Ranjeet Singh v. Permanent Lok Adalat & ORS
!"#
$$%% &'( ')*%+(,%-%.!'/+!'#'
$
' '
!
!
0''+/'#$$%% (%+% 2'. '
!(',#!/'+/' '
(3+/''$4 55555
6#'('$$%('%(7#'+ %# (") $,.#%'!"%3("+ )"#8'$8#%($#%"#''
$,.#')*%+(,%-%.!'/+!' ' #'9 -!:+8#',.#$$%%,.#$$%%(' ! ; # "% !'/ (#'. + <= #'' '''9# <=:'%)$('"') ('$%.+8) !(%.+ # $$%% # $('# #' #'!'$/#% >+8##8")$''. '"' 4 2<<?>> 6# /#% 8 (' 8
>
,. '$ 4 66 @1 1'% @(';)$. 6#/#%8$'%.,.#'#' A% !'/ '$ 4
' )$% $$'8'*+#(#'B%'#/#%%/'#$ %"8#,%%
#'/""#? >+#/#%8 % ($ ) # # ," "/ # $%+ A@ 4 >
>('! <@;+"(*8$' 8'"' > 6#''+ $') '"' 4 2>?
8 " #/#% #'"''= >
C('8(+8##/%($> <
6#$$%%%"%)8##'$(' )$.,#(''$'"/,.#$%(#' 6# ('%)#$$%%8'$(,.#(')$. # "'( # # ') # (' $%.
C(' # , /%+ )(# ('" # (''. )$''.'"'+8##8/%%.' .+$$% '$')'"'#/#%#,)D# # # * $% ' # C$'. # )$''. '"' ','$$%'$')'"'(%#/ ,)
6#$$%%+""'/,.#'$(#(' %)+ % $ (' ! ; # <= '
& %) $( '" ') # (' $%. C(' #%) )#'('+8#'"'#'$'## /#%+ 8## % '"' ($' A@ 6# -!+ )#$+/8'
C(' 0"""'/+#$$%%/* (',.8. /% 8' $ (' '% ? # ;( @+ 8##8"4 ;E
<
6#($'8'$8),.#%'!"% 3(" / (") + 8#% '''" # ('. $'/('! <> #'&#%+
<== ','/.9&:+$%"'%($#
#"'%(&'
!%%""'/+#$$%%#%# (") #'("##%'$$$%
-$ # $$%+ '$ 4 ' $$'#'("#(%#$$#)+8#%" # (")$,.#%'!"%3("8%%#,.# -! $ 4
F -!G $'') '$ 6#%( '$4
##(#%'# $('$$('##/#%+8'','(*')# ''.'$+/'' >
2+#(' )$. '$ 4 # %. " '$ # $$%
'
'(%'#$$%%(,)## (") ($ 8## '% # , $% ,. -! 8%% ,. # %' !"% 3(" $$%,% # $' @ ('#' (,)#
($'+#/#%8," 9'/:8#($')'"'+)$%('! < #& @#$'+#$$%%8("# /#%8$'*(##( '/'+$''##+ # $$%% # %'. " # /#% $ ') # (#'. ''#'H('A') #;'%' &#%(%+ <=< '#'9#(%: 6#(+##%.(,) # '. () ' $." # 'H( % ' $') '"'+ 8## 8 = @ ('#' (,) # # /#% H( # , ( $') '"' ' /% ') = > ($ > <+ '8##('.$'/#+#'8/% . # ') # $%.+ (# % $% # (")
! '$'" #% ('
' '+ %' (% ' '$ 4 (' )$. (,) # # /#% , '/ %. ' $'$' '"'#$'+#/#%8,"(8#( '"'+ 8## $(#,% (' # & 6# $$%'$')'"'8)8##/%. # )$''. '"' 8 $$% %. ' C$'. @ ('#'(,)#')!>
#&+
$''#))),.#'&#% ))+ < ;'% 4 < 8
+ # )$''. '"'8/%%.'$'C")#8 '8,% @ ('#' (,) #
!
($'+# (")'',.#2:,%$C;('
($' # , ' % $% "
! #"%"'"(+8#'#'
($' #,$$% = E#/#'%'(%'#$'8##' ,%$'(#% < @$(,%.+ # $$%% $%. #%' # $('# 8 /#% >+ 8## # )$''. '"' ' )$%" # '. ')%+ # $$% ' $') '"' 8 ) = >+ #8/'+ # /#% H( 8%')(##(#$%.#%'#'/" "#? 6#$')'"''8( 8# /%. ') = > ($ > < 8 " '"'(),'2>?
