High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/154/2018dismissed

Sukhwinder Singh v. Mc Gobindgarh And ANR

2018-01-29Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

!" #$$ %&' (')!*!"+, -./01!"('2-!"30 455'66%"& 7'2*.* .")!68 %"(! 9!"(3%20%"(%"&0'2 44'*5"('"&*

: -

-# 2'*'"&+ 2- .2"%8(;)%&' 2&0'%55'66%"& <<<

0%66'"3'!"&0!*!"&2%=).2&%55'%6!*&2('2(%&'($ > 5%**'( 9? &0' 6'%2"'( #2!& .2& 2';'2*!"3 &0' %1%2( 2'!"*&%&'@'"& 1!&0.&9%)/1%3'*9?%1%2(!"3)@5'"*%&!"!"6!'.&0'2'

6%!@ &0' 12/@%" 9'

2' &0' "(.*&2!%6 2!9."%68 %&!%6% 0'2'!"% &'2 2'

'22'( & %* A&0' 2!9."%6: 1%* &0%& 0' 0%( 12/'( )"&!"..*6? 1!&0 &0' 2'*5"('"&=@%"%3'@'"& B

B & ,

%* .9'1'66 5'2%&2 %& .9'1'66 *8 8 B %"( " @"&06?*%6%2? $ C=%"(&0%&0!**'2;!)'*1'2'!66'3%66?&'2@!"%&'(9? &0' 2'*5"('"&= %"%3'@'"& "

1!&0.& %"? "&!)'8 )0%23'= *0''&8!"D.!2?2)@5'"*%&!"%"(&0%&0'0%(9''";!)&!@!E'((.'&&2%(' ."!"%)&!;!&!'*

0' 2'*5"('"&= %"%3'@'"&8 " &0' &0'2 0%"(8 ('"!'( 2'6%&!"*0!5 '@56?'2 %"( 12/@%" %"( )"&'"('( &0%& 2')2.!&@'"& " (%!6?1%3'*&02.30 ."!)!5%6 .")!60%(9''"9%""'(9?&0' ;'2"@'"& 9.&*!")'*@'12/1%*&9''H').&'(9?&0' ."!)!5%6 .")!68&0'2'

2' &'@52%2? 6%9.2 12/ 1%* 3!;'" & %" !"('5'"('"& "&2%)&2 0' 12/@%"1%*"';'2'"3%3'(9?&0'2'*5"('"&= %"%3'@'"& 2&0'5*& .9'1'66 5'2%&2 "2 1%* &0' 12/@%" 5%!( %"? *%6%2? 9? &0' %"%3'@'"& 0' "&2%)&2 0%( 9''" @%!"&%!"!"3 % 3 / 2 5.25*'* 2')2(%&0!*1"6';'6%"(&0' ."!)!5%6 .")!60%("6!"/* 1!&0&0'*%@'8&0'2'

2'8&0'D.'*&!" &0'&'2@!"%&!" *'2;!)' &0' %55'66%"&"

(!("&%2!*'

"&0'9%*!* ';!('")'6'(9?&0'5%2&!'*8&0' 2!9."%60'6( &0%&## .21!"('2%6-!"308#%&'2-.556?-.5'2;!*2 &0'2'*5"('"& .")!60%(52;'(&0')5? &0'2')2(%* #B%"(&0%&%*5'2

H#B &0' 12/@%" 0%( 12/'( 1!&0&0' 2'*5"('"& B B

B & B >

!'(%?*%"(

!' (%?*8 &&%6$(%?*%"(!"&0'6!30& &0'5*!&!"%*"&'(%9;'8&0'2''H!*&'( 2'6%&!"*0!5 '@56?'2%"('@56?''9'&1''"&0'5%2&!'*'*5')!%66?*!")' &0' ."!)!5%6 .")!6 0%( "& 52(.)'( 2')2( & 52;' &0%& 12/ 1%* 52;!('( & &0' 2'3!*&'2'( "&2%)&2 2 &0%& &0' "&2%)&2 1%* 0%;!"3 6!)'"*' 2@ &0' %9.2 '5%2&@'"& '*!('*8 " 2'*6.&!" &0' 2'*5"('"& ."!)!5%6 .")!60%(9''"92.30&"2')2(;!('10!)012/ 5'2%&!"3&0'&.9'1'66*1%*52;!('(&&0' "&2%)&2'*!('*8 H#B 1%* " &0' 6'&&'2 5%( &0' 2'*5"('"& ."!)!5%6 .")!6 %"( )"&%!"'( *!3"%&.2'* &0' H').&!;'

!)'28 ."!)!5%6 .")!68 9!"(3%20 %(@!&&!"3 &0%& %* 5'2 2')2(8 &0' 12/@%" 0%( 12/'( 2 $ (%?* %* ('&%!6'(!" H#B

FBG

0' 2!9."%6 0'6( &0%& *'2;!)'* &0' 12/@%" 0%( 9''" !66'3%66?&'2@!"%&'(!";!6%&!" -')&!"= &0'"(.*&2!%6!*5.&'* )&8 ,>8 &0'2'

2' &0' 12/@%" 1%* '"&!&6'( & 9' 2'!"*&%&'( 1!&0 )"&!".!&? *'2;!)'%*5'2*'2;!)')"(!&!"*%*%556!)%96'"&0'(%&' &'2@!"%&!" 0!**'2;!)'* 1';'289%)/1%3'*1'2'('"!'("&0'32."( &0%& &0' 12/@%" 0%( "& 12/'( 1!&0 &0' 2'*5"('"& 2 &0' 5'2!( !" (!*5.&'

