High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4821/2013dismissed

Commissioner And Secretary To Govt. Of Haryana v. Rajinder Singh

2016-01-14Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain6 pages

! ! ! !

"#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* ")+",- .

")+",- .

/ 0$11'((')$,")%$&,$#",- ")%#0$,( 22$33")#( 4$,(+( "5')%$,')60 $(2)%$)# * * * * 78 78 78 78

,$($)#*

,$($)#* , ')60.",-")" ,"5$(0,,".%9&"#$

,#0$,$(2)%$)# :::::

:::::

. $(2)%$)# 0"% '3$% (+'# , %$&3","#') ")% 1")%"#,-')5+)&#')($$;')6"%',$&#')#0"#0$<"($)#'#3$%

,,$'1=+,($1$)# +331$%'&"3&3"'1>+"#,$"#1$)# 0'( <'

$ 0$&"($ #0$,$(2)%$)#.')=,'$ .<"(#0"#0$ 0"%,$#',$% ,1#0$2(# $9$321$)#

'&$,")%<"( $)#'#3$% , 1$%'&"3 ,$'1=+,($1$)# 1$%'&"3 $?2$)($( ')&+,,$%)#,$"#1$)# $) @

.<'

,$(2)%$)# $33($,'+(3-'33")%<"(6#"%1'##$%')1;"3 (2'#"3 0$,$1"')$%"%1'##$%')#0$("'%(2'#"3 ,1

)

. <'

$ #0$ ,$(2)%$)#<"("6"')"%1'##$%')#0$("'%(2'#"3")%<"( "%9'($%#=$(0'

#$%#3- "1'3-(2'#"3. $30'.<0$,$.

(0$,$1"')$%"%1'##$% ,1

#,$"#1$)# #0$<'

#0$,$(2)%$)#<"(#";$)')"&"($

$1$,6$)&-")%#0$,$(2)%$)#0"%(2$)#A .

BC)#0$ #,$"#1$)# $ 22$33")#(C%$ $)%")#( ') #0$', <,'##$) (#"#$1$)# "9$,,$% #0"# #0$ ,$(2)%$)# <"( )3- $)#'#3$% # &3"'1 ,$'1=+,($1$)#"(2$,#0$2,$(&,'=$%,"#$(=- (#,"%+"#$ )(#'#+#$ 7 7 , (0,#. 0")%'6",0B33 )%'" )(#'#+#$

$%'&"3&'$)&$(77 ,(0,#. $30' $(2)%$)#<"(

$,$% &0$>+$ ') #0$ (+1 A/ . DDBC. =+# 0$ 0"% )# "&&$2#$%#0$("1$ ) #0$ 23$"%')6( #0$ 2",#'$(. 33<')6 '((+$( <$,$ ,"1$%=-#0$#,'"3+,#*C F0$#0$,#0$23"')#'

'($)#'#3$%#"%$&,$$ , 1")%"#,- ')5+)&#') # #0$ $

$&# #0"# 0$ '( $)#'#3$%#,$'1=+,($1$)# +331$%'&"3='33>+"

#,$"#1$)# $G

F0$#0$, #0$ 23"')#'

'( $)#'#3$% # ,$3'$

1")%"#,-')5+)&#')"(2,"-$% ,G

$3'$ H

",#'$( 3$% #0$', $9'%$)&$ ') (+22,# #0$', ,$(2$&#'9$23$"( ,'"3+,#9'%$5+%61$)#B%$&,$$%"#$%

2",#3-%$&,$$%#0$(+'# #0$,$(2)%$)#C23"')#'

0$("'% 5+%61$)#B%$&,$$2"(($%=-#0$#,'"3+,#<$,$+20$3%=-#0$

',(#22$33"#$+,#9'%$5+%61$)#B%$&,$$%"#$%

')")"22$"3 '3$%=-#0$"22$33")#(C%$ $)%")#( $)&$.#0$ 2,$($)#"22$"3=-#0$"22$33")#(C%$ $)%")#( 0"9$0$",%3$",)$%&+)($3 ,#0$"22$33")#(")%

0"9$6)$#0,+60#0$,$&,%"9"'3"=3$)#0$ '3$&",$ +33- )#0$2,$($)#&"($.#0$ "&##0"##0$<'

,$(2)%$)# #; #,$"#1$)# ,1 1;"3 (2'#"3 ")% 3-

"1'3-(2'#"3. $30'')>+$(#')'()#')%'(2+#$0$)3- >+$(#') #0"# ,$>+',$( &)('%$,"#') '( "( # <0$#0$, #0$ ,$(2)%$)#<"($)#'#3$%#&3"'1 +331$%'&"3,$'1=+,($1$)# >+"#0$"1+)#(2$)#=-0'1,0$<"($)#'#3$%#,$&$'9$ ,$'1=+,($1$)# "( 2$, ,"#$( 2,$(&,'=$% =- .

