High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1166/2015dismissed

Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd And ANR v. Subhash Chand Gupta

2015-07-02Mr. Justice K.C. Puri6 pages

!" #"$%&%'

(

)&*%' +, ' %-.%/%!+ '%0 12!# '# '!*"+ 33".. '!& 4"+&5& 56* &** '#53! "&3'#"'! 7892 : ;*"!*"+"3+!"+& 2$ ."<&3 3"+&1 ,6" ..<"#! &""!*"-5#01"'!= "&

6"+"

"++"#!!*""3+!"+&+'!="& >;*"!*"+!*"-5#01"'!&*5.#6"+"3+!"#%'!*"%0"&!="& +"&"'!7 +5+"'#"+*5..?#4$ !" +!*" 33".. '!

+!*"+" &'&1"'!%'"#%'!*" 33.%$ !%'?#". , @# ,& %' %.%'0!*" 33" .&! '#&$'#'"# &! '#&#%&3&"# $$+#%'0.,

"'# '!8 33".. '!8 )&*%' +, ' %-.%/%!+ '%0 12!# '# '!*"+* 4"#%+"$!"#!*"3+"&"'! 33" . 0 %'&!!*" -5#01"'! '# #"$+""# !"#

A3 &&"#6,*+%56* &** '#"++ %? ." +'"# ##%!%' .%&!+%$!5#0"? .< .4%#"<*%$*!*" 33" .3+" "++"#6,!*"

"'# '!& 0 %'&!!*" -5#01"'! '##"$+""# !"#

>3 &&"#6,

+ /%- , '! "*0 .? !*" !*"' ." +'"# ##%!%' . %4%. 5#0" "'%+ %4%&%'? .< .?< &#%&1%&&"# > *"$ &"

%'6+%"

%&!* !3. %'!%

* & %."#!*"

&5%! +#"$. + !%' 0 %'&!!*"#"

"'# '!& .."0%'0!*"+"%'!* !*"%& '

"."$!+%$%!, 3<"+ $'&51"+ $11"+$% . #"

"'# '! 5'#"+ !*"

$'!+. '#1 ' 0"1"'! #"

"'# '! * 4%'0 $11"+$% ."."$!+%$ $''"$!%' $$5'!8>B ( !*%&&*3' 1"., B&""3<""!&

%' C +? .< .?"*&%. .< .?%&!+%$! +%# 6 # '< .< . %# "."$!+%$1"!"+

< &5! +#"+ '#3. %'!%

14"# '

33.%$ !%'!#"

"'# '! +$* '0%'0& %#1"!"+ !"+%'&3"$!%'?

$! 1"!"+6"%'05! +#"+< & 33+"$% !"#6,#"

"'# '! '#*"

&)"#!*"3. %'!%

!#"3&%!&(

B8 &"D3"'&"& +$* '0%'0 1"!"+?

<*%$* < & #"3&%!"# 6,3. %'!%

'# 1"!"+$* '0%'0 +#"+< & .& 3 &&"#6,#"

"'# '!0%4%'0#%+"$!%'!!*".%'"53"+%'!"'#"'!! $* '0"!*"1"!"+ '#+"3+!!* &6""' 5+!*"+ 4"++"#!* !'

( !< 3"+&'& $ 1"! !*" &*3 3. %'!%

'# !.# *%1 !* ! !*", +"

"13.,""& #"

"'# '!*", .&!.#3. %'!%

!* !!*",* 4"$1"

!$* '0"!*"#"

"$!%4"1"!"+ '#!*",+"14"#!*""."$!+%$1"!"+ '#!.# !*"3. %'!%

!* !!*",<5.##"3&%!!*"#"

"$!%4"1"!"+%'!*"&!+" '# !*"+"

!"+'"<1"!"+$ '6"%&&5"# '#& 1"<5.#6"%'&! .."#'"D!# , '# !*", !) < , !*" #"

"$!%4" 1"!"+ ' !*" '"D! # ,? 3. %'!%

33+ $*"##"

"'# '! '#!.#*%1!* !*%&"13.,""&* #! )"'!*" "$!%4"1"!"+ *%&&*3,"&!"+# ,65!!*",* 4"'!%'&! .."#!*"'"< 1"!"+& + "

"'# '!!.#!*"3. %'!%

!* !'3<"+1"!"+%& +" #%., 4 %. 6." !3+"&"'! '#%!<5.#6" 4 %. 6."%'!*""4"'%'0 '#

> <%..6"%'&! .."#!%.."4"'%'0'., '>

(<*"'3. %'!%

&)"# "'# '!!%'&! ..!*"'"<1"!"+!*"'%'&!" # %'&! ..%'0 '"< 1"!"+?#"

"'# '!%.."0 ..,* '#"#4"+!*"!<'!%$"&6" +%'01"1 > '# A!!*"3. %'!%

'# &)"#*%1!#"3&%!& ?

