Baljit Singh Alias Choocha v. State Of Punjab
9('%&",
9('%&",
9('%&",
9('%&", *#*% *#*% *#*% *#*%
<
$&&'$
!"#$
D/( &"(-
:(-%*%
*"
D/(%8&"9("
, , , ,
-(%(" , -(%(" , -(%(" , -(%(" , 6. / ! ! 6. / ! ! 6. / ! ! 6. / ! ! .
.
.
.
-/ "9$*2 9:&'
-/ 08-(( !"#$2 *"
+/
?????
?????
?????
?????
.
.
.
.2 / 4.7 / 4.7 / 4.7 / 4.7
! ! ! ! /
-(%("
$-9
@3
$
-1 !*- 1%$
"$ 3
4)&- %$&- 5!!67
-"# &3
</ / 2
-(#% (-(9 &))("'(% 8*"%$ *"9 9(- -'& '
-*#%
%0'$& -&8'
!*+% @< 4)&- %$&- 5!
' 672
& !*
"8*- .&9$2 % -'
8* *- $
/
=("
B*( (% &"
''*%(9 ("#
8(- ""
'
:"#
" &;'
( % 4/3 =% 8C&
=7
(#(9 -('&:(-(9
3/
.( -"(9 '&*"%(
'*% &90
%"'(
</ / / .( -"(9 '&*"
"%(
%*+= (9
&-0 8-&:%&"%
'
%'-*8* &*%
'&=8 F $2
$* %2 8-&%('* &"
%*))(-%
"$(-("
9()(' %/ .( -"(9 '&*"%(
0(9
$(-(&)
% ("(9
.
.( -"(9 '&*"%(
%*))(-(9
=&-(
-%/ $*%2
80(9
)&-/
/
.( -"(9 '&*"%(
&8 88&%(9
-#*"#
(# &"%
%(-&*% *-(
"92 $*%2 9&(% 9(%(-:( '&"'(%%
.( -"(9
'&*"%(
%*+= (9
--(9
-#&-% !( (' &"
$*%2
9%=%%(9/ .( -"(9 '&*"%(
%((1%
-('&-9 '*% &90 '(- )'
/ @/ &9 F$'$
1("
-('&-9/
</
'&*"%(
-:
- (%
#&"( $-&*#$
-('&-9%
--(% (9
</ / F$(-("
":(% # --(9 &*
8-(%(" (9
3/ / 3/ &
8-&%('* & F "(%%(% ' (9
(;
="(9
(/ -:
'&" (" &"%
#:( -%( 9(+
%%*(%2
F$'$
&'"
9*-"#
'&*-%(
$% 9&(%
9((=
88-&8- 9((8
$(%( -:
'&" (" &"%2
#(2
8-( *9'(
& $ $"#
"#+ +-&*#$
)&-F
"9'
1( $&&9
+%'&"9"#
8-&'(%%
% '( " (-)(-"# 8-&% %('* &"
(:9("'(/
//
"9*+ 8( & $-9
(=8
%('*-(
8-()(--(9
9%=%%(
F $9F"
/ E/ / 1((8"# :(F
8(-&9
=&-(
%*+%
8- -&#-(%%
"(9 :&*- '&"%9(-
8-&) -()(-("'(2
-(# -92
*9#=("
%%(9 !3 3 3 3 33 33 33 33 3 3 3 3
)B A$ )B A$ )B A$ )B A$
:(-%*% :(-%*% :(-%*% :(-%*%
"& $(- $(- $(- $(-G (:
F$(-(&) 9%
*"9(-,
H
%
(8 &#*( 8-"'8 (=(-#(,
!('&"9I%*''(%%:(
> $("'(
#-&*"9
!*'$
%('&"9I%*''(%%
F$( $(-
F $9F"I9%=%%(9
9%=%%
&- %('&"9I%*''
%*''((92 8( &"(-I
-(B*-(9 %$&F %*+%
=(-( %*8(-)'
&% ("
8$&-'
(;8-(%%&"
%((
+% - ' (9
%*+%
())(' :(
'&"%
J
& (;$ *% :( #*9(
F$