<
@#$'+#(',%*$% > #$'/%8+$$%,%('"#$', A'$'$'$$'+! <> +#.$'' ," ) ,. # ;'% 4
<+ ' '$'( #'('
I&(
# J4 $' #%% '/ . )' /#% 8' )' /#% #%%('$')#/#%,'/.$(,% $%'.#'$%(%#/#%'"' ' 8# # ;#$' # ' '"' # /#% # , ($ ' %% # /#% '' '"' )'* $%.#$'',)' '/##"##%%$$%. )' /#% $ %' (, (# ).,$'',,.#;'%1/') 555 '&$ J
48#" .#" ! > # 8' )' /#% ). $$%. . '"'" (#'. ' #' $'', (#'. #/ # /#% )$''%. '"'#$'',)''#(# $'',)')$''.''"' )$''.'"')'*
'"' ) (' # #%% , /%%.'$'C")#+#%% ,'8,% '/#8#')'/#%'"' #8##,.#,##) 8'*#$ ,. # $' )# ' ," 8# ,. ' . (' '(),.#'%#8'+#$' ).+$.)(#+.+).,$'',+ , C ,. (# ('#' $' ' $' # '"'" (#'. ' #' $'', (#'.+ # ).,+).%%8
@8#'#)'/#%#%(' #'$('# "')+ % ' #.$#+ #
!
'"'"(#'.'#'$'',(#'.#%%( )$''.''"'(#/#%+8## #%%'$'%",%.$')%.#(%%) '#$'8#8#)(#"')#, ',.#8'
K
,'$'(%! <#8#$'#%%'/ )'/#%.$(,%$%8#(/%'"'"',. # '"'" (#'. ' 8# # $'/ & '"#$'/!> +#8'#/#%). $$%. # '"'" (#'. ' )$''. '"' )$''.'"')'* @(#)$''.'"'"',. #(#'.+#%%,/%%.'$'C")# 6# $'/ ! > ('#' %' # # $' ). , C'(#('#'$',.#'"'"(#'.%.# $(% #' ' ! > $'/ # $'(' ' '"' # '%/ $'/ #' ' '$'(#'('''' I'" )*+,-./-+01 203 -0 4) 5/6)J
$$%,.',#%#8')'/#% ' '"' #%% , (# ') #%% , )$ ,. (# ()+ $'(%' ')#%%,)8#(#$')., $'',,.#;'%1/') '/#8#')'/#% %.8 ,.)'$'#+#$$%#%%,),. #),#%%%#8'(#$$% #%%,),#8'#)'/#%'# $('$#
$$%'''(,
#%% , )$ ,. (# ). , $'', ,. # ;'%1/') K 555 I
@#8'%)*$$%(' (,
+'+#).,+('(, = 8##$'$'',+#'"'"(#'.).+ #/"'"'#'()#+'H('# 8'$.+%(.#).,*" #) (' + (# )( C" #(' '($ ). , $'', (' (,
'/#(' #%%,* " # 8' 8#' # 8' % $. # )(
E#'#8'#$#)(('(,
+ #%% , * " #) ('
A' # $('$ (,
+ # ! 1/')).$'',')(#/"'"' #$'%.#$'#8')*" $$%('(,
'(, = K
6#%.('"''8##'#
-! # %' !"% 3(" 8' '' #%" # # $$%%%%))$')"'$ ###/#%+8##8$'*(#$$%%:#( #"'(####+#/#%#//% '"')$%('#$'/! <> #&
6# ' $( ;%.+ # /#% 8 (''#$'') >
6#8/#%
( 8 " )$''. '"' ' )$''. '"')'* -$#$$%%$$%."'$')'"'+ #)8$$')'"')'*8" #/#% $.#'"''#,$% '' C(' + 8## #8 # # ) /% ') = >> <8(= >+ #/'.C .'##
'(%'#$$%%#'((%. # # /#% 8 ," 9'/:D $" $') '"'+8$'*(#$$%%:#(')8#'8 % @'"(#! <#&''%. '/"/#%(%(%.'"' /#%+8## ,"()'%.$'*,)#/'/ #('.$'/('! <# @ ('#'##*%#%'!"%3("# ''%.$$'# (")'',.#2:,%!($') ;('
($'
@
($'+ # %) 8 # C+/%/"/#%+#)$''.'"' 8###C$' @8#%,.#2:,%$C;('##('' 8%,%#C+,'/(' I( E #/ $'( # '' $ ,. # #' '() 6# %. ( ' ' + 8##' # 4% ;)) '' %8 #%" # # $$%% % %) )$ ' )" '$ # /#% 8# )%. # /#%8,"'/#8#(.
