High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/53267/2021allowed

Vivek Seth And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Another

2024-08-27Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu26 pages

!"# $%&'

( $ )) *#%+%,

* -. /

! "# $ %&

' # % ( (

$ )( )) % ) (')(

* ++++

" ( )

,-* .

(

)!/012

3 4)

*07**7*728!3)

!*789,76,*7'!-7 #

( .

!-67 (

$ -1-

)( )) % (

((

4) (

%4)

% %

$)% ((

((

! "# $% & '$% ()*+, - .

/, )01, 2!)3', 2 , $% 4! 5 2 , 6 7-8, .

,49:9!

, 1+, ',2!, 3', ; :

:" " <

, '(2:

%.. ( 6 *) ($=, ; , 4 > (?

,5>:

)778800, 9 , / / @! & 9$ <:. 6 <6:

,:)*A,6 , )71, '

)+0, 6 % ,.

% B$1-8$1=0$1=A$1=+$1A7 ,: , <> ! <"

/ ' %

! ## ,:

#> "# 2 !

! !>

/ >/ " ># ./ -87-, "# 2/

:" "

< 6 /

" />

" /

/ "# #

-8 / " ># >

2 ,>

2/ / ?

! " -2-

/ " ; 2 :

/ "# 2/ , /

" ' - 77

/ /

:" " < "

" / > ! # ! > > / "/ ! 3 "

" "

> " " " / / / 6 ">

" ' 1788888 / ! '62 -* - -87- ' 18 -D * -87- >

/ ' 08 7+ 7- -87-, ' 08 -+ 7- -87- ' *8 -1 -87* E

/ 7D -87-

! >

> "# , 9 2 , # <<,

:" " <

! >

18F ! />

" / / . 9 , -87- / " ! ? ? 6 "# 2/ / > #

>, /

/ >

9$ <:. "

< ! 5 9 , /

/ @! & ,

<:. << <<

-0 -87- E #

6 ! -0 -87- ? ?;

9 ,/ / @! & ! > "/

!> "/!

, -3-

/ / "# 2/

%8* -87-,

> /<< > /

> " / > "

;#, )01, 2! 9 & (?

" 9 2 : ! > C

/ ! D7-8-88-A10-7A8> >

/ "

8* -87- ? >

> >

" / ./ -87-, / > #

> / "# 2/

! "

- *0 "

, )+*,2!

" " / G+* "G % 7- -87* <<

! >

9$ '

< " ! - *0

! *0F

> !

" ' >

< =0F > !

" << 6 ! 7- -87* ? >

%7D -87-

! >

> "# ,9 2 , # <<,

:" " <

! >

18F ! />

" / / . 9 , -87- ! 7D 7- /? ? "

> "! "

-A 7- -87-,

> " > > ?

# 9$ <:. -4-

< > > / 9 @! &

9 / /

<:. "

< 9 "# 9 / // / > "

" " "

/ "

$ ? >

?( > !"

" > H

/ ,

! # >

/ >

D7-8-88-A10-7A8 !

, 012! H > !H !

/ >

H 6 , !

" >

#, "

! -A 7- -87-,>

> E !

> / ?

D7-8-88-A10-7A8 6 , D7-8-88-A11D8+1> >

> >

"/!

> > #

#>) > ,>

6 ! "# , 2/ > !

/ > " /

"# , , -5-

! !

-7 -871 -80, - , 6 , 2!

!, , 9 "#

/#> ! #

<<G

/> !' 08

' +8 6

/# 6

? >

? .

! -870,>

! /

!" "

! ! ,E "# /2 / 6>

-- 8+ 70> "

, ' 0,10,=8888$) > !

" /

> / > ! / E

<<"

! -7 -871 /

-- + 70 ? ?2 3>" ! / "

/ >

-870

! -1 8D 70 >

> / , 9$

:" " <

,9$ # <<, > /!

/18F /

9$ # << ! ' 7,A0,88,888$) 6>

, "08 -1 + 70*- -7 6> D* > !

+A,! , !DA8 D7 E

, +*, ", )+*,2! ! : -1 70 ? >

? 2 % -- -870 "

> " >

/ /

E !

