High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1356/2015dismissed

Amarjit Singh And ORS v. Jagdev Singh

2016-10-20Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal18 pages

!"##$%&%'(

)( *+

! " ! #

$ "

%%% &'( )"

+*! &,( "" " " " " " ,-./,..0

'1',,..0 "

2/ 1 !

3 ""

" ""

4 2 '0 ++ ! ! * +

" " !! *

* ! "

&5( 4 ,-./,..0

2/ 1 ""62 " "-7./...89)"

,/ :

!; "

! "

! "" "; " ,-./,..0 :

! * *

! )"

",/

8 * &-( : ";

" !"; ,/./,..1 "* 3! *! " """ ; ! * "" 3 " " "

"" ! * *" "" "

,, '1!

! ! """ "5 ,'./,..54 < "

" " '' ! * ""

'1',,..0

! '1',,..0!; *! :

! ! *

* !

! " 52 ! *

! * ";

" *",/./,..1 &/( "" !!

" "* ././,..1

;

"" ""

" ""<

"" " *

,0./,..1 ,/./,..1

,2./,..1 ! # ! *

* ,0./,..1

! < " * ! ! ; "" ! "

! "

"" " *

5../,..1 <

; ! " '. :

! *

* !

&2( "" * ! ! *" ""! " *

",-8,/.5,.',

""! " " ! " #'75- ,'./,..5 = *

* " &0( ! *

* " ! * "

" ; " " ,/.0,..- ,0./,..0 3 ! *

! " " ""

3 ! *

" "'....89" ""* !

; * ! " 9 )"

"" "

* " " ! "''...89

; " "

&1( !

"" >; " ! 3 " "" " " ''...89 ! *

; )"

" " 5

,'./,..5 # ! ; 4 " '....89!

* ! < "; "

< "

# !

3 "

* ! *

! !

"5 !

! &7( ""

* ! "!

9 "1. Whether plaintiff is entitled to relief of specific performance of agreement dated 24.05.2007 and 18.12.2007 or in alternative for recovery of Rs.72 lacs as prayed for? OPP

2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief of permanent injunction as prayed for? OPP

3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief of possession as prayed for? OPP

4. Whether the agreement of sale dated 24.05.2007 is not enforceable? OPD

5. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form? OPD

6. Whether the suit is barred by limitation? OPD

7. Relief."

&'.( " ; =' ) ?+=,?*

@ + =/ *

" =2= 0

= 1 ?*

! ; *"

* ""

; @ $ )= '

" &''( :+"

; "

""! "" " ! * +

,,.5,.'5 )"

9 " "*" )

,0'',.'-:

*" + &',( " "!

* < " !

"a) Whether under the specific relief fact to get a decree of specific performance the plaintiff has to prove continuous readiness and willingness and financial capacity to pay the balance amount?

b) Whether the plaintiff has to stand on its own legs and cannot take the benefit of weakness of the stand of the defendant?

c) Whether under the fact of the circumstances of the present case the respondent/plaintiff has failed to prove the factum of payment of earnest money to the present respondent appellant?

d) Whether the findings recorded by the Ld. Courts below are totally perverse and had been returned on the basis of non appreciation of the evidence and thus raised the substantial question of law itself?" &'5( 3 "

&'-( A " "

! *

B=/C

" "" ; " ; "

* * "

" ! ; ! !

* " < ! ""# ! " *

B=/C "" ! <

" " ; "

" :

,-./,..0

'1',,..0! *" "

!* " !

" " " * " " " " "

" " :

! ""

* *

&'/( A " * "

!!"!# $% & '

( ) " &# & *

+$$ , !!"# &- & & ./! "# 0+ 0 '

"(#&- &&!1"2# * 34 5 6 !!"(# $% & ' !(1 " &# 6' & ,' !!"!#$%&'

)) " &#

4% 7 "# '

4 '07- "8# '

4 !("!# $% & '

1)" &# *

" "" ! sine qua non "

" " " :

" "

" 3 * " " " " ; "

* *

B=/C " "" ; ! ?

