Hardeep Kaur And ANR v. Punjab Public Service Commission And ORS






   
   

 ! "#$%$&'(')*   
 
 
 


!!

"

#"

"

$%
 %!&'
()&'
*++&""& 
 "


," 

"
   *  +  ,
-
,


.
  ,
  +  ,


 
.  "

-


&
( .
)' 
!!

"

/// /&"
&"

&

0'
!


*! "
1
 


"


.
2& "


 
$ 2+

 
 .
 
%3
! 
(& 2!
4 2.
)&
5&'

5&

 
%3

!!

"

 
'

'


 "
5
&"+&""


%&  '

"

)
!

!!

"

'



'& 2"
5 !
%
6&



/


$%
 %!&'
()&'
*++&""&
 
" .
7 *++&""& 8
&""



) &"+

 9

&!!


"

"
 "'


 & .
* &)
('& &"
& 
*
; +

.

$%
/
5&

<6+& 
"&
"

"
5"
!
  = =
!

2.

>

5"
"
& 
&



"&"
&
(
78.
7?8.
7*8
 
7;8.
%

!!

> "
&
'
"&"
5
"+
5&


 !3
&

 '


+%& 2
 
> "
&
'
 
"&"
/
*++&""& !

>
%@!
"&"
78
! 2
5& 
& "


 "5"

& "


&'&!
5%"& .
 
)&

 %!&'
&'.
 
 = =.
)& 
%$'

"
+

' "


 "5
@3
+ 2"

.
%$'

5"
!"
&"


 "5

>


&
> %@!
"&"
78
&'


%!5

0#') %!




5"

&2 "5
)&
& 
 "5
@3
 
''

"5
5"
0#') 1!")% &!
-

A     


 

 



   !" # $   
 
 

   
 # $  
 

  #$  
  
 
#$

 & 
6 "
5
% & 
%3

*++&""&
%"&"
5
&
5"
' '!




2 1!  &!35"

&2 "5

>



,"

!

!3.

)&"
 "5
@3

"&"
(
78
 ! 2
5& 

'+%& 
+& 0!&"

5"
!
%3

*++&""&  =
+

!!


&2 

 9
 
!!

  
& 
+& 
"& '
99
' "
5

%
' 
& B !
* 23.
3
5
5!!
5& 
C 

%& 2
' 
"
"'


 & .

5"



'""
!&@
&

)&5
 '

%
'  '


5).
% 

'

"!!& 2
' !
'++ '.

5&
 %& 2
*D


 =
)415"67"#(6 4)8"1 419'&,$:6'&$ ;;'((')")%")#5$:
5"
&!
""&!& 2

)&"
 "5
@3



'+%& 
+& 0!&"


2


' !

%
5
''

"5"


> 
/
*++&""& .
)& 2
' "
 '
& "
'& 2".
"

%+&




' "'& "
'&"&
5"
@ 
5& 5


 >


&
%@!
"&"
78
& "!


2

> !
+@"

!!
' "
''& 2!3.
)&

 
  .

"&
5&
 5"
&""

"
&

'

"
D

.

 %!&'
&'
 
  
5"
&""


%3

*++&""&
5& 5& 2
>


%@! "&"
78.
 
%"
 
)&"
 "5
@3
 
+& 0!&"

5"
'&'

! 

  
 .

*++&""&
5
E
+@"

!!


' "
'""

%

>


.

!!

".
5
5

+&
"&
 9
 .
5
5
!'



=
 .
"'

&)!3
:

5"
2& "

&"
%'@2

.

!!

"
&!

 .
"
& &' 
%).
 
""&!

 %!&'
&'
 
  .
5& 5& 2
>


%@!
"&"
78
 
+& 0!&"

5"
)&"

&
 &+






"!!.

'"
 
!!

"
% 

! 
(& 2!
4 2
"
!"
& "
'& 2"
&"
"5

>


&

A#$

F.
)&
& 
&2& !
 "5
@3.
5"


&2 "5.

 "5
'

& 
&
0#') "!
5"
5 2
 .

 .
0#') %!
' !
)
%

&2 "5
D&'
&"
53.
)&
)&"
 "5
@3
 
 =.
 "5

>


5"
'!
"
0#') 1!")% &!
G .
&
>


"


+

+%&2 3
 
0#')( 1!")% &!
5

''

"5".

