← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4737/2013allowed

Mukhtiar Singh And ORS v. Jalandhar Improvement Trust And ORS

2016-05-27Mr. Justice Arun Monga12 pages

      



 



   !"

#$ %"&'('#) * + + ,

+



 

     

    

  

 +



 

     

    

  

  *  - . +

  /.



 

   ! "   #$ # %  $      ! " 

 &' # %  $    ! " 

 &( #  )(*+*),-'+$   .  ! " 

 &( #  ),(/*),-''$ ' 1  " !  2 % 3   

5 ,  % "     5 + 1  4

  %   5  /.

+

.    "     " 3  %



  

 

   

  !"#$" %    & 

  '

     

  !"#$" %    & "     ! "   )

  

   !  

 %"

"   ""#$ %  

 3  3  "  



6   +  7   "  ! 

   4% 3   ! '66,  

   # " ! 88$ !9  

" 

 ! !!" 

 "     %

&'(-- 

      -/-,'6::         "  ': -//;) %

,/< "    3  3 +- 2     3 

%2     .2 .!    ,/-+'6::   ""#$ "   

,='''6:: 

    !   

)

"

       "    2% 2  >!   ""#$    3 3 3 

':-6'66/ 

"  ,'-6'66/   

!

!

  ! !   )  "         

  " " 

2  ! 3     



   "      ""#$

 " ! ! "     " " 

 &+) ?%!

  3    >! !

 

 "

 

"  4

!      ()*+ ,

  !"#$" % ( ""   9

"   " " 

 &()



 .

3  !

 @ %   " "! !    3

 "   ""#$ 

 

!2 "  !    A   % "   

! 2  ! !    

 "3

"

)      

                

 

     

           

   

  

 !"  #  $  

 %& 

       

 



 

 

    

            

$    

          '

    

  

  

 

(     )   

%*   !  ! ! "   &'(--  '(+/= !

! "   "   "" 



 

)

"

 &+)?%!

  %   %   ! 

 %

   ""#$ 

     %2 

)

"

 &+)?%!

  " " 



)

&(   %   %   

"

 &' 

,  4

%  %

!  )    " "   #$)  ""#$ 

   " "

 3  3 "   %2   

 %2 



 .

 3  A   4

! '--',-'' 2

3   " 



 . 

    ""#$      !   "   

,-- 9 2  

!   "  " '-- 9 2   "

 &( 

"   ?%!

)

)

"

 &+ 3 3

2    

'   

>! "  4

!   " 

 

  %   %  3  "   " 3! 2  %



%2  ! !! ! 3 3 @ " %     -

   .#  / 

  !"#$" % 0  0 12*   &     ! " 

 &(  



 . 3 "  A 

   " 2 

+--/,-'' 3%2    "  3  A

'--',-'' 3     "    31 *  4

 3 "

3! 3     ,,-*,-'(  "   "3



 )  

+  ,    

,          -        

.

- 

              #     

     ,     .

-  

 )

       -  .

-  ,     

     &              &     

* @ %  @ 8%  A   

 

%!     A %  "   %

31  4

        4

! "   A    "  3! 3 

" 

  ! " !

 ! !

!  %2 32 " 

   ! 

 3   

 "

 3   "     ! " 

 &() 



 .   "  3    %! "   ""#$ 

 3  A " 

 !     !  ! 

%!      A       3   "  A     '--6,-', 3!    )  #  

 

         

  

   

        '/

'

#     #  0  

        

 - &    +    -    #)

      -                 

 &  

   

             

       ,  

, -       - 

  #        #    0      $    )

      

&    ,  -           #  0       

 -          +  

        

  #       

    

  

  

 )

  - 

  1 &        

 -  '" /'

' ($ #   

 

 2     

 /'

'

 .34 #(%%*  "    %  %2   #$)  ""#$    

  @ %    ""#$       "  

    '6*/  

  !

 

 >! !

        ! " ?%!

     2  3   3 

" !    3    2  "



 %2  3  A " 

  ""#$      "   

,-- 9 2   2   !      "    3%2   %

&'(--



  %     A " >

  

! 2  !  2    ""#$  %      "  "  

    A " ""

 "

 

 %2   A      !  

 %" "  

 &') %   ! ! "    3 "!   

