High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1523/2015dismissed

Harvinder Singh And ANR v. Punjab Coop Agriculture Development Bank And ANR

2018-05-16Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*+ !,-&($#,&(./!($!("/#, 00#11!("'

2#,'3'

/#3(4!5 0.,&%31"3,##-#106#("!(7 5/!,8!($ !("/#, #'0($#("'

) 9: ;

: ,#'#(")< ,!($##0!'34!8$-%!"#8

,!00#11!("' (# ,,#'0($#("' =/#"/#,"/##0,"#,' 1%!1(#>'0!0#,6!?5#!11>#$" '##"/#43$.6#("@ 5#,# #,,#$""/##0,"#,,(" =/#"/#,"/#43$.6#("'/31$5#,#0,"#$&("/#$&.#'"@ << << ;

603.(#$&(0,#'#(",#.31!,'#%($!00#!1&'43$.6#("!($ $#%,## $!"#$ 8 0!''#$ 5? 1#!,(#$ $$&"&(!1 &'",&%" 3$.#8 !A&17!8!

&,6&(.43$.6#("!($$#%,##$!"#$80!''#$5?1#!,(#$

&-&13$.# 3(&, &-&'&( 85/!,8-&$#>/&%/'3&" 01!&("&

' , ,#($&"&( !%%3("'!($0#,6!(#("&(43(%"&(>!'$&'6&''#$ /#'/," !%"'>/&%/!,#,#B3&,#$"5#("&%# ,$&'0'!1

!00#!1!,#"/!"#/!1&(./8 !"/#, 01!&("&

!($ !"/#,&(1!>

5"!&(#$!1!( ,6$# #($!("<5!(78(!6#1?83(4!5 0 .,&%31"3,!1#-#106#("!(7 85/!,">!'%1!&6#$"/!"

',#0!&$1!(!63(">&"/&("#,#'" ,6"&6#""&6#8!'6#("&(#$&( 01!&("!($0!&$'88 <(C8'8 <(CCC8' D8 <(*8'C8 <(D8'8 <(

<< CCD !' 311 !($ &(!1 '#""1#6#(" !%%3(" !1(.>&"/ '35'&$?

'8D8C <(+CCD!($("/&(.&'3"'"!($&(. 1!&("&

' !11 >&"/&("/#!65&" =!&-#,%/#6#!((3(%#$5? -#,(6#(" ($&!!($ 3(4!5 -#,(6#("/3'8(,#%-#,?%31$5##

#%"#$ ,6"/#6/3'8 !%%3("' 01!&("&

'!,#,#B3&,#$"5#,#($&"&(#$11"/#5!(7!%%3("' 01!&("&

'!,#>&"/$# #($!("'>8$# #($!("'/!-#"/,#!"#(#$"/#6" ,#%-#,!63(" ,6"/#6&11#.!11?!($ ,%&51?8 ,>/&%/"/#?!,#.&(." 03""/#&,1!($(!3%"&((8!'6#("&(#$&(,#%-#,?("&%#

,'+8C8 < ,601!&("&

' (,#01?8$# #($!("5!(7"7'"!($"/!"1!(>!'5"!&(#$&( "/#?#!,CC!($#5"=!&-#,%/#6#>!'!001&%!51#(1?" "/'# 0#,'('>/5"!&(#$"/#1!(!

"#,?#!,CCD 54#%"&('>#,#!1',!&'#$ "/!"01!&("&

'!1'("&''3#$("&%#3($#,#%"&(DC 3(4!5 0 %&#"&#'%"8C*85# ,# &1&(."/#'3&"/#%&-&1'3&"&'!1'5!,,#$3($#, #%"&(+ 3(4!5 0%&#"&#'%"8C* #0'&" !63("5?

'>!' !$6&""#$853"&" >!' $#(&#$"/!" #("&,#1!(!63(" >!' $#0'&"#$">!''"!"#$"/!"$3#0,%#$3,# !,5&",!"&(>!'!$0"#$!($!

'36 ' +8C8 < >!' 3($ 3"'"!($&(. !.!&('" 01!&("&

' 30" 8!'0#,$#%&'&(!((3(%#$5?>!? !>!,$#'0&"#"/# &(!1 !>!,$801!&("&

'!,#("0!?&(."/#'#""1#$!63(" ,6"/#01#!$&(.'8 11>&(.&''3#'>#,# ,!6#$)< =/#"/#,"/#01!&("&

'!,##("&"1#$",#($&"&( !%%3("!'

