High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/265/2016allowed

K.S. Basi v. Pb Small Industries & Export Corp Ltd & ORS

2019-07-08Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

!"!" ##"" $ % &'("")

*+#

, -

% &'("")

*+#

, -

##""

. / " # ""

# 0 1023 4 %

5 ! 6 7 ##""

# 8

&7 (6 7 ##""

# 8

$ / # 6 7 # 8

# 8

6)"" #1 ;

1" '"11##""

; # ': "!" # 7

1" '"11##"" <% &'("")

*+#

, -( 6, ! 1": 61 1 #" 11< . / " # ""6 ! #

/ # '

! ! % &'("")

*+#

, -

!! 0

6 , ! 6 1 >! " 11""

# 1 )

" %"

( ! ? :

86 )

"@"% 60';" 6 1 1

7 ""

3 43

8 17 8 ""!"67 6 '

: ' ! # ! 1 #" 1161

7!1 "" 1

43 !

1# ( &

! 1 (

#! 111 (

" .#"

# 7 1 116 ;""

6 " 7!8 '

'? ": ;!7#"

8 A ""

'( 7 "

3 43 1

( 1 6B6.A #" 11 # ( 1 6.4 436;;>;" ! 7 "

43A 11 # (1B64.6 64. 6. >!1 <, "

# "

#" 11 43 1 "7 #:"# #" 11B 43 6;7

' 1% &'6 11 "

' ""

A 44# '" 7

(

< 6 11## < 1 # (! !"!;

1 ? 11

( # A ! " 7 ! # 8 44 '

! #" 116 "" .

43#

8 ! 11 ""

7 :#"

( ':

8 17 1 8 7 "

44 ""!"67 6 '

: ': & 1

:1'!

'# 7

< 11'1 !

116; # 11 ( ? 6 1" #

6 '

## 1"

# ;

( ! ) ;

( 1" 8 6 > #7 "!"

'& ; ""

1#"

? ' "" 43 1 #"

; ( ':

8 4346 1 1 "

# ( & ; ( '"A 11

## ,

; " " ( "

1 1 ( A ;'

':"( ""

1 #"

? ; "" 43 #"

;

( 4346; ;'

! B 44 ( ': # 1"( 6 ; ('

( 6 ; (

? '""

11 # B64.

64. 1

11;> ># 7 "

43 6 ;7 #" 11 1" > #:" # 1 #"

) ; #:"

#1 ; "7 11

6 11 1" #: ""( !

C; 1

; ; 11 43>! +#" ;: ""

'"" 6;7 6 #":

A ; ( #" 11 43 33 43'

1" " :

# 1 ( #" 11 #" 11 1 "1" ( ""

6 1 7 "

43""

? ;"" A

7 1 "" 1 ""

7 "

43 433 7 "

8 3 4346 #"

; !11 11#"6;7 6 11 ; # 116 1 7 "

4346 #"

? ; ( ': ; !

) ; #" 11 44 # '" 7

( ': ; ! ! ## "

# (! ! ; ; 1 # ? 11 D # "!" 446 ;

;"" ; (

; : #": 67

" "

#":; 44 ! 7 1 ; !

) ;1

;

1 (16B.7 ? 83B

B 44 '! (:1 ! E1 #"

6 1 ; ""

86; # ( 1#"

;+ 17 A #:"#;" 7 81 (!

6 # : 1 ("1 ) # ;

( 1" '"1 1

86" > #7 "!"'&

> # 6; (" # 1 ;

8 ;

(

1 (# 1 ? 6 8 7 1 ##" 1 ""

; '(

##" !

8 ""

8 (7 "

" 1

'! ?:

1 ""

6E1

"# 1#"

' # ':(A

8 " "7 #1 ( 446 6 11 ! 6 ; ? ) 6 " 7 1 ("1 C #" 11 1" #"

! ""! ;

( ; ! 7

#" !1 #

61"";! ; ( D 11;""

)

"#"

# 0';" 6 F %% D ""

431#"

8 ': 8 1 #"

11""!"67

' ! # 11F %% D ""

"#"

8':

8 17 8""!"67 ' !

# 11F %% )1 8 # 7 6; 11 " 1

" # : 1 F %% D 11 " # ( & : 1 F %% B D ( '" # 1 (F %0 D 1" ; (F %0 "1 )

# 7 6 11 +(

( / # %D 07 ( %D

6 +(

( & !6 %)*,0D ,#= / (0D 1 " "1 #

8 6 ! 11 17 6 8! 11 17 6 8B17 11

3 ! 6 8 ! 11 17

1 6 8! 11 17

":6 11; ( ; C; 7 & !( C#" 11;!!

7 & !(

1" ##"'1 ,

= !6 6;;!

