← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/480/2013dismissed

Mauj Khan Etc v. Deen Mohd. Etc.

2016-07-05Mr. Justice Arun Palli25 pages

    

 !"# #$%&%'( )*+,-

.

 

   

   

 ( / 0 0   

    



     

 

1#&#'"(     

    

  



 

 2*!""!'%'34-  ! "

 "#

    "#

 

$





% &'()*((+



    , 



        

     $



 "



  %

"





 



#"#

  

-"

!

#     &../     -"  0#  !

  $

-

#   %     &1'*     

 

    







+(#  #



        

    #   

# 







#

3 " 4

 " 

# &11+ 1/

#    5, -  * 6 

 



  $

 % 

  





 # "  " #

  

 



 3" 4 

  

 



#

 

#



     

# 3" 4

"

    !

#

7 " 7

# 

" 

# &11+ 1/  "#

   8    



 :

$;



 %<



  = 3& >

 

    ,







# 

#



-"0#!

 

?0-- * >

 

  



  #

?0-- 8 >





 " 

?0-

) >

 

           



 ?0- ' >

 

 







?0- + >



   

#



 ?0- / >

  " 

  

  # 

?0- . >

 

  



  

 "#      ?0- 1  

4 ) @##



A

< & 

   

" 

# &18. 81

*((& (* $   "

%BA-&

-)-.

-&1 -*'

-*1! #  6   BA-8 -'-+ -/ 9

 

  

 BA-* -8& :



  

 BA-*(

-*) -8( !

  A

  < &>& 

: >* 

" 

# *((& (*"# #

 #  BA& ' 0 

   :

  

  # 

 

 



"

+(# 

 

:

    ;

'

&../



 

  #   "



$ 

%

 "

 "#

 









  

9

 



 7" ;

:



)1!'%'34!'5"4#1&6&1!2 !'$4!+!"!'5"4#1&$*((8%$&% :$:%1*

  "

8

&1'*



 

 

 

#      # 

  



 

 





#



;

*$ %

              

 

$  "

 %

  

 "

 

#





  # "



 #  

     "

  "#  A:

#

  





:

    + 2  



:

"#

$

%   "

#



 "

  





 +(#  

 

   

    

:

 

#



  

# 

#

 ! 

#

3 " 4 " 

# &11+ 1/

  #

 





:

, ! 

  

::





&../ &1'*

  # 

"# :

 / 5   

 

  

     



:



:

   

  

::

:

 

#    

   

   



9@ 

:

4%74!1!'6& %'!'$%!*22%&&%'#1-!1+!'!!'5"4#1& $*(()%$)%:$:% ')8

"# :

   



7 7

&1'* ::

    

  . 0

 

:

   

&18. 81  &1.+ ./



).

# 

 

  

 "

 

  3 

4    #

  

  3      4  

# &11& 1*    < 1 "



 



#

 

"

$ 

).# %!



 &11+ 1/          

 

   

#$ < 1%   

 "

  3 4  $ %        

" ,  

.



  

  



#  #"



  #

#

 $

 "



 

 

# &11+ 1/% >



;

:

)13!

6&%*84%!2&1+1C&**

    



;

))

-"C 

  "





" ,

#

 

"

 

:

 !18!&4#7%6&!1&#20!*$*((8$&%-C 88* 

"#



:



     



  

A

  

 

  

    



  "# 9:



 



  

"

1 0   " 

 

 

      



 ,



    

 - ; 7 $ %

" 

 "

 

   

#"



  $ 



  % 



  



  # "

 



 D

 #



  $

 %



 

   &( @

:

    



  $ 

% "





 3E  4 &1++ +/ 

$

BA- ."

:

%5







@   )30!*!'5"4#1&6&!34:%1 %'34*(&)$8%:$:%''1

   

 

 3 

4  

 

 "

#



#





 

#

  "

#



 

  

 #









@ 

:

)84!26&!'&!!2!'5"4#1&  ('(1*((.; < 8((*

*((/ 

 &&   "



'$*%

&../



,



#

  

#

 "##

#



"##

#

 

 

# <   "

 "

#





# &11+ 1/  

#

   "

 "##

 < 1    

A 

F 

  

 

"

'$*%

  2 

 

   ; 7  $ %  "



 #



    

  "



# 

#

5 

 

  





#

 0

 

   "

 :  

   

#    

 



 

:

  #

#  "

    





  &*  

 #"





 

    

 :  :

  "

           

 

     

 