0,!?#$ ,@ =/#"/#,01!&("&

'!,##("&"1#$"0#,6!(#("&(43(%"&(!'0,!?#$

,@ =/#"/#,"/#'3&"&'5!,,#$3($#,"/#3(4!5 <0#!,!"&-#%"@

<< =/#"/#,"/#'3&"&' !1'#!($ ,&-13' !($&'1&!51#"5# $&'6&''#$>&"/'0#%&!1%'"'@ #1&# ,&!1 3,">/&1#,#1?&(.30(43$.6#(" (951#30,#6#

3,"&(

8 * +8"7-&#>"/!",#6#$? ,#($&"&( !%%3("'&'("

!-!&1!51#"$# #($!("'">!' 3,"/#,/#1$"/!"$3#%3,'# 1!>/!'5##( !$0"#$/#,# ,#80#,6!(#("&(43(%"&(%!(("5#.,!("#$ /!-#/#!,$"/#1#!,(#$%3('#1 ,!00#11!("'!($/!-#!1' %('&$#,#$"/#%!'# ,#'0($#("'!($/!-#!1'#E!6&(#$1>#, 3," &1# !,!'0#,6!(#("&(43(%"&(&'%(%#,(#$8&(01!&("&"'#1 &"&'

'"!"#$ "/!" 1!($ 01!&("&

' &' 5#&(. !3%"&(#$ , !11#.#$ ,#%-#,?

'+8C8 < &"&''8$# #($!("'!,#!$0"&(.$3#%3,'# 1!>8 , >/&%/(0#,6!(#("&(43(%"&(%31$5#&''3#$ !,!',#($&"&(

!%%3("' &' %(%#,(#$8 $# #($!("<5!(7 &' %-#,#$ 3($#, "/# 3(4!5

0#,!"&-#%&#"&#'%"8C*8!($5# ,# &1&(."/#%&-&1'3&"8%601&!(%# #%"&(DC 3(4!5 0#,!"&-#%&#"&#'%"8C*8>!',#B3&,#$ ("&%#"$# #($!("5!(7&'!11#.#$"/!-#5##('#,-#$3($#,'!&$ '#%"&(/#,# ,#8%&-&1'3&"&'"/#,>&'#("6!&("!&(!51#>&"/3"("&%# 3($#,#%"&(DC 3(4!5 0#,!"&-#%&#"&#'%"8C*3,"/#,8&( "/#6!""#,'%-#,#$3($#,"/#3(4!5%&#"&#'%"8C*843,&'$&%"&(

&-&1 3,"&'5!,,#$3($#,#%"&(+ 3(4!5 0#,!"&-#%&#"&#'%"8 C*" 3,"/#,%6#'3""/!"!3%"&(0,%##$&(.'>#,#&(&"&!"#$!.!&('"

'>/&%/'/>'"/!"'6#0,%##$&(.'6&./"/!-#"!7#(01!%#/# 1#!,(#$%3('#1 ,!00#11!("'/!'&( ,6#$"/# 3,""/!""/# &-&1 3,"

>!'#E#%3"&(."/#,$#,

<< !6 "/#-&#>"/!"& &">!''801!&("&

' %31$!1>!?'

!00,!%/"/# &-&1 3,"&(#E#%3"&(0,%##$&(.'!($ &1#54#%"&('""/# #

#%""/!""/#?/!-#0!&$"/##("&,#1!(!63("/#6!""#,%31$/!-# 5##($#%&$#$5? E#%3"&(. 3," !,!'8,#($&"&( !%%3("'&'

%(%#,(#$8"/#5#(# &" ,$#,FF31#* 8C+&'%1!&6#$8>/&%/&'

,#0,$3%#$!'3($#,)< 9* #%,##&('3&" ,!%%3("5#">##(0,&(%&0!1!($!.#("< (!'3&" ,!(!%%3(" 0#%3(&!,?",!('!%"&(' 5#">##(!

