← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2586/2016dismissed

Haryana Urban Development Authority And ANR v. Rakesh Budhiraja Etc

2023-01-06Mr. Justice B.S. Walia12 pages

  



      

 !"#$"%&'&#()**+

 , -

     .//"00 (!' ,"1'2' 3  

  .*"'/#(4"(!

'

#1 5)

#(670" 1*2'!&%"**8 0&  1"'"(!)

1* 14""/ 9/2!:4;#% !"$#1!<" //"00 (!'*

1* *3* (4 : 4;#% !": 1* < 1 57&1 < 1= ;: 4;#% !": '* 21& (4 : 4;#% !": 1* 9 >  1! / &(=<:4;#% !" (4 1*320?&(4"1< 1= ;:4;#% !"$#1 1"'/#(4"(!#**

1* 2(&'<"<0:4;#% !"$#1-'#$1"'/#(4"(!#** @@@ **8 0& :* 1 0 AB

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

AB  1"$"11"4 !# ' I  %! EFFJ 7"'&4"' !<" %&;&0 %#21! < 4 (# 921&'4&%!&#( !# &(!"1$"1" &( !<" 5 !!"1 5#1"#;"1: /21'2 (! !# $1"'< &('/"%!&#(:(#(%#5/#2(4 70";&#0 !&#('?"1"$#2(4* A+B "1%#(!1 :0" 1("4%#2('"0$#1!<"1"'/#(4"(!'7>1"$"11&(=!# !<"4"%&'&#(#$!<&' #21!&(

 



!



 "

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

!

)

*"



)



 





"

  $+% && $ % #*-" 1("4%#2('"0 %#(!"(4'!< !#(%"!<"1"&' '/"%&$&%/1#;&'&#(!#4" 0?&!<;&#0 !&#('#( %%#2(! #$ 72&04&(= 7>0 ?' G H#(&(= /0 (': %!&#( $&1'!0> < 4 !# 7" ! C"( 2(4"1 "%!&#(   %! EFF (4 #(0> &$ !<" 00#!!"" 4&4 (#! '<#? % 2'" #1 4&4 (#! 4# !<" (""4$20 ' 1"K2&1"4 !# 7" 4#(" 2(4"1 "%!&#( 

%!:EFF!<"(!#&(&!& !" %!&#($#11"'25/!&#(72!!< !(# %!&#($#1 1"'25/!&#(? '92'!&$&"4&(!<"$&1'!&('! (%"* ADB  < ;" %#('&4"1"4 !<" '275&''&#(' #$ 0" 1("4 %#2('"0 (4 ?&!<!<"&1 70" ''&'! (%"=#("#;"1!<"1"%#14 '/1#42%"4*/"12' 0#$ !<" 924=5"(! (4 4"%1"" / ''"4 7> !<" 0" 1("4 &;&0 24=" 2(&#1 &;&'&#(: (%<C20 1";" 0'!< ! '2&!< 47""($&0"4$#14"%0 1 !&#(!< ! %!&#(&(&!& !"47>!<"4"$"(4 (!'G //"00 (!'2(4"1"%!&#(F: 

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

&#(G 1 &'&(=&00"= 0 #1 2( 2!<#1&H"4 %#('!12%!&#( /1#<&7&!"42(4"1!<" %!:EFF (4"=20 !&#('#$EFE (4 '!# ?< ! %!&#( %#204 7" &(&!& !"4 = &('! !<" 00#!!""  (4 2(4"1 ?<&%< /1#;&'&#( #$ 0 ? (4 7> 1"$"11&(= !# !<" 4"%&'&#( #$ !<&' #21!

 



!



 "

# $% && $ %"

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

ADB   



, - .  

/   "

 + $ % /& &(?<&%<!<"/0" 1 &'"47> ? '!< !!<"'2&! ? '/1"5 !21"* #?";"1:!<"' &4/0" ? '(#! %%"/!"4?<&0"#7'"1;&(= !< !'&(%"!<";"1>7 '&'#$!<" %!&#(&(&!& !"47"&(= = &('!!<"  %! (4?&!<#2!921&'4&%!&#(:!<" &;&0 #21!< 4!<"921&'4&%!&#(!#'"! '&4" !<" (#!&%" (4 %#('"K2"(! /1#%""4&(=' (4 !< ! (# 0 ? !# !<" %#(!1 1> < ;&(= 7""( '<#?( 1 !<"1 &! 0'# < ;&(= 7""( 00"="4 !< !  /"%& 0-" ;""!&!&#($&0"47"$#1" #(670"!<"2/1"5" #21! = &('! !<" 924=5"(! #$ !<" #(670" &=< #21! &( 

 



!





