High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4723/2013dismissed

Meenu Gupta v. Shivam Siksha Samiti And ORS

2015-08-20Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg5 pages

!"# $#%&'&(

)

* ##(++,"! ,,#--!(" .#/'+' 0&.!1&2'0!!1&"##!($"0#/' #',($#("' 34567 80#"0#/#,/"#/' 6%!-#9',!,#/'1!:;#!--9#$" '##"0#<+$=1#(">

;#/# #//#$""0##,/"#/'/(">

80#"0#/"0#<+$=1#("'0+-$;#/#,/"#$&("0#&=#'"> /#'#("3/7=(&0"/&?$.%!"# /"0#!,,#--!(" ##(++,"!,-!&("&

4!,,#--!("0!'$&/#%"#$"0#,/#'#("!,,#!- !=!&('""0#<+$=1#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ )

,!''#$;:0/& &1/&?-#!/(#$$$&"&(!-&'"/&%"+$=#?1;!-!.&$#90&%0"0#!,,#!- ,/# #//#$ ;: ,-!&("&

@!,,#--!(" !=!&('" "0# <+$=1#(" !($ $#%/## $!"#$

,!''#$;:0/&A&.#2 !$!.? -#!/(#$$$&"&(!-&.&-+$=#

+(&/&.&'&( ?1;!-!9!'$&'1&''#$

/&# !%"' "0#,/#'#("%!'#!/#"0!"(#!<&($#/7+1!/9!' !;'-+"#9(#/&(,''#''&( "0#'+&",/,#/":?90'-$"0#'+&",/,#/": .&$#/#=&'"#/#$'!-#$##$$!"#$

* /.!-+!;-#%('&$#/!"&(""0#

!($0!($#$.#/"0#!%"+!-,0:'&%!-,''#''&("0&1!($"0# %/,' <&/& /&%# '9(;:"0#,-!&("&

&''"!($&(="0#/#&(+"!"&("0#/#

0!';##(#("#/#$!($'!(%"&(#$&("0#(!1# "0#,-!&("&

-!&("&

"0#/# /#&(%("&(++',''#''&( "0#,/,#/":&($&',+"#!'"0#9(#/ "0#'!1#!($&"&' /0&'+""#/'+/,/&'#"0!""0#$# #($!("'0!.#'"!/"#$ %-!&1&(=";#"0#,!""#$!/ "0#'+&",/,#/":+($#/"0!"!<&($#/7+1!/ -!&("&

%!1#"2(9!;+""0&'!--#=!"&(90#(0#/#%#&.#$!("&%# /1 "0#+/" #0'&-$!/!0!?90#/#"0#$# #($!("''"!"#$"0!.# &-#$!( !,,-&%!"&( /'!(%"&( "0#1+"!"&(&("0#&/(!1#'("0#;!'&' ' %!--#$,!""!(!1!?90&%01!""#/&'!-';#&(=%("#'"#$;:"0#,-!&("&

&(%#"0#$# #($!("'0!.# !&-#$"!$1&""0#%-!&1 "0#,-!&("&

?0#(%# "0&''+&"

,(("&%#$# #($!("'!,,#!/#$!($ &-#$9/&""#('"!"#1#("

!($"2+,,/#-&1&(!/:;<#%"&(/#=!/$&(=1!&("!&(!;&-&":%(%#!-1#("

"/+#!($1!"#/&!- !%"'?%!+'# !%"&(?.#/& &%!"&( ,-!&("!($-%+'

'"!($&"&' +/"0#/!--#=#$"0!"0&.!10&2'0!!1&"&0!$"!2#("0#'+&" -!($(-#!'# /"9#("::#!/''"!/"&(= /1 B4

C '*?

