High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2745/2016dismissed

Kanwal Singh And ORS v. Bhim Singh And ANR

2017-10-30Lok Adalat Bench - 36 pages

!"#$ % &$'( ))** +'(,-, .$"/"#$ %&$'(, ) 0 12.*34+1315 )(','& ($"!

6 /1% 7%89 &'7

&, ;;;

$' :(','& ('#-!

( ,'9% ! $ , <'' "!'% <= &$'

&,<'"# ##("'8'% &$'99-(('& "%"#, &$'!'

('%9-(&, <'! %'9(''"#,-"& &$':!

(:,,',,"<= = :

(&"&" % :'(/ '&">-9&" $':

('<'"# %%(',,'% ,:'(&$'"(("#"

!:,"&""

&$':!

$':!

,:('

'(('%,-"& (:,,',,"<= = :

(&"&"

%:'(/ '&">-9&"& 8'(('%&$ :!&<'

("#

?@ ", ,"&- &'% "&$" &$' %" %'$ 8"!!

#' 5:

!:-(7 '$,"! % ",&("9& ':

&$', ,9 (8'%-& % !!&&'%&&$':

(&"',%-("# (&"&" &$'8"!!

#' %"%'$$'%'& "!'%%',9(":&" &$':!& ,

00 #"8'"&$',-"&& ,:!'

%'%&$

('"

:,,',," &$':!& ,:'(&$'"((',:'9&"8' (( #'/'&$':!

":,,',," ',&'($ :(&" &$', %&$'%'

:,,',,"#&$'('/ ""#'

,&'($ $':

(&"',$ 8'9,&(-9&'%&$'"( (',:'9&"8'$-,','

9$,"%'!'

8"#&$'/"%%!':(&" ,8 && ,

8'(('%&$ &&$-#$&$':!& ,'8'(:

(&"&"'%<=/'&', %<-%,7<-& &$':

(&"',<=/-&- !9,'& '(':,,',,"#&$'"((',:'9&"8'$ ('

&$':!&$' "!"# &$',-"& ,'9',,"& &'% ,"& !!'#'%&$ &&$'

&, '(' (9"<!=&(="#&98'(-: ('

/('&$ &$'"($ (' $',-"& "!'% (:,,',," (' &$'%",:-&'%:!&<= =

(&"&" % ( :'(/ '& ">-9&" & (',&( " &$' %'

&, (/ ( ","#9,&(-9&"-:&$' ('

/('&$ &$'"(,$ ('"&$', "%:!&

&"9'7 ("&&',& &'/'& "!'%<=&$'%'

$'!'

!9-(& ( /'%",,-', $':!

,'A /"'% (% ("#$ ,)B73 ".$ # , )B % (',$ -/ ( ,)B ,"&':!

%9:= > / %"

'(':!

9'%('9(% ,A)7A) %A) 7(',:'9&"8'!='

!"#$ ('%$"/,'!

,B &'(9,"%'("#&$''8"%'9' %$'

("#!'

&$':

(&"',7!'

!9-(&%'9(''%&$',-"&(%'("#&$ &C&$':(','&,-"& &$':!

,",%'9(''% %&$':!

('%'9!

('% , '(,"

:,,',," &$'$ (' &$',-"&:(:'(&= %&$'%'

(' !, 9!!'9&"8'!=( !,%'9!

('% ,&$' '(,":,,',," &$'$ ('

&$' ,-"& :(:'(&= !,7 %'

&, (' (',&( "'% (/ ( ","# 9,&(-9&""&$'/"%%!':(&" &$',-"&:(:'(&=&"!!&$' "

!%'9(''D E ''!"# ##("'8'%7 "!'%<=&$'%'

&,$'

('% %%"&" ! ",&("9& 3-%#'7':

&7 %",/",,'% &$' ! 8"%'

>-%#/'& %%'9(''% &'% %-:$'!%&$'>-%#/'& %%'9(''

,,'%<=&$'!'

!9-(& ? 1'9'7&$':(','&'#-!

('9%::'

&&$'$ %, &, *'

(#-'%&$ &&$'9-(&,<'! '(('% " %'9(''"# &$' ,-"& 1' 9&'%'% &$ & &$' :!

, % &$'

(' '(, &$':!&"%",:-&'&&$''A&'& (''

9$7

,:'(&$'(

(&"&"$'=$ 8'9,&(-9&'%&$'"($-,','

9$ ,"%' &$':!&&$'"((',:'9&"8',$ (',1' -(&$'( (#-'%&$ &'8'&$'

(&"&"$ ,&<'#"8''

'9&1':( ='%&$ &&$' !<' !! '%

%&$'>-%#/'&, %%'9('',:

,,'%<=&$'9-(&,<'! <','& ,"%' &","/:(& &&&'&$ &9'(& "",,-',$ 8'&<''%",:-&'% <=&$':

=,& #'"(,&!=7&$ &&$':!&<'

("#

?@ ,"&- &'% "&$"&$' %"%'$ &$'8"!!

#' ,9 (8'%-& % !!&&'%&&$':

(&"', %-("#:

(&"&" &$'8"!!

#' %"%'$'9%!=7"&",&%",:-&'%&$ &&$'

('":,,',," ',&'($ :(&" &$':!& %&$'

('":,,',," '

,&'($ :(&" &$':!&$"(%!=7"&",

!,&%",:-&'%&$

8''F- !$ ('"

&$':!&$'!=%",:-&'", ,&" $'&$'(&$'(' ,(

(&"&"G

%"" $'&$'(&$'%'

&, '(':,,',,"#/('&$ &$'"($ ('

"&$':!&

( ,&$','9%",,-'",99'('%7"&$ ,9/'('9(% &$ &B

!"#$"$",9(,,0'A /"

&" %/"&&'%&$ 0 ,F- ('

(%,'A9',,!