= !6 6 ;7 & !( # ##"6 & !( #

11 #" 11""

# 1

" #"

8 ( ! ? :

6 )

"@"% 60';" 6 7 ""

3 43 1

8 17 8""!" ""

437 ""!" 11""''

#: (!#:( #"

8 #

( 1 ""

111 # ( & ;

1 ( #! 111 (#"

8 +# 1"; 8; ;

1 1" 1

: 1" # ! " ##"'1 ,

1 ; ; # .#" 116 ;

4 ## ! " )7

" "1 #

' !!

)1 & !( # ':

= !6 '"

' ' 1 -( 6 4 "; 1 -( # 7 7 :

6##"# 1

##" ( 1 # ' # "" ' (

!"( ' # 1 1 7 : # 7 :##" :

##" (: ' (

1 # ' # 1 ##" 1 ,

11 1

##" (>! ##" ; # C"( 1 1"!1 1 " : ; ! 1 ) # !

11;""

;""

43 : 434; ? ; ( < 1"

#" # 11 ': #"

7 "

84 43 433 7 "

8 3 434C#" 11 "

1" (+( ( ; : 1 (# 1 : # 44'

'1" ( " B 446;" ":

C#" 11

:! 7

"1"( ': !7 (61 "::! 7

1 ' 11':

8 , ) 1 : ( 01 8 7 " 7 "

(: "! (1 1 1 ! :6 1'

(>!

( # 1 ("" ! '

' 1 6;'

C 1 :# 1 !G # ( ' ":

# ( C 1 6 > (" 1

'1""; 6;( #

#" 11':% &'("")

*+#

, -

; 1 # (# B1 *7 ; ": 7 11)

!7 ? ;

! 111 11;"

"7 # B1 ) *7 " ":

7 ,

(:# ( + 1:1 ; >">": 7## 6 !

'! (( 1

"7 6 ( # '" # 7 ' 6 " 1 1 #

" C 1 6 ; # ;

1 ' 7 ': C#" 11 "

7 :;""7

7 1 ':+(! 11"1# 11

; C 1 6 ## 1 "; ##"" ,

'"7! #" >'"11

8 1 ' 6; # # ( ) (

1 #

( !

' ; #

# 11 1 (1 ""( # " !

C#" >': "

' 1% &'

"7 (" 7!C#" 11 ; 7 ( :11

111 8 '(

!:;

? 1 + 1 (1 #:( 1 ""( 5 6 ; "

1 ":7( '

'!# # >! 1

# ""( ( C#" 11

:! > 7 !1 ;;

!61 ": # ""(

( ; ( 1 7! 6 >#! ? 1 ! '

8 # #

; 1""; ""! ""

.")1 #" # # 1 # 6

8 "

' 1 "

"" 1 ""

6 (# 1 ""

( # C #" 11

:! >

7 ! 1 1 !

44 ! " < :# 1

": + # 1"( *711

(( 6 > 11 ( >;'

(# 1 44 ; ,

# 1"( 1 ( 1>;" !6 "

7'1" (( ":; ; !1 1

(*7 ;6 7 1 ( >;

"" 1""

(# 1#"

( '#" '" 1

:#"C

! 1 ( 1

# # 7 1 # # ## "1 7

1"; & "(1 #" 11 5;7 6

" 0

= !6 ;

# ##" 1( 7 " ;""

& !(

6;;; :& 1'" 5 (#" ": ( "; '& ;" (! " ; ; "( C

!!7':(!": 1

:5( 7 ;"(! " #1#"

; 116

7! " ; 6 ;; # ! "

6;7 # " # ; # 7 7 ( (#"1 "!"

? ( *711 (( 6 > # # #

; 1""; 8

(# "!" 7" '

; ? ' ""! ; # 1"( * " "; "(

##": 7

"! "

*77

? '""! !

; # 1 "( 6 ; ( C,

""; " ! 7 !

1 "( 1"(: !

(! #; #" ; ; 1

(

>;'

( ('1 1"!1 5 1

( 1 " ": ! ; #" 1 #" 11 "> ( '

': "( C

< 7! # 11 ; #" # :1 (6 11"

1 #" 11 # ""( # "6 ""

; ! ":"" #"

( 1 "

' 1 ; (C#" 11; 1 ": "

1 " # ( & *716 >

# ; !7 ': 8

#" 116 ; 1 (17 " C";""

#!; "1 (# 1 6#" 11 ! #) 1 11

" ; ' :;"" :

; ; ! 1

!1( "

6 7 1 86;; ""

1 (# '"

#1 - "1

11; B 1 -( B "; #1((7'"# #

' # 7 # "6; 11 ;"#1 # #

:' # 6# 7 !

"( 1 : (1 (;# '! ( 1 #5 11"(("1 ' # ' # C 1 6 "( 1 : 7"'" # 7 " ; 1 7 # 7 ! "( 1 : 1 # 1 ((7'" #

: : ' "C

1 11 C& !( #

;"" 6 ' # # # ## " ## 1 7

1"; ;;

!": #

':"

= !6 C ;

!'!

':# 1 # ##" "

:6 & !( # ':

= !6 & !(

(! 1#" 11

C##" "";

!":; 3 4 &

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#