" /

, #! / ?(9 -6-

> -8 70 ' ** 18

! ! > " /' 7,8+,88,888$) > >

+A / ' =+,17,1*1 A8

<< > !

" E ' 7,8+,888$) "/

! !

-870 /G

!6:I78F' 7,8+,888)6:> /

/ << 9 &6:

/ 6? ' -0 > / <<

, -87= > > >

" / /

-- 70 ? ?3

C "

/ # ", " / "' 7,70,18,888' +- ! -1 70' ** 18 > " (9 > > / # ' 70

! '62 6

--, -87=, E -8A+=D ' **,18,888$) '

/ # / / >

> ,

" " " E

" > >

/ " E -8A+=D ? >

/ / / / / /, / > ! >

-7-

/ !/ > 6

!,> / ! >! / "

> />!

7=D , #

! /"

/ (29 7+ + -87A ;/"

> ?

! 7+ + -87A, H

" 9 & (29 > /

$ / /

> " / / 9 & E

H >

/ "

/ " >

! / >

6 ! "

! ! ! 7+ + 7A, > / > " / > !

/ / "

? >

/, "

#> >

! > " "

-A 7- -87-, "

/ D7-8-88-A10-7A8, >

/ #> ! , > > " C ! % ! D7-8-88-A11D8+1/

! >

! "

> " > "

/ >

> >

! " -8-

", "# 2/

! / > /

/ " $

-7A8> >

! / >

> $ # 6 ! ! " /

/ "# 2/ > > / "

/ . -87-, / > >/ #

! /

/ 9$ E " "

/ > " !

<< "

! * -87- 9$ E :" "

< >!

/ "

-7A8 E

/#> ! "

"# 9 2/ > 9$ E :" "

< 3!/

/ / $

-7A8 9$ E 6

/ " " J " / > , E >

! >

2! ! >"

> # 6

/ /

E /

/ -9-

" " !/ "

!/ 6 > "

2/ , (? 9< ;4 /

! >

6 " "

/ > !

> >

/! KK L !

; .

( )

!<!!*7*!

.88,00678*7*! ((

8 6

#E ! .'5 88=-, -A 8- -8-8, !

7-8);, 18=, 1-8 7+8

& # : , :

2! ? )7 ! >

! ! -1 8= -8-8 ? )-

& /"

?)0 ?

18F 9$

:" " <

, E

> ,

9 "# 7F,9 2 8 7F, # <<0D +F 9 ,5

18F 6 / "

! ? )=,

9$ # <<> -10-

DD +F 9$

:" " <

> -- -870 "

!> # 9$

:" " <

/ -870, .' !

0 / ' 0,18,=0,888$)

E /

0 E

:" " <

9$ # ,

78F <:. " <

> >

:" " <

<< !

/ > / !

/<< ! ,>

/9$

:" " <

-* 8* -8--

!, 9 & 6 > ,

" 2 , 3/,

) 3#

/ <

5 - ?

, ! E

3>",

!! !

L -11-

, #

!-7**7**

% ( % %

/ .

/ )

(

%( " ( ) = % >") )

" "

(> ))

* ( % "

;")

( .

<6,

! M")% ) )

)(

)" .?; ( )

</*,!*,*' *,, .

*7!1

)(!!

( .

;")

()(*7!6

% ((

> ))) ((

" (( "

( ' ) ?% 2 9$

: ?5 # ) ) ?% 2 9$<:.3>")

" ((%(

> )1

* ,7@ ( :

> ( ) *7!< : # ) ) ?? ;

* % :

(

2A 3 (

!-7-*7!0 -12-

" ((

> )

(

> 1

) %

) & ( '

& .

)

07@ ' *7@ ( : ?5 " )

)

" ( > 1)

" % " "

* B8 8B ( :

> )( ( )") "

( )

(

> 1))

*,7/*7!<

)

.( )

-*1> ")

( % )

(

!//62

7DD=3((

% "

( .

) ( (

)"%

)

) %

* > ) ("

) # ? .

) (

* % ( ( )"%

)

*. .