$!

% < 4 0'#7""(4&'5&''"47> #(670"2/1"5" #21!*-" 1("4 &'!1&%!24=" 0'#!##C&(!# %%#2(!!<"'275&''&#('#(7"< 0$#$  !< ! ";"( &$!<" 00#!!"" $ &0"4!#'<#? % 2'" #1 1"$2'"4 !# 1"5#;" !<" ;&#0 !&#( ' /"1 (#!&%" 2(4"1 "%!&#( :  %!: EFF: &! < 4 !<" 2!<#1&!>!#1"'25"!<"72&04&(=72!#7'"1;"4!< !!<"' 5"'<#2047"!<" 0 '!1"'#1!";"(&$/"15&''&70"&(;&"?#$!<"0 ?0 &44#?(7>!<"200 "(%<#$!<&' #21!&(

!

)

* 

)

  



"

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

AB  $#1 ";&%!&#( #$ !<" !"( (! &(&!& !"4 7> !<" 0 (40#14 #( %%#2(! #$ ;&#0 !&#('72!?<"1"'2%</1"5&'"'?"1"7"&(=2'"47>!<"!"( (!?&!<  ! %&!2(4"1'! (4&(=#1&(%#((&; (%"?&!<!<"0 (40#14:!<" '! !"$$&%"1 %#204&(&!& !" %!&#( $!"1=&;&(='2%<$&(4&(=?<&0"&(/ 1 =1 /<#*F #$!<"924=5"(!:!<" #(670"200"(%<#7'"1;"4!< !1"'25/!&#('<#204 7" !<" 0 '! 1"'#1! (4 '<#204(#! 7" #14"1"42(0"''!<" ?1#(=4#"1< 4 7""(/"( 0&H"4!#!<"5 L&525$&1'!0>* -" 1("4 &'!1&%! 24=" $21!<"1 <"04 !< ! /1#;&'&#(' #$ !<"

%!:EFF7"&(='&5&0 1!#!<"/1#;&'&#('#$!<" /&! 0#$2(9 7

";"0#/5"(! (4"=20 !&#(%!:E&(;&"?#$!<"4"%&'&#(#$!<&'

#21! &( ,&/&( < 15 6' % '" 2/1 : #(%" !<"1" ?"1" '/"%&$&% /1#;&'&#(' !# 4" 0 ?&!< ;&#0 !&#(' #( %%#2(! #$ 72&04&(= 7>"0 ?' ' /1#;&4"42(4"1 %!:EFF (41"=20 !&#('EFE: %!&#($&1'!0>< 4 !#7"&(&!& !"42(4"1"%!&#( %!:EFF (4&$!<" 00#!!""4&4 (#!'<#?% 2'"#14&4(#!4#!<"(""4$20 '1"K2&1"4!#7"4#("2(4"1 "%!&#(   %!: EFF &(%024&(= / >5"(! #$ /"( 0!> #1 %#5/"(' !&#(:!<"(!#&(&!& !"$21!<"1 %!&#($#11"'25/!&#(72!(#'2%< %!&#( ? ' 92'!&$&"4 &( !<" $&1'! &('! (%" (4 !< ! &( !<" %&1%25'! (%"':

? '1"K2&1"4!#&(&!& !"/1#%""4&(='2(4"1"%!&#( %!: EFF:&$!<"1"?"1"'#5";&#0 !&#('#( %%#2(!#$72&04&(=7>"0 ?'#1 H#(&(= /0 (' (4 #(0> !<"1" $!"1 /1#%""4&(=' %#204 7" &(&!& !"4 2(4"1 "%!&#(F %!:EFF* AB ( / 1 =1 /< #*D #$ !<" 924=5"(!: !<" 0" 1("4 &'!1&%! 24="#7'"1;"4!< ! '/"1!<"1"/#1!#$!<" ($#1%"5"(!! $$:!<"&00"= 0 %#('!12%!&#('&*"*!&('<"4'&(!<"1" 1%#21!> 14< 47""(1"5#;"4 (4 !< ! &( !<" %&1%25'! (%"':  < 4 (# 7 '&' !# &(&!& !" $21!<"1 /1#%""4&(='*%%#14&(=0>:! C&(=&(!# %%#2(!!< !!<"/1"1"K2&'&!"$#1

AB  ! C&(= %!&#(2(4"1"%!&#(F %!:EFF:( 5"0>#$! C&(=#2! /1#%""4&(='2(4"1"%!&#( %!:EFF(#!< ;&(=7""(&(&!& !"4 (4!<"' &4 '/"%!(#!< ;&(=7""(%#('&4"1"47>!<"0" 1("4!1& 0 #21!: !<" //" 0 ? ' %%"/!"4 (4 !<" %!&#( &(&!& !"4 7> !<" 1"'/#(4"(!