4" "  "! 

 ! += " 

 4% 3   ! 3   -(-,'6:( 

   '6:+  3    

       3 

  , !  !9 3 %     

,-- 9 2      %! 

"    3  A    ""#$  %  "   

,-- 9 2  

  %2           "  % !  "  

" ?%!

 % %2 



 .   .

   !  

 %" " 

 &()



 . %   " "!    !

 %

&,(*6 " ,-''  %

 % @ 8%  A     ,,-*,-'( %   !   % 

%!      A   !      )

   2    ""#$  )       A 3

!     " !   "

 

 %2 @  A 

 3   3  A 2 " %    !   

 

,,-*,-'(    

"  ! %"   A    ""#$  %   4 !

" ! !      %  " !

  %

  2  %   "!

-+-6'6*(  

"

?%!

 3 !9

     '6*/  3 

   ?%!

 3      "   

'   

"  "



 %2  3  A  

 %2        "  % !     2   %   !  "! 2 " %   !      " ?%!

    %2 

! !     % !

     2    !! %! 2 " %    "   ""#$     %   3  %2 7  ,  , A A  "   

 %9   !  %   "   3 " 3    " 7  ,+  ' A A  3 3 3

 "    3    "  !

    ! "

! 2 " %     !

   4

! '--('6:/ 3%2       ! " ?%!

      %

!

!  %

    %

&++:  9   

  

   % %   "3

%  9  " 3 3  "  

) ' 1  4

! '--',-'' " 

3  A 

  ""#$ " 

2 "  " 



,-- 9 2     

4" , 1   ""#$       "  

5 + 1  ! "   )

   ?%!

 

 

!2 "  "     

4" ( 1  ! " ?%!

 3 "  B  "

!   " '6*(   '6:+ 5 / 1  4

! '--6,-', 

 %2  3  A " 

   !  ! 

%!      A   

4"      !  "   

   % 

"  3   3 > %2  3  A  

    "   ""#$    

,-- 9 2   "!2  !  ! 3  '6:+  3! 3       3

  "!  

"! "  "

! 3   -(-,'6:(   ""#$ !

   % " "  

!  3           "   

     " !     " '6:+  '6*/  3    !   %

! %2   A " !

 " "! !         4       %     !  



! "   !  %    3

 %        

,-- 9 2     ""#$ % %4!   %2 "  '6:+       ! " ?%!

 3       "   

       "  3     2  ! '--('6:/   " 3%2   %

&++: 

'   3    %      

       >! !

 ! !  ! " ?%!

 

""    2  3!       "  3     ""#$ %       ""#$    !     2    " !    3  !

     "  !      ! "     "

 

!   " 2    2  >!



 32 %!   2 '66+ 3%2 "

 &(      . "    !

 %

&,(*6 "

,-'' 3

 %  !  2     !

  3 "  "!   A      !   

! '--('6:/    "!   %  "   .        ! "  ""#$ 3 % " 3  !" " 7  ,  , !  7  ,+  ' A A   ! 

   3  2 "    ! 3  ! "

!  ! !



2  !  !!    ""#$ " !9

  3

 " ""

  

>! "  4

! '--('6:/



3  4

! '--('6:/  "



 %2  3  A 

!

       " 

%!  % !     %  3      

!! %!  ! 3  "3 .

 ! "  

   % 3

3! 3           % ! !  3 "  "!     ""         ""#$    '6:+    "  3   4

! '--6,-',    5

 

%!      A     )

  2      %   2 " 3

!!

2  4

! '--6,-',  %2     %  9 " 3 %

&/   3 " "

  ""#$ 

  

#$ !!

2   %

  

  %2 3      4

! '--',-''    '

  %2  "   >     " "   ""#$  ! "   

,-- 9 2     '6:+   %    @3   "  "

  



  

%2     

   " !2 "  >!   %2    

 !    "  %

&'(-- 

  " "  

) "

 &(  



3  !9 2 "  ! 3



"    !

        "3

!

)  !   ""#$ !   "   "    

3  !  %2 ""

,/< "

 ! "       

   "  !9

"  

 %2   ""    "  3  " ,   "  !  "

!   !   ""#$  %  %2   

 ! !!

2   %

  '

  2 3

 /.



 + + , 2