← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1446/2018dismissed

Rakesh v. Union Of India & ORS

2019-10-31Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu7 pages

       

 !"  

 

      

  !

"##  $ % & '((   # (   !# $ !%&%!'  $ !% %% 

  )*%+

)!,  "(  - ! )"+ .

! "(    !

   

/ "(    # (  

 )"+"  "(    # (  

  %% '  1!2

  "## !

 (3  !

,%(3+ ( 

    (4 !& '(( 4-!

5 !

- #    5 !

 - (+ (  1!

 ##   !(   (  !

 -  #     ! 33  !

( (67( +3!+ ! ! (( %  -( 2 8  !#!

 , (

 '9% 7 !

# (  % (: !% & 8%(       *       2 8     *!

  $   %  $  8+ $   ( %3+ .!

5 $     1!



 ## (    2 8(  !#% ;# < 5 // -% % !

(-  !

( 77$(

( (7 !

- (  + %  = >?

-(@ ($     ;@$</ -% !

 A%

% +  ( %+  +   (# 

- !7 -  3(5 ' -#  ( !    - %(

+( (%3 @ ($      ;@$< 1!

#   (  ( !

+ %  = >?( ( +( ( (7/    ( (  67    - (  5      ( ( +3!+ ! !

-  %( 3  !

@ ( $     1!

 #  (  B 

- C

 



 



     



  



   ! " 







  #  $

&'

 



 ()* +")  * ,") * -.& / 01+%23"

4   5  ,-6"  7  8  )  9 



      

  

 :  ; 

    <    =   

 

!;=' 

4 "-

  * +#               >=

 ?  #

       >  >      

 

 "         

(  

!;==

 

>@ >   !;=  



   



 

                 

 1  3A "#  !

( !

-  ( 3  13





 



     13       

 

   



   ! "  





  # $

13'

 



 ()* +") * ,") * -.&/ 01+% 23"4 5 ,-6"78)  9



      

  

 :    :

2(*3 9%(3 3   -   5  !

 (3 %(  ,   ' -!   ! !

!(% + (##  ( 3 ! " 

/( !

( (76!(  + ( !

# (  :! 

%+ # 2+ ( !       ( *-  

/ :%(3* /  !(

 %( ! # 



(

*!+$!

DB  ! ?''

/!(



/%+*3!

 !



##   "#  %  ( (6# ( !

8  )

3 # 

 =  ! 5!(

 (  ++   5 



(

- + 3

  =# 1!

 5 5!(% + (4

 ,   4   3(3 !

% (#  88 -1!%

(#  %(

% (   %  3 -' - (35 3% ( !  !

# (  - - 3   3  (  !

 (   "  

/( ,  3 !

         = 2(*3 9%(3 !

( !  !

#    ( ( !( 

  +(     !

  ,       !

 +    !

 ##   67((!

  %( !

  

( ' -

 ( !  !

 !( (    !

-5  +   ( !

+#%3 (     ,  3  !  + -        " (35  !

 #     - (+ ( 6 2( %   !

 !#+53% ( !  !

 ( (  76  !( 

 ((  (  5 !

 " 

 # (  

5!( , +  '! #    ( (!

!(

5(- !

   # (     "   3 ( (76/

3% ( !  !

2( *3 9%(3 !  (!

(3 !  !

 ,   " 

/!(

%3!    # (    !

5!( , ( !

+   7 1!

    (

 !

# !

 '    + !

# (3 !  !

#    ( (% +

)  !(

 -( :! 

%+ # 2+ (( 

( (1!

 !+ ! (   ( (    ;" B% ?  "?=<   +  !

 :!

%+   #   2+  -!

  !

 

  ( (  76  ( + !

"  

/!

( ((!

 %(

 ? % (   + 5 - ! !

A%  1!

(  # (%

- C0            

 

$ ;

!;=2+%,B2,,     

   

 !;= ' 

  0    ?% • C 

  " 



=

 

  

      8 "'  

         "

 

  D  • 

   .2-

 



   ! "

• # $

   &2+

   

  

!;==

   "

    

  D  •  

            

6&2+ 

 "     

       

          &&2+                 

 -&2+ $      &B2+"

&B2+"6B2+ ,.2+ 

  6B2+"  .B2+"  -B2+    .2+



   #   &.2+ 

   

    

 

    "

    

     

    

    

       

          

 

 " E7

   

    

 "     

    B        

  6&2+"           

     =

     "

  D  / "         -62+

  #   $ " 

   " 

     

        

    C   

" 

   "

%CC     

   

   6B2+ 



!;==

 

 "  

    ;

                   #   $ "

 

 



D                  

&2+ -62+ 

   •

 "&    "

     

    

  



   



        0          E7     

               F              



@

   

*      $ ! $!;="E7

6-2+   

  

+2+    "

 %

:! 

%+ # 2+ (E + 1!%    !

 

  ( (  76   + !

 " 

/(

  5 !

A%    ' - !

 +   !

+    1!% (+ ( &%!"  %% "

     +,-./('

0 3 !

*#  3>  ( F !

  

>