High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5079/2013dismissed

Food Corporation Of India And ORS v. M/S Churhia Mal Rati Ram Commission Agent

2015-07-16Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal2 pages

!"#$% &'()) $#

*+,-

$. ( &/0/'12

,1 3 4, 4 % 0 '.1 ,%."#$"%5(6&$. % ,%"7 . #5(6&$. %.8 $)) ##$'.0 $9 08 /'($# 8 ( '($'.0$% :

% .8/0&"%./7)"!'/'!.8 9"(!7 '.

$'(( &% .8 # $%' (#; %$)) ##$. &"%.5;8 % :<.8$. .8 .%/$# &"%. ;$0 % 6 %0 ( $'( .8 0"/. /# ( :< .8 % 0)'( '.=)#$/'./

% % &6 %<5;$0( &% (

%/ #<5.8 $&.05$6$/#$:# '% &%(5$% .8$..8 % 0)'( '.= )#$/'./

&$%%/ 0'8/0 :"0/' 00 &77/00/'$! '. "%/'!.8 ) %/(

%7 > ?. ?5(%)%$./' '(/$)"%&8$0 (;8 $.

.8%"!88/78 )$<7 '.;$07$( ; 6 %5$0"7

> @=;$0 ;/.88 #(8 0"/.;$0 /# ( %% &6 %< 5 5 @=/'&#"(/'!/'. % 0.

.8 % /' 2 @= 8 &'. './'0"!8..: %$/0 (:<# $%' (&"'0 # %.8 $)) ##$'.0;$0.8$.;8 '.8 ;8 $.)"%&8$0 (.8%"!8.8 % 0)'( '.= )#$/'./

;$0#/ . ($'(; /!8 ($. 8$%$7A$'.$5.8 % ;$008%.$!

; /!8.8 % &6 %<;$07$( %7.8 :/##0 .8 $)) ##$'.0'.8$.

$&&"'..;$0.8 % 0)'0/:/#/.< .8 % 0)'( '..8$6 '0"% (&%% &.

; /!8. . %8 $%/'!# $%' (&"'0 # %.8 $)) ##$'.05('. /'( $'<% $0'./'. % % /'.8 9"(!7 '.$'(( &% .8 # $%' (#; % MANOJ KUMAR 2015.08.04 09:18 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document

$)) ##$. &"%..8$0: ':0 %6 (/'.8 /7)"!' (9"(!7 '..8$. 52

:$!0 ;8 $. ; /!8/'! A/#!%$70 $&8 ; % )"%&8$0 ( :< .8 $)) ##$'.0

> @=; % ( ("&. ( %7.8 :/##0 .8 $)) ##$'.0'

$&&"'. $## ! ( 08%.$! ;8 $. )/' .8$. / .8 % ;$0 $'< 08%.$! ;8 $.'.8 :$0/0 ; /!87 '.!.(' :<.8 $)) ##$'.0 $ . %#/ ./'!.8 0$7 %7%$/',$%A .$.$ 8$%$7A$'.$5".0/( .8 7$'(/$% $5.8 % 0)'0/:/#/.<;$0'. .8 &77/00/'$! '.5% % '& ;$0 7$( . "# *>- .8 "'9$:!%/&"#."%$#%("& ,$%A .0 ' %$#*"# 0-5 8/0"# )%6/( 0. 0.; /!87 '."). B .8 :$!0$..8 0/. ; /!87 '.$'(/ '; /!87 './08 #($..8 0/. 5.8 )%("& 08$##: ( 7 (.8$6 : '&%% &.#<; /!8 ("# *- .8 $ % 0$/("# 0)%6/( 0.8$.. 0.; /!87 '.8$0.: &'("&. (/'.8 )% 0 '& :.8 .8 )$%./ 0 ' .8 &$0 /' 8$'(5 "'(/0)". (#<5 .8 ; /!87 '.;$0'.!. (' :<.8 $)) ##$'.0/'%$/',$%A .5%$.8 %5 ".0/( $. ') 8$%$7A$'.$ . ;$0 '. /' .8 )% 0 '&

% )% 0 '.$./6 0 .8 % 0)'( '.8"!85$0) %.8 #/0.5.8 ; /!87 '. ;$0(' '(/

% '.($. 0$'(/'&$0 .8 $)) ##$'.08$( "'(/'/./$##< .8$..8 % ;$007 08%.$! /'.8 ; /!8. .8 :$!5.8 <&"#(6 %<; ## &$%%<".; /!87 './'%$/',$%A .'.8 ' C.&&$0/'$'(/'.8 )% 0 '& % )% 0 '.$./6 0 .8 % 0)'( '. /' &7)#/$'& .8 )%6/0/'0 .8 "# 08 <&"#('.: ) %7/.. (.( ("&..8 $7"'.

%7.8 :/##0 .8 % 0)'( '.#$. %')% )$%/'!.8 /%;'0.$. 7 '. 08;/'!08%.$! /'. %70 .8 ; /!87 '.!.&'("&. (:<.8 7$.$

8$%$7A$'.$ ".0/( .8 %$/' ,$%A . 8 /'(/'!0 % &%( ( :< .8 # $%' (#; %$)) ##$. &"%.&$''.: 0$/(.: ) %6 %0 0":0.$'./$# D" 0./' #$; $%/0 0 8 $)) $# /05 $&&%(/'!#<5(/07/00 ('0 D" '.#<5.8 $&&7)$'</'!$))#/&$./'0$% $#0(/07/00 ( *$9 08 /'($#- "(!

2 7A MANOJ KUMAR 2015.08.04 09:18 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document