Balwan Singh v. Union Of India And Others


    
    !"#$%&'$%%&()*+, -./012304565178%99%%: ;.<=.7>57?@ 9999#0/5/5170A B0A6C6 D751712E735..73)/@0A6 999F06G17307/6
 H  I J KL
 
  MMMMM #A0607/8  +A9>./56@NCO.AP.A?QR3S14./021A/@0G0/5/5170A +A9P.CA.SP10<QR3S14./021AA06G17307/T169&/1U MMMMM 
  VK

J 9 W@0 GA.X0A O.30 57 /@0 GA0607/ G0/5/517 56 21A YC.6@57? /@0 30O.73 71/540 3./03 '9Z9%%&Q R770[CA0 #$U G.6603 \X A06G17307/ T19:$;.7] 21A 02204/57? /@0 A041S0AX 12 0[4066 G076517 4.<4C<./03 21A /@0 <.6/  X0.A6Q G.53 /1 /@0 G0/5/5170AQ . >0G1X =@1 A0/5A03 57 ' U 17 /@0 GA0O560 /@./ 07@.7403 356.\5<5/X 0<0O07/ =.6 =A17?<X 5OG<0O07/03 12 )F)# S530 45A4C<.A UUU =90929 ^_%:Q =@54@ @.6 71= \007 A04/52503 .73 /@56 !1CA/ 6/.X03 /@0 6.O0 S530 1A30A 3./03 99%%&Q =@0A0.2/0A 17 Z9&9%%:Q <0.A703 41C760< .GG0.A57? 17 \0@.<2 12 A06G17307/ T169 .73 %$D)E @.3 6/./03 /@./ 71 60G.A./0 A0G<X 56 A0YC5A03 /1 \0 25<03175/6\0@.

<29 %9 W@0 566C0 6/.736 41S0A03 57 2.S1CA 12 /@0 G0/5/5170AQ =@1 A0/5A03 57 ' UQ 57612.A .6 /@0 A041S0AX 56 41740A703Q \X /@0 `C3?O07/ G.6603 \X /@56 !

menbd  Q >t# % .?.576/ =@54@ =.6 356O56603 17 U9%9%:9 W@0 A0<0S.7/ G.A.6 12 NA56@.7 NCO.A >57?<. (6CGA., A0.3/@C68  !"#$&:$%&Q304530317%9'9% % >t#$'&Z$%:Q>/./012#C7`.\.731/@0A6S69NA56@.7NCO.A>57?<.

  



   ! " #$%   #& '(  )$&*  %$ +(,#$-.#% #$   (#$   ,   / 01          $!2 ,# ( %& 

 

# ,    $( # 

#$

  !  .

 &$ # ## (3.  % 

 $  2     &,3 % %#   $

  $  $(  $

 $

   $ 3 $3 #, ! #  & $4 %&&   !3  $( #  3 $#      #%2#  !   $  $ ! #%2  !3  &,3    !$  $ 3 (% ## (

#$  5 $3  ,#&$#3 !%$(   &,3 

  #, ! #  ## (

#$   !    &6#.   ( 

(%  &  ! $   $& $

 

( $

 ,$3$! 7% 

   $  !  &,3 ( . $ $ 3  # ,#  ,$%   ,   $##$

  $$# $%%#

3 %  &$3

  $2

    $    $   !   !



#$    &  43  !   #$  $  $ 3 (!8(  ,   &   $  &$3 !   $   !  %##%  #,# $   $

 $,,%$    #( 9$2



(%  $  !   &,3 $

 &$  & %$

  ,   $

 $##$

  $$#  $ &$

# $   ( 

   # $2

 .   ( ! ( $#. 8( $! $

 $# #  :2# &  

#%  #%2#3   "% $&(  &,3 !%$(  $ #( $

 %##%  #,# $     #(. (% $ !   $

 

( 1 



  #8(# &(% &$ $    $3 $  $

  $ &  $#3 !  



  $  &,3 &$3

  $$3 #(  $%%(&($     #(#% $

 $2

 ;(% $ !   &$3    ! ( <    &$# ("(#   %  &,3 $

  $&3 &$3

  $2 ! $!  $#  $   !  

  !  " 

   &  &,3 %$   $# ( $     $    & $   $

  $ !     3 &,#$#3 $

(  ! #%2#  !$%4 #& &. 3 ( 

  $2  %&&    &2    $ 3  $

  $ ",

 (#  #

$3 $$# $

 (  $2 %(  # %$  $%%#

  # %  5 $2. ##.

  $    

 $   %$  &,3  $# #%,    !   " 

   &   $ ## ( #,# $   # $,,%$    $ 3 #(. # ($  . %#%($# $

  #(%   $2

   $ 3 $3 % #!(    (% ## ( #,# $  

# $2 3 %&&   $ 3 #$( . &#,# $  .

%,   ! $  

#$   (% !  .  !    " 

  &$3 !  ,,  #  ( (#. !(   $&( $#$ 3 ,$    &,3 %$

  ! #%2#  #& &0 =  2   $!2.  ,     $   #& 

   



  !" # $%  

 &'( () * ( +((!% ,!-.// !" -0012 3( !% --4-00/5

6!

  -00/&5 +7 488 933!

(%:)$2 ( (  ( 3 

6!%% ;!)   %!

(: ! ""3

3!

$ "

!  6((!%  <%  %(2 (%  (%

:% 6 (! (" %$

3!

$  =% ""32  !%

)) =

"% !  6((!% ;((% "!  !%  !"

3(6 !"  3 ("( 3!6$ !" (  !

 > 3(!% !" 

6!%%  (%

: 

"(?(!% !" 6$2 !; 2( (%(%@  9 :(%")

" %3 3% =  !  A:% (% BCDEFG HFIJKL MGN OPFPK DQ RKSFLF  2 ; (% =$

)$(%: !% OFCJT UFE MGN OPFPK DQ VFSWFIF X % OPFPK DQ YIZFT MGN UFQJ[

FGJC \ 2 #!%]=)  6  '!  )  :% ))$2 

3!

$ !" !%  6( (% ?3

   (6 (

(=) ! = ""3 X 7 % 3!% ) "!

 

6!%%   6( =  ""!

  =(%: %=) ! 3!% !

  "3) 6!

((!% %  ; ! %$ ( (%3(   63  (%  "!

%(!% A:%  !

 3( %$ 3!%  $ );2  % 6((!% ( ( 6!

!"(%  !"A:%6

(% RSJGCFI RYEFSOJI^LF & 6 5 4 <%

(; !"  =!

2 ) % 3!% ) !% (%  3(!%  "

!  6((!% % _ !;( ;''+`XX8`-0-X2"()=$(

a ab
VacHVaUd ecHfg NN h ij  * 6_(%:k  !% l m k,! * 6!

=) l m k,!  -0-- ''%7(% '4n X 8//4 66&85 ''81 4 &-0845X ''X