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

%!:EFF&7&4* ":<#?";"1:%#(!"(4'!< !!<" &;&0 #21!< 4 (# 921&'4&%!&#( !# "(!"1! &( !<" %&;&0 '2&! &( ;&"? #$ "%!&#(  #$ !<"

%!:EFF*"%!&#('F: (4#$!<" %!:EFF 1" 1"/1#42%"4 '2(4"1)  

 

   



 





     



 

  

  



    



    

     

         



     

     

     





    



    ! " #

  

       

     



 

$  



      

      

   

   

 

   



 

AFB  





         

    



   

       

! % & 



     

  

 

  

 

'  "  

 



        

             



     

    





  

         

  

   



  

 

 

       (

 

 

 

           

    



 

      

     

     

  ! ) #

  

    

   



  

  

'  %



 $

               

 

$  



     

   

  

 

 

     

 

    

                

 

     

 $  '  %   



   

    !   # 

   $ 



 





  * 

     

            







 +  # 

    



   

  , - $      +   # 

   

   

 

  (       

           

 

$

 

     

  ! * .

+  # 

   

 



    $

 

$

   



   

   

 

!

AB  / .

+  # 

   

     

 

$   

 

    

(      

  

 

 

     



   

 

                      

   



  

    , - $   +  # 

    





   

0 



  $  



     

! 1 #  

   $  

 

  +   # 

 

'  *   



           

 



$        

  2$



 3

 .

 +  -

 



   



  

  , - $      

  2$





 .

 +  -

  4



  

  

$    

  (      

         



$



    

$     ! 5 .

 

  2$



 3

 .

 +  - 

  4



   

  

$   $



$

 



  

   

 

, - $      

  2$





.

+ -

 4



   





    

  

 !   

        

  

    $ 

 (

 $   #

$

 

      

        2$



   

           -

 

 $ 3

#6!"1"75  



 #  



  

AEB    

 

   

 ! " 6$   $ 0  



   

 

 

 

  8

  

 

 

-

 

 $ 3

#6!"1"75 

  #   

   



! 

   

9 ( 



  $    #





$

 

  

   



               (

  $  







       

$

  



     (

 



       

$

     

    $ :

          

 

   $ 



   

$

 

  

   

 

 

 





         

   



$

      -

 

! ;- $       

 

'

  

$

 

  

    +   # 

      

 



      

       

 $

    

 

    (     

$      $  

           !       

       

      



     +  # 

   

       (

 

! - $  

     +   # 

     

 

   

       

            





 <!

AB AB #4#27!!<"1"&' 7 12(4"1"%!&#(: %!:EFF !#!<"&('!&!2!&#(#$ %&;&0'2&!&(1"'/"%!#$5 !!"1'%#;"1"42(4"1!<"

 %!: EFF* #?";"1: !<&' 1=25"(!#$0" 1("4%#2('"0 $#1 !<" //"00 (!'&'(#!"4!#7"1"9"%!"4#(!<"'<#1!=1#2(4!< !!<"5 !!"1&'(# 0#(="1

 

 (4'! (4''"!!0"4 7> !<&' #21!;&4"&!' 4"%&'&#(&( * ,  - "





 2

"

# $%"

!/3"

  $#00#?&(= !<" 4"%&'&#( #$ #(670" !<" 200 "(%< #$ !<&' #21! &( !<" !  1 





2

"

4&"

#5'

$6% +' ?<"1"&( &! ? ' <"04 !< ! ";"( ?<"1" !<" '! !2!" "L/1"''0> 7 11"4 !<" 921&'4&%!&#(#$!<" &;&0 #21!:!<" &;&0 #21!'!&00< 4!<"921&'4&%!&#( #;"1 #14"1' / ''"4 7> !<" 2!<#1&!&"' 2(4"1 !<" %! &$ !<" &5/2=("4 #14"1'?"1";&#0 !&;"#$!<"/1&(%&/0"'#$( !21 092'!&%"#1!<"' 5"?"1" 4"<#1''! !2!#1>/1#;&'&#('#1?"1"?&!<#2!921&'4&%!&#(*"0"; (!"L!1 %! #$!<"4"%&'&#(&(,&(#4325 16'% '" 2/1 &'1"/1#42%"4 '2(4"1) =>!!#     

        %)

  *



!  *   

  $      

   

   #                  

 + !  .  

