High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4677/2013dismissed

Ashok Kumar v. Raj Kumar

2018-12-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan6 pages

!"#$%

&&'' (%# )"#$%

& *%

% (!% +, % & %

% $(%$+, % %&

---- *' ) "#$% .%#/ # % %,%0

++1 2

+1+ &% &'$# +1 2 % % !"#$% ,%$ '% .%%3#$

+1+ 2%$ %$%+4# / &% %& ,#%# %! /%#% ' $# 3 %/%%.# &0 0$# &' &,%'%5# $ %,'/'

.0 &' #& +/, /%# &' .% / &% #

+ &&% '3% $ / # % / &%'$ %0 .) '' / $ .'0 # %$+#% % /

# % &' ' &% #7 # 3' %,'# . '.0 ' /%#

$%+3 .%%3 0$# %$ &' $%+ &#% 8'%)&%$ &' , /9 / : ;9 : 9

$'7 . &% #% ,#'03% .0 $ %7 & #$

+ 2 &' ' 3 ' 4# /&% % %$ /.' $#

+1+ 2

# &#% 8'%)&7 3/%.3 &% 3#' &0 ''$ , ' % $&' &0$ ''$ + &' 3#'/ , '% %% $ 73 '/% 3#'&0.' $#

+1+ 2 &' '0 $% %% / , ' $ &' 3#'/ &% ''+ 3,%+ #.5# '0+ &' ''#3 #. , '3 /' +3 3'% %,%.0 &'7 &' ! 0 #'&%+ #/ $&' . ' .0 7 #.5# '0 ,' # &%%% .0 #. 3 $ #'

7 %#'& /.3 &%'< !(%##. < # / %$ ''/ &' + + %,%$' #

= &' ' %&' %,% /

''/ 3% $ 3 %%% / ,%$

&' / &%+''3 /#3%%$ ,%%

> % &' ' %,% # $# ' /3 %3 %? **

> %&' '# ' &% #?

> %&% # $ .' %$? *

> %&' $ ;#%3 ' '%# $%'%$ ;#%? *

@ %%&%, + &' &&%*> .4$ /A0 / +>%%*> % / *>

B' % , #$ 94 * 94 *1 #&&%

% + &&% >

3% /'0 #$.%> .4$ /)$% / > C / +,> B' % , #$ 94 +%! 94 8 #&&%

% % / '% # '% &%+ %'

;#%#:

&' +#: ,#% +%#'# &' 3$ B3,%+ &% #3%'.% %3

C' / //%, .0 )#/$ %+ ' &&' ;#%%D#/+8 3 +3

3/ +3 ,)#/$ 1

& &&'+ )#/$ % & .0 %' ;#% % # / &&'' . ' %,%

++1 2 %$ %& !"#$%' /3 /%% %E

1 &% # %&%$ %$ ' / #''%'

@ 3%% &&' # 12 ''.&.0 %& = ' /3 )#/$ %%.0 !

! % ;#%.030' /%/#'% &&'&%0 / $ . &+ $&#/ )#/$ % & .0 . #'.0 / $.$

/ / %/#'% &&'+ &' ) "#$% &&%.% ;#% %#/ # '

@ , %'% # '% &%./ %#/ %%

@ $&#/ )#/$ %&.0 1

#%%$ ''/'0% %$0+% % $.#& &%&%&&%' , %% %&% '3 % % #& )#/$ % = ;#% '%D#/+ 8 3 &&% , '/ '3 #.) %#% / .%%3 #$

+1+ 2%$ &' + 4#&% %&

,#% &' &%$ /%#% &% &'$# 3 %.# ' # + &' 3)#

' / #%%,%0&% &'$#

+1+ 2 % E

1 &% # %&%$ +$# / +1 2

> '$ / '# + ! % & >%%A0 &&% /*> +3 .%%3#$

+1+ 2%$ &' &0$ %E 2&% &%

#$+ $# %,.0 3 % 3 + $ %0%/% / % %/%. // #% %

B /%''0 $# . %,.0 %$ @$ &% 94 * %&94 *

*>&' )"#$% ,94 *>2 '%% ,% /, &' %/% /, / #$

+1+ 2.0 $ 4# &% %& ,#%# %! /%#% $# E

1 &% # %&%

#$ / %$ 0*> % / + 3 &%, , 94 *> 2 #&&% /

= ,% #&.0 $% % %'% %8'%, '.0 &' ,#%+ &0 /$$# %/% / $4# &% %&% 8'%, '3/' .0

%$ &' &% %&3%

%/%+.# $ ,#%3 '% D#/+8 3 %0 3 &

&&% , = &' $# $% , / &'#.'.0&%& % &%..' +3 .0,%# % # $$ #$

. ,#% / '3 F% 3)#

% / #'.0 &' / .0 )#/$ $' #&' .0 %';#%

= %%+@ 0$% &&' % #%. '/'+,' 3''% )#/$ &.0

= &&' $% /'0

8%)

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#