A?>( B8 "

"'# '!!*+" !"'"#3. %'!%

!* !% *"<5.#'!#"3&%!!*"& 1"

!*"' !*"

!$ &"<5.#6"+"0%&!"+"# 0 %'&!*%1"'$"!*"&5%! ' 35! ! '!%$"? #"

"'# '!& 33" +"# '# %."# <+%!!"'

&! !"1"'!! )%'03+".%1%' +,6-"$!%'&4%C&5%!%&'!1 %'! %' 6."%'!*" 3+"&"'! +1E!* !3. %'!%

%&"&!33"#6,*%&<' $! '#$'#5$!! %."

!*"3+"&"'!&5%!E!* !3. %'!%

* &'!$1"<%!*$." '* '#& '#* & $'$" ."# '#&533+"&&"#!*"!+5" '#1 !"+% . $!& +1!*"$5+!"!$'

1"+%!&?#"

"'# '!&#"'%"#!* !3. %'!%

%&* 4%'0 $11"+$% ."."$!+%$ $''"$!%'%'*%&3+"1%&"& '#&561%!!"#!* !3. %'!%

%&* 4%'0 #1"&!%$ "."$!+%$$''"$!%'%'*%&3+"1%&"&6" +%'0 $$5'!8>B ( '#%& $'&51"+ #"

"'# '!& 5'#"+!*"& %# $$5'!'516"+ '3%'0* ++ B""3<""!5&"%&!"' '! 3. %'!%

56* &** '#53!

'#!*""."$!+%$$''"$!%'%&+5''%'0%'!*"' 1" 56* &** '#53! "

"'# '!&#"'%"#!* !"."$!+%$1"!"+ 3. %'!%

< &5! +#"+ '#

3. %'!%

14"# ' 33.%$ !%'!#"

"'# '! +$* '0%'0& %#1"!"++ !* !#"

"'# '!' &)"# 3. %'!%

!#"3&%!&(

B8 &"D3"'&"& + $* '0%'0 "."$!+%$1"!"+..!*"+ 4"+1"'!& !*"3. %'!<"+"#"'%"# 6"%'0<+'0 '#%'$++"$!

+"3.%$ !%'< & %."# +1!*"3." #%'0& !*"3 +!%"&?

..<%'0%&&5"&<"+" + 1"#78 ;*"!*"+!*" &&"&&1"'!+#"+# !"#> (1"1

' > +&AA>( B8 '#1"1' A ++"$4"+, & ?

B8 +"%.."0 .?'5.. '#4%# '#'!6%'#%'0 53'!*"+%0*!&

;*"!*"+!*"3. %'!%

%&"'!%!."#! #"$+"" + 1 '# !+,%'-5'$!%'#%+"$!%'0!*"#"

"'# '!&!+"

5'# &51 &

A>( B8= > ;*"!*"+!*"&5%!%&'!1 %'! %' 6."= ;*"!*"+!*"3. %'!%

* &'.$5&&! '#% '#$ 5&" $!%'! %."!*"3+"&"'!&5%!=

".%"

*"3 +!%"&* 4"."#!*"%++"&3"$!%4""4%#"'$"'!*" +"& %# %&&5"& !"+ 33+ %& . !*"& 1"?!*"!+% .5+!#"$+""#!*"&5%! !*"

3. %'!%

4%#"-5#01"'! '##"$+""# !"#

> ( "".%'0#%&& !%& %"#<%!*!*" +"& %# -5#01"'! '##"$+""

# !"#

>?!*"#"

"'# '!&#%+"$!"#!*"%+&!33" .?<*%$*< & #%&1%&&"#6,." +'"###%!%' .%&!+%$!5#0"? .< .4%#"-5#01"'! '# #"$+""# !"#