(

  $ (   +$+ 0  !  %)   (



(  0   +$+    (  

  +$+ 0  

  (  

    !.





    ?

! 2       

     0      +$ +   (  

     

$

 

      $    %)

  *! =.     $

   

 

  

   $  

    4  ?



     +

      2$





$



   +$+ !  & 

AB    





 $

 $  #

(  0   +$+ 



  

 

  

 +$+        

     

        

 !@ AEB -" 1("4 %#2('"0 $#1 !<" //"00 (!' < ' (#! 7""( 70" !# %#(!1#;"1! !<" 1"K2&1"5"(! !# ! C" %!&#( 2(4"1 "%!&#( :  %!: EFF&7&4 ' /1"1"K2&'&!"!#!<"! C&(=#$ %!&#(2(4"1"%!&#(F  %!: EFF &7&4 &( ;&"? #$ !<" 4"%&'&#(    ! "   #  



 $

% 

&'()*+,),+ -(& '/"1?<&%<&(% '"#$;&#0 !&#(#$72&04&(=/0 (#1'&!"/0 (:1"5"4> ; &0 70"!# &'!#/1#%""42(4"1"%!&#( %!:EFF (4(#! 2(4"1"%!&#(F*&(%"  %!"4&(;&#0 !&#(#$!<"/1#;&'&#('#$!<"

 %!: EFF &!'"0$: !<" &;&0 #21! < 4 !<" 921&'4&%!&#( !# <" 1 (4 4"%&4"!<"5 !!"1&(;&"?#$!<"200"(%<4"%&'&#(#$!<&' #21!&(,&(#4 325 16'% '" 2/1 *21!<"1:&!&'#(0>#(=&;&(=(#!&%"2G'  %!: EFF (4 !<" 00#!!"" $ &0&(= !# 4# !<" (""4$20 &( !"15' !<"1"#$ !< ! %!&#(%#2047"! C"(!#1"'25"!<"'<#?1##5 ' 0 '!1"'#1!&(;&"?#$!<" 200 "(%< 4"%&'&#( #$ !<&' #21! &( 

!

)

*"



)



 





"

  $+% && $ % #* <" (""4$20 (#! < ;&(=7""(4#(":!<"&5/2=("4 %!&#(? '1&=<!0><"04!#7"2('2'! &( 70"* AB  (!<"0&=<!#$!<"/#'&!&#( '?"00 '924=5"(!'(#!"4 7#;": (#%&1%25'! (%"'"L&'!? 11 (!&(=! C&(=#$ ;&"?4&$$"1"(!!< (!< ! ' ! C"(7>!<"0" 1("4&'!1&%!24="*(!<"%&1%25'! (%"':(#K2"'!&#(#$ 0 ?52%<0"'''27'! (!& 0K2"'!&#(#$0 ? 1&'"'$#1%#('&4"1 !&#(&(!<&' "=20 1"%#(4//" 0* <" //" 0&'7"1"$!#$5"1&! (4&' %%#14&(=0> 4&'5&''"4* #?";"1:&!(""4'(#!&%&(=!< !4"'/&!"#14"1'#$!<&' #21!

AB 4 !"4D**:(# $$&4 ;&!#$ 21;">K2 ;&#0 !&#('&$ (>< ' 7""($&0"4* #?";"1:!#%0 1&$>:&!&'5 4"%0" 1!< !!<" //"00 (!' 1" ! 0&7"1!>!#! C" %!&#( = &('!!<"1"'/#(4"(!'&( %%#14 (%"?&!<0 ?&( % '" (>;&#0 !&#(%#(!&(2"'!#"L&'!&(!<"'<#?1##5&(K2"'!&#(* AB  //" 0 4&'5&''"4 ?&!< !<" $#1"5"(!&#("4 4&1"%!&#('*  00 5&'%* //0&% !&#(' 0'#'! (44&'5&''"4*

$.!



%

3 )

**+ A#B 



 C

  , C6 

  , C6