F&* '&"% * ( %*+% &F"
*"B*(
(=8 "& $"# +*
* & +(%
()
*9'
F%9&= %*'$ %('&"9I%*''(%%:( J
'$&&%
8( &"4%72 '&#("
*'
-('&-9(9 " "# %* %('&"9I%*''(%%:( 8( &"4%7/
:"#
%*''(%%)*
+&:( 9%'*%%&"2
&F"#
8( &"4%7
%*'$ (' (9
$(-(&)/
%:(
8( &"4%7
9%=%%(9
8-(%%(9I9%=%%(9 "&"8-&%('* &"
=(- %/
''(%%:(
8( &"4%7
(%%("
0I8(- "("
"#( '-'*=%
%$&F"# "%+ "#( F&* %*))'(/ ((1"# %('&"9I%*''(%%:(
4%7
&"% 8( &"4%7 %(B*("
"#( '-'*=% "'(%/
"(% 8&%%+
9&F"
"#( '-'*=%
(:(-0 ' %I'-'*=% "'(/ 1"# %*'$
&8 ("9( :&*-/
-#&2 %%*(
9%'-( &"
8( &"4%7/
%(% %('&"9I%*''(%%:(
*'9 %&"%
8(- "("
-(B*-(9
*'$
9(%8 ( %*'$
+("#
& $(- F&-9%2 *%(
'&*" ("
"'(9I(" (- "(9
%*'$
%('&"9I%*''(%%:( 8( &"4%7 9('8$(- &-9
9(- %%(9/M
//
8(-*%
C="
&-9(-%
%%(9
&*- 2 +-&*#$ )&- $
8( &"(-2 "9'
"9((9 8-&'- % "
$(-(&) % 8(- '*% &90
'(- )'
/ @/
-"
"(9 '&*"%(
%*))(-(9
8(-& &9
-%2 =&" $%
0%/
:(F (-2 -#&-
'
"9% * (9
#$ - - '
&"% * &"
/3/
$%
*9#=("
A* F"9(- :(-%*% A* F"9(- :(-%*% A* F"9(- :(-%*% A* F"9(- :(-%*%
*"
*"
*"
*"
%%( E E E E 4 <,,
<7G
0"#
9('9("9
*9#=(" % &"6+ !*8-(=(
*%%
A$ &&"
:%/ &=( !('0/2 $ 4@ ! @G +9*
($= "
:% /!/ 47
! <G *
!$ 1$ :%/
%$ -
"& $(- -2 437
G
&$9 *% K *%% :%/ 4 ( $7 -(8&- (9
3
!
3G -="
88(
&/<I
E/ /
H$
%F
!*+$ :%/ L(%
("#
MG H %$ 9$1 K K
:%/ L(% ("#
M2 !8('
.( 88(
4- /7
&/<<3 / @/
H &$ ==
") !$ 1$
:%/
*
MG -="
8 88(
&/
</ @/
&8
A-%$"
K
&8
-*%=
:%/ "&"
<
<
"1*-
$ *9$ :%/
9$0
- 9(%$2 47
E EG $*%,
HE/@/
-#$
%8((90
)(#* 8-(:("
*"9*(
";( 0
'&"'(-"
''&=8 "0"# =8 -=("
''*% &:(- -'$"# %&'(
" (-(% :"# -(8(
' * -('("
+&:(-()(--(9 !*8-(=( &*- 6%
9('%&"% &8(""# *8 "(F :%
%8((90
)*"9 =("
-#$
)(
+(- 02 &"% * &"/
-#$ %8((90
--(% F$'$ '&" "*(%
":(% # &"2 "B*-02
88(
8-( *9'(
-(%*
9*( =8 '&==%%&"
'&"%*==
)"
'&* -"#
B*'1 9%8&%
%"( B* &:(-'-&F9(9 &*- 9&'1( %2 8-(%%*-( 8-&%('* &"
'-="
*-%8-*9("
=('$ "%=
(;'*%( 1((8"#
''*%(9
"9()" ( 8(-&9 '-="
*% '( %0% (=2 $(-
#* " ((
%8((90
" ("9
=8&%"#
8-&'((9
%&"