A !"++"8 33+ %& . !*""4%#"'$" F !%.. "".%'0#%&& !%& %"#<%!*!*"-5#01"'! '##"$+""# !"#

A '#-5#01"'! '##"$+""# !"#

>?!*"3+"&"'!+"05. + &"$'# 33" .* &6""'#%+"$!"#6,!*"#"

"'# '!& @ *" 33".. '!%'3 + 0+ 3*F !*"0+5'#& 33" .* & 1"'!%'"#!* ! ..<%'0&56&! '!% .G5"&!%'& . <* 4" +%&"'%'!*"

3+"&"'!+"05. +&"$'# 33" .78 % ;*"!*"+5&%'0"."$!+%$%!, +1 #1"&!%$1"!"+ + $11"+$% .35+3&"%& 15'!!!*"

!= %% ;*"!*"+<*"'!*"

!%&4%&%6." +1!*"' )"#","%!%& '"$"&& +,!&"'#!*"1"!"+ +$*"$)%'0= %%% ;*"!*"+5'#"+"$!%'&> '#> !*"?%4%. 5+!* &-5+%&#%$!%'!"'!"+! %'!*"&5%!=

2" +'"#$5'&". +!*" 33".. '!* &&561%!!"#!* !6!*!*"

5+!&6".<#"$+""#!*"&5%!

'.,'!*"0+5'#!* !!*"

%$"+?<** &$'#5$!"#!*"+ %#* &'!6""'"D 1%'"#!%&&561%!!"# !* ! ',65&%'"&&#'"%'!*"+#%' +,$5+&" 65&%'"&&&* ..6"3+"&51"# !6"$++"$! %'4%"< "$!%'A !*"4%#"'$"$!?6!*!*"

5+!& 6".< * 4" <+'0., #%&$ +#"# !*" +"3+! $*"$)%'0 ! %& &561%!!"#!* !%'$ &"!*"+"3+! $*"$)%'0%&! )"' &%!%&?%'!* !$ &"?' $ &" +%'-5'$!%'%&1 #"5!" .& !*"1"!"+<"+" 5'#! 13"+"#!

< & $ &" !*"

! "'"+0, '#'%'-5'$!%'%'!* !+"&3"$!$ '6" ..<"# * 4"$ +"

5..,$'&%#"+"#!*"& %#&561%&&%'65!#'! %'# ', +$"%'!* !&561%&&%' !%&&"!!."#3+%'$%3."& . <!* !&"$'# 33" ..%"&'.,%

',&56&! '!% .G5"&!%' . <* & +%&"''!*"3+"&"'!$ &"?6!*!*" 5+!&6".<* 4"#%&$ +#"#!*"+"3+! $*"$)%'0'4 +%5&0+5'#& %'$.5#%'0!* !3"+&'<** &$'#5$!"#!*"+ %#?* &'!6""'"D 1%'"#! %&'!#%&35!"##5+%'0!*"$5+&" +051"'!!* !'

%$"+B

%$% .?<*%& 3 +!,!!*"+ %#* &6""'"D 1%'"#+" &' 6.""D3. ' !%'* &6""' 0%4"' +!*"& 1"!< &'.,!*"1"16"+ + %#%'03 +!,?<*$5.# * 4""D3. %'"#<*"!*"+!*"!*"

! "'"+0,* # $!5 ..,! )"'3. $"!* !*"5+!&6".<* 4"6&"+4"#!* !$ &" "."$!+%$%!, +#< &!* !1"!"+ < &&" ."#65!!*"& 1"< &'!&"'!!!*"2 6+ !+, +"&! 6.%&*%'0!* !

$! +" &'%'0 * & 6""' 0%4"' + '! &"'#%'0 !*" 1"!"+ ! !*"

2 6+ !+,?"4"'#5+%'0!*"$5+&" +051"'!&?* 4"'*"&%! !%'%'

*.#%'0!* !'G5"&!%' . <* & +%&"'%'!*"3+"&"'!$ &" > '&"G5"'!.,?!*" 33" .%&<%!*5! ',1"+%! '#!*"& 1" &! '#&#%&1%&&"# A $3, !*%&-5#01"'!6"&"'!!!*"!+% .5+! +&!+%$!

$13.% '$"