0%66'"3' & &0' %1%2( 9? &0' 2'*5"('"&= ."!)!5%6 .")!6 1%* %))'5&'( 1%2( 2'!"*&%&'@'"& 1!&0 )"&!".!&? *'2;!)' 1%* *'& %*!(' 9? &0' #2!& .2& %"( &0' 12/@%" 1%* 0'6( & 9' '"&!&6'( & )@5'"*%&!" 6%)* 9? 9*'2;!"3 &0%& 10'&0'2 &0' 2'*5"('"&= 12/@%"1%*'"3%3'(9? "&2%)&22(!2')&9?&0' ."!)!5%6 .")!68&0'

%)& 2'@%!"'( &0%& ';'" !

&0' 12/@%" 1%* '"3%3'( (!2')&6? 9? &0' .")!68 0'8 %& 9'*& 1%* '"&!&6'( & )@5'"*%&!" %"( "& 2'!"*&%&'@'"&*!")'&0'5*&!"D.'*&!"1%*%5.96!)5*&%"().6("&0%;' 9''" !66'(.51!&0.&!";!&!"3%556!)%&!"* 2@'6!3!96')%"(!(%&'* 0' 6'%2"'(#2!& .2&%6*&/!"&%))."&&0%&&0'12/@%":**'2;!)'*1'2' 2%66? &'2@!"%&'( "

%"( 0' 1%* .& *'2;!)' *!")' &0'"8 &0'2'

2'8!";!'1 &0'(')!*!" &0' ":96'-.52'@' .2&!"

"#$$ ##8&0'D.'*&!" 2'!"*&%&'@'"&(!("&%2!*'))2(!"36?8&0'#2!& .2&@(!

!'(&0'%1%2( &0' 2!9."%69?06(!"3&0'12/@%"&9''"&!&6'(&)@5'"*%&!" 6%)*!"*&'%( 2'!"*&%&'@'"&

# 0'2('2 &0'6'%2"'(#2!& .2&(%&'($ >0%*9''" )0%66'"3'("&0'32."(&0%&&0' ."!)!5%6 .")!6!"!&*56'%9'

2'&0' 6'%2"'( 2!9."%6 &/ &0' *&%"( &0%& &0' 12/@%" 0%( "& 9''" (!2')&6? %55!"&'( 9? &0'@ %"( &0%& &0'2' 1%* " @%*&'2=*'2;%"& 2'6%&!"*0!5

FG 9'&1''"&0'5%2&!'*8&0%&%&"5!"& &!@'8!&1%*&0')%*' &0' ."!)!5%6

.")!6&0%&&0'12/@%"0%(9''"%55!"&'(!";!6%&!" 52;!*!"* %"?6%1%"("'!&0'21%*&0'*%@'2'%*" 2&'2@!"%&!"C2'&2'")0@'"&8&0%& ."('2&0'"(.*&2!%6!*5.&'*)&8,>8&0'2'1%*"2'D.!2'@'"&&0%&&0' 12/@%"@.*&9'%55!"&'(9?@'%"* 5.96!)%(;'2&!*'@'"&8&0%&!"%"? )%*')@5'"*%&!" 6%)*1%*"&%55252!%&' % #'0%;')"*!('2'(&0'*.9@!**!"*@%('9?6'%2"'()."*'6

2&0'%55'66%"&

& (@!&&'(6?8&0'%55'66%"&12/'( 2%5'2!( %552H!@%&'6? I ?'%2* 0' 52)''(!"3* 2'@%!"'( 5'"(!"3 9' 2' &0' 2!9."%6 2 % 5'2!( )6*'&

?'%2*&0'2'% &'289'

2'&0!* .2& 2 ?'%2*"%668 &0' %55'66%"& 2'@%!"'( .& *'2;!)'

&!66 (%&' !' 2 % 5'2!( %552H!@%&'6?BI?'%2* 0'12/@%"%(@!&&'(6?12/'( 2% 5'2!( %552H!@%&'6?I?'%2*"@"&06?*%6%2? $ C= 0'2'

2'8 !" ;!'1 &0' (')!*!" ":96' &0' -.52'@' .2& !" 0%2%& -%")0%2 !3%@!@!&'(:*)%*'*.52%8@(!

!)%&!" &0'%1%2(9?&0'6'%2"'(#2!&

.2& 9? (!2')&!"3 5%?@'"& )@5'"*%&!" 6%)* !" 6!'. 2'!"*&%&'@'"&1!&0)"&!".!&? *'2;!)'!*"& ."(&9'1%22%"&!"3%"? !"&'2 '2'")'

'*.6&%"&6?8 !"(!"3 " @'2!& !" &0' %55'%68 &0' *%@' !* (!*@!**'(!"6!@!"' "*'D.'"&6?8&0'%556!)%&!"*''/!"3)"("%&!" >(%?*:('6%?!" !6!"3 &0'%55'%6!*%6*(!*@!**'( %J'*0!"(%6 -#%6!% .(3' .(3' , %@!& #0'&0'2*5'%/!"3C2'%*"'(+ '*C #0'&0'22'52&%96' + '*C