@4,#/:#!/!($!<&($#/7+1!/?"0#!--#=#$.#($/9!'/#'&$#(" 0&.!1 0&2'0! !1&"& 0# ,''#''&( "0# -!($ 9!' "!2#( ;:

$# #($!("!($'&(%#B

?"0#$# #($!("&'&(%("&(+'

!($+(&("#//+,"#$,''#''&( "0#'+&",/,#/": !<&($#/7+1!/?"0# .#($/ "0#,-!&("&

0!'(/&=0"?"&"-#/&("#/#'""&("#/ #/#&("0# ,''#''&( $# #($!("0#,-!&("&

!($0#/ !1&-:1#1;#/'9#/# !9!/#"0!"$# #($!("&'&(-#=!-!($,#!%# +-,''#''&( "0#-!($ ;#&(=-#!'#0-$#/?09#.#/?"0#:;#&(=&( -+#("&!-,#/'('=""0#'!-#$##$ #D#%+"#$&("0#&/ !.+/<+'""=/!;"0#,/,#/": $# #($!("&(

%((&.!(%#9&"0(#!<&($#/7+1!/.#($/'"0#1+"!"&( "0#-!($ 9!'";#="#D#%+"#$;:!<&($#/7+1!/?/#'&$#(" !1&"&;+"9&"0 +-"#/&/1"&.#?0#$&$("$"0#(##$ +-!($?"0#/# /#?1+"!"&(%+-$("

;#'!(%"&(#$&( !.+/ $# #($!("!($"0#/#.#(+##("/&#'/#1!&(&( "0#(!1# !<&($#/7+1!/?90&%0!/#,!-,!;-:9/(=?&(%//#%"!($ ;!'#-#''# #($!("0!''"!/"#$,/%##$&(=' /"0#!""#'"!"&(!($ '!(%"&( 1+"!"&( "0#'+&"-!($&( !.+/ $# #($!("("0# ;!'&' -#!'#$##$ $!"#$ B

/#=&'"#/#$ &("0#

&%# +;

#=&'"/!/? !0! ( "0# '!1# $!"# !<&($#/ 7+1!/ .#($/ 9!' (" &( ,''#''&( "0#,/,#/":'0#%!((""/!('

#/!(:,''#''&(""0#

(1#/&"'?"0#$# #($!("'$#(&#$!--"0#!.#/1#("'!($,/!:#$ / $&'1&''!- "0#'+&"9&"0',#%&!-%'"' #,-&%!"&( 9!' &-#$ /1 "0# ,-#!$&(=' "0# ,!/"&#'

--9&(=&''+#'9#/# /!1#$34 80#"0#/"0#,-!&("&

&'&(#'"!;-&'0#$,#!%# +- ,''#''&(.#/"0#'+&",/,#/":!'$#"!&-#$&("0#0#!$ ("# "0#,-!&("?'&"+!"#$&(.&--!=#!0!?"#0'&-!($ &'"/&%"1;!-!!($!'$#"!&-#$&("0#0#!$("# "0# ,-!&(">

(%!'#&''+#&'$#%&$#$&( !.+/ "0#,-!&("&

? "0#(90#"0#/"0#,-!&("&

&'!-'#("&"-#$",#/1!(#(" &(<+(%"&(!',/!:#$ />

80#"0#/"0#'+&" &-#$;:"0#,-!&("&

&'(" 1!&("!&(!;-#> 80#"0#/"0#,-!&("&

0!'("!,,/!%0#$"0#%+/"9&"0 %-#!(0!($'> * #-&# * 0#,!/"&#'0!.#-#$"0#&//#',#%"&.##.&$#(%#("0#! /#'!&$ &''+#' "#/!,,/!&'!- "0##.&$#(%#?"0#"/&!-+/"$&'1&''#$"0#'+&"

"0#,-!&("&

.&$#<+$=1#("!($$#%/##$!"#$

B ##-&(= !==/&#.#$? ,-!&("&

,/# #//#$ &/'" ,,#!- ;# /# -#!/(#$$$&"&(!-&'"/&%"+$=#?1;!-!0#-#!/(#$$$&"&(!-&'"/&%" +$=#?1;!-!.&$#<+$=1#("!($$#%/##$!"#$ )

$&'1&''#$"0# !,,#!- "&-- ##-&(= $&''!"&'

&#$ 9&"0 "0# !

/#'!&$ <+$=1#("' !($ $#%/##'"0#,/#'#("/#=+-!/'#%($!,,#!-0!';##($&/#%"#$;:"0#,-!&("&

) 0#!,,#--!("?&(,!/!=/!,0 "0#=/+($' !,,#!-?

