High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1385/2015dismissed

Balbir Singh v. Mahesh Inder Singh And Other

2019-12-18Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

%% &"' $$ ("

!! "# "

$ % &&&&& " ) !"

!"'#$ $$ ("

$"* +# " ,"

% - ./ $" 0'"# 1 - /2.3 $" 0'"# 21 ' & # 4$"* 5$ 6$+* $ " 7'"%'"

, 6$+ ' ) $ % #" %,"

# ) '!

#""* , #" %,"

#""*

"# !" '0* "' "'* "#") 0%" 8 $ $"* $"

#""

6$+* 8 '0 /

# ) !$ ! # !" #" %," # * '

8 8 :' "#$ $ % '"$"0"* 0' ! '

:' " * " %"0 ;' ""# ""# %'

% 8"

8" % * $""

% $ % +

%" 0%'" +$$ ; #$* . & # +$"

< 0 # ! + 0% %%" !0 % " "#" ! + %%"

5$""

" ,+ %" *

!"", $"

%" 0 %" # 0 # 0% %%"

" %%" "#"

( 5$ =0% -*

#'" # , &;)

#$* 0$ 0%'" ! ! + 0% %%"

'" #'" ! ! ;' ,) '") ! + 0% %%" ,'

"'" 0' "%

"% 0' 0* $,8"* "% #8

>$ 0 %%" !+* %) $"

,) "

( " ,+ %" *

0 +,

# " +$ "#"# " ./ $" ' - +

"%"# $0 # #" %,"

8 #" %,"

/3/

# ) !" '!

#""* 6$+* ,$" 8" $ ! + 0% %%" #" %,"

:' 0'"# 1 - ./ $" 0'"# 1

"# % * %%" !" '!

#""* "#" #" %,"

0 %"'" 0 ,) 0%" 8 0$ 1'0"

0$ ,""

@#"

% 5$+'"

'"$"

0 +, $"# *

" 0' ! " #

8 $" + "! %

; % # $""

>$ "' 0 % * 8 :' ='" =8 @'#

!# %' * %%" ," 0* # '* "# 8"' %" 0") !; $0 %%

%," ' )

% + "* 0 A 0) ' " "8 " "

"# )

!# % A "

-' *

0% $" 0 $"# 6"0") =%"8 #"' '" 8 %0 + 4* 8"

:'")*

" '0

' %)!

!+ $ $) , 0# -% !' $" %"%"

% 0' !+ $ % 0% ') 0' "# "

*3 *2

$ 0' ""

0" "8" " % 0%'# # 8 '0* ,' ) $"'#$ ,'

,$0 %% '$"B -'

'# "0# "* %") 0

( ," 0 " 8"' # !;* # :' ' ) "

-' 0 ' ! 6"0") =%"8 #"' '" 8 %0 + 4* '0

( ,)*

% %) 0' !+ % 0) !+* ""

"#' "B 0' %)# 0% ') "#" '0

"0 !+ %"'# ' =" ' !+

' !" 6," < :* $""* ,"# ,"

; % -

0"* " % "8 0

( %" ," 0 3* 0 '% % '0 :' ' ) "! # !$ %" $""* 0 %" "#" !" '!

#""*

0" " %

"8"* ,$ %")# 0

% # %"* ,# ' "0 >$$"

" " %") "C

>$$"

;' %") "C

>$$"

%% ' %" 'C

>$$"

$ ' %" 'C

( '%%" * $0 %%" 6> ! -0# 0%'" 6> $""

( "!' * -0 ;

1'0"

>* $$ ("

> * 0$ > $""*

( $"

$"# "#'0* " ='" =8 @'#

8 * 6$+* '

* '

"' # '* 0 ""

* 8 ;'#0 "

D # ##"8* !"'#$ %% !"

" @'#* 6$+* ,$ 8 ;'#0 "

3* 0 %%

# * $ ++ "

$ ='"* ,) # %" #' "

%% * ,$$ #8 ."% ."%

$8 %' %%" $"'#$ ' "

( $8 $" " ' %" ! ## $"'#$ ""

8") '* 0) 0 $" ,$ %%" $#$ ) 0%"!! '8#

, 8"* !"", '0

" ,+ %" *

#* "8 0) 5$ =0% -

%" 0%'" +$$

5$'#$* "# $0* #'" ! ! + 0% %%" %%" , "#"

!$ * #'" # , &;) #$* 0$ 0%'" ! ! + 0% %%" !' " $# %%" $#$ ) 0%"!!

D" * ,$) # , &;) #$* 0$ 0%'" $' # ! + 0% %%" ,$ $ ' 0' $0 8

D'"$"0" '0 "! "#' "

,""

" !# $" "#"

( 8") ' ! 8 "! ,' %") "' ## #'" "#"

,$' 0+# " 8 ") "#"

#" %,"

#""* %'! "8 # $"# ') ,' "#"

'0 ,$' -' %%"# !" $0 0# -' '0

5$'* ! 0# 8")!)* "! '0* # ,* '!

#""

,$ $ ## # ) 8 ) '0 0+ )

0 ' 8 8 # ! + 0% %%"* "") %%" "#" ,""

!' 8 0 8"# %"' +, ! + 0% %%" %%" 0'

(

) " $ $' $8 ! ," ' + -' %" "% # ! + 0% %%" %%" , "#"

,""

! + %

"# $0* "'" 0'

!' ,$' !# ) "%

5$ ! 8! * "$"* 0 ' $ ! %"%## $ ;' ,"## ' #" %," ,$ $

# "'* 0"%" $# 8") "' '" $) %"8 + "0

" ) 8 # )% # ,$' !"## '#$ # 8# 8 ! $ $ + ),$"

0%'# %," ! $" 0 ' # 8 '0 ' ' 0

=' %% """ ;'#0

!"## $%" &''' ()&**&* ,$" !"8 %") "

, !-* 8" " $ ", $0

"# " ' %% * $$ ("

%%" , !-

0 ""* $""* 8" " $' ", $0

<,8"* ( ) 0" $

$ # # ) 8 ) '0 #"' "'* 0"%"

( $0 %"8 $ #* ,$$ $ 0"! )

< 0 %* 0" ) " %%" ='" " -0

( )* ' '% $, '0 # * '

< $ $"# '* $""* ;'#0 0'$ $ % %%

$* " ' "% """ ;'#0 "

! +,-. &''/(0)

(12)345 # ;'# $ ='" ,$" !"8 "0 #"0 !, %" "' '0* ='" + " 8 %'"%

< '"$"

""" '$") $ "

2! "!

.56&7(0) ( )0&5 <0$ 6"$ <#$ ='"* ,$" !"8 %"

,* $8) !'" %" '% %" 0%'## " $, $0 "

"'' $" %"'0% '0 8 )

' %"8 ,' %" ,$ 8 "!' %"'0%

$0 $ ! ; % %"%")* "' * 8 %% $ !0# $""

# ; ,"

< + %" % ,) %"

='" ! , %"%"

) ' , # % $8 "'" '"" # " " %"0 ;' %")

( )* " ='" $ '

8" $ ' %%"

$8# 7" %," ,$$ $8# ! $ %," ) "#$ "

" + ' !"# %" " ) !"" , ' !"##

;'#0 % ='" ! , ";# 0 * , "* '"

) # ) "

"0)

'! :' , "

%% ' ,$' 0" 0 "# )

)

#+,

- $