  

 

   "   ::

  

   



9@ 

:

 4%7 4!1!'&/ $ % &8   

  









 



  



*

#



 0#  #

#

G   

"

# 

 



#

# 



'$*%

&../ 

3 

4 #



 #  

    #  

;

 

 

 



:



 

 

&18. 81

&1.+ ./

 "



3 

4 #

 

 

   "#

3      4 :



#

 34





 

   "#   









#

" 

 

 





2 

  

  

;

:

)13!&/ $ % "

"#

  

 

:

 , #  

 

#

 

 &)  

 

"

"

$

%



 

# #

 < 1

  

#



 

  3@

 @  4

 #

  



  #

7E  7  

 

 &' 5         

 

    





:

"



#   "



 



" 







#

"

 !;

'+ .

-"!

# &../

 



= 3' #'!'"&4!7%'31%34" $$)<!'$+ 

$% 

 



  







   



 

## "

#  #

#    



  

      

  "



"



$"%     



 "#



"##  #  





 #   

$% 

 

  



"#



  

 

#  #

0

"

&.+.   # 

   

$ % 

#

  "# 



 # 



 

# # 



         #  



 

##  

#       



    $%  



 

 #

 "



  "#

A 



$*%   

           #





##   

"

#    



 

 

 

"



#"

       

 $%

" ;

$&% $8% !

     

  

  

  

   "#     

 

 #

#  

 "# 



   # + %34" $$)<!'$+ "4#1"#'!'"&1#$15#5!& 4!7%'3"4#1%34":# 1#<!&&%'3 )'=!:#'!'$+$"-

.  



 "#

;

E



#  #

0

"

&.+.



 

#    # 

 



"

 

#

  

#"

" "#



:

 



  / AAA AAA AAA . &"!:*%&42#'" 1%34" $$)<!'$+'31)'5& "4#1  "4!'  "4&#  #><1#&&*+  &"!"#5  %'  $" <

   

 

:



 #

 " 

# #

 



     ;

1

&../ 

= ?; %34" $$)<!'$+'"":#!$@)%1#5:+ 2#1#*!<&# "%2# <

,



#"#



 4 ;

*$ %$ % ;

8

)'=!:$$)<!'$+ #'!'"&  6#&"%'3   1<1%#"!1+  %34"&  $"-  ;,  





= 3*$ % 3 43 

4 7

7

 

 #

 -"

!

# &../$-" H2

&../%D AAA AAA AAA

$ % # 

4      

    

#"



 

 #



  

 

  

"



#

  "#    

 "#  

      





  

     

   

 

 #

8 6#&"%'3    <1<1%#"!1+  1%34"&  %'  $$)<!'$+ "#'!'"&!'5#>"%'3)%&42#'" $11#&<'5%'31%34"&  *!'5*15& <

   # 

#  #









 



 # $%        

 $ 

 

    # 

I  "#  #   





 

  

 

    ;    

 

%

 

    

"#  #

"

  

  

"

 

#

  "

   #

"#  

=

-  #





,



 ; "# 



 

:



 A 

 "  

  

   

 

"

 # 



$"%

 

 

 #



 #

 #





  " #

#  



   $%

#

# 



    

 D $ %

#

"

"

#    

"



 "

    #"





 4 &+ !

'$*%

&../

   

   

8(# #

 "

#    

  

       

"

   "

     

'$&% $%

    ,

#

@# 1



 "

 ,



# #"#



, 2

  









8(#  

  

#    

 

  

"

 

 

 ! , 

 



 

 

# &11+ 1/

 





#  34 



 

 #"



#      &'()*((+?

;

 #  

 "

   

 

 

 "



 



#

   

 "

  

,

 

? ! #  

   

    

 "

   3E   4    "



 

# 

"#  

 ?

&/ ! "  ,

  

 

= % >





$ 



  







 

8/

-"C  &..* #

"





 

 # &11+ 1/  D  



 

 # &18. 81  



 

 

.





 

  "##

 ?

%  

 

   

    

 "

    



 3E  4





#





'$*%

-"!

# &../  



   , #



8

-"0#!

$

-

# % &1'*?

% >

  "# :

 

,

# 



*$ %

&1'* &. !   ,  

 

 



  



E   "



 " 

&18.

&1.+

 



 

"

'

&../ !    

  

 :

       

 

  " 

 

&18.

