Dilbag Singh @ Dilbag Singh Sandhu v. Union Of India Through Secretary And Others
!"
!# !
$!!
!
!#!
%
& '
%% # (
)) '
*%% #+"! , - #+"! ,!#
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
%
1 " #
,
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
*%
1* 2!
2!
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
%
1*
! #
,
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
1%
11 +#
,
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
%
4 !
!2 ,
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
4%
4 +#
,
%%)) ./
#!
!#
,
%% 0
!2'
5"+ %
, ,+ !
,
5"+ %
, !+ 3,!
!+
!
"#$
% & "
#
$ '
( "
!"+
,' ,% % #)0)
7 % ) * + , - &! .
* ,
/ ! / !!
1 0" < < *
23 4
(
0!" )- 5 *! * 6#)$
)=
+" 70!!
" )< /" 9 * )>
&:
!"
;
!" )>
&
5
!
-?
= / -) %
/ )9' ) ) @
" !!
"
!!
!
@3--.BB3 -?-=
! ) - "
3
! "" #$ %&'( ! " )* +,
- .
-" $./ %
# " $% &
'()* +
01,23$$ "4 34,5 46
35 4 ""#$"7 7
34430
4$ %-(.""//%#
& &
$,-.
/ 0 $ '()*
120/3
40/3
10/35 / '(4* 3 16'477'38
/ $% 9! + - / $% 7:72474;
'(4* )472474;5 < / $% % = >?@ / $%8 9!
0/3 > 4) ):7)47):($&4;A$ 1:;* 9!
0/35+ ) , " " " 3 ,% % , /8
(( , / ) ?--.
)= )? -?--
( )-?32
=-?
0
)B.?
D " " - ?)).
-, ?, -?-,
2 " )-?32
=)) =-?
0 )B.?
*
"
&! , ?)))
?) ?. -?-,
( =-?
=.< =<)
0 )B.?
D " " = ?-?.
)> ?> -?--
( =-?
0 )B.?
D " " ?-).
,? ?> -?--
( =<)
0 )B.?
*
"
&!
.
?-?=
)-?32
*
"
1 )= ?> -?--
( =-?
0
)B.?
&! < ??,,
)? ?- -?-,
( =-?
=.< =<)
0 )B.?
"
" ??6=
). ?- -?-,
2 "
"
" > ??)
)> ?) -?-= )-?32
=-?
0
)B.?
)6
5!
)>B.
=-?
=.< =<)
0 )B.?
) = 0
> *0 <
" " , *0
&! ; -, ?> -?-,
2 ?= ?) -?-= ?B ?) -?-=
!
"E
?B ?) -?-= *0
( -) )> ?) -?-=
"
!"
5! /
?B ?- -?-= " "
; ?> ?B -?-= /"
/
F ! ;E # F;E$
""
"
&
" !
,,<)-<=B??G3
!
& "
&
H H @ 4
"
--.G--<
0
;
5! / # F5/E$
"
% ,/:;)) ;
:< )& )'
- ) ' "
&!
!
!
- - E " ! -#)$#$
'
-??- # F-??- E$ " H!
0
!""- $.%&'( )*0 +,
- . -" $.
/ % 3$$4$8$4 0
%7-!.
-" $./7'
++*406
3 %-!.
&/% 9"8: 30)
33 4 % " $ ; $ !7(7 2< 4$
; 30 6
3 = -"$.&&!/
%'
333 ! ' %' 3 4 1: 44 0
!" $; $%777 &!
"" "
&
""
!" ;
H
!"
" 6#)$ F-??- E 6#)$
/
& /"
/ !"
""
F &E
:!
" 6#)$
F &E
!" ;
!
!"
" 5! / F!!
E
H
5/
" &
4 - , 5! / E
!" " H! "!
01,23$$"434,3 406
33
4 "" -#$. -". / 7 -+ 7'. +,
0>8:3 4 %7""-#$.
-$4./'&'-+% ! % /.3 :43 33 4 0
= -"$. %?777
% 333 %7 / *%
8<)
#)/) ' %
#,
2'
# 6 !2#2
!#
#!+ ! ' , ) !
" ! -#)$#$ -??-
/
:43-+.