1#("&(#$"0!" --9&(='+;'"!("&!-E+#'"&(' -!90!.#!/&'#(&("0# ,/#'#("!,,#!-34

& 80#"0#/"0#&1,+=(#$<+$=1#("'!($$#%/##',!''#$;: "0#6$+/"';#-9!/#&--#=!-?#//(#+'?,#/.#/'#? !=!&('""0##.&$#(%#(/#%/$!($!=!&('""0#,/.&'&(' -!9!($!/#-&!;-#";#'#"!'&$#>

&& 80#"0#/!"/+#9(#/%!(;#$#(&#$/#-&#$ &(<+(%"&( !=!&('" /%&;-#&("#/ #/#(%#&(,''#''&(!""0#0!($'

!,#/'(90&'(#&"0#/&(,''#''&((/0!'!(:/&=0"? "&"-#/&("#/#'"&("0#'+&"-!($ "0#"/+#9(#/>

&&& 80#"0#/"0#/#-&# &(<+(%"&(%!(;#$#(&#$""0#"/+# 9(#/&("0#!;'#(%# ,/$+%&(=(/#%/$%,: '!-# $##$#',#%&!--:&("0#%&/%+1'"!(%#90#("0#"&"-# "0#

&'("$&',+"#$!($"0#,-!&("&

0!',/.#$0#/ 9(#/'0&,!($,''#''&(.#/"0#'+&"-!($!$$+%&(= /!-!'9#--!'$%+1#("!/:#.&$#(%#>

&. 80#"0#/!-#''##%!(;#0#-$&(,''#''&(90#("0# -#!'#$##$&'(#.#/!%"#$+,(!($"0#,''#''&(0!' (#.#/$#-&.#/#$""0#-#''##!($"0#'!&$-#!'#$##$ !-/#!$:$##1#$";#%!(%#--#$> . 80#"0#/"0#&1,+=(#$<+$=1#("'!($$#%/##'0!.# %!+'#$1!(& #'"&(<+'"&%#!($&//#,!/!;-#-''""0# !,,#--!("4,-!&("&

.& 80#"0#/"0#/#-&# &(<+(%"&(%!(;#$#(&#$"!"/+# 9(#/ -&1'&-:!($9&"0+"!'%#/"!&(&(="0#!%"+!-

* ,'&"&( ,''#''&(("0#'+&"-!($> F 0&'&'!1#/#'+&" /,#/1!(#("&(<+(%"&(-!&("&

%!( '+%%##$& '0#&'!;-#",/.#0#/,''#''&(0#/#&'%(%+//#(" &($&(= /#%/$#$;:;"0"0#+/"';#-9"0!",-!&("&

0!' !&-#$",/.# 0#/ #D%-+'&.#,''#''&(.#/"0#'+&",/,#/": 0!";#&(=! &($&(= !%"

%!((";#&("#/ #//#$&("0#/#=+-!/'#%($!,,#!-1/#'90#("0#/#&' ("0&(=("0#/#%/$",/.#"0!"'!&$ &($&(='!/#"0#/#'+-" 1&'/#!$&(= !($1&'&("#/,/#"&(="0##.&$#(%#("0#/#%/$!($!/#&--#=!-?#//(#+' !($,#/.#/'#/!=!&('""0##.&$#(%# "&' +/"0#/'+;1&""#$"0!"-#''##%!((" ;# 0#-$ " ;# &( ,''#''&( ''#''&( "0#'+&",/,#/":9!'(#.#/$#-&.#/#$""0# -#''##-!&("&

1!:;#%49(#/!

"#/,+/%0!'#;+"'0#'+%%##$'(-:& '0# &'!;-#",/.#,''#''&( 0#/.#($/!($"0#/#!

"#/0#/,''#''&(.#/ "0#'+&",/,#/":-!&("&

0!' !&-#$",/.#0#/,''#''&(.#/"0#'+&"

,/,#/":?0!.#(0#'&"!"&(&(0-$&(="0!"('+;'"!("&!-E+#'"&('

-!90!'!/&'#(&("0#,/#'#("!,,#!-('#E+#("-:?"0#!,,#!-&'9&"0+" !(:1#/&"!($"0#'!1#'"!($'$&'1&''#$ %,: "0&'<+$=1#(";#'#("""0#"/&!-+/" /'"/&%"

%1,-&!(%#