← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1469/2015dismissed

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd v. Varinder Gupta

2016-01-15Mr. Justice S.C. Datta9 pages

  

        

  !"#$% & &'( )*   + 

 

      

         

  

"$) ",-./$*01 /$*//12 &.3.

 

  

  

 !

"!#$ %& '&%&  

     

     

 !

   

   

"  #      %& %' %((  

 ) *)

+



"

  ,  

      ( %- %(.

 



 )



"

  ,

"   /  0

 

 "   

  

     

 "   1 "    "            2 !%.'&-,# *2 &3'!%,#    2 !'%!-,# 

  - ( %%!

(% % %%'+ 



#   ( 5

      







  0 6 7 



 8 / 6

      

 "    "   



 9

    2 (%%%%%%,#    " : -';;.3  ; %& %%!

      "  

 ,

     

 "    <   ; ( %%! "  0    

     



   /92 " : .!

 - ( %%!  = .'; !-% 9 



  = = &



    " 0  2 &3'!%,# =

  

 



      "

    - ( %%!

 

 



   

 

  

     " 2 &3'!%,#    " 0 

      ; ( %%!   

'

2 -%.;-,# 

2 ''%%%-,#       ,"   =  





         %- %. %%.

   1  

 0  

0     % (( %%.

%. (( %%.



   

2 '(;((,#     

0 

 

   2 &3'!%,#        (; ( %%.

 "    

 >    

   0   "$



  

 ?

  "

    

#?

 <

   

  

, 6 @

    2 '(;((,# "     , 6 @

  

 (3   "     

(.

  "      



     2   

    , =  2

0

 0 , @   A   

  

" 1  

" 

 

    " 0   

< "  

       # ! "## #      $  %&'()*+

, -).(%&+    /   %(&*%+    #  / -*!--&&%  !&&--&&(0  # $     #      1 - "## #         2 !-3 

4 

  #

 1 % "## #  #

 /  15 ' "## #  # 

    15 ( "## #  #  

   #  

 15 ) "## #

  6 6 /  / 15 7 8

              %& %' %((

     



"    

     ( %- %((   



    A  

"

   " 1     (%      # 0 "## 6# #   64 #$  /   /  # $  6

#     #

/ :    6# #   64  $  6  6   1 0 "## #   # ;

 6  / 

/ #  64 #$    

 

-).(%&+ 4#  #

  #  4   # /   (!7!!+1 A        "

 "  

     "

 "  " $   A     B" =

  ( )*"+ , - .*  !/ *0 -%1 +2, , #   %%% .

! # ))1*2,.* !/ *0 -%2, ,*# 

/% 3'  , 5

,/ ,  / *0 -% 2, , * .* * 2! ! !!*2, ,*# %%

  

 

  = 

   "  

 " 0    

       " "  

         C

 "    

   



 D 

      # !!  $ #

#    # $

6/

 / 6 #      #  #    #  $4 # #       64 #  #  #  

 #      #

#    $  # 

 # $  4# # # 6 

  $  #  6 #  

"! ;   #    6  #$ <    #  #          =# >   

       6  #    6  

  6 #  =#  6  #

 <    # ?  

# #

   # / / 

6/ # / 4# #  /  /  # 

          64 #   =#

 4  6 #  /

 # / $    #       / #

 $   

 # 

 # 4 /#   # 

/   

#$

  #   #  # 6 $  #   @?5%   #      # #  / / # 

/  

 #    (!7!!+  4# /< # 

/  

#  #   # 

/    /  # 

/  

 #   /  # 

/  4 # #   $ /  #    /

6/ 4  6   #  # #  4 6   :>  # 

/  #   6    

 #   #

   #  $4 #  $4  # /    #  

  $ =#



/  / 6

  #  / #  6 $  #  6





  # 4

6?  /

?#6  

/  $    / #  #

6 $   4 =#

 4 #    #  /   4  # 4   $  #   

 #/  # 4

6? 

 #

      $   #

 =# 6  $  #

6 4## 6 #   

#

/ 

# $     

  6 4    #  6

 #

 $ 4    #    

?/ =#

  #

/ # 

$  ? # 6  #

/  

 #

 =#       6

6

 #  4  # / 4# # 4    # /     # 4     6    #      =#   4 4  4   6   #   B     $ / #    $4  #   4     

  # /       6   $ #  4

;

 #

/ 5"! 

 6    4

 #

 #      #     / 

?/  #  #

/ 6 6  / 

?/  6   6  <           #  #  #  

  

/   #  #  6  4#     /

6    $   #   

#  4

  #  #

 6   #   /$ # 

?/   # 4

#4 # # #  4# #  6  /   

/ # $  #   #  #  /   #  #   #  !- =#   #    #  # 6 # #  #  6  

  

/  #   #  # 

4

 6

  # 6  # / 4# # 4 / $6  #/ 6  #

         / 4#

6/

 / 6    #  / 6

 5"!  #



?/ #

   / #  # B  

/ 4 # $ 6 # 

  #

  77-&&' $   !(7-&&' # /   # 



#  #  #  

 

  

/ # /  #

   #

  # / 6  #

  #  #  4#  # # B  

/ 4 

  -!!-&&' #  /   

/  

/  (!7!!&&   < #  

6/ #     / $

#  < 6$ /  =# 69    6

  

# 4 #  # /

  #$   4#  # $ 6 4

  #  /

 $  $     4  6 4 # 6 B   # 6  4# # #      # 6  5  #  

  5"! # 

/ #4

         /  # /   6 

  #  $     

  6 4    #    #  6  # #   #

  6  4#  

6  ;     #

 #   #   #  

   $  #  #   #  $  -).7%&+   

$   4# # /  #       #  #   )3  / #  

   #   D 

   6# 

 $

  #    

 

   $   #      # 8        "       "

  

       E     

         "  

 "     



   A  

     "

 "      "

 # 

#



 

9      "

 "            "

 "

: 1 

 # " 1    $   :  

" 

  

*   + 

4 5 &6768 0

*