(O&M) Nagina Judge v. Purshotam Singla & ORS
!" #!$!$ " #$ "%&%%' ( "%)(*+#
,
-./ !$ 01
%/ -./!!$ 0% "%"%2%# , ( "% "% (# ,
-./!!$ 01
%/ -./ !$ 0% "%34"3# , ( "%5 3# , % -%
% * ), (
) (
# , , 4 , ) (
) %*%!6- -% $%!$$78$0%$-%!$$.8 7% !%!$ ,)
3
$9%$0%!$ #
: ( ,, # ) +
)4 (4 3 %
# 3
, '# ; + < = "3>( ?
3 # # (
, 4> ()
)
@#
) ( 4 ) ?# )4 (4
$0%$!%!$$-
!- <-<( 4 ) ( :
3
# , 4 % # ## )
: 4 ( , % * @ % @, > ,?# % %% " 3
$9%$0%!$
( ( 3 @ # % %% " ( , 3
!6%$.%!$ 0
8
%*( (
, ) ) + % * )
) )
, , ( # 4 3
) ( (( 4 ) %* 4 4 %*
$0%$!%!$$- !- < - <(% *
( 0-#97#$$$8 >
A 4 :-<?%; # 0$%$$ ( ,
( , 4 4 $%$$ ( ) )
0 %$0%!$$- )
$%$$ )
0 %$/%!$$- )
) #
<% *
4 ( 4 ( # 4( )
)
) + %5 0 %$0%!$$-
% ) , 4 4 (
) #
<( $%$$ (
) (
6 $$ %% / $$ %% )
4
+ )4 BA
, " #
<% 5 , 0 %$0%!$$-
3
> ? ) A 6%0/
$%7/ (( )
4 4
%)
) ,, % , 4
(
,
, )
%*
0$%$.%!$$- ) )4 , ( ,, ( ,)
< ) * 4;
3 ( 4
)
BA
, "
,
%*#
, ) #
, 3 ,
+
% *
# ( ) 4 )3
+ ( 4 ( ( ,
) (
$0%$!%!$$-
( # ) )4
# 4 4( (4 4 (
)
(
( ,
( )4
A )
) 4 ,
#
( , $!%$6%!$$-
4%; #
) : ) +)4
4 ,
( '4 ( $ %$.%!$$7
:)
)
% *
) ) #
@# ) )
#
4
#(
,)
) 4 )
%
# @ ( % C
(
$0%$!%!$$-D; !% C
( (4 4 (
D; 0% C
, > %?
D; -% C ) D; /%
% *
, # A C ;%% @<+ ( )4 4 C! + = & @ 3)<+ )
BA% BA%-(
)
,
C0 < @ + * ;
# 3 ) )
)
,
# ( C- "3 = , ,
3 /$#$$$8) ,) 4 * ;
