High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1378/2015dismissed

Gurjeet Kaur v. Manpreet Kaur And ORS

2016-05-09Mr Justice Jaswant Singh5 pages

! ! ! !

"#$ $%&'&()* + "#$ $%&'&()* + "#$ $%&'&()* + "#$ $%&'&()* + ,-.$$#/",- 00$11"(# 2$-','

"(0-$$#/",-"(3#4$-'

$'0(3$(#'

+ + + + /"5"1.&#&(64 00$11"(# 2$-','

"(0-$$#/",-"(3#4$-'

$'0(3$(#'

) ) ) ) 78 78 78 78 94$#4$-$0-#$-' #4$1%"10"0$-'5":;$ "11<$3#'$$#4$.,365$(#=

;$-$ $--$3##4$$0-#$-'-(#= 94$#4$-#4$.,365$(#'4,13;$-$0-#$3&(#4$ &6$'#=

-$'$(#) -/"0&1/">>"-?3@%"#$ -#4$"00$11"(#' - "-5&(3$-&(64A?3@%"#$

--$'0(3$(# -/ &34,?3@%"#$

--$'0(3$(#' "(3 BBB

"."(#4-&? -"1

"."(#4-&? -"1 4&'-3$-'4"113&'0'$

#&#1$3"'7,-.$$#/",-2'"(0-$$#/",-"(3#4$-'7 7,-.$$#/",-2'"(0-$$#/",-"(3#4$-'7 7,-.$$#/",-2'"(0-$$#/",-"(3#4$-'7 7,-.$$#/",-2'"(0-$$#/",-"(3#4$-'7"(3 + #&#1$3"'7/"5"1.&#&(642'"(0-$$#/",- 7/"5"1.&#&(642'"(0-$$#/",- 7/"5"1.&#&(642'"(0-$$#/",- 7/"5"1.&#&(642'"(0-$$#/",-

"(3#4$-'7 "(3#4$-'7 "(3#4$-'7 "(3#4$-'7"'#4$&'',$&(@1@$3&(#4$'$"00$"1'&'%55(

-#4$'">$ %(@$(&$(%$? "%#'"-$;$&(6#">$( -5

#&#1$3"'7,-.$$#/",- 2' "(0-$$#/",- 7,-.$$#/",- 2' "(0-$$#/",- 7,-.$$#/",- 2' "(0-$$#/",- 7,-.$$#/",- 2' "(0-$$#/",- "(3#4$-'7? "(3#4$-'7? "(3#4$-'7? "(3#4$-'7?<4&%4-$"3'"',(3$-) (#4$&('#"(#-$6,1"-'$%(3"00$"1?#4$"00$11"(#A ,-.$$#/",-?<4&'5#4$- 3$%$"'$3,-0-$$#&(64?4"'

C,$'#&($3#4$ @"1&3&#: #4$.,365$(#'"(33$%-$$'3"#$3

0"''$3 ;: 1$"-($3 &@&1 ,36$ ,(&- &@&'&(?

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

,-.$$#/",-"-$$(#&#1$3#;$($ &# 0$('&("-:;$($ &#'"(3 %50$('"#&(&(1&$, #4$&-'(7'3$"#4( 4$ 0-@&'&( - 6-"(# 0$('&( &' 6@$-($3 ;: $(#-"1 &@&1 $-@&%$'0$('&(,1$',1$DD;3$"1'<&#43$ &(&#&(

"5&1:?<4&%4-$"3'"' 11<')A F; 7 "5&1:7&(-$1"#&(#"@$-(5$(#'$-@"(# 5$"('A & <& $&(#4$%"'$ "5"1$@$-(5$(#'$-@"(#?

- 4,';"(3 &( #4$ %"'$ " $5"1$ @$-(5$(#'$-@"(#G $"3&(6 #4$";@$0-@&'&(&'%-:'#"1%1$"-#4"# 0"-$(#'"-$(#&(%1,3$3&(#4$3$ &(&#&( F "5&1:G?#4$-$ -$?