" /% '"' )$% (' # $'/ ! <!> #'&#% K I" @$(,%.+ )$''. '"' 8 "' '$ # /#% H(+ 8## # C$'
#%%"*$% 8# # /#% 8 8#( . '"' 4#" # , ,'("# '' ,. # $$%% #8 # ,' ' '
+ 8# # $' )$''.'"'C$'+#$$%%+8'# /#%+ #' $$% ' $') '"' )$% (' ! < # ' ) . $$%'C$')$''.'"' # "'( ) $% ' @ (' /8+ #''+ (" /#% # $(,% ' 8#( . '"'%.$(#,%('!
< # ' &#% ,( % ()% ,'##')$%.' K
@
! ($' # %) 8 # C # /#%+ # )$''. '"' 8## # C$'+ ') $% ' .+ 8#' # , '/ $$%."#'
($'+#''#$ #2:,%!($');('#%(' I"'@#$'+#)$''.'"' #'$L/#%#C$'=
4%. 8#/#%'/+,(%*#'.+8#' 8 /'"# $% #' # # '$L$') 6#'#"''("" # # '$ # $$% ' '"' ' # # 8 8" '"' @ # '()+ #'
F ><!;; >G$$%+ # $ # ;(' 6#
F > < !;; >G8#C+))'% $#+#'$$%#/#%*
""
3#$('+8#'##*$% @H(+ ##'8$%."#'+8#8%D # )'% # %.+ 8 '/ # $%')8#'8%+'#C$'.)$''. '"' 0( ' #+ # '$ 8(% #/ '/ ,* # /#% E# )$' # ;('L $ # %8+ # 8# (',% # $%%. '(% %,%. ('+ #' #(% , ()% ,'# # # ' (' 6#''+ # #+ # /#% # , '/?( 8#( /% '"'+ )("%'/%! < <# '&#%+ <== K
$(#,/#! <#& $'#,)'/#%'),"'/+(%#)'"' 28/'+#$'/%'"'")'$(# /#%+,"'/'(+ $'*8'#(+ "'"+'#'/%,%'"(%'$%$'*"
@##+)'%#,$%,'(' . # , ''' ,. %' (% ' # '$+ )$'($#;('##/#%H(8,"'/' (+'/#('.$'/ 6#(+%'(% '#'$'$$(##(%$ #',/ # / , ,. %" $$'$' $%"?/ @ # , # /#% H( ," '/?(+$'/%8#8#/,/% (#+')('$%.+#'"'+'#8#/, ,'#
"
= @8(%%,"(%''#,'/)
($'+ 8#' ' # $' )$''. '"' # C$'+ # + # 8' # /#% # #' $$% ' $') '"' ' ) . $$% ' C $' # "'( ) $% ' 6# ('#$'#$$%%+ 8' #/#%+#%.*$'#'"'#/#%,( # '"' ' 8 % ( $('( (# $$% )= 6#$'%)$''$# /#%',"#'H('A') #(% 6# '%/$'#A')+'$'(#'(' I;M6@A@;6M A@4!M;6@ 4 A &M2@;M ;' # # $'(%' # $$%''(##/#%)$%8## 'H(')#'&#%+ <==+#(% )#'('
4
!"('#@$"(#'. 4)
"
M')
#
K
< '/'+$'(%(,
!> #&8(%#8##$$%''"'$') '"' , ) / ' # $' $'',+ (, $.)#$'', !>
('#'$(%#($ (#$.)('(,
+#%%,*"# 8'#/#%H(('! # 6#
"& /#% H( #/" , '"' " $') '"' )'* ( '"' ' /% ') = > > <+ 8(% , ' (% ''. #8+ # # ) 8 %. ' )*" ( )$% !> #(%')#'"' @#%"##,/+
($' "(#,% $$%,%# 2/""/('#("#(%'# # %' "% 3("# ;('
!
($' 8##8,"$'' -!+#,. )'%,'("###;('##/#%H( 8,"'/?(+8'"')8##'"'' #' 6#'%/$'# (")C'#'('+ ''' I6# # '$ 4 $('# 8 0%''+8##8('8##$')$. ' # $' ') < < = < = $( A('#'+ $( # 8 %
= A'' "#%)+#$'("# ' ( # # # /#% 8 '"' ! < # 8 ''' + 8## )*'"'/#%)'.'$%."# ' @$(##/#%#$' 8,"$%'8# K
@#%"##'(+#$''(' $$%%%8 (%%.+#)$(" (") )" ;E
< 8%% # 8'
"'
$,. -!' 6#('%)$$%% ,.#8'$'?$$%%%%8#C##(' )$. '$4 #%%,%).#$$%%' ###/#%+,'',..#'$'/%8 # $'('%)$'#.' >)'#
.' #/ %$+ # (' )$. ' $ # ($' (' %) $$%+ ' 8#%8+ 8# $' 8)#').
6# ' $$% $ # ' ') # % #
%
E##'$*"?' N 4 E##'$',% N 4