) (

)

-13-

: ?5

8?5 & ??2 9$<<3

% =

717<*7!* 5)

(

)

) = 9

) %

*!! .

)

(

) "

) 23 ( )

% ) A=

(

2A 3 (

!-7-*7!0

)

% .

? .

) (

* ( (

(

)

C23 4 4 /5647 8485)77 )4 2(50 8

90 ) &:%"&:,% (( ;/(( (54 8<5/83 4)( ( $ =) 0 >/

=)) (5 49 &:::

/834 2 84( !0

!*789 #. % %

(

+ ( .

) (

)

( 5# 4)

$)% )%"

B 2

& (2

) & ( "

& .

)

'"D

18& E

)

( )%

) 2

*77<*7*7 -14-

&% ( ((

5") *7!* '& (2

!'*3"

) % % .

)

% ) *!! . :

(( ,7@ .

!/!7*7!* && *,7**7!*:

)

:?5 ) D

)% E

2 E3 %

() (

% (

% ( A & G (

"( )

& &

& )

%(:??

% =

& ;

**7-*7!< (% " ( :

((

H3= % .

(

)

9 7,A0,88,888$) 5 %<< +* " "

/ 9$<< -15-

5 -8A+0A

-1 8+ 70/ # 08,88,888$) << * / 5 :

/ 7,88,88,888$) -8 8D 70 1 ? (9 :

/ 5 *-,=8,888$)

! -8 70

-8 8* 7= / / # << 0 .

/:< -0,88,888$)

-87= ! /

/? !

:" N "

< $) $) $) 9 2 9 "# 9 /B // $) 9 55 J

9&2

J )==,9

6>, ',2!L &!

)

E 8)

*,7/*7!< ( "

* 2

LM:

2C /L3

: # ) )?? 2 L3> "

*:((

(( ,7@ % C.

I ) )

8: # ) )??= )

% (

-16-

) 2 )(!3 %

(

)

8 - 7 6 , / !

, # !, " ,

, , "/

" , , ! >

, "

(

: ,

> # $ %&' $( )*' '++'# ,#-*%.' -$3.14'#%)1$3 5%14 /2 ,#-*%.'# 9 %&' $( )*' ,#-*%.'# ,&/'# $( '0,1)2 .*%#'. # 18,88,888 ' 7,A0,88,888$) & << - - 6

/ ! #> !

) + $ %)' %#)1-,+%#. &$,3)

-1)+)-870 ;/ '62 "

B6' O 08,88,888$) 5:;'--8708D8-88+**=+- - -7)8D)-870 ;/ 5(.6 "

B6' O *-,88,888$) 8888*==D8D-+ * -7)8D)-870 ;/

/ D*,88,888$)

+* ", ) +*, 2! DA8 D7E .

5 +A 2.

-17-

- * 6

//6? > / , /

/ 6? !

1.5,)''.$+,)1$3 + - / , "/, ! /# > " >

! !

, "

/, ,

" :

! !

78 ; :/ / "

! !

" /$

+ - - :

/ ">

78 ; :/

H "

+ - 7, / / :

" :

/ !

78 ; :/ ?

+ - * 6 :

/ " /

/ /,

/ >

( /

-8; :/ ?

/ /

-18-

, 7DD= + -

! /

3 $(!

+ - 0 6 "

2! + - =

!" /

,7DD= + - 6

! /, /! /

/ 6

/ / /

+ - + 5 >

! / "

! , //

/ / 5> :

! / / + - 5

" /

6 / :

-19-

+ -

+ - :

, 5>:

" ? "

$7'3-2$# %#)3'#.*15 !

!/ >

/ P ! !

>Q >

> ,

! // ">

$) 5 9 & : .9$

:" " <

$) 5 9 "# N9 2

: -1$8D$-870 ;/ # << $) :(25 6(: '65(' 5 9 "# 9 /B // : -1$8D$-870 8 %#)"

/ (?