$-(()& 8*-8&%(/ -%
8-& (' %
=8-%&"=(" G %('&"9
8*+ %*%8'&"
9*( *"-(%& '-
-%1
(:9("'(
%% #( =(2 $*%2 =8 -"# $=%( )/
#&(% 0"#
:(/ ''*%(92 8-(%*=(9 %*+ (' (9 8%0'$& &#'
8$0% &"(-&*% '&"9 &"%/ B*
%*'$
''*%(9 )-(B*("
0/
$(-(
"& $(-
'&"%9(-
#(/
(#
''*%(9 +("#
'&" - @
:"# '&==(-'
B* -#&*-% ("*=(-
&*- %
8-&%('* &-
:"# %)(9 %&"
#-&*"9% (:"# &))("'( -#(9I
(#(9
(;8(9 &*%
9 &88-(%%:( &"G = #
''*%
F(
'*-
"0 9()("9 $=%( )2 +* $(-(
%8((90
$% -#$
9('9("9
*9#=(" %
9&F"
%(-(% ) )*"9 =("
-#$ %/
'&"'(8 ( - '
(%%("
#* " ((9
8-(%(-:(9 &*-
+(#"%
' *
-(% -
''*%(9
'&"%(B*("
#(%2 #(
-(:%&"
"0 8&%%+ 8(-=%%+
:&9
%"'( &))("'(
'-="
8-&'((9"#%
:(- (9/
%8((90
B*
"&"
'-="
*-%8-*9("'(/
:0 :& *=( F&-1
-(%*
( & '(2 "9*+ 1((8% (" -( % -(%%
% - "/
%F&-9 =&'
"#"# =(/
9&(% %(-:(
"0 '-(9 1(%
)) -%/ 9(9
:&9 &88-(%%&"
8-(:("
8-&%('* &"
&+
9%8 '$/
#* " (( %(-:(%
''*%(9
&88-(%%:( 8-( (:(%
''*%(9
";( 0
'-="
-#(%
8-& (' %
&% =(=&-(% 9==(9
''*%(9 9()("9 '&"%(B*("'(% 8-( -
9( (" &"
""&'(" 2
8-&:("
& $(-F%(2
%'
9(8-:
&"%
)(2 *%*
=8&- " 2 +*-9("
9( (" &"
""&'("
=(=+(-%
%8('
F$'$ 9(%(-:(% (# &"%
-(
'&==(-'
B* " 0
@</
L$ '&"%9(-"#
1((8 ="9 @< F$'$
''*%(9
-"# 8*+ F"
'&"9 &"% F$'$
''*%(9 #*
1( '&==
"0 &))("'(
F$
% -"#("
-#&*-% =*% =( '* &*% %'-* "C(9
)*"9 =("
-#$
%8((90
-("9(-(9 "*# &-0 *"F
- '*
F$(-( %*'$
04%7
*% )(9
("9 8-&%('* & 1(8 +($"9 -%
-()*#( -#&*-%
9&F"
!(' &
(#%
*-( F%9&=2 &-9(-
%(% 8-&:9(9 3 ' /
&F (0( 8-& - ' (9
0%
%0%
(#%
8*-8&%(/
+('&=( '&=8 :&
"& F $% "9"#
"0 $"# '&"
"(9
#&:(-"(9 -# @<2 =*% % -1(
*9'
" ("
'*-+ =("
9-*#%
(;8(9 &*%
-& *%(2 -%1% "%)&-="# 8-( -
&* '&=(
" $( '
8-"'8 -#&2 *"(B*:&'
'&"'
*9( F $"
&"2
+(- 0 " (9
&:(--9"# * &-0 (=+ -#& '-( @< '&"%9(-(9
F&-9%2
8(-
#-&*"9 *"9*(
@</M
@< <
'19-&8
''*%(96%
-#$
)(
8(-%&"
+(- 0
-- " (9
0%
*9'
8-&'(%%2 "( $(-
-+*
''*%(9 "&-
'&#("
%&"%/ "
"9:9*
"&-9"
8(-&9
1"# @</
("%*-( %8((90
9%8&%
'&"% * &"
%8('
&*- % F(:(-2 *-"
( %&"6%
