High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/485/2013dismissed

Yashpal And ORS v. Urmila Devi

2019-02-06Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"#$ "% &&$$ '%( )%*$+ "% & #%

%%+ ,"-&.+ %"&&$$ %/"(" .+ %"%& 1%$- . " % " &$ !"&$. *#%2"."%*#$.%" 3$4 .5,(*%.

3$ .",(*%4(6"%7$$("67 4 77"( "*"8%(6"(6 " 4 1$+5.(8"/" %.$&,(*%4 96 :" 7$$*)%*$+477"/"55(*%+ 6% ( % % &%* 5( %% 6 " &% $* 6 ( % "* %%

& "&$ +%$ 8% 6,":.,"( :

.,$$: ;< .

;;.

. ;

. 2

*(% 6 2 $ *%$ ,"( : . ,$$ : ;

;;

.( "%+ (($ &(%.

="$#" 2&%"5*8 %"-% % 6""&$ ." 7%%%7 %"($ .7"%"$ 7

($& *#%2"4&$ :*%66>"

*#%2"7 $8$&- -% 7$%$

$(* : " 5*8 % " -% > " " *%66 +(% " &$ * #%2" " 8

%* 8- " > " ( " %. &$ * #%2"""8 2$$: ;

*(%

*%$ ?+$+%%*%$ 2$$:

;;.%* 6% 8 6 ($+> " *%$ 7 $ 8- : 4 *)%*$+"( "*.&%% %" &$ & "$%7$+%"+ .

7"" %("&+%"%8 $$ 6*" >""( "*7 & "&%&%-(% "$*. 68( "% %"".&$ && " " "- % $ 68( " &%&%->" : % %(

"% &"&$ >""&$ "$ ( % 6% &%* 5( 7" %6% 2$$ : ;

;

< <7"% "&%7%%

* ( @(> " 7" " "% &"&$ %8$-.$ 666%+"&$ " 8%(6"(%6% &%* 5( "/(% #" 2

6 . : &&% $ 7% * % 6 &%$* %- 85 " " &$ " &&%""/(%7"$ " " *%66"$%-8 %* "%6 $*%66 "8 " +%" :8-"&%% %"&$ "( "*.7""$A( %&%. ;> *( 7"%6%%*& *%66 7 % $- 2" %& 7 "%>

+%"$ &%+"*%66"8 %* + " : %- & . ; % %*& " *%66 (" $ %+% & "%* 6$ ("($ .7""7

& "&$ 7"%"-" %(% $ "(*%21/>"" : "$( % $*6 "&$ 682"& "($ 8( 1/%%*+$31%*"&$ .% "$ $ "*%66$%- & )%*$.7"%""6"%?+$ %"%

*%." +%%"*%667%&%-% $-.

"7+%."( "*"%*"$ 8- A( 6"%& &% " 3$4%& "B%* # "-. ($ &(%> " &$ : " % $$6$ %( "( ,$$: ;

*(% 2 $>"" 7% 6 "+ 6 "% "&$ 8( % 6"*&$ 7%" 6 6"% "% 6"%731 "5 $ )%*$7""

"-" %6" " 7% * $ 8"$ :. " " 2 (& &$ " *%66 " $%- 8

%* %6 $ *%66 7 " +% " :8-&%% %"&$ "( " *.7""A(%&%. ;>"*( 7"

%6%%*& *%667 %>" :"$$( %$*(8* 6" : 8 67 %"($ 8% 6,"7:.,"( : .

,"%: ;<;

;;. ;

(+$$6($ &(%.

="$#" 2"A D"%*%66>"($ ( %$*"A D"% +(%( "* +*%66

<<>""*%667% &%-% *%66*( 7. ;>"" & 2 $ ;*%$76+ "&$ " **%66>"( "*"%+. ;

%*)%*$ %*"*%66 $%

+ 6+ "%6 $*%66)%*$+ $ " +%"& "$ 8% <

;; "( %$* >"" %( %+%&% 1/ $8$8%*+ + & " +%" ( %$* %%*& *%66>""( % $* " %@( " %& & . ; %*"*%66 %*$$-" +%"+ &

"($ %%*+$"31"( %$* 8( >" "( %$*7$ ="&$ "$%&$ "7% * $8- : %+% 6"$$6 " 7% * 7"%%% 6"+%* "&$ &$ (*7% * " ( % $* $ 8- :7$$ 8"$"&$ ""*%66 $-8%*8-*2 6 %* "%+%"*%66 " %* %@(%%6% " $-"%*8-A( %6($%%*& ("%*& %@(% *&($%-%6% "(* A 6("%6"