; 9 ">;=/8 ; " " :

" ! !< * !

" ! " " ;

" :

" "

&'2( " " ! "=/ *

" " !

" 51 " " * !

A "

!" ; " ! * " "=/

=1 &'0( "

* "

"='!

! !

* ! ; :

"* ! " " " 3"

! "

! * !

! *;

&'1( 3 "

! *

B= /C ""D ; 3 ; ! "" ""! " " ; ! ; " ! ! *

! ! ! "

; 9 "

* * < * ! ! " ;

! " * ! :

" " *

""! " "=0

#/-'8'!

A* ! ;

>;= 08 ) " ! ! " :

" " ! *!

"''...89!

"" ; "

>; ! ?*

B=1C

* " @$ ";>;=18

* "

# ;! *

; " "" ; :

" "

! ; &'7( )"

" ""4"

! @ $9

! *;4 !

" > @$!

! ;

*" ! " +!

; "

9 "

! ! " :

; "@$!

! !

; " "',

'1 "

! "

" * :

; " @ $ ! ! " !

" :

" ! ! *

;

; " * ! "

" !

" &,.( :

9 "

*" * ! ! !

" "* :

* "! " ; ! inter se*!

"" )"

* " " !

; "

" ! > ! !

:; ! *

3 :; &,'( A "

" * ! < ! * " " "

; ! *

" ,. " " " ; "+*!

" ""

&,,( A "

0 '

$ '

!/"/# & "&-# !/9 7 7

! "/# && !/) '

)"!#&"&-#!:

4& ;*& !("1#& "&-#! / '

"8# '

4 $ '

"!# & "&-# )

/ /! 5 !/ < (!

!/ * $ '

* +

" !

''-" > :

* * " "

* *

! *;:

* *

#; ! :

! "

! "; " # !

! ! ! " 7," > :

""!

" " *

* "

" "* &,5( " " ; " ! *

"" 3 "

9= /

;

* ! +

+ "

; " ! * "

" ! :

"=/!

; 9 "

; ! "" ; " :

" "

; ! " "" !

** * :

! * ! > !

" "; "

* " "

" "" )"

!< * "

! " "" "" " *

; " ! " "

" *

; &,-(

" @$! ;

D ?!

! * " ! *;> @$

! > " "

! ; :

! ! < " '5/'50

'51" 3

> 3

! "

" * ! ! ,-./,..0 *

" * :

; " !

! 3 #'0"

! " " '....89

" ""! !

"00. Defendants are ready to pay mortgage amount and get the land redeemed and also to get the possession of the land00". &,/( #1 " !

! ; "

*" "

* "

> ! "

! *;3 !""

! " " "

" !

!! +* ! "

!!"; &,2( > #'5" !

"!= "

! " " " "" " "

" ! * " *

= / ! "

"" >;=/8 :

! * ! "!

9 "00.. I tendered into evidence my duly sworn affidavit Ex.PW5/A, the same may be read as part of my statement. I have seen original agreements to sell Exs.P1 and P2 in Court today and identified my signatures thereon as attesting witness00.". &,0( " " ! ! "" * ; 9 " *

>;'

, :

" !

>;'

, ! * "

" " ; " = / * ;

" "" &,1( " ; ")='@$! *

! :

! ""

; 9+' "" ""

; >;'*

; " ! ! " " ?!

! ; ">;,*

* " ! "" ! ! ; "" "" &,7( !"" "

" "" ! # * < " ! * "

" < !

* " " *

# * ! !"

> ! * "" !

" " * * < #B*C * !

< "

" "" "

E #B C!< ""

* ! +*!! " E #B C!* *" +*!!

&5.( ! " " < " ! * < "! " " +:

* "

,.'.,.'2 ,-#"-#..#!&'#/0&1#!2%'3 #&0 ,-#"-#..#1."!45# #&0