Phulwinder Singh v. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.(Bpcl) And Others
!"#$%"&'('#)** + , ****"!'!'#)"- ."-("( +
+* +
, ***"(/#)%")!(
0 1+ * , ,
,
,
, 2
- 3 0
! " ! ##$%##& '" (
) *"
! +, +& #+-, ./" #,0 " !" 2
!" 2
! " !
" ) "
3!1 "
5
"
" 1 5'
" #$ -+ #+-6
"
(
#7 -- #+-6 "
!1
#, -- #+-8
!
" ""!
1 /
6+ -- #+-8 ./" 70
!
"
! ""!
4" "
"
1 ) 7
1
! *"
, )4-5-'(!-'&!, )4-5- "
"
"
"
! ! " "1
1
!
" 3 "!!!
! !1
!!
1
-- #8 -# #+-8 "
! 9! : ' ! !
"# 4
"
1
"
!" .
/<0
!
*" "!!! *" ! !1
=
"
+6 +< #+-&
"
!
" @ " . 0
3 "
"
/
-7 +# #+-8
=
-# -# #+-8
1
"
%
)
""
! #8 -# #+-8 ./" --0
(
! #8 -# #+-8 ./" --0 " '
1
"
!
-# 1
" !
"
!
! 1
!1
"
/" "! "!1
"! "
& 1
!
!1 -6 !1
")
!
!!
*"
(
3
9!1
6
*"
!1 " ! 1 !
"
/!
"
" --
'*"!1 #,
"
#7+++%
"
9!1
"
;5'
*"
!1
"
#,
2 "
+6 +< #+-&
"
3 !1 " -- !!
3
"
!!
!1
!1
"
"
")
"
" !1
= "! !!
/" ## #& ;5'
3
5
!1
"! "
" ! !
4 " #,
!1 "1
=
" "!
"! " "
" '!
" $ - .:(((0 3!1
% A9 !1 BC
% A9 !1 BC *" !" *" %
*"
!1 ! !1
" 3 "
= "
!1
;
" !!1 "
3!1
% A9 !1 BC
7
3!1
% A9 !1 BC
"
% A9 !1 BC *"
') !8" $#-9 #$ ) $$'% :'! $-#9 !8";#')!#<)"-(=;#')!3"((""
/<
(
1 "!
"!
! "
"
!1
! ;5'
!1 ;5'
!!
!
! !
=
"
" "
!
./" -0
/"
!1
"
"!
1
1 1 )
) DED
=
/!
!!
!1 !
!
") !1
!!1
> !
1
=
/"
/"
/" #8 -, +8 #+-,
3
" ! " )
!1
1 ! !1
"!!!
"
" ! " )
1
"
"
!1
(
+, +& #+-, #, 1
(
) " *"
)
!1
!
""!
"1
1
*"
!" "
1
"
9!1 ;5'
!1
! !1
"
" " " "
" "!
"
*"
" " ;5' ! 1
= ;5'
!
""!
" --
!1 ;5'
3
" ;5'
"! !!
! !
!!
"
! !1
!
!1
"
!"
"!1
" *"
" !
" )
!! "
!1
! !1
"!!!
"!
"
!!1
"
! !!
" ! " ) !
3 "!
1
!"
!!
)
(
!1
"
/ " ! ##$%##& '" (
'*"!1 1
!!
1
!!
,
, **
!