High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/270/2016dismissed

Amrit Lal Gupta v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-01-27Mrs Justice Sabina4 pages

!"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !"# $#%&'&() !(*!+, -

!(*!+, -

.+&"/!0*1"!

11#00!("

2#+'*'

"!"# *(3!4!($"5#+'

#'1($#("'

) ) ) ) 6 / 6 / 6 / 6 /

+#'#(")

+#'#(") + #5!(-$7%!"#

+"5#!11#00!(" 88888 88888 88888 88888 -

- 11#00!("5!$ &0#$'*&" +$#%0!+!"&("5!"5#9!'

#("&"0#$ +:+!(" &("#+#'"(!%%*(" $#0!,#$1!,.#("

+#"&+!04#(# &"' 5#%!'# "5#!11#00!("-&(4+&# -9!'"5!"5# 9!'9+;&(:!'"#(:+!15#+9&"5"5#$!($*110&#' #1!+".#("11#00!(".7#$!(!110&%!"&( +1+#.!"*+# +#"&+#.#("(<

<11#00!("5!$+#=*#'"#$"5!"5# .!,4#1+#.!"*+#0,+#"&+#$!

"#+"5##>1&+, "5+##.("5'

("&%# 1#+&$ 9#7#+- "5# $# #($!("' $#0!,#$ "5# $#%&'&(("5#!110&%!"&(!($*0"&.!"#0,-!11#00!("9!' 1+#.!"*+#0,+#"&+#$7&$#+$#+$!"#$<

< "#+"5# :+!(" 1+#.!"*+#+#"&+#.#("-1!,.#(" +#"&+!04#(# &"'

" "5# !11#00!(" 9!' *((#%#''!+&0, $#0!,#$ 4, "5# $# #($!("'#(%#-"5#'*&"9!' &0#$4,"5#!11#00!("

#'1($#("'?# #($!("'

&( "5#&+ 9+&""#( '"!"#.#("!7#++#$"5!"!11#00!("5!$+#"&+#$ +.'#+7&%# (

< !($ 0#!7# #(%!'5.#(" !.*("&(: " @-<-< A?9!'+#0#!'#$"5&. #(#+!0 +7&$#("*($ 1!,.#("9!'.!$#"5&.!0(:9&"5&("#+#'"!($ %..*"#$ 1#('&( 9!' !0' +#0#!'#$ " "5# !11#00!(" 9&"5*"!(,$#0!, ("5#10#!$&(:' "5#1!+"&#'- 009&(:&''*#'

9#+# +!.#$4,"5#"+&!0*+")?

C5#"5#+"5#10!&("&

&'#("&"0#$""5#+#0&#

$#%0!+!"&(!'1+!,#$ +D

C5#"5#+"5#10!&("&

&'#("&"0#$""5#+#0&#

.!($!"+,&(3*(%"&(!'1+!,#$ +D

C5#"5#+ "5# '*&" "5# 10!&("&

&' ("

.!&("!&(!40#D

C5#"5#+"5#10!&("&

5!'(%!*'# !%"&( " &0#"5#1+#'#("'*&"D

F C5#"5#+ "5# '*&" &' 4!$ + ((?3&($#+

(#%#''!+,1!+"&#'D

#0&# G

!+"&#' 0#$ "5#&+ #7&$#(%# &( '*11+" "5#&+ +#'1#%"&7#10#!' +&!0 *+" 7&$# 3*$:.#("A$#%+## $!"#$

H F

$#%+##$"5#'*&" "5#10!&("&

5#!11#!0

&0#$4,"5#$# #($!("'9!'!009#$4,"5#&+'"11#00!"# *+"7&$#3*$:.#("A$#%+##$!"#$ E

F#(%#-"5# 1+#'#("!11#!04,"5#!11#00!("?10!&("&

5!7#5#!+$0#!+(#$%*('#0 +"5#!11#00!("!($

5!7#:(#"5+*:5"5#+#%+$!7!&0!40#("5# &0#%!+# *00, &+'" 11#00!"# *+" 95&0# !009&(: "5# !11#!0

&0#$4,"5#$# #($!("'5!'5#0$!'*($#+)?

