High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/514/2013dismissed

Manjit Kaur v. Sub Divisional Officer, Sirhind And ANR

2015-09-11Mr. Justice Amit Rawal3 pages

!"##$%&%'(#)"#*+#,- !'.%"/!0, ))#11!'"

2#,&0& 0+%3%&%'!1 %$#,-%,4%'5!'!1#)!,"*#'" !'"4#, #&)'5#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& 64#"4#, #),"#,&1$!1)!)#,&*!7+#!118#5"&##"4#.059*#'": +#,##,,#5""4# #),"#,&,'":

64#"4#,"4#.059*#'"&4015+#,#),"#5%'"4#%9#&":

,#&#'"( ,*%"4!'"-53$!"#- ,"4#!))#11!'"& , !.#&4#4"!-551 0'.!+- ,"4#"!"# ;;;;; *)+%,' %3%1%&$& <=> <<>

,"4#,#!&'&*#'"%'#5%'"4#!))1%$!"%'&-84%$4!,#5017 &0)),"#5+7!%5!3%"-"4#5#1!75!7&%'%1%'9!'5?5!7&%',#>%1%'9 "4#!))#!1%&$'5'#5 ))1%$!"%'&&"!'55%&)&#5

#901!,#$'5))#!1

4#!))#11!'">)1!%'"%%&%'"4# #901!,#$'5))#!1!9!%'&"

"4#$'$0,,#'"%'5%'9&+"4"4#0,"&+#18-84#,#+7"4#&0%", )#,*!'#'"%'.0'$"%',#&",!%'%'9"4#5##'5!'"&,*,#$3#,%'9-,#!1%@%'9 ,$11#$"%'9"4#!*0'"-!11#9#5"+#"4#,#'","4#,#1#3!'")#,%5-!'5

!&8#11!&$4!11#'9#""4#,5#,5!"#5?AA)!&&#5+7"4#>$0*> 11#$",- )!, !'5 ,5#, 5!"#5 ?= )!&&#5 +7 "4# #)0"7 **%&&%'#,#B#,$%&%'9"4#)8#,&"4#**%&&%'#,0'5#,"4# 0'.!+

0+1%$ ,#*%&#&!'53%$"%' #'" #$3#,7$"-?= ,&4,"C?=

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

4!3#.0,%&5%$"%'"#'"#,"!%'!'5",7"4#$'",3#,&7#0,"4#,&0+*%"& "4!"84#,#"4#,5#,4!&+##')!&&#58%"40".0,%&5%$"%'!'5%&#,,'#0& '"4#!$#%"-"4#%3%10,"80154!3#.0,%&5%$"%'-#3#'%"4#,#%&!' !1"#,'!"%3#,#*#57!3!%1!+1# , !.#&4#4"!-1#!,'#555%"%'!153$!"##'#,!1- 0'.!+ !))#!,%'9 ' +#4!1 "4# "!"# &0+*%"& "4!" "4# 0,"& +#18 4!3# #B#,$%&#5"4#.0,%&5%$"%'3#&"#5%'"4#*%'!$,,#$")#,&)#$"%3#4#,#%&

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

023 '(-.&