# 3 ,
% C/ = 4 , , C7
4
* BA
, " #
< ,
,
( )4 4 C9=
C %
2 A C.
% * ( )4 4 C6 ( )
0 %$/%!$$-
)
<%C $ <)
, 4
%;
;+ < C ) 4 C. 4C !="3
C %*
,
, BA% BA%71
, 0$%$.%!$$-BA%91 4 BA%.1
BA%6 BA% /1 4
4 BA% 71
, 0 %$0%!$$- BA% $ BA% 91 4
, 0 %$/%!$$- BA% 1 4
,BA% !1 4 4 BA% 01 4
)+BA% .1 4 BA% 6#BA%!$ BA%!$8 1@ @ BA%! 1 4 ( BA%!0 BA%!-1 4 )
BA%!/1 4 5* BA%!71 4
%0@<BA%!91 5* BA%!.BA%0 1
@ BA%0!BA%./15* BA%.7BA%6 4 4 BA%6!% ;
, A 3 C (
) C!=3 (
, , (
BA% /% C0 ,
*
)
,, )
( )4
3 C- = & ( E BA ,
%5
#
, BA% 4
1 BA% ! BA% 0 ( 41 BA% 4
1 BA% / 4
,1 BA% -8
1BA% 7 4
1BA% 9 4
,1BA% . 4
1BA% 6 4 3) 4 !$$.$61BA% $ 4 4 %
)4 @$9%$0%!$ )4
@ , 3
!6%$.%!$ 0# (
% & "%"%2%# , )4"% "% (# , ( "% &%% ' ( "% )( *+# , )
8
"%34"3# , )4"%5 3# ,
8
% 5 )
(()*+,* &*-./,/./0&/,!12+3422*&$ 5& 06 0+70&2 12/+&# *5*8 099/08 : :; $
! < : ,/.*,/, - :% @
) : (, ( ,
- 3) @
# 6 . (
3) &4% 5 ( (#
( ) + ( :<<:(=*-,)360+++0 5>&613+?*1)03+# , 4
4 )
( :)
$
# , 4 , 4
%*
( ,
, 4 ) 4 ,
# ) ( ( # ) # ) )4
( @ % %&( , # )
@#"%"%2%# , )4"% "% (# , ,
@ %
) % E )# ( , 4
%! -
) )4
% * ,
)
)4
, ( )4 ( ; 5 / @@ *-@+*1*-40-, &*4-/,AB12/90+1B# 4
:<< $ (61 3721*0+)03+5>&61380A)03+#0-,
::: ! $
C ()0+06 20-, 5>& 2060- $08#
)
4 4 4 )4 4 %" , # )4
(08*9*-42 0-12/+50,23*-42 12/+&# ! $ <C: 4 ( % * , 4 ,
$
, 4 :
( ) (
( 4 ( (%*
G ) )
( )4
) ,
%* , 4
4 ( 4( 4) 4 ,
, ,
#
)4 <+# 4 ,
+ )
BA
, " 8)
, 4BA%9#BA%.#BA% $#BA% 9#BA% #BA% !#BA% 0 (
( ( )4) ,, # )
( +<+
* *) $0%$!%!$$/#BA%!0 BA%!-# ,
(
% &,
( $%7/ #
G ) 0$%$$ (
4 $%$$ ) #
(( (
% * , 4 4
A 3
C (
4,
!%$$ '4 ($ %$.%!$$7
)
)4
)4 %E# , 4
#
, , ) ( 4 ) # !%$$ ( )4
% @#
, 4
:)
)
(
)
(( 4 4
), % *
4
)
@ ,
; - !9@@ (
/ @@ )
,
)4(4
$0%$6%!$$-(
8F@
(
A
-%*
#
,
((*880040- 20- /,,B 0-,0-12/+5*8800-?//50 /,,B0-,12/+&# ::!C:; 0-, (2B06 908 *-,08 0-, 12/+& 5 $0-, .D3*&*1*- *./+ 0-,0-12/+# ! C
,
4, ,+
4
, )4
)
4 (
( 4 )
)
4 )# ( )
( 4 #
6$ B,
0$4
) )
) )4"%"%2%# , )4 "% "% (# , ( (
) 4 3
% , , )
) 4( + )4 ,
,)
)
( ) )
4
# , ) ) (
4 ,
# 4 ) ,
+
@# @3 ( ,
4%
:::
! C
!( 06 085>&05*10=/+60#*
) % * ( 0+*0 80. 0-12/+ 5& 8A0 8+0 /+6*-,0#&3E0#
!C;*880040- 20- /,,B#& .0&/ *A*,! 2B06 908 *-,08#& .0&/ *A*,!
