Union Of India v. Ashok Kumar And Others
!"# #$%&%'( )
*
( + , -,.
! "
#### -,. , $ %&'& (
)*! * "
" " )*) ) !
! )* + ,-./0111
!
+ 203 ., .3,- !
+ -526 0.
.335!
* "
! "!! ) " + 5-0116 % 7 ( + 540116 % 78 "%
(" " ( 9
* " 7"
.6 0116
'! : ;"
" 7"
.- 01.1
" " 9 * !
* , 6 " 7" !
$
! " # $% &' ( "
)*
"
(
+ , *
- .
*
* ( * * - -
- --
.
* ( - -
- +-- "
/*0 1 *2 3 *
) #
& (" *-" 45 6
" #
"
) + " #
--7 +
-- " +
-
- &
3
8(+ *
--+ + - ! ( ( -
+
1
#*9:*:::;5
- ++ -- +
( -
&
51 +
-
( +*
<(
- + +
"
) - .
-
5. .
-
-- +
-
2 = >
2 -
-- = >
--+
-- = >
+
--+
1
):*:::;5
+
! ( = 0 .% & & (
& " ) ( . " )9)
/ /#&
1 *2 +
>8 ?*2 3 0(*-
+ + -
-- -
-
( " # )
"
) (-
--
- 7 1
#*9:*:::;5+
(
# ? * ( - - -
+ --+
+ = = >
+ 2 2 % &
/# " #* "
) (-
* "
) + -
--
-(
0(*
3 *
(
3 -
3 3 @( -- + ! -
% & -
--1
):*:::;5 /# & % A
2
( --( " ;
;:)
" # 1
)*9 *#//;5 -
)
" # +-- +
1
#
> " #
( - &
1 0(* - ;
# 6- " #
(
" + ,-./0111 % ( ! )
)
) ! ) " ) *
8!
) )
) 78 ""< + 540116 " 7 "
+ -526 0.
.335 = )* ! " "
) '
+ 5- 0116 "
*7 " ) )
+ -526 0.
.335
!
"
* !
)) "
)* .6
' " !" $ %.( > 8 " = "
0.
35 ) ?'
%0( + . !
)" " 7 8 " ! ?'8 "@ %2( >
0.
35 )
= ! )
= ?' %-( > 8 " * ?'8 " %4(>
7 * )* " "
* ?'
%,(>
0.
35@ "
) ?'
%6(>
7 * 7
* ?'
%5( > ! ?' %3( ?
)
)
)" * !
" """ )" ' !
78 " ! $ *
* + 5-0116 !
*9 *"" )"!+ ., ;
9 )" !
"* + ,-./0111 + 540116!
! + 5-0116 )*
!
" 7" .6
" ""
" 7"
.6 0116 < 78
"
! ) : ;"
" 7"
2
" ) 7" 2 0113 )* : ;"
"
78 " !
"
) ) "
+ .5,2 0113%
" (
+ .5,- 0113% 7 ( ! ) )* 7" - B ! 8&) ! ! ! ! 00113 < .0-14 0113 B ) " 7" .6 0116 )* " )
* 8&) 9 + 54
< : ;"
! "
' " ) 7"
.6
+ .56 00 " + ,-.0111
.1 " 7" .- 01.1 ) ) 7" 2 0113 : ;"
/ !
7" - 0113 )* " "
< 78 "
" ""
" " 7"
.- 01.1 : ;"
"
'
)*! * "
"
" ! *0000 * $"
* *! )* 0- .
01.6
!" + ..1,4$ $01., * *.,0"
)
! ! " * C ) "
!
) ! ! " )" ! ! &'D
&
* ' " % ( *""9 )" !+ ., B ; < : E< : : " / ! ) !
< :
*! ;" .- .322 <
"
*
* !
)
" )" ! * " * ;" =
., .3,- !
* ! < D C " $ 78
" ! )* 78 "
9 *
*! 7 8 " < D C "
> .365 = )* ) 78 "
+ 61./520/@:/:F/> /55 5;* .355 )*: :F + !:
B ) F= :2
$ ).1 * ) F= :2
.355 78 " = "
+ -526 0.