0")%'6",0B. $30' #0"(=$$)0$3%=-#0'(+,#')0";+)#3"9$,(+( 0";+)#3"9$,(+( 0";+)#3"9$,(+( 0";+)#3"9$,(+( #"#$ ",-")"

#"#$ ",-")"

#"#$ ",-")".

8@/."(+)%$,*C E0$&+1+3"#'9$$

$&#<0'3$&)('%$,')6#0$ &3"'1( "33#0$2$#'#')$,('(#0"##0$')%'9'%+"3 &"($( "33#0$2$#'#')$,()$$%#=$%$"3#<'#0 $?2$%'#'+(3-=$&"+($"##0$#'1$ 1$$#')6+# #0$ 1$%'&"3 $?2$)%'#+,$( ') #0$ 0(2'#"3(. #0$ 2"-1$)#'(,"'($%=-#";')63")(+2)')#$,$(#.=- ("3$ 5$<$33$,- , 3'>+'%"#')6 #0$', 19"=3$ , '119"=3$"(($#(')&3+%')6#0$ '?$% $2('#(.'

")- +&0 "&#( (1$#'1$( ')939$ #0$ 3' $ #'1$ ("9')6 ") $123-$$ 0+(. #0$ >+$(#')

%$"3')6<'#0(+&0;')% 2"-1$)#(%$(3$"9$"

0$"3#0-'12,$((')<'#0")$123-$$ $)$,"33- (2$";')6.#0$$123-$,'($?2$&#$%#3;"

#$,0'( $123-$$(#0+60"(2$,#0$#$,1(")%&)%'#')( (2$3#+#')#0$#$,1( $123-1$)#,#0$,+3$(

,"1$% ') ,$(2$&# #0$,$ F0$,$9$, #0$ ,+3$( 2,$(&,'=$ #0$ ,$'1=+,($1$)# # =$ 1"%$ # #0$ $123-$$(. #0$ +))$&$((",- %$3"-( (0+3% =$ "9'%$% 0$ "&#( (2$3# +# ') "33 #0$($ &"($( ,$3"#$ # (+&0 ;')% %$3"-( ")% #0$,$=- #0$

2$#'#')$,( 0"9$ "&$% #0$ +))$&$((",- 0","((1$)#( F$ ",$ #0$ 9'$< #0"# #0$ '12+6)$% ,%$,( 9'%$ <0'&0 #0$ &3"'1( #0$ 2$#'#')$,(0"9$=$$),$5$&#$%",$)#(+(#"')"=3$ +)%$,3"<."(#0$23$"($#+2'(#0"##0$0(2'#"3( ",$)#,$&6)'I$%,",$)#&)#"')$%')#0$3'(# "22,9$%=-#0$69$,)1$)#.<0'&0%$()#(#")% #0$#$(# 3"<0+(.#0$&"($ "33#0$2$#'#')$,( %$($,9$##0$(&,+#')'($%')"&&,%")&$<'#0#0$ ,+3$(")%("3(#0$ +%6$1"%$3"< 0$,$ ,$.

<$ 6,")# " <,'# &$,#',",' ")% >+"(0 #0$ '12+6)$% ,%$,( ,$5$&#') ') ,$(2$&# #0$ &3"'1( $"&0 #0$2$#'#')$,(<0'&00"9$=$$) '12+6)$% =$ ,$ +( ")% <$ "3( &11")% #0$ 69$,)1$)#=-'((+')6"<,'# 1")%"1+(#0"##0$ &"($( "33 #0$ 2$#'#')$,( =$ %$"3# <'#0 ') "&&,%")&$<'#0#0$,+3$(")%#0$ +%6$1"%$3"< <'#0')"2$,'% #0,$$1)#0(#'(&3",'

'$%#0"# #0$2$#'#')$,(1"-(+=(#")#'"#$#0$',&3"'1(.' ( ,$>+',$%.<'#0 @%"-( ,1#0$%"#$ ,$&$'2# "

&$,#'

'$% &2- #0'( 5+%61$)# ")% #0"# #0$ "

,$(#"#$% 2$,'% #0,$$ 1)#0( (0"33 ') "%%'#')"3# @%"-(")%<0$,$9$,#0$"%%'#')"3 23$"(,#0$"%%'#')"3%&+1$)#(",$)#,$>+',$% #=$(+=1'##$%.#0$"

,$(#"#$%2$,'% @%"-( (0"33)#=$"9"'3"=3$#$'#0$,('%$ #'( +,#0$, %',$&#$% #0"# +2) %$&'%')6 #0$ &"($( #0$ 2$#'#')$,( <'#0') #0$ "

,$(#"#$% 2$,'%. #0$ 2"-1$)#%+$")%2"-"=3$##0$2$#'#')$,((0"33 =$1"%$<'#0'))$1)#0#0$,$"

#$,. "'3')6<0'&0 #0$9$,)1$)#(0"33=$3'"=3$#2"-')#$,$(#"# #0$,"#$

J2$,"))+1"

