High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1364/2015dismissed

Ashwani Kumar v. Vijay Kumar And ORS

2015-09-19Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

!"!

# $% &' "() ! *$

+""

+!,- *$

( "

." #

,- . (' /

(

!( 0!

' /

( / "1"

"

.- !

(!" !

!"

- -" !

!!

( $

!( 0!

' /

'

"

%( / "1

" 2/ !"

( 3 " " ( ( ("

%,

- !

!!

( /!) ( % /' ( "

!" ) - -" !

!!

( " "

! " !!

$

" !

( "! ( "! " !" $ (

% !" '

$' " !

$ !

( "! - !

- $

! %- ( "

!" " "

%- ( ! !

2!/! 0 !/!"!

'

$'

' !

" )(!

( %- ( ("

% !"$!""

&5 )(!

( (" %

( !

( " 4 !" (

(

" ( ( $ )! !

)" !

% ) ( "

!"

" ( "! -

''61

)(

'61 )" !/ %- ( ( ( "

!"

( (

5' $

" )" !

% ) ( "

!" ( !$' (

!" !

''61 7( 8 !

( " )" !8 "

( $ "!

( "! - )" ''61' ( )"

9" !

"!

( "$

:'5:'61' )(!

( (" %

!

( $

" ;( (!"

$

( '

( " ( "$ !" 7( "

!" ( % <

<" !

( %"

$!" ! ( $ -

" -!

(!

""

!/ %- ( "

!"

( ( $ )! % "

!%

''61' ( " $ " ) (" %- ( ( ( "! ( "$ /!

!

( "

!"

!% ( "$ " ( ! $ 5' )(!

( ("

%

3!" ( "" !

!"

( "!

( )! !

" 5 (/ %

%- ( "

!" ( !!

( (/

% '

( $!""!

!

"

- /!

)" 9!' )(!

( ("

% ( $ ( 2 ' ( ' ( ,$ " "" %- ( 2 " % )

% "" !

4 " (!"

' ( ("

!

( ,$

(!" 2 "" !

" ! "

3

" ( ( ,$ " "" %- ( 2 " % )

"" !

"/

% " "! " ( / "6"

!"'

( ( '

" ( ! !"

( ! ) $ " ) !

'

" (" % "" %- (

" ( ' % )! ( (

$!

!

8!"

( "%"9 " ' )(!

( (" % - "! %- ( ' )(!

( (" % - /' " !- )( """"!

( (" "

% ( / ( $ (" "

% ! " ( " ' (

(

"

%

( ,$ ' !

)(

(" % %- (

" ( ' )

% % " !

( 3 -" !"$!"" ( 7( !" "" !

'

)(!

( %"!

!

(" % %- (

" ( ' !" ( ( "

!" (/

% ( )! !

( $ 5 ' ( ' (-

! ( % ! ' " (" %

!$ !

!/! "! ' "!

!

"- ( ( ! )! !

$

5 !

- " ) " $ - )(!

( "

"! !

)" ''61 )(" ( " !

!$$ /%

-' (

"! !

!"

" :'5:'61 7( 8!

" ( !

!

"! !

!

( )! !

( $ !

( " 7(

!" (/ % % / ( 8 !

( " "

(- (/ ( $!

)!

""" 0

(' !

!" - 2<' !

!

% !" "

1!

! (!$" (" !

" (!" "" !

" 7( " (" % !% )" "! %- ( !" % ( !

( "$ !" " "' "

"! !

% ( ( "! - ( $ -' ( "

!" (/ % % / ( ! (" % - ! "

1!

! (" " !

(!"

""18$!

( ( ( "( ) ( $ )! ( ( "

"! !

- ( - " "

( "

( $ - !

(!" !

$1 8 " 7( "

"! !

(/!

( ( " !" "

$ ( ( ( """"!

( - )" ( / ( "

!" 4 !"

!!

%!/ ( ! "

) (/ "! ( " )! ( !

( "$ ) ( / ( """"!

( )! ( !/!

(

"! !

"" !

(" % $ ( ( """"!

( - ( % < !%- %

$!

(" % ! - ( ! - )! ( <!

!% """"!

( "!

- 4 $-

% )-

( ( (

( $ /

% !" ( ( $

" $ "' ( )/' ( "$ (" % , %- :

%- %"/!

( ( ) % ( $

" $ "' )(!

( $ !" - /! %- ( (" 7( ,$

)(!

( !

(" % %- (

" (

!' )

% % ( ( "

" " ! " )! ( "! !

' )(

"!

/- )" ! !

( %(! !" % ( "$ )"

%- <!

( ( !!

%(! !" (/ % " $ )" $ %- ( - / ( %(! !" %- "

- /!

- % " (

- ( %(! !" (" % )! ( "<!

$!""!

( 2 )! ( !!

( 9!$

( " !

"

- /!

' ( "$

% !

." !" - !

"' " (" % !

% /

: = ( ( 2 " % ) (/

!

!

" - ! !

( /!

( "$

% !

)! ( "

( !"

/"! - !! - !

( "$ 5 "%" ! 9" !

) !" !

/ / !

( " 7( ' !

!

$! !

( " ' ( "$ " " !"$!"" & ( !( ( !"$!"" ( ! "' ( !

" - ! 2 5:12 ' "

" " !" " " !

"

!"# $ % &