.335 $ !
+ -526 = 0.
.335 " 00 .335
! ) ) ! ) "
A
= )
+ -526 0./00 .335 7 8 " "
*
= 8 "
$
>
" : .333 ! )* :
' $ $
; " ) $ 78 "
)*! * >+ ..0.,.333%8 " 7 ) ( ! ! + -
B!
) )* : C
6
" * .0" !
) !
6 ! " >+ ..0.,.333
/
" .0" !
) )* " ! ) !
78 "
8!
! "
" "
"
" "" ) ! " ! )
*
)*
! * ) ) !"
)
) %F=
:2(! *
* "
+ 203 ., .3,- = )*
;" ! < D C
" 7 8 " ) " "
F= :2
) " $ 6- ( 0 . % & ;= @ 4 & & &(
+= @ 4 &
- C )
(+
> @ * >8* "+ > = "
:
; );1<>;>8;C3; * 2
$6
##*
" 2145 3'B B )*!
!
)*! * )*! *
)
"
$' A )*! * ! .- .322 ;" < < : E < : B )*! *
203 ., .3,-!
)* )*! * ) F= :2 !
* "
$'
)*! *
., .3,-!
)* *
*
., .3,-! "
) "
+ ,-.0111
"2,* > ! ) " " ) "
= ) ) ' "
!
"* ) " 8 "
) !!
!
! 7 " 7"
) 8!
" 02 7" "* *" $ 9
* "
* )" ! + ., )
)*
0./00 .335 * )
)
$ * *" 9 )" !+ ., ; !
!!
9 )" !+ .,
)
* :
* *"9 )" !+ ., )
0./00 .335%F= :G(
) "
) * ) !
!
! " " 7"
)
" 7 : ;"
"* =
!
)
"
"
.1 " 7" ! )
$ (
3 - * !
8!
>D
--*( +
0 .% &
"
)
-( 3 1
#*9:*:::;5 + +
( 0 . % &
-(
0 .% &*
-
% 0 *
* - (
- - +
( ?+
* +
( 1
#*9:*:::;5 " (
0 . % & -( - - "!-
+
+
( 1
#*9:*:::;5
&
51 *2 *+(
--
-
+(-
&*
0 .% &
! (
( * *
*
&*
-
- & , >-&* > 2 * - * ( .
) ) :: + --
- %E 6 .
<%
% 3 1 & --
F& - G
E F6 .
G
E*( .
# ::
)*
)* " "
" " ! *"
$') " !
!
! *
"
" $
" 9
00 .335 * )* "
$
! )
B ! )
)* ) ) !
B ! )
)*
!"7" 8&) !
$ .( F= ' %.333(2
444%
( 0(
** * D
0116 %
(.4-,%
( 2( C 0116 %,(
.01%
( -(: ) " + " .33.%0( <30%@8( 4( %
+ 2-6,01., 2 01.6(
9 *
$ *
7 + 5-0116 ) )
7 )* ! *
+ -526 0./00 .335
!
= *
*! 8
+ -526! )
!
" B ) *
) )
)*
"
$' !
"
+ -526 0./00 .335 F= :G
+ 5- 0116 *
" " 7" .6
! )* )
!
"
)
.6
+ 540116 *
) ! "
!
)* < < 78
") 8&) ! ! !
"" " !
!
! !
"
)*
" ! )
*!" ! !)* 8&)
)
"*
! " 7"
) !
!
!) )
A* !
+ -526 0./00 F= :G
*
*!
$ !
! 9 9 )" !+ .,! * B !
!
))
"
) )*
B " )* ) !!) " ) "
:" "
* " *
* " 7" )* ) !
8
*9 ! ) 9 !
! 9 " "
! = "
7
.11
" ) !
!)* 8H) !12!'!'!3#'41!'!'4 !'"5#16&,#7&582!13%'%!'4"5#1&9
0$%:%;/ !'"&5!<!1%6& =1&5""!8%>!1%9
*0 + " !
"
)
! !
!* ) ! *) B + )
* ! ) )
"
!
!
- 01.6 -,. &
C - ;
H ;" C-
I H ;"