" &3 ,)
= !;
;
1
!;
;
* !;
;
!;
;
=
!;
;
-#)$#$ I" ! !
""
&
"
!
""
I" ! !
""
&
"
!
""
> ? / 00< ) @
8
/) / <6
00< A/)& 8 )
8/ 8 ?))
/ <BC
" ! !
""
&
"
!
""
""
""
:
>
:
I" ! !
""
&
"
!
""
""
""
:
& 908
) ;& (
/:6 ) ) :< 8 )() D0 ( );E ) 8/ ) 00<
8<
)&
: ) (;
/8 (( :/
8
< 00< ?) ;
<
)8< )
)8< :
)& : )
/8 (
< );)
)&)< 8 :8 /8 (( , - 0 / 2 E H! )*@ -+. 2
&
'
2
"!
01,
23$$"434,@-+.
" " ->B
+
3 A;$ *3
444
+ +, B$$
4+ 3
$, 4+ 3
3 3 3 4* + 9 43
A+ 3
C;3 *4
$, 4+ +,33 3 $
$ , $* 43$3
$
4$
,4+ +,
4+ +,: 4$3 34 , 4 4+ +,B$$4$3;4 4 , 3 + 33 ;4 4 3
A+ +,C -%.-.B$$, ;3 *4
+4$
4+ +,
+ 3
4+ ;
$3 4 4$*$ ,
4+ 3
3*4"$)
+
,D$3*C , ,
&
"!
& 2
3+ !
" 2 H! )*@-+.
&: "
"!
" "" & )*@-+.
, = 0
# !$ F" !E ""
&
"
!
""
" !
&
!
""
&
!
"
! &
""
: " +" F" !E 0 -?)6
!! ""
=
" ""
:
"
! ""
!! &
""
" : 0 -?)> " F" !E +"
""
" ! &
& &
! 0 -?)> +"
"
*!
&H
F-??- E &!
!
"
!
&
F-??- E " !
!
!3
!"+
!" ""
: "
: " !
!
!
! !
!"+
!
, 6 0 > 8:@ -+. /
""
""
0 J
F" !E
""
:
& !
""
"" "
& "" &
"
!
""
J
""
& !
F" !E & 0
!"
K
""
!
F" !E &3
!! & -?)6
-?)> 0 "
""
& !
" !
""
:
& &
"
+"
/
& > 8:@ -+.
:43-+.
, .
0 "
"!
01,23$$ "434,@-+.
+ ! " F-??- E F" !E &! "
F
"" " H
F" !E
""
&
!
&
""
: , < @ "
" & &
"
!
'
!
" !
@
E
!& " "
!
" !
"
! " !
&H
""
"
E & + , B
" )*@-+.
F" !E
F
"" "
"" 0
""
!
H
F" !E & / 2
)*@-+.
0 3$$4$8$4 @ -+. /
&3
#$ F" !E !
++ *4@ -+.
""
* !
-#$ 9"8:@-+.
! " 2< 4$
; 3@-+.
0
2
&
0 4 1:44@-+.
" )*@-+.
""
: &
!
& ! F-??- E
, > ;
H! 01,23$$ "434,@ -+. > 8:@ -+.
:4 3-+.
!"
: 5/ , )?
"E
"
@ -+.
2
H!
!
! ""
FE FE " ! !" ==3=6 -??- :
"!
2
"
"
-#$#$ -??- 01,23$$"434,@-+.
: &
! " % !++# !+
#
!, ,
"+.' 3$ !, !# 2+! ,' , )) +
! "
"
F &E ; 6#)$
;
/
& /"
/
K
/ ""
F &E
:
" " F &E ; " ;
?> ?B -?-= &!
/"
/
!"
F &E J
" &
0 "
*0
"
" )<,
, )- 5/
"L "! & ?= ?) -?-= ?B ?) -?-=
0(
6 ->
) B> 3
& & :
!!
!"
"
!
"
!
!
@
"
! !
0
!
,,<
* "
! ""
)-- , ), /&
H H @ 4
! "" G" 0 !"
"
!
" ! 3
&
! !
! & &
! " &
( A& , )= 0 "
F;E
:! F &E
"
!
&H
H
!
" )B?
!"
""
" " " -B< 01,23$$"434,@-+.
""" &
&
K "
!