&1.+ ./

 

 "

#





 "    

:

"

$





  :

"#

 

 "#

 % " #"

 

 



 "    :

< 1 &&

#

 & 1/  4  & . 3!"4

 

 "

 "#

 

 5  "

    

 "

 3E   4     "#





#  



"

#

 "

 !

3 

4 

##











  ##

 

 

    

 3 F 4     

   3E 4

7

7 $

=3  #

   !

4"# 55> *(&) % ! 

  

 

"#

 2



 "

 

"#

3       # !  

 3 4    

    

 " 



  



" 

  



  

A



  

  :

   #  

    

 "



 

    

#



  

      

 "#       







#

"#

 "#  



# 





 

 "#

  



'$*%

&../  

    #

#

 



"

#  

  





8(#  &1  

     

  :

  

 "#  

 

   C7  ; 7

$ % C7 

  #

 

!

#

&../



&1'*2   

  

 





 

  

  D #

#

 

     



     # # #

  

3E  4  

"# 

   2





@ 

:

  

#

 #



   #





 "#

   #  

  

  0" # 



 # 

  "



 # 

&../    

# #

 

  

2

  

  

 

 

 "

  5 

    C7 



   

# 

&../ &1'*

 "

"

 # 

"#

'

&../

#



;

;    

   #  

 "

    



:

  "

"#



#

"

  

   *( :



; 7 $ % "

#    #

 "    

 

 

'

&../



 #

  











  



 *(#    

     # 

 

 







+

   

   



 

,



"#

    "#

5 

  "# :



@  2

 

 #



 

:



  

 

 #  

    "#

 







8(#  

$

    

&11+ 1/

 # "

  

"







%   "

  

"

"# :



 #

"





 

 *& :



  

,  

  "



   

  

 

 

 "##

  7

 



 "  $

%  #



 

   < 1



  & 1/ 

   





 

"





))

-"C  &../! 

"





&18. 81 &1.+ ./

   # 

 

!  

 

   "

"

    "

 



   

  



  3 " 4



"

  "   < 1

&11+ 1/  



  

##

3

" 4  "

" #"

#   #

   

 "



 



 

&18.

&1.+





  





  "





 



"

 

 

  "

   

  &18. 81 

 &1.+ ./   

     

"

 



&11+ 1/

  ** ! 



     



2  

 

:



  

 # 



#

&18.

&1.+ ./  # #

 

    #

  

 *8 :

  

 "# :



&11+ 1/"

 #"  

2 

#;

8/

-"C 

 &../



 

 = ?9 #&"1%$"%'&  '  7!1%!"%'&    #'"1%#&  %'  1#$15&A B





 A

  

"#- 

 $%

8' 

 

, 



 

 " ,

 "# $% 

    

     

 

 

D $"%  



"#









"#

"  

D $%   

   #



4 !   

"

" #

  "#



" #

,



#

 "#

 







 



#



  

 

 







#  # !



 



$ 

 :

/

-"C 





   (*(1&1*1;

  0

1"# 9:



  -" 2

 



 

  







" 

-"C  &../ -

/'

:

/ #

:

< 1

&* 



 $    &*

  

%  

 

# 

   ,  -

/*.

#  

  

 # ;  # 

 3

      





 



4

# #

# 

 

" ,

  









< 1

 



  

  



 

*/

!

# $;

  */ 

 !

#    $

 &../% 

 

 

A





% !

 

 

# 

 



 

  

# 

 

 

" #"





  

# < 1

 

#

 



  " 

8/

 5 2







:











" ,

"

 #

"

"#

! :



;

:

 )13!&/ $ % 

  #

  

:

 !18!&4&/ $ % 2

7 C



  



@ 

:

  

 





  



# 

  



#    

"

  "



#  "

,

  

:

 , #  

    #

 

"#

    "

       



 

   &18. 81



8(# 



'*

&../ *) :



 , 

"

 

:

 

,

# 



*$ %

&1'*2  

"



 # "

 *$ %

 



"

 #



 

#"





    # 

  

 

   



"



#

   "#

"#

   

 :



   

  !

 

   

    :

  

   

 

 



  #  "

  "#:



    #  

 

,

"#

 # 

 ,





'$&%$% $*%

&../

"# 

   

8

&1'* *' :

 , #

   2   

          

        

 











,    

   &18. 

 #

#

# 

 #   

 

 

 

&11+ 1/    #

# 3 #



 "

 

 "

#   "#



   

 



'

&../ ! "

# #

,

   



8



&1'*$



#



&1'8%    

     



 

)*+,-

.

0