4% * ( )
)
( *70-,0+ ! AB $ & 5 ) 3A+060-* 12/+&# !<;( 3*8,/+& 0-12/+5&
060,0& 0 0-12/+# ! :; (0+0,060-* )0-,0990- 5 0?0807&26* 12/+&# ! ;(01B0 0*- ,/0,! 12+342 $ & 5 -*& 26/, 3&2,*/ ,/0,! 12+342 $ &# ! ; () =*,B0-0,06 12/+& 5 =0*+050-# ::<<;( /660,0 +0A2070+ 12/+&53-46/-#& =B&B0 &&.*01*- 12/+&# C! 39+/6/ :; ( 0- )03+
,/0,! AB $ & 5 0+10+ *-42 0-420# ! ; 0-, ( 0,607360+* 12/+&5&0&0BB0- 12/+&# !39+/6/ C< ) , )4 )4 (372A*+*-42 12/+&5&+*? 08*-42 12/+&#::C ! ; ( &1 340-* 5 06/&2@0+ 0& 0-12/+#
!
*5*8! :;(01B0 0820+60 0-12/+504?*1 0*=/+60# ! *5*8!C0-,( 3*8,/+& 0-12/+5 060,0&
0 0-12/+# *A*,!; * @ 5 >& 3*8,/+&# .0&/
*A*,! ( ( )
( ( H ( G ( (
4
( H G
4
H( G 4 ( % * , 3
) (
!
"
" #$ % $ #!
" " # %
" %$ "
"
" # %
# %$ & #!
!
" & " " ' % %$ # !
!
! !
" " & (! #
$ #!
" " )
%'
! !# ! " & " # $ " $%
% %*!
" + "
$#$
%#!
" " #!
" %(!# $ ! " & "$
" " #
##$
$ #!
" , !" ! #$$% &
&% -. % %
"
" % #!
" &' # # ! %$
# " / 0()
"%# % &
#!
" # ' # $ ! # #
' " % " !
" 1 * 2 >& 3*8,/+&# .0&/ *A*,! , )4 +
4
4(
)4
)
: #
%5 #
) ,
, 4
$0%$!%!$$- 0$%$$ BA% 7 ,
)
() ( $%$$ 0 %$0%!$$- 0 %$/%!$$- ( 4 ,
,
A # BA% BA%7 )
4 BA% . BA%!$# BA%!$ # BA%! # BA%!/#BA%!7#BA%!9BA%0 #BA%0!BA%./#BA%.7BA%6 ,
)
( , 4 ,4 ,) ( ( ))4(4 4 , 4
% *
G ( ) 3
# ) , )4 "% )
%
,
( ( (
#(, 4 (+
) , ) :
, )4 # '4 (
#((( 4,
$ %$.%!$$7%
7> ?
( ( 3 + ) ( ) 3 , ,
) % &( , #
) ( )
, % , ) + # :
3 @# )
@
,
)
)
@ $/%$-%!$ #
( (
, 4 ( 3
@ ( (
%" # ,
4 ,
( ) ,4+
, (
# ( ,)
) 3 4
+ )4 ( (
)4
# ) %* (H372A*+*-42 12/+&5&+*?
08 *-42 12/+&#; ( &1 340-* 5 06/&2@0+ 0& 0-12/+#; (01B0 0820+60 0-12/+504?*1 0*=/+60#0-,( 3*8,/+& 0-12/+5 060,0& 0 0-12/+# *A*,! )4 ( )4 , @
4 (
((
, )
)4
(0+0,060-* )0-,0990- 5 0?0807&26* 12/+&#; (01B0 0*- ,/0,! 12+342 $ & 5 -*& 26/, 3&2,*/
,/0,!12+342$ &#;()=*,B0-0,06 12/+&5=0*+050-#;0-, ( /660,0 +0A2070+ 12/+&53-46/-#&=B&B0&&.*01*- 12/+&# *A*,! ,
4 %
@ (
@ ( +
, 4 ) ,
(
)4,
!!
#
)4 @
4 3 ( @
, # 4 (
) ) ,
%
:C A <(+080+9 03801 065>&$18$072A*+*-42%)*+908*-42 0-12/+# 5 #
) % %
! 0+.2%
C +8 I 8 C
) I 8