0,&(%&0!1!($!(!.#("8!($&(!(?"/#,'3&"("/#,#&(5# ,# 0,-&$#$ ,8>/#,#&"&'(#%#''!,?8&(,$#,"!'%#,"!&("/# !63(" 6(#? $3#", ,6!(?0!,"?8"/!"!(!%%3("

'/31$5#"!7#(8"/# 3,"'/!1185# ,#0!''&(.&"' &(!1$#%,##8 0!''!0,#1&6&(!,?$#%,##$&,#%"&(.'3%/!%%3("'"5#"!7#(!' &""/&(7' &"9 /#6!""#,>!'#E!6&(#$5?(951#30,#6# 3," ($&!&(

+ /# 1#!,(#$ %3('#1 , !00#11!("' ,#1&#' 30( 11>&(.

5'#,-!"&(' (951#30,#6# 3," ($&!)< 9* '366!,&'#8!'3&" ,,#($&"&( !%%3("'%!(5# 6!&("!&(#$(1?& !0#,'('3&(./!'!,&./"",#%#&-#!( !%%3(" ,6$# #($!("3%/!,&./"%!(#&"/#,5# ! %,#!"#$ ,,#%.(&A#$3($#,!'"!"3"#G, 5 5!'#$("/# &$3%&!,?

,#1!"&('/&05#">##("/#0!,"&#'!'&("/#%!'# !5#(# &%&!,?

!($!",3'"##8, % %1!&6#$&(#B3&"?>/#("/#,#1!"&('/&0&' '3%/"/!",#($&"&( !%%3("'&'"/#(1?,#1&# >/&%/>&11 #(!51#"/#0#,'('##7&(.!%%3(""'!"&'

!%",&1?!''#,"/&'

1#.!1,&./"3%/!,&./""'##7!%%3("'%!(("5#%1!&6#$!' !6!""#, %(-#(&#(%#,("/#.,3($ /!,$'/&0,("/# .,3($"/!""/#0#,'('3&(.$&$("7(>"/##E!%"!63("$3#

<< "/&68!'"/!">&110#("/# 1$.!"#' ,%(-#,"&(.'#-#,!1 "?0#' 6(#?%1!&6'&("'3&"' ,!%%3("'8"!-&$0!?6#("

%3," ##!""/#"&6# &('"&"3"&(9 ".#'"'/>"/!",#($&"&( !%%3("'%!(5#%1!&6#$>/#(!

,&./"&'%,#!"#$,,#%.(&A#$3($#,!'"!"3"#,&"&'5!'#$( &$3%&!,?

,#1!"&('/&05#">##(0!,"&#'!'&(%!'# 5#(# &%&!,?,",3'"##,&'%1!&6#$ &(#B3&"?>/#(,#1!"&('/&0&''3%/"/!",#($&"&( !%%3("'&'"/#(1?

,#1&# >/&%/>&11#(!51#"/#0#,'('##7&(.!%%3(""'!"&' !%",&1?!''#,"

/&'1#.!1,&./"(0,#'#("%!'#8('"!"3",?,&./"&'.&-#(1!&("&

'%1!&6 "/#5#(# &" ,#1!"&('/&0>&"/5!(7 -#(& 8&"&' &$3%&!,?,#1!"&('/&0 5#">##(5!(7!($%3'"6#,853"#-#("/#(,#($&"&( !%%3("'&'(""/# (1?,#6#$?!-!&1!51#""/#6 1!&("&

'%31$!'!6!""#, ,&./".#"

'"!"#6#(" !%%3("' ,6"/#5!(7" &($3""/!">/#"/#,#("&,#!63("

0!&$5?"/#6&''/>(&("/#'"!"#6#(" !%%3("',("!($& !(?>,(.

!63("/!'5##(%1!&6#$ ,6"/#6!($"/#(%!(%/!11#(.#"/#'0#%& &% #(",?5# ,#!00,0,&!"# ,36"5#&(.'8'3&" ,,#($&"&( !%%3("&( 0,#'#("%!'#>!'("6!&("!&(!51#/#,#&'(&11#.!1&"?,&( &,6&"?&( %(%3,,#(" &($&(.',#%,$#$5?"> 3,"'5#1> ('#B3#("1?8"/#,#&'

( ,%#&(0,#'#(",#.31!,'#%($!00#!1!6#&'!%%,$&(.1?$&'6&''#$ &(%#6!&(%!'#/!'5##($&'6&''#$8"/#,# ,#80#($&(.!001&%!"&(8& !(?8 !1''"!($'$&'0'#$

;

*+ '47' =/#"/#,'0#!7&(. ,#!'(#$ ) #' =/#"/#,#0,"!51# ) #'