← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1826/2018dismissed

Prabhu Nath v. Presiding Officer And ORS

2021-11-03Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih,Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil10 pages

  

    

 

 

  





 "#

    $$$$$ "%%

% 

#  % #  

% $$$$$%  %  

 & $ % %   %$

 & $ % %   $

 

        %   

#  '()       



!

"

#  $% &'

$&() !

 *#+ # , !  #

-

#    



       !



  .



    ! #   # "

#  $%+ $&() !

 *#+ # !



   (&&&&./ %&&&&./ !          #     01 



    / 

                   !

/ #     

    

 # !

 *#+ # 3 ! 4    *$/  *(&5(6567  8 (9'5   (9'6

 $:!$&(95;

/(6  / 

  (&&&&./ 

 !4 !

#4<= %$'$&(>         # $%+ $&() !    

                   

 

 /4 

: ., '

(>    $

('



   / !         !# #

! /    

! ?

('



  

 #   ##

!    #/ @   7  !



        #       (9$&./                  7  

        #   

        #          &$ &$      (9$& 

 

!     # @     *$>/A(9' "



  / 4           !              (9'#  

  *(&5 656(9'7  !

  5 B!

B6  = %&>9 ?&= !$&&                       <

  

#     / 



 

   



   

    

 



                           

!"

  !

     #             

  

 #  + $&(&C #!  

 

 





 

  $ %!

      !           

        

&

     

     



$ '!          

  

     

 (

  

 $ )! * 

 !; <<(

       

    2;

<$       2;

<?    

2;

< # 

 /($ /$& ;

//!#  # #



: ., ' (>!

/4

    ' (>$

('

'

7        ?

('    #@   -

  !



 -    "

     

!

               #         

   

  ! 

            

   !   (9'   

   *$>/A$>/ $>/-(9'

  <

  #      $9&

        4 

5* #:6(9%  ! 7  !

     /4   ;

  * 

+ 2#  </(  

2;

/? ;

// # 

  ! =  ! # # (>

('





 

 !!

(&:!$&($     ! 8

  ! # / 4 ,   / # ?

('

   ! 8

     ()$

 /4     !

     $

('     #      /4        

   /4   

 

   



  ! =     !

 #@   

)

#    7  ! # 



 ! =      /4             #     

   <

 !!    !

            #   ;

// ;

* D

5 </(6 

 ! =     ' (> $

('    ! 8

 /4 

 #     </(  B

 ! 8

#   

 ! =   

   /4

-  ! =   /4      

  

   # : <

 $9&

 

  # #  ?

 (' !

  # <



     ' (%$

('  ! !!

* D

5 </(6 !

    <

      #@     *$>/A$>/

$>/-(9' <

!

   (&&&&./!  9>

  ! 

 #  ! 0%1 

   #

  <

 4 <= %$'$&(>

#  ! / 

 $:!$&(9  #

 #    (&&&&    # #    !

/ # #  @  ! /4      !!

 <

  

 4  

=    !      <

 #  

: .,  #/ 

     !

   4 ,   #       ()$ 

 !      #  ?

('

/4  !"

          ?& = !  $&&      !

  <

!!

 ($  #  ?

(' # / 

 # 

!  #    -  !

   

    

#  

(&&&&./!

 $:!$&(9   $%+ $&() !

  *#+ #

     <

     #  #/ "!  

       !

  #  !

     !         !  



<

    

 "

   

!

-B!;4       >&&&&  (&&&&&./

(   <

  #  $% + $&()    !

  #/     !

 #     

@  !  #  

    # $%+ $&()   

! *#+ #  #  #/ "!      !

 #     <

     !         !     



  4      #     #        

#



!

     

    !  !      !

    # #         /        @    !  !       *# + #

 3    #   # $% + $&()    @   !

 # #  @  ! 7   <

  



$'  # $&&   #   ?

(' 

   ($   

<

   !!" #  

   #4 



    ! 

/ 

             

        !#

 #      #($  :@ 

!

  *#+ #  %&&&&./-B!4     -B!  ;  4                !  "

 #            !     *$>/A(9'

    

 !

            #       #        #     7 

   

 $  $   

7 

  ($  

/   

 $'

&) $&&   &?

&> ('

   / 

       !#  #      #($

    



7 

 

  

 !"# $%&'C-B!;4  #  !   !         <

       ##  #@    

  !

"

 #

 4   .  #         # 7  E(   % )  *)  %+ +  ,

+

-./ 01 *  2

3!

# $$ 4"5- <

  ! 4  (? 

*     

# &$  &?

  ! 4 

   !

 #  -#  4          

     !

   !   4     /

    "   "     2    *  = #  * 3

!-B!;4   !    !  *$>/A $>/(9'/  

!

 ;   #      "

 7  !

 ! 4  -# 4  # #  /   !



# :     -B!;4   6 +./78 0*  /

!# $$993-  /  ! !"

  #   <

# #   #    $9&

        "

   @  

!

 *#+ #  %&&&&./!#    !   ( (( $&(>   81.

&3:

"   ;

 701  /<::+- =

%2

>+ 7>82 $ -  

;

7      

#     @                 

                    !   ! ?&&&&./     7 

   &$  &$  !#   ! %&&&&./

 !          7 

       01 

   

 4        !

      *#  + #     $% &'

$&()     # !#    #       4#    #    4    /   



  #     *$>56(9'       "

 @



   0 ?&&&&./



!

 *#+ # "

 

  !

4  "

   -        # $% + $&() !

 *#+ #  3     

%   

%   %

 

   "#  



  +

 ,+

  ,+