5"

''"& 
*++&""& 
)
5& 5
>




H
&""

'
 &'.

*++&""&
' "
 '
% 

5&
* 
5"
&'



&!


&)&
&
"'

&
% & 
+

6 "
> 
>



 .

E= .


(' 3
 
*++&""&
%3
53


&)&
"


& "
"



)
%
'&)
+

"

%$'

6 "-


  %  &'(  !
 
)*  


  
     !   





 
 


    !+ ,+- 
 )  


 


  )        !)
  ! 
   

 %  .'
# $ #$


  !)  # $
 + - /

    ! 0  +  / 
    !


 ) + !


  
  
     !0 +  



  1

0)



 # $    
   
 0)

 

 

23
  
  "


"


 
*++&""& -
&' 
& 
6 ".

*++&""&
( %
*++&


'&

''

"5

%
 1!")% &!
5).
"

%">

!3

*&)&!
D&
 

 =
5"
&!
""&!& 2

)'& 3

>


%@!
"&"
78.

"&
>
5"
+%&2 "<'

"& 2
 .

".


*++&""& 
)
5& 5 
>
& "!



:

5"
' "& 
& 
"

%$'

6
 -

!%&
0#')(

1! ")% &!
5
''

"5.
%

"

&!!
"
&
0#') < "!


 """"
5"

+


 .
 .
&
5"
!&

!
%&
'

"& 2
 .

".

>
" !
%
5& 5 .
' !
5& 
2&) '
  "
&
=   >.

*++&""&
& 
%"

&

"

!!

' "


) 3
& $ "

&'
5& 5
>



 .


*++&""& !!5
+
2")? 1$)$'#  %41#
') #5$ @4$(#')


 0"0$:(549%A')"64:"99#5$&")%'%"#$(F
!!

' "
'""


%
5
5

+@"

"&
> 


5@
 
"'

&)
!& 2"
 
 &".
! 
(& 2!
4 2
+ ! 
5
> "

 +& 
!&"
 ' '!

-

&4   #
$  

/


 0
 +



     2  

  3
)

  
 5
  +


  " 6 #

$    
 

  !



   
 " &7  &  &8 
   

 ) 

)

        :   /


)

 
!     
    (  !
      
!  ! 
 
;

)


  3
*#
$   



    * &(/

  
 0
 +

)


     
  3
    2         

 / 
 


 
    &< ;

   3
  3
  




     
  
(
 
  =
*

 2

 /   

          ) 
  
 =
 *    
  0 +
  .     +



  

 0 / %  +


 .  %  5.

 





# $


   
  
) )  =

  ! 
         =
 * 
       
 ;

 
  



 


!   ! 
   
  

  /   





 
:  *&+

 

!)

+

 0 +
 


      
,1-

,+-  ) 

 +




* .>.  .>&< 
  =
 *   3
 2  
 ,-




!
  =
)  



 

%  5.) 
 
 

  2
   
+



, ! 
 -
 3


 


     
 




  %  ?

 

3
 
 



  

     3 

) 

  
 ) 


        )  

  

   , -

      2@

   3
   

     2;

   

 
  

+


/   

   ! 


 
     &A


  


  )   

  
    :

!( 0
1 ) +    
 
 
   BC+D  E B  F  D  ) &< #.$ 0++44

G  0  +    

    !  
 
    0   
 0
 +

   C




  C
  +

 
   )

- 0 + 

   '5

  

  +



  
 !   

  
   
 
  
 3 





 

  
) 
      

  
   / )       
  
 

   !     
   
 
    !           



  
        


   ! 

   !    B  

02H?

EB 10C

/ H #&>$&0++4> G   + 

   '5


 






  
          

   0
 +
   

I    
        

 
     

   
  ! 
  0
 +
 

 
 

 / ;

 

  
;



   0
 +
  
 
!

)
 
!     

 
!
 

   +
 
 

  
)       



 
  
 
  

     J

!


 

 +

   
 


     ;

 +
 
      
     




   

   
 
  


   
  
 

 
           
   

  )
  +      
/


  &

    ) 


  
3


+      )


 
 
!)    

 
!     
 