: -20-

# $ %&' $( )*' *%#'*$+4'# ,&/'# $( '0,1)2*%#'. 9 $( .*%#'*$+4137 $3 ,++2 1+,)'4:%.1. 9 "#

7F - 9 2

0,888 7F * 9 & -8,88,888 18F 9$ # << -D,D8,888 0D +F ;

;

9 %#) :"

/ /

!: # $ %&' $( )*' *%#'*$+4'# ,&/'# $( '0,1)2 *%#'. 9 $( .*%#'*$+4137 $3 ,++2 1+,)'4:%.1. 9$ # << 1D,D8,888 DD +F - 9 "#

0,888 78F * 9 2

0,888 78F ;

;

9 &, ( "(

**!7*7!<

( (% (

(

((

7 ?(9:

/ 5

! -8 70

-8 8* 7= / / # << '

! ! **,18,888$) -

/ 9 5 << +* ", 2! ' ; > -21-

5 +A !DA8 D7E

I7=,888$) 6 RDA8 D7E

I7=,888$) 7,00,*1,0=8$) % / (:

I=A8$) E

=,08,08D A8 < DA8 D7E

I7088$) 71,0=,*=0$) 6 / 7,A=,17,1*1 A8 < / 7,8+,88,888$) ; / =+,17,1*1 A8 6 / !

=+,17,1*1,A8 5 <<

E ' ' 7,8+,888$) "/

! !

-870 /G

! 6: I78F ' 7,8+,888$) 6 6:

/<< 9 & 6:

/ 6? , 7D=7 * .

/ :< 5

-87= -0,88,888$) !/

9%B

/? !

:" N "

< $) $) $) 9 2 9 "# 9 /B // $) 9 55 J

9&2

J )==,9

6>, ',2! -22-

& "

) ( )

*,7/*7!< (

( ,7@ : # ) ) ?? )"& %

( "( 5

( (%

**!7*7!< : # ) )??"

%//-@ ( .

> '& (2

!'*3

( (

) = 7!@

*,7/*7!<

)

( ) )( " > ")

* ( ( % )

!//6

%> %

)

%( (

)

"( %

7676*7!/ 28!7 .88,00678*7*!3 )"% " # $)% #

% F

( )) % 4)

%( (( ( 5

(

%( " ( .

) ( )

)

% (

)

8 # $ $&5+%13)$ $3-+,.1$3 %)' $( 41.5$.%+

*1*) 7- -87=

> "

7* 8D -87A 7* 8D -87A 7D*7) 7A -87A

# !

C > -23-

7* 8D -87A +A-) *8 8A -87A

> "

< 0AD0$ $-87+ 8* -87+

> "

-87+ *D8D$ $-87D$ ' -87D

# !

8= -87D

-*-)$:

3S 8- -87D " 8= -87D

1A00$ $-87D$;6 7+ -87D " 8= -87D !

=-A-$ $-87D$;6 7+ -87D " 8= -87D +80)$:

3S -7 -87D " 8= -87D &# .) )( (( "

%( %

1,18

!*7<*7!6 28,3

)( )

8 E / # / ! .'!

/// # /" > ? /

" /

> L &+ # ( %

;")

<6, ! "

.2#938 100:*7!-

!0!7*7!- )

0 # (

-24-

) .

*7!6 ;

:??

%( ((

>")

)(

)

* ( (

)

</*,!*,*'*,, .

*7!1

)(!!

;")

()(*7!6" .?; ( 9

"((

% ; ) 27/3

%( %( ((

(

" ( " ( (>

5#> ((

(

)

I ) (% & ;

4) ( (

B )

) )

( !-6! "&

) "

) (

) (%

% ( >

)

( > ( %

(

)

) ()

" B

( ( ) ( .

) (

* % ( ( %

(

&) ( 23 4 4?

((

/(( (54 8<5 /83 4)( ( $ =) 0 >/

? 3>") %

()(

((I%

)

-25-

# "

((

(( (

)( ( ) "

B8 8B & (2

!'*3

: # ) )?? , )( "

)

) (

5# (( )(

)( "

%(%) (

(

() "(&) (%> ) % "4) .

4) (

(( > 5# (

((

4) (

)(

% 4) ((

( "

)

" .?;

(

(( (

#8<8(0%, /

J # !$ @ J ' @ -26-