(= "())'("'0
)-*% - 9* 0+&*"9 ("%*-(
9&(%
"9:9*
6% )*"9 =("
-#$ %2
* (/
L$
#&*-% '&*%
"'( +( F(("
(#%
'-&% -#$
''*%(9 "#(9 &"2
*% ) 9( (" &"
8*" :( =8-%&"=(" 2
*% '(
(B* 0/
")(-("'(
F$(-(
=(2 -(%* 8-& &"#(9 8-('&*% )*"9 =("
-#$ %
)(
"92
%*'$2 '&"9 &"
+(- 0 8(- ' %
#:("
& $(- ""# '&==(-'
B* " 02 )( (-(9
//
*- $(-2
8(- '*% & &90 '(- )'
=* %(%I %/
' *=
#-&*"9 %*) ))'("
)2 9('
"( '&"'(%%&"
B*(% &"
F$("
&*
B*
B*(% &"
&'"
' %I'-'*=%
/ (
"'( -(#
'(9
*9#=("
&"6+ !*8 8-(=(
&$9/
&$9/
&$9/
&$9/
=- :/ // =- :/ // =- :/ // =- :/ // /
/
/
/
"& $(-2
"& $(-2
"& $(-2
"& $(-2
47
<@ 47
<@ 47
<@ 47
<@ G
:%&"
("'$
*9#=("
&"6+
'*
#$ !-9$ :/ (2 @ 47 !-9$ :/ (2 @ 47 !-9$ :/ (2 @ 47 !-9$ :/ (2 @ 47
EE
EE
EE
EE >
*9#=(" % & &*- &/3@@
1$ 1$ 1$ 1$ 1$ (%$ !"#$ :/ 1$ (%$ !"#$ :/ 1$ (%$ !"#$ :/ 1$ (%$ !"#$ :/
9('9(9 // 2
:/
:/
:/
:/
@ 4-
@ 4-
@ 4-
@ 4- -="
/ -="
/ -="
/ -="
/
!*))'( 9( ("
" &"
*"9(- -
-- " (9 ' %
'- -'*=%
E/
:(F
+&:(2
&F(9/ ( &"(-
&-9(-(9
)*-"%$"#
I%*-( 0 +&"9%
%) .9/ '&"'(-"(9
& &*- I* 0 #% - (/
99 &"
'&"9 &"%
'&"'(-"(9
&*- I* 0 #% - (2
-(= +&*"9
&F"#
'&"9 &"%, 47
47
9&'*=("
-02 9*-"#
47
=%*%(
+(- 0 " (9/
=8(-
"0 (:9("'(2
+%("
$=%(
"0 +()&-(
4:7
'&==
"0 &))("'( F$
4:7
9(8&
&*- /
4:7
#:(
":(% # ))'(-I!
"#( 8(-=%%&"
& 4:7
%%8&- 2
"02
8$&"( "*=+(-
'&"'(-"(9 &
8$&"( "*=+(- 8-&-
*- I
#% - (/
"0 ""(-
4:7
%*+= = 2 )-% F&-1"#
(:(-0 =&" $2
))9 &*- 2 ())('
'&==%%&"
"0 &))("
&))("'(
+("# 2 %%
=&:(2 )&- $F : 2 +()&-( '&"'(-"(9
"'(
+("#
)&*"9
"0 ("
-#(9
))9 & $(-F%(2 F $2 "'(
@
@
F$'$ +* '&*- =(- % $(-(&)/
-%(2
&'"
@/
+-(
"0
)&-(% '&"9 &"%
$&%(
F$'$ '&"'(-"(9
& &*- I* 0 #% -
9-(' (9
$(-("
+&:(
%$&F"#
"0
& $(-
%*))'("
*%(2
(I'&=8
+(- 0 =& &:( "'(
/
-9(-(9
''&-9"# 0/
& $"# $(-("
+&:(
'&"% -*(9
(;8-(%%&"
&8"&"
=(- %
/
!"'( 9('9(92 8("9"# =%'(
"(&*%
&"2
"02
"9% 9%8&%(9 &))/
*#*% *#*% *#*% *#*% :-
L$( $(- %8( L$( $(- -(8&-
4! .
! .
! .
! .7
"#I-( %&"(9,
(%I&
(,
(%I&