← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1821/2018dismissed

Sarva Haryana Gramin Bank v. Rajpal Sangwan

2019-04-11Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh6 pages

      

!" "#$%$&' (

) * +,  +- & + .$& &/ * 0" 1

$#"02! / 33"44 &!

5"+%6%  73 4*$&82* &89 & "%3&1"&!

':

 *;*0 * :

 *0    

       

    

;*0 * !" #  $     %   &'() *+ (+*,-. 

&&  & . &0 12 '3 4       

.5 - '

&.  .& &3&&

 (7 +8 (+*9  : &  .;& &   <    5      ;



$#"+%  &1  .34-""%  *"+,$#"  "864 !$&%0 

 &&"<6+"=0

  &&            ' .      -<     .& 8=9(' & .

- ' - -3  :  ' .   & 8= -  -  - &   .& &  8= 3 >(? $%#$34$& +-  3+#""1$&8%  !"+  +"!$+"."&!   &

$#"++".34-""92$%6&1"+%6%3"&%$&& #2 +8"

.$%#&16#!  &1  92  !! $&%  !2"  8"  %63"+ &&6 !$&0 %2 44  @"  1""."1  !  @"  $&  %"+,$#"  ","&  !"+ !2"  8"  

%63"+ &&6 !$& +!2"%3"#$ $#36+3%" #&!$&6 !$& &1 #&#46%$& !2"1$%#$34$& +-3+#""1$&8 &1$%%6" $& 4 +1"+%!2"+"&

2"

$#"++".34-""92$%6&1"+%6%3"&%$&%2 44 &!@""4$8$@4" + &-%6@%$%!"&#" 449 &#" +!2"3"+$1 @"-&1!2"1 !" %63"+ &&6 !$&

A  2"  

$#"+  +  ".34-""  8 $&%!  92.  1$%#$34$& +- 3+#""1$&82 %@""&$&$!$ !"1%2 44#" %"!@"$&%"+,$#"& !2"1 !" %63"+ &&6 !$&@6!!2"1$%#$34$& +-3+#""1$&8 %2 44#&!$&6" %$ 2"9 %$&%"+,$#"6&!$4!2"3+#""1$&8% +"#&#461"1 &1 $& 4+1"+$%3 %%"1$&+"%3"#!!2"+"

(  2"  

$#"+  +  ".34-""  8 $&%!  92.  1$%#$34$& +- 3+#""1$&8%2 %@""&$&$!$ !"1%2 44&!+"#"$," &-3 - &1B+ 449 &#"% !"+!2"1 !" %63"+ &&6 !$& &1 4% &!@""&!$!4"1 +!2"3 -."&! +"!$+"."&!@"&"

$!%!$44!2"

3+#""1$&8$%#.34"!"1 &1 $& 4+1"+$%3 %%"1!2"+"& "<#"3!  2$%  9&  #&!+$@6!$&  !  &!+$@6!+-  +,$1"&!

A 6&1  <34 & !$&'  +  !2"  36+3%"%    !2$%  +"864 !$&0  !2"

&+. 4+"!$+"."&!@"&"

$!%%6#2 %"&# %2."&! 3+$,$4"8"

4" ," &1+ !6$!-. -@"9$!22"41!$44!2"#.34"!$&

!2"1$%#$34$& +-3+#""1$&8 &13 %%$&8 $& 4+1"+@- !2".3"!"&!6!2+$!- &1!2"+"4" %" @"&"

$!%%2 44@"

%3"+!2" $& 4+1"+ !2".3"!"&!6!2+$!-C  & &

' . -'        .  &          &    &  

  &.  & -  ..       '-  &'     :                -    -' '

> & 8=5  33- &'& . >

  ' .3-< ? >  & 8=  &''' 

 &' '<&.' '  .& & ? .

 & 9(  3 >D + !6$!- &

$#"++".34-""%2 44@""4$8$@4"

+3 -."&! 8+ !6$!-"$!2"+ %3"+!2"3+,$%$&% !2"

 -."&! + !6$!-#!0)D A) )D + %3"+%6@ +"864 !$& 092$#2","+$%2$82"+

,"+-

$#"++".34-""%2 44@""4$8$@4" +8+ !6$!-

( &0

+"!$+"."&!0

@1" !20

#1$% @4"."&!+"&1"+$&82$.6& $! + 6+!2"+%"+,$#" % #"+!$ $"1@- ."1$# 4

$#"+ 33+,"1@-!2" &/0+

1  +"%$8& !$&  !"+ #.34"!$&8    -" +%    #&!$&66% %"+,$#"0+

"!"+.$& !$& %"+,$#"$& &-!2"+9 -"<#"3!@-9 -

36&$%2."&! !"+#.34"!$&  -" +% %"+,$#"'

+,$1"1!2 !$&+"%3"#!  &".34-""!2"+"%2 44@"&

+ "$!6+" 8+ !6$!- +1$%.$%% 4& ##6&! .$%#&16#!

"<#"3!$&# %"%92"+"%6#2.$%#&16#!# 6%"% $& &#$ 44%% !!2"@ &/ &1$&!2 !# %"!!2 !"<!"&!&4-

A  2"  .6&!    8+ !6$!-  3 - @4"  !  &  

$#"+  + ".34-""%2 44@"&".&!2%3 - +","+-#.34"!"1-" + %"+,$#"+3 +!!2"+" $&"<#"%% %$<.&!2%%6@7"#!! . <$.6. ?.&!2:%3 -'

+,$1"1!2 !92"+" &

$#"++".34-""2 %#.34"!"1 .+"!2 &A -" +% %"+,$#"02"%2 44@""4$8$@4"@-9 -

8+ !6$!- + & 11$!$& 4 .6&! !!2"+ !" &"2 4  .&!2:%3 - +" #2#.34"!"1-" + %"+,$#"@"-&1A

-" +%'

+,$1"1 6+!2"+!2 !$&+"%3"#!  &

$#"+!2"8+ !6$!-$% 3 - @4"@ %"1&!2"4 %!3 -1+ 9&'

+,$1"1 4%!2 !$&+"%3"#!  &".34-""3 - +!2"

36+3%"% # 4#64 !$& !2"8+ !6$!-%2 44@"!2" ,"+ 8"

!2"@ %$#3 - 

E01" +&"%% 449 &#" &1%3"#$ 4 449 &#" &1

$#$ !$&8 449 &#"3 - @4"16+$&8!2"

.&!2%3+"#"1$&81" !201$% @$4$!-0+"!$+"."&!0+"%$8& !$& +!"+.$& !$& %"+,$#"0 %!2"# %". -@"C  &

?     & .-'>'      -<> .

&   ' .

& 9( -  .  ' .

  $-' .

- &--.& .

9(@

@@' .@-   

&  .

 . ' .

3   &. 

   ? & '

   - - $'-   ' .

 .

   & .

 

&  '<-. -  - --. *8*1

   ? 5  .- ' ' -@

@ - .& 9( & & ..

' .-  A   -  

- ' .

.'    & .

B& - ' .; 3 & .&& .-

=  C &&    &. &  &.    -< "  &. &     -<' - &  . ' "- &  .

' & .     .& ? -  .  '. <-.  && 3 3-< & .3 & 012 '

$   ' & .'

;*  *

    ** +8 (+*7 



 A<&D EDF A-  EDF