High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4912/2013dismissed

Darshan Lal v. Naresh Kumar Etc

2019-09-27Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal11 pages

!"#$%&'($$) (''#

#&' (% !"

#$ ***** $) (''#+% )# %%( # $ $$ % # * "

""+

(" *&#)+,#*&+ $ *& & $"

" $ " ( %%

, " *& #

% )+ !

-+ ( " .

/# $$ % $ *& ++"" +% 0

!+ , # # % 1 " + ( '++2# # $$%% )+

( #

%)+, #+!

" /#$ 0$%

$$+ (%%

$" % + ( 2 . % % " % 2# + ,# "#

03 , $

, &/# % , ( *4"+ (

/#$ 0$%

%, &

& , %% $ # $ # " " 5 ! %( % " +$ #

*+#

% (# % 4"+ ( 5" #+ /# 0

% # , +"! # %%( , #( 4"+ ( % " $ & 5 #

# $% # # , "+ # " ("& 0 # 6 % # '+ #% && 5# %* (% ""

%%&

* ( "+%+ /# $ # * *

( # +* *% 2$ $ "+ & #% 7# &

""+,% +, +

# "% # % $ ""+

8 9

+ *& # $ /# $ *

+ *% 2 $ $ "+ & + % + +%%&(&$ (%% 7 ( %$ " " " ( &% $"+ +"#&$ "+/# &

03, #

*&#$%

" ! *&# /# ( # (*+

+ +% (

/#!

%+ % , %# . 2# # %%( (,# "##,# "+*

( /#

$% & *-" ( ( %"+ :

&:"

+ " :$$%:"" % +

":% !

%+ " /#

% )+ + $ +" $ -+ (

)+/$!# "

, #( 4"+ "" (%%

, %% ($

$ (*&## 6 % " " $ *& # 6 # $ 0$%

4 +*# # )# 1 ; ;3 2# '+ ( , ;3 '+ " ( , ;3 7#, )# & +*% " ;3 6 )# * ;39

4 #'+ 6 ## 6 % /*+!

" #$ 0$%

1 # 6 %< 0 $$ #, *4 4 '

1;3 -#'+ 1;3 (#* (#1;3 /#

%)+ , + +,# , $% " +$ # $%

!+ # $ 0$%

+ ,# "# # *+ $! , "

+$ #

0 , "

# =!+ %%& + $ 0$%

, " $ "

% % $"

" $ " (%%

=4 $ & " %" , # $ ,#/#$ % % *& ( # % 4"+ #+(# $" )+ "

% /#$ , %#% %$ + % +*>+4"+ % #

!+ # * " # *

( #

%)+ %%# +,

*&#)+ $$ % )+% % , ## !

? #$% &*-" ,+% " # (%% * $$ # *% 2 + *

"+ & $ & + + + #

% ""+

/* (# " "+%# ,+* # %%, (

/# (=4 *

!#+* # , #+ &-+

/# + #+* #* (,*

* #&$

$ & ,# # + %% # $ %& # # 6 % " &0$+"# '+ 2# '+

( , +*# # )# 1 ; !* $$ *!#

/# $ "

*, # % * & , >+ , "

( * (

*% 2 + #+*

! /#, # ( %& '+

2# '+ % " ( # "

* $ ! 1 , +*# #)# 7#, )# & +*% " $ +" # ( "

( # %!

& $" (%% /# ( $$ $ $ $ *+

# ! $# !*+

$ # ( # ! # $

03 + % % "

03 +"##,

4# (

# & "+% %& #"

"+ "# $ %

>+ , % ! #! # (

/# "$ "

# +*# # )# , ;3 2# '+ ;3 # ( ,# *+(# # $ $ $ $$ (# ( 2#'+ ;3

% 4$%

,#& &#+*

# "+ 7+$$ # " ## % +$-+ ( # )+

!"# !$ % &#' ()*+,+- ,./- 012 !3 %# % &#

4 5. #&"&# . 6% '()*7,*- ,./-8( #+* *&"+% # % $+ # %& +" % !% # #

%& #

%%, ($"

"$ " (,+% * ( # # $ # )+% ,+% +* # #+(# # # *

03+ # %%( (*+# $$ + # + , #

& *& # )+@# $+$ "# * -+ ( 5A*% # +$ )+ "

# % &#

9%# !"# %&# '()*+,(- ,./-187 )+% # $ 0$%

# # # # +$$ "

( # )+ , ## +* # # * +$

%" "+$% , #"" $$"

" +" *&#$ 7 (+ # # (+ %& "" (+

" #)+ $$+ ""2 *+%% & *% 2 + # ( * *

% + $$ ( %% 7 , # " $ %( % " *+ # # " 4 ',

+%%& ,%% # # ( =4 * # , (, #( " $

03+ # + #+* , # !*

#"# ( # " & # # % ""+ +

03 , + * + ( ,# "# "$% "

" # $%

#, / +" # #)+#+% ! %%, " &% $"

"$ "#(+ # $ (+ # +"#$% # # $ &, #

"+ %%&*

7 +#+* # $#% !+ " - " *, % # 2 . % +*-" (%% #

*% # $% # $+ % # %& +" !% # # #

%&7

+* # % ,# "

+(# %% ( *% % "

# 2 +%("

" &-+ " #)+"

( "$ *&# )+ 4"

" &$, 7# !# "+% #$ $+ #$ $3*2

" B ! (#+* *&"+% $ # "

(" *&

#)+ &* ! " $$ %!

