← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2908/2016allowed

M/S Sun Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd v. Ashish Vij And ORS

2024-01-08Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal12 pages

     

 



 

   

 !"# $%& ' ( ('

)* $+ #,- -$%& ( (.

/  0   0 ( ((1122)%* 3! 4  3 

(

(( 1$%#%* 

/  0   0 ( ((1122)%* 3! 4  3 

(

(( 1$%#%*  &

5 0 (  0 60 



  

 

   

0 607 

!)2 

   

      

       #

$

       #  &  

  

(

 

"

)  #  ' ! *    

 



  #   

$

   " 

!

   "

!    "

 



    "



    + ,!   

 !*

  '-

     " 

   .   /    123 

 



     + , "

 !-

/   





   

!   *  

    

5!)"

6!



119   



     :

  $88

; !   '< !



$88(  8 8 $88(

= .    ">    

 ! ? 0 ' >  .





   "   

 

 

    !! "#$! $  %  ! &  ""

"

 ! '"(")! ! !  *

(

    

+!  %$  !   !%!

     !

   ! % ! "

"(!%! & , - & ./

 &  ! 0   

"

-   !

 ! 



  !!      "

!   0  1 0 !"* @

 $88( *  "



" !

? 0 ' > *    / 

 

2  $88( *  

= *  "

"

 "

 )

=       ? 0 ' > .

    

$,( "

/    $88(  2  $88(      "> "  ? 0 ' >

$4  $88( * 



     "

 . 

.

 "  

$ 8 $884   * 5 $88888,      

%      8$  $88(    

   

   $88( 

2 A) 2

/  .      8 8 $88( 

= *  "

 )

= *   !

 ? 7!# ' >    

$,( "

=  

   ) 

 !

  7!# ' 

/   

"

   "

*   

% *



    2  $88(

   

 

     "

/      $4  $88(

/     

   



"

   .

 8( $882

=   .



  

.#

% 8@ $882 A) 8 *  "



A)   8@ $882

  ; <   

=    !

 #  



" 

  

)    

$889 ;A) (<     "> "

$ 8 $884  "

 * 5 $88888,     

  

   *  

   " 

     "

4

;  < 8 $884

   

  

 

 !    

  *  !  



 "



  ;<

B ' 



 !

 

 

# 

 

     

 ! "##"$%&'()'



    



  #     '      

  "

     ;< 

 #    

&      # 

   "

"

 "

*  !  

   $C 

!  

 "     

8

% B    

  

!    !.

 !

  

*  



    

  

#    !

@  "

      

$4  $88(   !

= !



    !

 2

 5   1@(

$

    

!



!# 

  

 

 $ $88( !# 

  "> 

 ? 7!# ' > !   .



= !



     





      $4  $88(

=   # 

 * %   ++  ! ',,-$%&'.'-  /+  0 

 %  1 ! ',,2$%&"#)3 

  

 !

- ,4 -$% )%# $%,24 -$%& (

     

 ! '     +   

D 



  A)  =5  "

!  '     .

 "



/ "

     

  "



 

/  

D 

  $4 $41 

3 )





 (8 

   /  A   93$ '  ! "

    

 )



/ "

 *   



    "

  "

  

)   ,

"

 

5

 

  )   

/

   

* 

    "

  ! 

2

/ 





 "



= !



$88(     > 

8 8 $88(

    8 8 $88(

*   "

      8 8 $88(  >

    

  

 $ $88(

   "> 



= 

 

!# > 

  "> "

/      ! ? 0 ' >  .



*     !     

% ! '  



   

9 "

 $ $88(

/     

  >



4

%

    "









  "

!



  "

      $ '  /

/

 

"

 

 !  "



/     



!



 "

@

   



D 

 "

  )   "

!  



8 8 $88(

/ 

     



   

%  

   



%  "

  



 "

  

3

B '    !

D 

    "      



  " 

  

 "

) 



7"



 " 

       

 



/



1       *



 



 

/   

     "



   

 

9

% B      

  !#

1

% "

 # 

 4 $ &

%  

  "

 !     $$@ '  /









5 "

       "  " !

 *

    "

   

 D"

5  

  ;D5 <   #

 !     

&      # 

+5  ! ',3,$%&'2#

 

 # 

!  

  

 "

 !

   "

% 



   " 

          "

 

    ( '  /

$8

  

    # 

 

++4  $ &

 

 # 

 #

8   )

 2

 5   1@(

 "



  "

        

   

   "

=  #

 !    

$

) #     



 /+   4  $ &

% #



  "

'      

  

   "

$$

/ "

  &  E B

 

 1 %  + 6 *

 !$',.(&'%% )#,  )  /    123  !    " 

   !     !  

   



"

  # 

 

/

 

 # "

 

)    

   

  

/ 

 /    123

/

  !  

    

   ( '  /



 "

!"



!  "

  

$(

% #  "



78   %   %

 /0$',.3&"%%-2 9%

!$',,.&''%%).'

/ +  1 %

!$"#'2&'2%%"'3

/   

  "

  

 "



     

 "

         

 ! 

 2

 5   1@(

"

:     !$"##)&( %%'."     

"

 )   

 14 $ &

    "  

   "

   

    

!  

$2

 *  

"

 >

8 8 $88(

!   "



    !    

/    ! '  

!



!#     

$4

/   

  !#



 

$   !

'*" *  $



 



   

$@

% 

"  

    "





      "!  "  

D 

  

D 

   "

"

5 (29888,

=      

   1C $ $88(

 " 

$3

 !  !   

$9

 

   

"  

)%4)!8 *97 .

0 60

  +!!0%,  -,/ +!! -,/