" :! "
!
"
"
&
!
"
!
!" 0
K
!
3
& & , )6 "
34430
4$ 34 %-(.""//%
""" &
" !
+ -?)<
-?)<
"
! B, !
+ -?)<
&
!! !
"
"" " ! H!
"" & " ! " =6 =B )*@-+.
"
% .!+ !
+ ++2
,
.,
, 1FG +
!++' , ).
+
! "E " " 3!" 0 " 6#)$ -??- 0
" )<,
H
"
& !"
F;E 0
" !
*0 &
"
" *0 " "
&!
*0 & " !
5/
!" "
" !
, )< F-??- E "
""
&
! "
! *0
6#)$# $
"
# $
#&$ "
1 !
" "
" !
" !
"
" !
, )B " 6#)$ 3 #$
!
"
)<,
#$
!
!"
"
K ! &
K
#$
!
! " !"
"
, )>
"
)<,
: "
!
" :
" " F" !E "
@3--.BB3 -?-=
*0
( -) )> ?) -?-= )-?2 =-?
0
)6 5! )>B.
0 &: *0
"
5! / &
"!
&
!
&
! &
3
!
3
"
! !
*0
!"
"
K ! :! " 6#)$
> *0 "
"
&!
*0
"
"
!
" "
!!
, -?
"
F;E
!
"E ! ;
" /&
&
!
!" ! ! &
( A& 0
" /&
"
&
&
! !"
5
K
F;E
&H
H
""
" .
-??-
! "
" &
4 .% , !
H ,,
D22#!+$E !# , ! ' , -) +
!
" 5! / !!
!" ;
"
H
" & ;
*
?> ?B -?-= ; )? ?B -?-=
)) ?B -?-=
;
"
H
5! / )- ?B -?-= "
)?
)B><
" !" !
! !
"& 0
H!
"!
4
0*40$ :3 4 " $++$ &!%D &!
?
333 %! & ? F
)?-#,$
+" 3 ):@
B =
)74(1*
8 C
C ,
/
8):D)5$ ! 8):'75 )'D()* $ 5
?
$ & 8):2'
<
"
8
% $
>
< / !
?
47@ 8 3 , E
3
8 B =
8
<
B = B =
B
=
4) @ C B =
" <=- !
8)79 .
8 ();* ) / 5
4! 5 5
5 + = - -C 8 )D 9 B = C .
0 8
8
B =8
F9C - 8()22)*): !)G:54 $ 8);9 H 440 8 C B =
B
=8 B
C =8 B
=8
B
= / 8
8 C
41 C
8
C8
/
& < / 8 B =
<
4;@ 8
)74(1*
$ 8, 8 8C I / 8 C 8B = / 8 C
C
/,
C 8 8
C
A
8
=
I
8 + , -- 0
24
34 340 *4 %77&-++.-?."" /& F!!
F
!
" " +" : " :!
F .% #, # I , ,
!' , -, +
! "E
" : ;
#+ 3)$
( A&
) , !
..
"& 0
!
!
& "
!
"
!
!
"!& "
( A&
!" "
- 6
= -
)- G /
!"
G /"! 0
'
G & "
!"
"
)B )) -?-- " & "!
0
""" :
F;E
"""
"
H
" F-??- E .% , ",I 2+!,
" !
!+ 2+!' , -= +
! "E !
H! "$= 7 (&
!
$3A2< # 306
33 4 333 ? 7 ?3 12 / " 8
/ 140/38 9C
// ;;
47748
8
@ 0/3 8
0/3 C
8 9 /3 @ 9C
// ;;4774
, 8 4774
/
;47/
$
8)2G7(
/$ +*/ C8
8 8
0/3 4774 GG 4774
C
! "" #$ "
%&'(+ .% !.!+!"+$
! !
,
!+ !.
2#$' , -6 5! / E
"
!
&
H
F-??- E
"
!
""
H
F-??- E :
"
, -.
! &
! 5/E
"
& , -< : "
!
&
!
"
" " "
/ 2
)*@ "-+.
""" "
H % #)) '
= ) 4"
" !
!
= - ( &
H
"
"""
&
F!+ 3,!
!+G
F,+ !
#
, * &;:6 < A .JA> .JA>