M/S Spencers Retail Ltd v. M/S Gupta Establishments Pvt Ltd
!
" #$ %
&
%
'
' (
)
*$+
'
#
,#
,#
- #
! " # $ $% & '
(') "*"+,+"-
$% . .
'/
. ' 0 $% $% % ,1 +"
234& ' 0 0
(') "-+",+"3
$% ' . ' 0 $% $% '
(') . $
, # $ $ '0 /.!5,"
,,/6"7.. '
"-1+ 80 '$",1+ 8 ' /.! & "3+1,++* 0 7% ) )) ) "3+1,++* 0
"
-+ +++& ) 0 "19 %4% :
0 8 % ; % ;
) # ;0 ) <",439) "3,++* 0 % ) % )+"+,,++2 0 #
'$% 0 0$% . ,-4,++7
%0 "3+7,++7 ; '
=0 ) ,4 "+ "++& $ ' ) +"+,,++2"3+7,++7 "
,* 3,2& ;
3+ 371&
% ' 4 -1+& 0 ' )
$% ' 7"",++7= % ) '0 4 # 0 $% 0 > 0 $ ''% $% ?0
% ; 0 %$%= @$ :)$%= ' . A 5",34,++2
?
B ?
# ) 0 $ '0 ' 0 $
- # )
1 !
' 0 '
0)$% .
A ,1 +"
234&
;
0 % ' C! ?
5"
% $%
0 % ) $
) 0 C! A ) $ )C!
A $ $% 0
) C!
A $ % . ( C!
A . ( C! ) %
A $ ) (
( C!
3 ?
;) 0
D) A " ) E;"E;"+!
;) 'F'>
D) A " ) E;"E;* )> )>:
* '
. $% (') "*"+,+"- 2 # '
(') $
)0
$% . ' . ' (') "-",+"3 7 # $ ''' $% )'
(')
$% $ . $0 "+ ' % )0 . . ') '
) $ $0 ) &') ","+,+,40 $% ) $ '
G 0 D) "" #% 0 D) ) )) $ ) 0 $ $0 ) ","+,+,4 ) '
) $( (')
$% ."*"+,+"- $% " . (') "-+",+"3 ) ) ) ","+,+,4 ", #
' $ ) ) ))
' $( (')
$% . "*"+,+"-
$% "
. (') "-+",+"3
) ) ) ","+,+,4 "4 # ) &') ","+,+,4 0
$ ) $%$ $% $
"- ?
' $ (')
$% . "*"+,+"- $% " . (') "-+",+"3 ) )
) &') ","+,+,4 0 $
$ '% "1 # )
,#
'
' ( # %
.
//0 Whether reasoned / speaking?
Yes / No Whether reportable?
Yes / No