High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/497/2013dismissed

Lakham Panjwani @ Luxmi v. Vikram Rana And ORS

2019-07-25Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!"# $ %& '!() **++ ,-( ,"- #- * $-

-./##*(-01 2 3-0!4+/( +-#**++ -#+/#(#-501 --* 2 7-+5 # - # *+ !"# $ %& 4 8( 5- (4#- ## 7"# &#9$. "0- :(2

+: 0; ( 24-#8-(4#(4 ,"- #7+% 0 <-# 1&+ #7 - -*- 85+4+-*- 1 &++ ( *+ /( +0 ; ( 24- #-(4# $- =>)(1 -" 44- *- %(

-- 4 # - 8+" 40 -# 4 (* -

" 4 5+- -# 4 4#) 4* #*(8+ -+ #&- #*+#*+ #&

#*+ # (++5-8 ## # *+ 085&5- 4 -( +--- 4# - -- 4 #*(+( %5 # *+ 1-#*(8+-0 #-1 4-4- -5 %( - 4 2 - 1# -# 85 &5 +# 4# -( -85 21-#*(8+- -+0 #*+ 0#*+ ## #*(-#*+1-4-+ ?#

#&- #*+&-+ 0&##& 8 4(85#*+ - 4 4 4#-*+-+ -# 5-?## 2#+*(-# *+% 4#*+#*+ # -#- ?## *(8+- A&?# 2

++( &# 2 - -( #-#( # *+-4 4#*+ - 2 B ( *+/( +0 #*- -# 4(* #*(8+- C#*+ -@(# 2 +#(#++4+ -( 8( 041 4-( # *+ 8- 4#(

8 4*( 0# **- #

/(- +*-&- 3 #&- (8 8#+ 2 0 # # -+ - #*+ -+4+8% ##(& 8+ #*+ # +( 8- 4# 0 #--#(8 # &- + 8#+ 20##" (**-+ -58% ##(& 8--( - --(+/$/ #*+ # -4#0+ + 5*48(#*4 & *(8+-8(*-1*4+85#

-0 # -+- #*+ &- 4## *+0&##++485#*+ 8#-& 0& *- *-+##(0&##&& 85##-# *+ #7"# 0 &## #- # (#- 8& ##(,"- 7"# ?# ##-*4##(( #- # #( &- 4 #*-*-5&& *857"# 0&###* 4 &

#(#- # -#- &-#- # &- 4 (# # 5(#*(8+ - ) -### -#(* 3 # 0 (# *-5- +#( # &- + 8#+

2 0+ (*&#1-++4+8% 4# #- *-1*4#8 #+ /1+ (2

85#/(-(8 9(4094#-3&#+8*-1*4 4+'

<-# #*+ # +( 8- 4#(?# (8--85#*- *+-%((# + *-5- +#( 3( -&-- C#*-&-- @(**-( +1 -#- 4#+- ( +-#*-0#-+ /(-(2 4 #*+ 0(28

*-(+ +50#-+/(- #(# *+ &#C#& 1%(4 -

D+ 444-185#%(4 -0# *+ #+ **+ #/(--9(40; ( 24-94#-0&#1%(4 -

E #**+ &##%(4 -*85 #/(-8+&0#*+ #"

"#-#/(- 85&5+ 4-4(+- **+*-5 4## 8 *0# *(4 %(4 -*85#/(- 8+&8 #(+85#-8-

2#**+&41 -* 3#1#-+- ( +-#*-84 #-(4##-- !- -9(40; ( 24-94#-# - # +4+ * 0 -+5 &# # *+ &#+ &#-& 4#(# " #+1#/(-+ -# +5## *(-(#-++ -5 %( -- 1+#++4 -# - #- 4 ##-# 7 &-!+0 4#-850##*+ #8 #- -4#+ 4 -5 %( -- 1+ -# 85 7 &- !+0 # *-- - *- 2 #&#-& #(&#(#*- #/(-0-(+ +5*-1 -- (+ 0(8(+ - -0&##*-1#&# #*+ 8 5(- *-+ ( -(8(+

-&#-&- (-*- + &#(#*- --- (8(+

0# # #++8+8+-(##/(- 5&- #++8 *-+(- ( 4 5-#( -*(#(8% --(#*-#+ !- -9(40; ( 24-94#-# -4#+5 -*-#*-1 +4##(+* # &#+-& 4# - ##&#-&+*-1((

E +85#*+ +#-- ( 4#*- (

-*#-0&##&1 (8% -*-1(( ++# *85( +-#**++ =*+ &-44+( (#( 85 4#*-1((&&#-&

(- 85# # - 1# -# #5# (* (#(- -#( --#*+ +#(0&-( 8(+ )-#+ 4##+ 4(4(85#+4+(- --

/$/+-+5*-1#*- &#-&- (&#( " 4 *- # /(-0 # (# *+ #++ 8 *-+(- + 4-#( # (8% - # &-(85#+4+(- #*-1 +&-F (8% -F F ( C#--0 (# -4( 85+- ( +-#*+ =**++ &-% #&-4#+5 !- -9(40; ( 24- 94#-#+8-1#*+ #-*+ 4# *++ 8(# ( *-1(( ## &#-*+## #41 " (- #*-1(( ##&#-& # ( #8(#(- C#%(4 -*85#/(-8+& -&++- 08(* *-*-**-+ **- 1 -- -*- +&C#- ++4+5-

- 5#- 2(8 +@( +&- #**+ C#--03 5 - #*- **+ 5 - (-8 # +4+0 1+ &++ - %(4 -*85#/(-8+& C#**+ - 4+5 7-%

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#