High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1470/2015dismissed

Bachan Dass v. Bawa Singh

2018-10-05Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa3 pages

!"#!$%&%"'())* $+'&& ,,!--'

.!/&0& 1%'2+ !&,"'3!'

/!&!' (

/)&+%&+ 01-435"$ !#"/

/)+!!/6 +6'435"$ !#"/ +!,,!--' ) &0% #%-!389 +!,-%' %##1%'2+#"//!$"5!/9"#' :"0' "# &)*;4< "1/3&,/%'$%,-&-&"%' !/!& $":,"'!' 1& 3!$/!!389 +!/%-"0/ %'+%&#5"0/"'))) %5%-,,!- ,/!#!//!3893!#!'3' $+'&&+&8!!'3%&:%&&!35%3!6032!:!' 3 !3=)),&&!389-!/'!333% %"'-%& /%$ 032!40/3&,0/)

!&0- ' -94 3!#!'3' ,,!--' $+' && %& %' &!$"'3 ,,!-8!#"/! +%&"0/ ) /%!# #$ & "# +! $&! /! + +! &0% #"/ /!$"5!/9 1& %'& % 0 !3"' +!,-!3%'2& + &0:"# &)>4<1&30!#/": +!

3!#!'3' ,/!&!' ,,!--'

"'$$"0' "#'"0 & '3%'2-"':"0' & -&" "1/3&8-'$!"#,9:!' "#?% 9$"--!$ %"')0% +38!!'#%-!3"' +!& /!'2 + "#' 2/!!:!' 3 !3 );) %)!)& !3 " +5! 8!!' !@!$0 !389 +!3!#!'3' ,/!&!' ,,!--'

%'#5"0/"# +!,-%' %## /!&,"'3!' ) "0'&!-/!,/!&!' %'2 +!,,!--' +&5!+!:!' -9/20!3 + +!&0% #%-!389 +!,-%' %##/!&,"'3!' "02+ '" "8!3!$/!!3&% 1& "1/3&"0 & '3%'2?% 9$"--!$ %"''31+%$+%&% &!-#%'#0/ +!/'$!"#' %--!2-$"' /$ <$ %5% 9) 0/ +!/0/2!3 + +!,-%' %##</!&,"'3!' +3'"

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

& /!'2 +"#'2/!!:!' 3 !3);)%)!) & !3 "+5!8!!'!@!$0 !389 +!3!#!'3' ,,!--' +!/!%'%'#5"0/"# +!,-%' %##/!&,"'3!' '3 +!/!89 $B'"1-!32%'2 +!:"0' 30!) $"'$0//!' #%'3%'2"##$ +&8!!'/!$"/3!389 +!$"0/ &8!-"11% + /!2/3 "30!!@!$0 %"'"# +!2/!!:!' 3 !3);)@) '31+%$+ 1&30-9,/"5!3%'$$"/3'$!1% +-1)0$+#%'3%'2+&8!!'/!$"/3!3 0,"'30!,,/!$% %"'"#!5%3!'$!) -%' %##/!&,"'3!' +3!@:%'!3 C -%'2+'3 C+%/'6%D-41+"1!/! +! !& %'21% '!&&!&)5!'

C'B 64$/%8!"# +!2/!!:!' +38!!'30-9!@:%'!3'31+" +33!,"&!3%'#5"0/"# +!!@!$0 %"'"# +!2/!!:!' 3 !3);)) :9-&"8!'" %$!3 + +!3!#!'3' ,,!--' "' +!"'! +'3+33!'%!3 +!!@!$0 %"'"# +!2/!!:!' 80 30/%'2 +!$"0/&!"# $/"&&!@:%' %"'+33:% !3&/!2/3&##%@ %"'"#+%&&%2' 0/!&"' +!&:!5!/93"$0:!' )#% 1& +!& '3"# +!3!#!'3' ,,!--' +

= +!2/!!:!' +&8!!'&! 0,8919"##/03"/&/!&0- "#$"'&,%/$9 +!"'0&1&0,"'+%: "+5!30-9,/"5!3&0$+& '3),,!--' 3%3'" 3%&$+/2!&0$+"'0&) +!$"0/ &8!-"1+5! B!'5%!1 + +!%' !/!& $-%:!389 +!,-%' %##/!&,"'3!' EF,!/''0:"' +!,/%'$%,-:"0' 1& +%2+-9!@22!/ !3'3&&0$+4+5!2/' !3 +!%' !/!& E>F,!/''0: #/": +!3 !"##%-%'2"# +!&0% %--$ 0-/!-%G %"')5!'&/!2/3& %' !/!& $":,"'!' '"%' !/#!/!'$!1"0-38!1//' !3) +!/!%&'":!/% %' +!,,!-'3 +!&:!%&4$$"/3%'2-94 3%&:%&&!3)

-0$B9 C+! +!/&,!B%'2</!&"'!3( !&<"

C+! +!/ !,"/ 8-!( !&<"