B5&' &' (" $&'1*"#$ "5!" "5# #.10,## 5!' +#"&+#$ +.'#+7&%#( <

"#+4"!&(&(:

1+#?.!"*+#+#"&+#.#(" #5!'("+#"&+#$! "#+ !""!&(&(: "5# '*1#+!((*!"&( ( %!'# !

1#+'(A#.10,## 5!' " +#"&+# ( !""!&(&(:

'*1#+!((*!"&(- "5#&+ 1#('&( %!'# 5!' 4##(

+9!+$#$'&>.("5'4# +#"5#+#"&+#.#("$!"#

*"&(%!'# #.10,##955!'"!;#(1+#.!"*+# +#"&+#.#("-"5#("5&'1+&(%&10#%!(("4# 009#$ "5#+9&'#!0'-&"&'("5# &0#"5!".!3+&",

1!,.#("5!'4##(:&7#(""5##.10,##9&"5&( '&>.("5'!($&"%.#'("5# &0#"5+*:5"5# #>!.&(!"&(?&(?%5&# 5+&.+&"/!0*1"!"5!"

5# 5!' +#%#&7#$ "5# !.*(" @-<-< A? (

H&#9&"5&(!1#+&$ '&>.("5'!($ !0' :" &('"!00.#(" @- -

A? (

<!($'#%($&('"!00.#(" @<F-F A?

(

H9&"5&(!1#+&$ '&>.("5'- "5# 0#!+(#$ "+&!0 *+" 5!' !&0#$ " %.# " %(%0*'&("5!""5#+#&'(&(+$&(!"#$#0!,("5# 1!+" "5#$# #($!("$#1!+".#("-!'"5#+#&'( #7&$#(%#+$%*.#("("5# &0#"1+7#"5!"

"5#+#&'&(+$&(!"#!(,$#0!,("5#1!+" "5# !11#00!("'A$# #($!("' &( +#0#!'&(: "5# "#+.&(!0 4#(# &"' -"5#"!"#7#+(.#("&'("0&!40# "1!,&("#+#'"!($(&("#+#'"&'0&!40#"4#1!&$ "5#0#!+(#$"+&!0*+"&'#++#$&($#%&$&(:"5# &''*#' !($ "5"5#&''*#'!+#'#"!'&$# !($+#7#+'#$G

$.&""#$0,- !11#00!(" 5!$ 1+#.!"*+#0, +#"&+#$

+. '#+7&%# (

< 11#00!(" 5!$ +#%#&7#$ @-<-< A? "9!+$' 0#!7# #(%!'5.#(" (

H 11#00!("5!$+#%#&7#$ &+'"'!(%"&( ""5#"*(#

@- - A?(

<!($'#%($'!(%"&( @<F-F A?

(

H!($:+!"*&",""5#"*(# @-F -

A?(

H!($%..*"#$7!0*# 1#('&(!.*("&(:" @F- -H FA?(

H 5#+#!'(':&7#(4,"5#&+'"

11#00!"# *+" 95&0# !009&(: "5# !11#!0 !+# '*($ +#!'(' ( "5# !%"' !($ %&+%*.'"!(%#' "5# 1+#'#("

%!'#-&"%*0$("4#'!&$"5!""5#+#9!'&(+$&(!"#$#0!,&( +#0#!'# +#"&+!04#(# &"'""5#!11#00!("("5#1!+" "5# $# #($!("' '*4'"!("&!0=*#'"&( 0!9!+&'#'&("5&'%!'# 9!++!("&(:&("#+ #+#(%#4,"5&'*+" &'.&''#$

!(*!+, -

.!5!7&+