**+8$ &%&%- &&% " " "+ 8%"$$6%& "@(-%*& "8

$8-$(A*>""*%66 $8$8%*

7"(&-* "*&%+* $*

"&$ 6"&%.$$7 6(7% %*

E""%"&$ % & "($ *%66F ##

E""%"&$ "+*"*&%+* " *%66&%&%-F ## E""%"&$ % $%$&%* 5( &%-%F ## E""%" % $%& 87- %*& ( $ % &-* . ; *%66* -$$6 "( %$*F # $ %%&%+"%."&$ "A* "5,(*%.+#E ="&$ !"#$""*$ &&%#E

" "% " . " A* #%8" /" % E . )%*$ + E. B(%& ,(*%. 6% /$%2E ","5 .+E %"% 6"$% ( $%"&%."%$ /(%(: &%$- +(%"&$ 6 " .(: 6 "&$

< +(%" .(: 6 "( %$* +(%"&$ ($ $-."("&$ 7 %&%$- $-"A 2 $ *%$7" %% .7"%"( %$*$8- :7 * G$ 666%+8-"5(6* %." :4*)%*$+"$ &&$ "/(% %9(6.B(%&(%7"% %85 7%$8- "&$ .7""7%6 $%9(6 ". G =%2 /(%. B(%&(%. 7" + 5(6* $$7"&&$($ $-.

%85 ("&$ 7%*="( %$*7% " :7( $5 & "$"%&% $ *(% 62 $ *%$(85 &-* *%66* -. ;%& ;&$ %8&7"/(%7" 7* "%*" &%&% &-5(6* ="5(6* %$ "&$ 66%+ "-"+$"&% %6($% &&$ 8% " /(%. 7"" 7 ( " %& C"+"%$% ( $%"&%86 "%(6""%% C -*% "&&$ H+ &%7 "&$ .

8 6 7 % " ( $ " *%66 " * 7"

& 7""&$ "(6" *%$$ 8- "G%&&$$/(%#%CC7$8-*)%*$+ "( "*. "7-"&(7"%6%%* 6 2 $ *%$$ #%C8-"G%&&$$ /(%% 6"" ."*%66" 8 %*8-&-* *%66*( . ;=" %6 $ *%66 7 " +% : 8- &%% % " &$ "( "*. 7" " A( %&%. ;?7+%. ("+% " 7 &8-"G%&&$$/(%%" % "*( 7"%6%%*& *%667 % $-2"%&"8 (8-"( "* ="(.

82 ""$ 7$$( %*%667"" &$ "-"+8 & "%*%66 *%66%"6%6"%*"*%66 &-* *%66* - 6"& 82 : *%66%"2 (&&$""%- &" *%66* -. ;%%*& *%66.

"(6"$%"&&$$ ; :$ "*%66 "% "$"% "#% $ *(% 62 $ *%$.7"%"%& ; : 7%6+

2 $ *%$"$ *&% 2$$:

;;.% 6$ : ="G%&&$$/(% &%: "5(6* " 8%+"&&$$ ; :"%+%* "" "*%66"% "$"% #% $ *(% 62 $

*%$.$"(6" "*%66."%"8 6+ 2 $ *%$ =" G% &&$$/(%" 8%+" &""&&$$ ; :"8%(6" %% *%66HA &(%&%"+8 A(8-"%

+(%( "*.&%% %"&$ ""A* B(%&,(*%.?6% /$%2E .

7""8%(6""(** %%"7 6"*%66 HA 7 %6% " (8 6%% E ","5 .+"&%6% 6*%66 HA "+ 68 %88-""%"G@%/" "5

1(" "G%&&$$/(%"8%+" &&$$ ; :$&%+%&HA7"%6% %*& (" %& &%+ " %*& *%66 @( $-8$"" :"* & ($ 7 %%%*& ("%& 7 *8$ + % %6% $6"

"6% . C"$8

8-"G%&&$$/(%"%"% &(%"

*%$$ %*&&$$ ; :.&$ "+ 8* "%% " % ( $ *(% 2 $ *%$="$ 8 6$$5 ."%%.&&$$ ; : ($ 6"%$& 8-%*+$*$8%*"% "%%"(6""7 $%5 & "$ "%#% "($ %%*& *%66 (&&%" ""( %$*$

8%%8-$* $% ( $%"%& " %%%("%-

8-? I8$(&%*/(%7"% 78%+" ((%((%-*%66%6"%+%- & 8-%*& ** 7" *%66* - &(% &%%&%$-(% &% &%$-8-&-* %&8-*%66%&%+( %

=# ( $" $* %%"&(%& %$

""($"3* C7(%"% 8%+" ((%((%-*%66.*%A&%- &% -%%*"% *%66 A 6(""%6"*%66%( % "=# ="*%66 "7%8-A( *%66 << ="%%. " ( % $*

% $- 8%%8-$* :"%& 7&%%&(%7% 8"$ "&&$$ ="5(6* %&8-G%&&$$/(% 7$$% .8(& &%&%&&%$ &&% + %% %&% $7="% $$6$-% %*-"%

G *% "&% &&$."* *7"

1%5

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#