# + *+ $! =>+ %%& % # " " $$ , %&*"

, $ *% 3 $$"

" 7 $+ *%& # , "+ % # $ +" # " ("& *+ 0 # 6 % # '+ 6 7"4 #'+ #6 # 6 % " " # , " , # !

+ % *

*& # %% # $

%% + ! %#+ #+ (% /#$% # (%%# *$$ # *% 2 +*

# % ""+

/#>+ " ,## !

% "

( #)+ ""$ (# ( %"

+%&+"#%# ( #+% + 0 (& +

"+ *% 2 +$+$ **

*&# 6

/# , # + # ( ! + %

( =4 2 !

# %& * + # 6 %*+ %* # #+* +"#$% # *

*&# # # #+* , %*

# ,## %%( *% 2 +,*

$ $/#

"( %(, &

& *% ##& *% 2 + +$ *& # %& # =4 * , ( , ## + #+* >+

" $

03 !*

7# !*$% # # ,## *% 2 +,*

#, $

03*&#$ 0$%

#" &##

#$% # "&, + *+

# # % ""+ !

, % $ ""+

8 9

+ *& # $ 0$%

# *% 2 + , *

# $+$ "+ & / "! +$ #

$% "

=4 # & ##

$% # % ""+ # + + ,

03 =!

# $% *& $%

( ""$ 4

,# , # ""

# $ 0$%

$ & #

03,# "#, + *# + (%

&% ""+)!%& # !+ &#, ""

2 $" $ & # /# # %

#$% $ ? % # #

+ ,# "## +,*

*% 2$ $ "+ &

% & *

*& # $ *+ # $ 0$%

+" $ $" $ &(

# #

# $% # # $ & +

+# 2 + $ $,# "## *% 2 +, *

# % ""+$+ $,+% +# + + , #+ + $ $ ,# "# # *% 2 +0#+* , *

# $+$ "+ & % " $ "2,% ( $ &%%#

"% *%""%+ #

" $ ? #$% &*-"

%# (

% # ( *+ *+ % %

, ((% + %

& " + ( %% 7 # !

, # "

*&"+% # (%%# *$$ # *% 2 + *&

+* $ %& "" ! # (#%&*-" *&#)+@+# "# #

#$% *% 2 + ( #+% + 0 (& , *% & # $!# " $% " %"# (*+## *%&

% # !+

, "+ # * /# $ 0$%

4 " * ( *# # ( , # 7#, )# & +*% " ,# C # ( $! )+% $ +"

" +*# #)# 1 ; ;3 2# '+ ;3 /# , , 4 # )+ # &

. $ *+ # "+ 4"+ !*

/# & , * ,#% #, ,+% % !& -+ " / " # % ( *, !*

" ( , # "

! & (# " # "

" 0 "$ "

$ + *& # "+%# !

#$% # #+* ( *

*% 2 $ $ # $ *%& "

2 4$%

# (, ,#&# 0.#+* #

( % /#

" # ( , % " ( 6 (+ "

# "+% %& #"

"+ "# # # (" +(( !

" # ( , # ! %+$ ( %% #

!+$+$ *4"+ *& "+ # "

("& *+ ,# "# # * *& # # 6 % $ 0$%

/# # %

% +*

# $% # +"# % 2 "+ $$ *& # " (0& % # 6 /# )+ "

( #

"$ "

*+ ""+ # +# +% , 4

% (/#" " +*

# ( *"

+ ( $ & *, #

( ( % "

&, (## $% *% 2 + "+ ($ & + +

*% /# 4$% , +(# #'+ ## 6 # ( 5 # 6 %* !# (# !#,% (## +

%% +$4$%

# 7# , # # #

% +"" +%%&

( #)+7!

, *!# "

# " #-+ (:

5 +$ !3 %%&# ;5 +$ "

#% (# $"+%

" "

"+ " #"

/# * (#)+# + $"

"$ "

( +% +

( # $%

! #

0 # (#%& * (+ *& "+% # $ $"

"$% # *

, #( $ "

(+% # # $# #

%&)+% # # "+ " "+% #$ # #- " *, % #

2 . % # *% # $% # $+ % # %&+" % !% # # #

%&/# $,# $$ "# #)+, #"% # # + *%% *% % "

2 +%(" 4"

" &-+ " #)+ %&C & (%# "

! &

( # " # $!

"% " 9#-+ ( "

#%&# 5 +$ 7!

, ,# # * "+ # *

( # $$

% "" (%& , #" (2'()*< 6- D1E+% F ;##$ (0 &0 ;##$ *% &0