High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2582/2016dismissed

Rashid Mohd v. Nirmal Singh & ORS

2016-09-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'(#)"#*+#, '-.

!&/%-/!**!- ))#00!'"

1#,&2& %,*!0%'3/ "/#,& #&)'-#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

,#&#'"( ,'%0/240!.-5$!"#.

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

3,##*#'""&#00-!"#- C8D=%"/!04%!"%'3/!'-!,&/!'%'3/!&!'-%=!&*"/#, ,#&)'-#'"&D"&)#,"/#"#,*&!'-$'-%"%'"/#!3,##*#'"" &#00.!,#*#'"%'#-.)&&#&&%'"/#),)#,"9=!&/!'-#-5#,!,&/!' %'3/!'-!04%!"%'3/#:#$2"#-!3,##*#'""&#00-!"

!52,0+!0%/-',!4&/.!"/#,-##'-!'"&"C

!'-!"#,/%&-#!"/.,#&)'-#'"&"C+#$*#"/#='#,"/#),)#,"9. =/2,"/#,#:#$2"#-"/#!3,##*#'""&#00-!"#- %'!52, ,#&)'-#'".=/2,"/#,#'"#,#-%'"!'!3,##*#'""&#00=%"/"/# )0!%'"%'8!'-,#$#%5#-""!0&!0#$'&%-#,!"%'D.;7

&&#&&%'!$$,-%'309=!&/!'-#-5#,""/#!))#00!'"7)0!%'"%.=/ ,!%&#-"/#$'&",2$"%'!'-&"!,"#-0%5%'3%'"/#/2&#"/"/#2,"& +#0=/!5#!%0#-"'"%$#"/#!$""/!""/23/"/#!3,##*#'""&#00=!& '",#3%&"#,#-.+2""/#)&&#&&%'/!&+##'/!'-#-5#,""/#!))#00!'"7 )0!%'"%!"#,!$$#)"%'3"/#200$'&%-#,!"%'))#00!'"7)0!%'"%%&#'"%"0#- " ),"#$"%' 2'-#, #$"%' <7 "/# ,!'&#, ,)#,"9 $"

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

4#"/#+#'#%"),5%&%'&#$"%' <7"/#,!'&#, ,)#,"9$"!'-,%3/"09&."/#$2'"#,$0!%*/!& +##'-#$,##-/#$'$2,,#'"%'-%'3&$!''"+#%'"#,#,#-=%"/2'0#&&!'- 2'"%0"/#,#%&3,&&%00#3!0%"9.=/%$//!&'"+##'*!-#2"2""/#%'-%'3 "/#2,"+#0=@2!!3,##*#'""&#00%&'"&2&"!%'!+0#.%'5%#="/# ),5%&%'&#$"%'C8"/# #3%&",!"%'$"."/2&.

,"/#,#3%'3,#!&'&.-'"%'"#'-"-%#,=%"/"/# $'$2,,#'"%'-%'3&,#'-#,#-+9+"/"/#2,"&+#0=.=/%$/!,#+!&#-' !)),#$%!"%',!0!'--$2*#'"!,9#5%-#'$#.*2$/0#&&'&2+&"!'"%!0 @2#&"%'0!=!,%&#&,-#"#,*%'!"%' ))#!0&"!'-&-%&*%&&#- 012

, *)+%

134 '(-.& +404356 73

837

+404 02!

837