High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1232/2015dismissed

Jai Singh And ORS v. Surinder Pal Kaur And ANR

2015-12-14Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"#"$%&%'() %%'*+ '#!+",& --".. '!& /",&0& 0,%'#", .1 0, '# '!+", "&-'#"'!&

( 23 1 3 ,"&"'!(4

,'%.105 , ,*6#7$ !"6,!+" --".. '!&

, ,%&+ 8 .6#7$ !"6 ,$ 7" !, ,"&-'#"'! 9+"!+",!+""-,!",&.$ .'":&- -",5 8;" ..:"#! &""!+"<0#*5"'!= ;","",,"#!!+""-,!",,'! 9+"!+",!+"<0#*5"'!&+0.#;","-,!"#%'!+"#%*"&!= 44 44 3

3 5-0*'"#%'!+"-,"&"'!,"*0. ,&"$'# --" .%&!+" <0#*5"'! '##"$,""# !"#))6- &&"#;8!+"##%!%' . %&!,%$!0#*"6 +%;> # <%!%'*+ * ,

+ .%6 %,5%'*!+"

<0#*5"'! '##"$,""# !"#6- &&"#;8!+"." ,'"# %7%.

0#*" "'%,%7%&%'6 +%;> # <%!%'*+ * ,

+ .%67%#"

:+%$+!+"&0%!!+"-. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!&+","%',#"$. , !%'

'#-",5 '"'!%'<0'$!%'6: &#"$,""# ' '0!&+"..6 '" .;%, %'*+ #%"# 0'5 ,,%"# '# %&&0"."&& +"-. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!& ,"$0&%'&%&!",& .;%, %'*+ 5 !",' .0'$."2&# 0*+!",& '#!+"#""'# '!& --".. '!&

44 +","%' ,"!+"'"-+":&%"," .;,!+",2&&'& $$,#%'*!!+" -. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!&6 #"$" &"# .;%, %'*+ ."! ;"+%'# ,"*%&!","# 9%.. # !"# ??@6 %' 70, !+" -. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!&6 :+"," & !+" #""'# '!& --".. '!& $. %5"# !+ ! +" .;%, %'*+ + # "A"$0!"# ,"*%&!","# 9%.. # !"# @6%'!+"%, 70, %"#""'# '!& --".. '!& .;%,%'*+ #%"#')@ !7%.. *" 0.% %#: '

0. &%#: '6"+&%.

'# %&!,%$! + .% %" 7%.. *" -. %'!% ,"&-'#"'! . %'!% ,"&-'#"'!%&,"&%#%'*%'&5"!+",7%.. *"%"7%.. *" %8 .06"+&%. + '0,6%&!,%$! !% . +"#""'# '!& --".. '!& ," ,"&%#%'* %' 7%.. *" ,%#-0, !! '6 "+&%. + '0,6 %&!,%$!

!% . +" .:", 0,! +".# !+ ! !+" 9%.. &"! 0- ;8 !+" #""'# '!& --".. '!& : & $ '$".."# ;8 !+" &0;&"B0"'! 9%.. "A"$0!"#%' 70,-. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!& '#$'&"B0"'!.86!+"

&0%!: &#"$,""#+"%'#%'*&:"," %,5"#%' --" . +"." ,'"#$0'&".,!+"#""'# '!& --".. '!&+ & ,*0"#!+ !'.8'" !!"&!%'*:%!'"&&: &"A 5%'"#!-,7"!+" 9%.. '#!+ !!+"!"&! !,: &'!&0'##%&-&%'*5%'#"#%"# %7" # 8& !", "A"$0!%' !+" 9%.. %' 70, -. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!& +",","6 !+" 9%.. &"! 0- ;8 !+" -. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!& %& &0,,0'#"# ;8 &0&-%$%0& $%,$05&! '$"& '#$0.#'!;",".%"#0-'!%&0,!+",$'!"'#"#!+ !!+"9%..&"! 0-;8!+"#""'# '!& --".. '!&: &'!5"'!%'"#;8# !" '#%'

44 !+"9%..&"!0-;8!+"-. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!&6 *"'", .&! !"5"'!

: &5 #"!+ !!+"-,"7%0&9%..&! '#&$ '$".."# +"-",0& .!+"<0#*5"'!& '##"$,""&;!+!+"

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

#""'# '!& --".. '!& ," +%& '"-+":&6 :+"," & !+" -. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!&6:+ ,"5 ,,%"## 0*+!",&5 !",' .0'$." !+"#"$" &"#6 ,".%7%'*%'#%","'!7%.. *"&+"#"$" &"##%"# %' !+" 7%.. *" -. %'!% ,"&-'#"'! +",","6 -. %'!% ,"&-'#"'!+ #'$$ &%'!5""!!+"#"$" &"# ! !+"!%5""A"$0!%'9%..+".:", 0,!+ &,%*+!.8$'$.0#"# !+ !!+"-. %'!%& ,"&-'#"'!& ,"'! ;."!%'.0"'$"!+"9%..!+"

4)4 #"$" &"# '# !+" 9%.. --" ,& ! ;" !+" ' !0, . #"&%," !+" #"$" &"# ! ;"B0" !+ !+" -,-",!8 %' 70, !+" 5 ,,%"# # 0*+!",&+%&5 !",' .0'$."+"%'#%'*& $!&+ 7";""' ,"$,#"#;8;!+!+" 0,!&;".:+","%&'*,0'#!%'!","," %'!+"$'$0,,"'!%'#%'*&,"$,#"#;8!: 0,!&;".:+",","6 '&0;&! '!% .B0"&!%'. : ,%&"&%'!+"-,"&"'!,"*0. ,&"$'# --" ."'$"6!+"& 5"%&#%&5%&&"#

) &<C&