Ram Jiwan & ORS v. Ram Kanwar & ANR




    
 




    



!"#$% &&'' (% 
!)#%$% 
&  !  "#

 
#

## *%

% $%

%#'+

%$&&'' ,,, #

## $ &&''  -  &'

  %  

%+     %%   %% $!./$'%0+'"

 +2 !%

5'%'% "

  1   +  2 !    %     

5   6 '!' $%  &&''  7  &'

  '       %  '%  #$ 6 '%' &%!2 $

$$/%2 #%&$8 3 $ ' % %% $%&-  %!' $%$%8  %%% $%+ %:$&%&%/6 .'  )$;'#$$ +$%

$%!'/$ % :%0$&%%&%./$' '$%%;<$
!=;<$ 0$%2><$#%)' %2 9 $ $%$ &%&%/ )%$;'#$%./$.+;<$
!=;<$

 '$/% 3 ?$ 9 $$%'#$%./ $ %0$%2%><$#%)' %2$ %#$

$&&''7&'

:$%&7 %$

 :%0$:$%%!'/><$#%)' %2% %% $%$% $%.%$%$% :%0$+%  3 30$%2$/% 334@# '$ &%&%/#$%./$#.%$%$ % &'

 %0$.$$%%0$%2A$%#$%./$  +&%%=%0$' '$/%

$%#$%./$ %$%%6 '

$%$ %7 $&&''$/%

4$ %$%$ '#$%6 '$%./$&&'' $  % %#''

 3 $ %&#  5

@#+%&'$'

$%'#$$$ '$+.!

$% % ! 3 43 ?$+.'' ''/%$ . %'?



'' '/

%./ $ %0$%2 $ ' '$% :% 0$ B#+%%$!

 5 ##% '/ 

$. '' ' ''+%

'' '/

%./0$%2 '#&'.%'$ $ $ %7 $&&'':$% %$ %0$%2 #% $%% %/&% ' %& 
'    #%  $   &'    .  '' '  #$  %+' $&%+ '#:$&&'' &'$#% $%% % $'% %%./><$#%)'  %2$.!!

% '/%'' ''/ :$%&%

 %%%$% :$% %$ # '

:$&'

'!.2#%&$8 )' 4!%' ' 3 $%
&7 $ #$'/ ''

$+%!$&'B#& ''/&'$+%  3 3><$#% %2% %%?

$% 

$%''+$%  0$%2$ %%.

95 $$%  $%''+ $% $    4 #$% %%%+!

  3 0$%2

%%  %&  7 
!     :$% %  %    $ %   $%    $ &&'' % $%' !8 %'?



 $%&7 :$%!% #$%./$&'

:$/$%$$% $ % $% $%&'./$!!' #&%/ % C''#  #% %!./$'%%'0 %$ . $&'

-  D$$%$&'

%'% %'% $

$$&'

%2#%& $8 3 $%$ '% ' $%+ %%%$% $ % '' E** B   &%+#$$%&'

%' %  %  &%!  2     $  %    '' E** D$$% !.'$&% %!E* +D$$% $&'

 $+    %'   '$&% E* + D$$%$&'

%&& %! ' $&%  ./$%# E* +D$$%  $       .  %    2%    %/

?

&%E* +D$$%$ $&''/!.%%./'!E * +
'   F+#'./.$$&% ;%%'0 %!$  './$&'

7 &&''&&' './$&&''#'!./$'% '  %  "

  1   +  2 !     

5

%+$% %!&%&&'$. ' ;% ' %$&&''+$!'/%

$.$ $'% %.'#$+%%!  './$ &&''7&'

&''/<& +#$'% !

D 
! $$&%&%/6 !$$% &&''A $%$$%.%$%$8 9?$ $:$

% %./.$$'% %.'#% &%+%$  $!B$ &%/$$&&'. ''#!&

2 !%

5&./$ '%0+'"

2 !%  

5&./$'%'%"  .  './$&&''.%$%

$  B  $+  $%  '%   '  %  $  &&''    $+ &% $ '#''&$&/ $%%#$$#

%$./ $!0 %/ B& $$'6 .' )$ ;'''$ $$'% 9 $$% :%0$&% $%./$ ' ' $%  %+  9 $ $%:$% 

$% )%$;'% %%$%$% $%.%$%

$% :%0$+% 3 3B$+&% $ &'  F8*D49  #$$  '    &    %    3 3
&+$% $&%% '/!$&'#$$#

'./0$%2%$ % $%&%%--% &&''7&'

' #$' '$% :%0$:$%%&+ $%%!&%? $&'#$% %$ !'/ '!%%+.#$&%% 3 3# % '/  &  
'      ?

    

8 ./$ %%%% % !:$%  +%% $% !B&% $ $$&&''7&'

A&%' '0$%2;'

$

%+' %%  %&     7 
!     :$  &&''A  $%  +%  $''   $   !% % $' !$ %$/%

:$&% # '$/%

./$&%&&''B$ .% $'/$'./$'%'%" $$ % $'.' $&%$ '%/''' .< $  &%            %%    %+   %  !&'%
'F8*58 ./%#$ '%+'$$ %'$' %& $&$#  '+ 

$ %+%F8 F8 %%' 8 ./$ % &&''%$8 ?<'

3!%'<'3!%'    %&+'/:$%'#% '/&%+%#$ '#B%%$$%%%8&'#$/$ #%$'' %'%& !*%%--%

 $&&''+%$'' $!:$&%&&''#% +%/#''#% $  '& >$  $  '%   %  .'#  $+  %%   %%

        $  &&''      #$'!    &%&% &&% +%%#$$#%%% %B!/ %&6  '#!

$' .'6 

'#+'+$&&' $%%

!#% ;% ' %$&&'' .'& / '' '/ %!/!&

2 !%

&./$'%0+'"

2 !  %  

5&./$'% ' % "

#$$'' %% %./$0 % % '/$&&'!#$%%  #%&'%((



)*+, % D$$%&< 9%

G9 D$$%%&%.'

G9