High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1488/2015dismissed

Rajnish Kumar Mutneja v. Mohali Club

2019-10-17Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!"#$%#

&&'' (%# )!!'*'#+

& ,%

% (-.*!#!/- %!&&''

0%!%&

2%'3/!%!&' ! "#$%# /4 3%5%.%!6'/% 7''+ 8/ % 9%:&#% ! +%#4! # 4 )! !' *'#+ !%% %%% ;*'#+; .4'%!%%<

&+3 '#+'!$$+%!&!&'''4'/#'' -4!&%-'=#%' #/!=3 ->#%4!!&'?!.4 %%$%3 #%4!%%! $$+%!&!&'%$

&%!-%! &'/!$$+%

@ '#+ % ' -%' 3% !-4 >#% ' $$+%!&+%40 , /%&34#$ / A?! -!'#+!$!0-$+%/ =. '% ! #4 # </ A/ '4 =!!/ ! $$+%!&=#'+''?!&'&!$#- %&0 <B< 0'?!4=!'#+9+%#%3/ +''&&%C$'3

A=%4!$% !%- 3+3!$?%>#!&'! $#=+!#?=!!&'=! '#+!$! +%/ /!=#%&%!! $$+%!&!+''#&3$! &%-##A+''?!!%>#!%%! $$+%!& =!%= ! $&#4 %% <

''4!$$+%!&+# 9'444%-/! &'+%#4!!#!*-'*#%

44/!&&%' =%$4!#4!!&' '. '# ' ! # $%/ ! %-%!%!&'4!!&' !&'#++''%4#'%'3

</!#4 #=% / A!%4%%$= #!$? < /!#4#=% /B

A% =!!!%'3==!%=/!%% /!

B #=% /<

A%=!!=#!$?

/!#4#=% / A%!%/ !%'3==!%=?

/!#4# =% B/

A!%'3==!%=?$'%'3

/!#4#=% / A%=!!!% '3=4=!%=

!#4# =%

/ A%=!!%$=#!$?

!#4#=%

/B BA%=!! %$!$$+%!&=#!$%$4! &3$#=! 3/!$$+%!&=#' +''+#/!=3!&'!+#' #'%&3!#4+''%4#'%'3$/ &%%#'%4#'!'#+?!$$+%!& !&'=''

%&3$#?

!!$$+%!&&'=''&%%#'!'#+ % ''=4 # &%#%? ! ! &' = &%- $'4%#%$&%'

!=4 !&'-%$.&3$#4+'' %%-4!%$! #4!!% %!&'/!&%3%$'!#

)!&'!'%&'!=%$ %-%4 ! ''4 ! =% $ =!% %%4!-%$!&'

&'4 ! &%/ ''=4 # =% %$

8!!%!&''!%''% &%3%D ,,

8!!%!&''!%'$%3 #&%3%D ,,

8!!%!&'!'#'!&% #D ,

8!!%!#!&''+'+$! 4%#'3'!D ,

8!!%!#!&'+%%+3'$D ,

< '

E%%&%-!/!&'4!$ %%,8 !!%!/!!C$ *& "

!%$8

%!%4'%#'%!&%/!%' *#%#0 B4!&'/#0

-#%! #''3/#!&'= $ )! = - #4$ %

9'444%-+3! #4$%/! &'!'&&'!*#%%7#4/ 04%/!'/=!!=4'%7#4/

04% !'/=!- #4$%

$!$%$4! #4$%&+3! %'*#%

'''4=!! #4$% &+3!*#%+'=/!&'!..!% !*#%+3=3'4%4#'%&&'&%34!! $+&/%#''3!$&#4 #4$% &+3!*#%+'=+#!&'+ % 0!&&'=#%& 5=-%/ !%=%&%+!'%&A

E!-!%'%#'%!&&''+ 44!%#4!!%%E!!%$%! &&'

)! &' +''3 44%- +3 %% <

&+3@'#+''4!$$+%!& !'#+/=!%!#='+3!$ < B % $%!3%$! F%%' !6$ /<B/'$+'%!%3%%$! =!!%4!#%%# )!#!-4+' +3&%!%3%'%'3$+%% B!6$/<B'=!2% 6$&%-4!-%3##/&&'&%%%/

< &&' $ % ! &%%+ &% !'' + $ '!#4!'$!+#&

E $3 + $ !% ! ! &' ! &&%!%*#$%9%#$/!'%%%'! 4%- !% +# = ###' 5 ! 4 *$$'+##'# 5=!&%& +3!$&%#4!$%+%%*#$%9%#$/ !'*$$+C'#%$!&% '$ #% ! 6$ +# ! 9% &&''*#%!%!&'$4! '#!4%#=$#C'#!&% )! %'-#&%0 B! #4$ &+3!9%&&''*#%/!'+4%&%# #%

$% & " "

' () *+* ) , )

)

' $

)

*++/

*+ !

01 %

!" #

$%&

( )* !

! %

2 &

+& ,,&,

/'(+& & !

3 ) " * !$% "

'(+&)*/ !

! !

E$3'4%$=!!9%&&''*#% !%4% 0%!%C'##!&%%$! &%'$4%4+!6$ !&' )!#='%'3+%%+3$= %4!'3$+3!%'*#% G-!%=/$%' !&'#'&#3''4'3%%$3=!! $&#4%%''4!$$+%!&/$#!! !+&34%%%!+''%4#'%'3=!% #'% 5'%4#'%:!&3$&+4# -%'4-&&%# )!%%/%$! %#'*'#+!$$+%!&=''

0#+'>#'=%!&&'

)!%%/E3$%!&%&&' 3 % #%+ ! '4'/ -' ='' % #4$&+3!*#%+'=

)!&&'$%4'3

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#