%<'=%&$'"(,$ (' ,F- ('= (%,/"#$&<'"&$'"( :,,',,":

(& (/&$",7%-("#&$' (#-/'&,7!'

(&$'

&,,-</"&&'%&$ &&$'%'

('&":,,',," 'A9',,!

%'8'"

"&",,7&$'= ('('

%=&8 &'&$', /' %&$'=$ 8' #("'8 9'& !!'#'%<=&$'%'

&,<'

('&$'!'

!9-(&&$ &$', ,:

(&"&"'%<= (

(&"&" $"9$ ,#"8'

'9& , &$':!

% %'

&, '(':,,',,"#&$'"((',:'9&"8'

,$ (',$':

"!'%&:(8'&$ =,-9$

(&"&" ,&$'('

%&$':

(&"&" ,%'<=/'&', %<-%,":-(,- 9' ,-9$

/"!=

(( #'/'&$',-"&:(:'(&=

!!, "&$"&$' %"%'$&$'('8'-'

('9(%7&$'('",%'& "! :,,',,"( '(,$":.-&&$", !,9('

&', 9&(8'(,= ,:

(&"',&$'/,'!8', (' %/"&&"#&$ &&$'= (' '(,&&$'

'A&'& '$ (''

9$"&$',-"&:(:'(&=$'('",%",:-&'

('# (%"#!9 &" &$',$ (' ,"&", !, %/"&&'%&$

(' ',&'(,"%' (''

,&'(,"%'$'(' (,&<' 99 ,"& -(&$'(#"&&$",9&(8'(,=$'9-(&,<'! $ 8'%'9(''% &$',-"&%'9!

("#&$':!

, '(,":,,',," (' ,-"&:(:'(&= 8' !,<''9!!'9&"8'!=%'9!

('% , '(, ":,,',," &$'$ (' &$',-"&:(:'(&=*'

(&$'

&,%'

&,$

"(!=,-</"&&'%%-("#&$'9-(,' $'

("# &$ & &$' %'

&, $ 8' #("'8 9' & 8 &' :,,',,"7 "

&$'"( :,,',,"'A9''%,$ &$'"(,$ (' *'

,,:'9"

"9 !!= ,6'% ,& $ &",&$''A 9&#("'8 9' &$'%'

&&$",,& #'7 ,&$'('", %",:-&' "&$('# (%& '(,$":,$ ('"&$',-"&:(:'(&= %'8'&$'('", %",:-&' "&$('# (%&!9 &" &$',$ ('7 ,&$':

(&"',$ 8' %/"&&'% &$'"((',:'9&"8':,,',,"&$' ',&'( %'

,&'(,"%', &$':!& *'

('%9-,'!,-</"&&'%&$ &&$'!=#("'8 9' &$'%'

&,",&$ &$',-"&,$-!%&$ 8'<''%'9(''%1 '8'(7$'9-!%&/ 6'-&

,'('# (%"#&$'#("'8 9' (","# 99-& -& %'9(''"# ,-"& &$'#(-%, ! &$", !7 "8'F-',&", !

$ 8' <'' ( /'% B$"!' (#-"# &$' !7 !'

('% 9-,'! ( &$'

&,9$,'&&:(',, !!&$'F-',&",7<-&$'(',&("9&'%$", (#-/'& &$ &9'&$'(' (

/"!=,'&&!'/'&7,'9%:

(&"&"9-!%& $ 8'<''(%'('%$'('",%",:-&'&$'!'# !:,"&"&$ &'8'&$'

(&"&"9 <'#"8''

'9&&$'('",99 ,"&#"& &$','",,-',"&$':(','& !7 ,&$'('",%",:-&'&$'",,-', /'&"'%":

( #( :$ <8'$'%'

8'&<'' <!'& ,$ =

-!&/-9$!',,&, = ="!!'# !"&="&$'>-%#/'&, %%'9('', -("#&$'9-(,' $'

("#7!'

&, 9-!%&:"&-& ="!!'# !"&=(:'(8'(,"&="&$'"/:-#'%>-%#/'&

00 ,,'% <= &$'!'

('% "(,& &' 9-(& 1'9-!% & ('

'( & F-',&" !

/-9$!',,,-<,& &"

!F-',&" !

$"9$",,"'F-

(&$",9-(&&'A'(9",'"&, &': '(-%'('9&"

&$') $'9#'& "%"#,('9(%'%<=&$'!'

('% "(,& &'

9-(&$ 8'<'' -%

9&- !!=9(('9& %!'# !!=>-,&"

"'%$-,7

-!& <' -%"&$'"/:-#'%>-%#/'& %%'9('':

,,'%<=&$' "(,&

&'9-(& %&$', /'%','(8',&<'-:$'!% &$'( (#-/'& ,( ",'% E ,"%'("# &$'

9&, % 9"(9-/,& 9', &$' 9 ,' &'%

<8'7 9-:!'% "&$ &$' ('

('0/'&"'%7 &$", -(& ", &$'

9,"%'('%8"' &$ &&$':(','& !",<'('

& /'("& % "&$-& ,-<,& 9'7&$-,"&/-,&

"! ? ',-!& &!=7&$'",& &'#-!

('9%::'

!",%",/",,'%7 $ '8'(7 "&$(%'( ,&9,&, !"#$%