#$,#0$$?2',- 2$,'% )$1)#0"(2,$(&,'=$% 0$')#$,$(# "1+)# ( 2"-"=3$ (0"33 =$ %$%+&'=3$ ,1 #0$ ("3",- #0$

'&$,(&)&$,)$%")%,$(2)('=3$

,%$"3')6<'#0")% ,)#1";')6#0$2"-1$)# <'#0') #0$ "

,$(#"#$% 2$,'% ")% #0"# #0$ ("'% "1+)# (0"33 )# =$ ,$'1=+,('=3$ =- #0$ 69$,)1$)#+)%$,")-0$"%#'(&3",'

'$%#0"# , ")-(+&0%$3"-=$-)%#0$"

,$(#"#$%2$,'%#0$ ')#$,$(# "&&,+$% #0$,$) (0"33 =$ 2"'% =- #0$ 69$,)1$)#')#0$ ',(#')(#")&$")%#0$%$%+&#')( (0"33=$1"%$"

#$,#0$3'"='3'#-0"(=$$) "(#$)$% =-#0$&)&$,)$%>+",#$,(H

+,#0$,.'#0"(=$$)0$3%=-#0'(+,#') #"#$

#"#$

+)5"=9$,(+( ,$1K+1",

+)5"=9$,(+( ,$1K+1",.

."(+)%$,*C E#'("($##3$%2,')&'23$ 3"<#0"#')6'9$) &',&+1(#")&$("9$,)1$)#$123-$$1"-=$3$ # <'#0 ) 2#') =+# # #";$ #,$"#1$)# ,1 "

0(2'#"3.<0'&0'()$",=-')#0$&"($ $1$,6$)&- #0"#=$(.'#<'33=$##"33-+)5+(#")%+) "',# %$)- #0$ &3"'1 ,$'1=+,($1$)# # #0$ 23"')#'

1$,$3-=$&"+($#0$0(2'#"3<"()#,$&6)'($%=- #0$ #"#$ 9$,)1$)# , #,$"#1$)# '#( $123-$$( )&$'#'($(#"=3'(0$%"("1"##$,

"&##0"##0$23"')#'

0"%1$#<'#0")"&&'%$)#")%.

0$ ,$&$'9$% #0$ #,$"#1$)#. #0$) 0'( &3"'1 , ,$'1=+,($1$)#&"))#=$%$)'$%)#0$6,+)%2+#

,<",% =- #0$ 3$",)$% &+)($3 , #0$ #"#$ ') ,$6",% # ))C,$&6)'#') #0$ 0(2'#"3. <0'&0 #0$,<'($'("0(2'#"3 ,$2+#$0$23"')#'

0"% %'(&0",6$%0'()+(')#0'(,$6",% ,'60##3' $ <+3%=9'+(3-')&3+%$(+&0"2,#$&#')##0$ 9$,)1$)#$123-$$"($1$,6$)&- #0$;')%"( ')%'&"#$%')#0$ "&#( #0$2,$($)#&"($3$"9$(#0$ $123-$$<'#0)2#')=+###";$#,$"#1$)#')" )$",=- 0(2'#"3. $(+3#")#3-. ($$ ) ,$"() # ')#$, $,$')#0'( ')%')6(",,'9$%"#=-#0$3$",)$% +,#(=$3<H

/ $(2)%$)# 0"% 2,9$% ) ,$&,% #0"# 0$ 0"% #";$)#,$"#1$)# $"('#<"("&"($ ")$1$,6$)&- ")% $1$,6$)&- &$,#'

'&"#$ <"( '((+$% =- #0$ &)&$,)$% (2'#"3')&$')#0$2,$($)#&"($.#0$,$(2)%$)#0"%#";$) #,$"#1$)# $"('#<"("&"($ ")$1$,6$)&-.#0$ +,#(=$3<0"%,'60#3-,%$,$%#0$,$'1=+,($1$)# "&#+"3"1+)#(2$)#=-#0$,$(2)%$)#)#0$#,$"#1$)#

0'( <'

$ +,')6 #0$ &+,($ ",6+1$)#(. '# 0"( +,#0$, #,")(2',$%#0"#')$?$&+#')2,&$$%')6(.#0$%+$"1+)#0"( =$$) 2"'% =- #0$ "22$33")#( # #0$ ,$(2)%$)# "3)6 <'#0 ')#$,$(# 8$",)$%&+)($3 ,#0$,$(2)%$)#0"((+=1'##$% #0"##0$&3"'1 #0$,$(2)%$)#(#% +33-("#'( '$% )#0$ "&#(")%&',&+1(#")&$( #0$2,$($)#&"($.

)(+=(#")#'"3>+$(#') 3"<",'($(')#0'(&"($<",,")#')6 ')#$, $,$)&$=-#0'(+,# '(1'(($%

")+",- .

/ 1"0"9',