!"(3+C(3(&66!"'()&+ (76(3+" $C!'41' < '4(3( 3( '(*4"!*&7 6&: +*&7( C&+ &77C() ' '4(2 " *267('!"   '43(( :(&3+(G6(3!("*("'(*4"!*&76+'C(  &")'4(!36&:C&+ !G() &''4(!"!'!&7+'&A(!"'4(&:&")  @ I 3&)(&: -J@

C(/(3<&+6(3+'&")!"'4(C3!''("+'&'(2("' !7()!"'4(C3!'6('!'!"<6&: '4(6('!'!"(3+C&+C3"A7:3(@ !G()/!)(3)(3)&'() $E:C3"A7: !"'(363('!"A'4((/!+()&:17(+ .&")'(@- 17(-- 987@ < &3' E: 217'!67:!"A'4( 2!"!212 '(*4"!*&76&:+*&7(  -J@ C!'4 . C(/(3<3(@ !G&'!"3)(3)&'() $C&+!++1()*")!'!"&77: '4&' !" *&+( &": &)/(3+( 6!"!" C&+ 3(*(!/() 32 '4( /(3"2("'J (&) 

!*(<3(@ !G&'!" '4(6('!'!"(3+C17)E(C!'4)3&C"&")'4((G*(++!/( &21"'2&:E(3(*/(3() 4(+'&") 13'4(3'&D("16!"'4(C3!''("+'&'(2("' C&+'4&'C4("'4((333*&2(''4("'!*( '4(!3(*'3<9'&'( 3&"+63'<

&3:&"&< 4&")!A&34<!"+'31*'!"+C(3(!++1()'&77 ("(3&7 &"&A(3+/!)( 2(2)&'()-  33(@ !G&'!" 6&:!"'4('(*4"!*&76&:+*&7(E: *"+!)(3!"A'4(!"!'!&76&:&+ J@&+6(3317(+'C&+ 13'4(32("'!"() '4&'3)(3)&'() $C&+(33"(1+7:!++1()E:3(+6")("'$ !G!"A '4(6&: '4(6('!'!"(3+&''4(+'&A(  --I - 3&)(&:C&+"' &+6(3'4(6('!'!"(3+F("'!'7(2("'E(*&1+('4(E&+!*6&:  --J@C&+"7: ' E( A3&"'() ' '4( /(3"2("' (267:(( &' '4( '!2(  !3+' ("'3: !"'

/(3"2("'+(3/!*(&+6(3 /(3"2("'!"+'31*'!"+)&'().. <E1'!"

'4(!"+'&"'*&+(<'4(6('!'!"(3+4&)"'("'(3() /(3"2("'+(3/!*(&+)!3(*' ("'3&"'"3& '(3 <C4(3(&+'4(:C(3(E31A4'!"''4( !A4(3&: +*&7( '(*4"!*&76+'!( H I - 3&)(&:&")'4(!36&: C&+3(K1!3()'E( !G()"'4(6&:7&+')3&C"E:'4(263!3''4()&'( A3&"'!"A'4(4!A4(36&:+*&7(!(

J@!"63(@3(/!+()+*&7(  H$  &")'4(6&: '4(C3!'6('!'!"(3+ !G()&''4("(G'+'&A( '4(63(/!1+6&:< +1EB(*' ' '4( 2!"!212   '4( 6&: +*&7( 9!"*( '4( C3!' 6('!'!"(3+ C(3( )3&C!"A

J@&")'4(!36&:C&+ !G()&''4(2!"!212 6&:+*&7(!(    H  I  - 3&)( &: 32 '4( )&'(   '4(!3 ("'!'7(2("'< '4(3( 3(<  -- I - 3&)( &: *17) "7: E( A3&"'() ' '4()!3(*' ("'3: 7(/(7 ' /(3"2("' (267:((+ &+ 6(3 !"&"*( (6&3'2("' &3:&"& "+'31*'!"+)&'()..  >-? "'4(& 3(2("'!"()E&*DA31")<+'&")!"'4(C3!''("+'&'(2("' C&+ '4&' & 2!+'&D( *22!''() 4&) E((" 3(*'! !() !" '(32+   7(''(3 )&'() -  3(*(!/() 32 '4( 

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

'4(3( " '4( 6&3'   '4( C3!' 6('!'!"(3+< 3(+'3&!"() '4( 9'&'( 32 2&D!"A 3(*/(3: 32 '4( 6('!'!"(3+ " &**1"'   '4(!3 E(!"A 7C +&7&3!() (267:((+!"'4(7!A4' )(*!+!" '4( "FE7(9163(2( 13'!"       *&+( +163& " &66(&7< '4!+ 13' /!)( 3)(3 )&'() $ <C4!7('&D!"A"'( '4( &*'1&76+!'!"<6&++())('&!7()3)(3!" '4(*"'(G' '4(63&:(3 '4(7(&3"()*1"+(7 3'4(&66(77&"'+'3(2&") '4(2&''(3 33(*"+!)(3&'!""'4(A31") "'!*("'4&/!"AE(("!++1() ''4(&66(77&"'+E( 3(6&++!"A '4(3)(3!261A"()!"'4(C3!'6('!'!"

C(/(3< '4!+ 13' 3( 1+() ' &**(6' '4( & 3(2("'!"() 67(&   '4( &66(77&"'+"'4(A31")'4&'&**(6'!"A+1*4&67(&C17) 3*('4(&66(77&"'+ !"''4('43"(+ 7!'!A&'!"E(+!)(+'4(:C(3(&73(&):""'!*('4&'!"'4( (/("'   &663/&7 "' E(!"A A3&"'() E: '4( 9'&'(J (&) 

!*(< '4( E("( !' C17)E(C!'4)3&C""'4(*!3*12+'&"*(+<'4!+ 13'3(K1!3()'4(&66(77&"'+ '+4C'4(!3("'!'7(2("'C4!*4E/!1+7:C17)E('4(67(&'4&''4(:C17) 3&!+(!"*&+('4(!363&:(3 33(2&")C&+&**(6'() C(/(3<)(+6!'(3(6(&'() 663'1"!'!(+'7(&3"()*1"+(7 3'4(&66(77&"'+'+4C("'!'7(2("' '4( C3!'6('!'!"(3+''4(E("( !'*7&!2()<"'4!"AC&+63)1*()<!"+'(&)63&:(3 C&+2&)( 3&)B13"2("'C4!*4C&+"'&**(6'() >? **3)!"A7:< '4(3( !+ " 2(3!' !" '4( &66(&7 &") '4( +&2( !+ )!+2!++()  "+(K1("'7:< '4( &667!*&'!" +((D!"A *")"&'!"   )(7&: !"

!7!"A'4(&66(&7!+&7+)!+2!++() &B(+4!")&7 9#&7!& 1)A( 1)A(

- .   &2!' #4('4(3+6(&D!"AJ3(&+"() , (+J #4('4(33(63'&E7( , (+J