#4$"00$11"(#,-.$$#/",-?;$&(6 ($ #4$0"-$(#%"((# %1"&5 0$('&("-: ;$($ &#' "(3 %50$('"#&(? & "(:? -5 -$'0(3$(#' "(3 $'0(3$(#A"(0-$$#/",- <&3< ,-0-$$# &(64 &' '1$1: $(#&#1$3 # 0$('&("-: ;$($ &#'"(3%50$('"#&(,(3$-#4$";@$0-@&'&(H,1$D D;&I 8$"-($3 %,('$1 - #4$ "00$11"(# ',;5&##$3 #4"# ,(3$-(3&"(,%%$''&(%#?#4$0"-$(#'"-$$(#&#1$3#E -3 ;$($ &#(',00-# 4&'%(#$(#&(?4$-$1&$3,0("3$%&'&( ;7;1$#4$,0-$5$,-# (3&"&(%"'$74&0-"$(6,0#"

74&0-"$(6,0#"

2'-&3,1$(6,0#""(3#4$-'? 2'-&3,1$(6,0#""(3#4$-'? 2'-&3,1$(6,0#""(3#4$-'? 2'-&3,1$(6,0#""(3#4$-'? * 8+ ?<4$-$&(&( 0"-" ?&#4"';$$(4$13"',(3$-)A F 4$%(#-@$-':&(@1@$3&(#4$&('#"(#%"'$&' (1(6$--$'&(#$6-" 4$(5&($$&'$(#&#1$3#

-$%$&@$#4$'"5$?;,##4$"5,(#'-$%$&@$3&'# ;$3&'#-&;,#$3"%%-3&(6##4$1"< ',%%$''&(G #<"'',;5&##$3#4"#"00$11"(#&'$(#&#1$3 -E -3 0$('&("-:;$($ &#'$#%&(@&$< #4$";@$3$%&'&(

$- %(#-"? 1$"-($3 %,('$1 - #4$ -$'0(3$(#'

',;5&##$3 #4"# #4$: "-$ ;,(3 ;: $(#-"1 &@&1 $-@&%$' 0$('&(,1$'4$-$ -$?"(0-$$#/",-<&3< ,-0-$$# &(64"1($&'$(#&#1$3 -0$('&("-:;$($ &#'$#%4$-$ -$?

#-&"1,-#"'<$11"'"00$11"#$,-#4"'-&64#1:-$.$%#$3#4$ %1"&5 #4$"00$11"(# $"-31$"-($3%,('$1 -#4$0"-#&$' 4$%-,J #4$5"##$-&'<4$#4$-#4$"00$11"(#'"-$ $(#&#1$3 -0$('&("-:;$($ &#'-%50$('"#&(-E -3 #4$ ;$($ &#'?& "(:?;$&(60"-$(#' 1"#$,-0-$$#&(64=$"3&(6 #4$0-@&'&(6@$-(&(6#4$6-"(# 0$('&("-:;$($ &#'"(3 %50$('"#&( "(0-$$#/",-<& $ 8"#$,-0-$$#&(64&'

$(#&#1$3#-$#&-"1;$($ &#'4$3$%&'&( #4$(7;1$,0-$5$ ,-#%&#$3;:#4$1$"-($3%,('$1 -#4$"00$11"(#&(4&0-"

4&0-"

$(6,0#"7'%"'$',0-" $(6,0#"7'%"'$',0-" $(6,0#"7'%"'$',0-" $(6,0#"7'%"'$',0-"&'3&'#&(6,&'4";1$ -#4$-$"'('#4"# 0$('&( -,1$' "001&%";1$ &( #4$ 0-$'$(# %"'$ <$-$ (# &(#$-0-$#$3&(#4$'"&33$%&'&(4$-$ -$?#4$%&#$33$%&'&(&'

(#"001&%";1$##4$0-$'$(#%"'$ 4$0$J,-#&(#4$%"'$ "&-$-@&%$%&$#:

"&-$-@&%$%&$#:

2'$$-5"'#4"("(3#4$-'? 2'$$-5"'#4"("(3#4$-'? 2'$$-5"'#4"("(3#4$-'? 2'$$-5"'#4"("(3#4$-'?&@&100$"1** *?

3$%&3$3( *?4"'4$13#4"#;$ -$"3$%&'&( #4$

(7;1$,0-$5$,-#&'#">$(&(#%('&3$-"#&(?#4$-$1$@"(# 0-@&'&( 1"<&'#;$1>$3&(#"(3&(#$-0-$#$3'4,13;$ 6&@$(4$-$1$@"(#$J#-"%# -50"-"D #4$.,365$(#&'"'

,(3$-)A FD D D D

#$ #

! ( @&$< #4$ "%#' #4$ %"'$ "(3 -,1$? #4$ "00$11"(#'4"@$(#5"3$,#"%"'$'"'#%1"&5 -E -3 0$('&($#% %%-3&(61:?;#4#4$"00$"1'"-$3&'5&''$3 ":*? + ":*? + ":*? + ":*? + >"(%4"(