 0
;

   
      =
*=
12 0
 ,- 

 
   ?
 ,1  +- 

         


     
 ,-   
     

  

  ?
,-

             
      


 

 
  

# 

$    ?
 ,-   
   /    
    ,+ !- 


 ,B-
, 

-



   ?   





  


3

)

3


    2/
    

   


 
  ,

3
!-)  
 3 ! 
      ;



    
 

   * &(+

 
   

)  

 
  

 

 2
 
     

    )  *&(+



  2    

 2
   #>.$ 

  


   

 

  /   


   
  3
)   
  
 



 /  .> 

 .&     

   

  
)
 + 
 

 
 
   

2 !    * &(+

  
!
 
 2)  
    

3

 =
 * 
 3
 F

 
 

) 
 /

   

)
+  3
 
*#

$





   +


 /    

       2   

 3
 * 



  !



     ;


  
  

  
 3

 

 
/


9 D
)

! 
'

"!

!!

"
 
 "


'
I6
'&.
& 
5@
 
"& .
"
"@ '


%).
& 8"


"+
 
' "
5&!


+ 2
>


"

&'

!3
'

"
 '

&'!
+ 
'

"

0#') "!

"

  
  
 

   
.

 "

&


'

6
&
5&'

>
5"
"@
&'@
0#')( 1! ")% &!
%& 2

''

"5"
D"
5
 "
' "&& 2


 
"&& 
> 
& "
&


 "5.

5& "

& 2

+%&2 3

'

"&
'

& 
& 
'

"
 0#') "!
&


 
""""
5"

+

.
&'@
0#')

%!
"

&2 "5
D&'
&"
53.
"
+ "

 
%).
) 



6 "
& -

%  .'
# $ #$


   !)   # $
  + - /

   !0 + / 



    ! 
 ) + !


  
  
      ! 0  +  


 
   1

0)



# $   
 
0)






23
  
  /
+


'
%
)&5
+
3 
"'

&)-
""

+& 2



""""
5"
&'


&
0#') "!.

5&


 %
&
5 !
)
% 
''

"5
 
&
&"
& &"
'

6 %") 
! 
(& 2!
4 2
""

+"
"&2 &' '.
 

  ?
,-

     

   
        


 

  
   

# 

$     ?
 ,-   
   /    
    ,+ !- 


 ,B-
, 

- 



  



"!!.
&


 
""""
5"
+


& 0#') "!.

)3 2
!"
5 !
)
!!
&
!'
"

0#')

%!299#5$"16$3
5 !
)
% 
&2 "5

>



D

+& 

&

&"
$

'



)
& +"
 &2& !
 "5
@3.
0#') %!
5"
&
"

&2 "5
?

+%&2 3.
5 
''


5& 2


''&

!
+&""&

 5&".

0#') "!!

 +! "
"&

.
5&'
&

' "

!+

 %
"
2"

)'& 3
 
>
& "!


 .
"
%")
%3


! 
(& 2!
4 2.
 '

>
& "!

5"


%
 %

!


 !3
!2&'!
"

!

&
5 !


&!-

' !

%
 3
''

"5
 
G .

2

 %
& 
+& "
 
' "


 '

%
>

&.
5 
&
&"

"+!!
 %

%&2
 % .
 
&
+3
)
'

"

+%
 
' "

.
 
& 
2&)
"&

.


*++&""& @

' "'& "
'&"& 
2&)
% 
"&
 %


!!

' "
 .
%"

6 8"
& .
 
&
"3 '
5& "
'

&'

A ! 
 
 3
  
 

     
>


5"
5& 5 *++&""&
5

E
+@"

!!

' "
'""

%


"&
> 

%& 2
&

!3
"@.
! 
'

"!

!!

"
' !

 

 2

'

"5
& 
' '!

"&
'
%3


! 
(& 2!
4 2
5"
& 
'

3


'

"


+
3
+ &!
&!!2!& 3


)&5
 
%).
5

&""



&

 
5& &+ 

 
$ 2+

 
%3

! 
(& 2!
4 2
/
!
%& 2
)&

+&
&"
''& 2!3
&"+&""

-:'(5)" 4:":'!   :4) "99'! 5'$4(#'&$ 4%A$    

"8") D 
"@& 2
<
" -
JI(
D 
, %!-
JI(