High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2970/2016dismissed

S.M. Ahuja (Deceased) Thru Lrs. Ashish Ahuja And ORS. v. Raj Rani And ORS

2018-11-26Mr. Justice Amit Rawal7 pages

!"##$%&%'()#*+#, -.

/01!& 2#$#!&#2 "/,03/4 & "/#,& 55#66!'"& 7#,&0&

!1 !'% "/#,& #&5'2#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

,#&#'"( ,,0'#/,!-2)$!"#

,!'"8!&/9!5-2)$!"#- ,"/#!55#66!'" , !:#&/!35!6-2)$!"#- ,"/#$!)#!",& ;;;;; *)+%,' <=.

,!9#,%'"/#!556%$!"%'%&,+,%'3%'3',#$,2"/#6#3!6 /#%,&!55#66!'">!"%&/80*!,/09!-?/%&&"!"#2"/!)#2%#2' ../#!556%$!"%'%&&055,"#2+9!'!%2!)%" /#!556%$!'"&*#'"%'#2%' !,!"/#!556%$!"%'!,# %*56#!2#2!&6#3!6/#%,&!55#66!'">,"/#50,5&#5,&#$0"%'3 "/%&!55#!6'69 &"!'2&2%&5&#2

55#66!'"=2##'2!'"&!&&!%6#2"/#1023*#'"!'22#$,##"/# 4?#,55#66!"#0,"-?/#,#+9?/%6#,#)#,&%'3"/#1023*#'"!'22#$,## "/#",%!6$0,"2%&*%&&%'3"/#&0%"-2#$,##2"/#&!*#

6!%'"%&&03/"*!'2!",9%'10'$"%'!6'3?%"/5#,*!'#'" %'10'$"%'!3!%'&""/#!55#66!'"=2##'2!'"&%',#&5#$"6!'2$*5,%&%'3%' 8/!&,!-8%66!>@@ >=. &%"0!"#2%'7%66!3#1,'2!-%&",%$"

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

&0+&#B0#'" &!6#2##2?#,##F#$0"#2+9"/#2##'2!'"&-'#'A .!'2!'"/#, ..!'2%'&0$/$%,$0*&"!'$#&-"/#56!%'"%&/!2!6,#!29#3,#&&!'2 %'3,#&&,*"/#*!%'&#,)%$#,!2=/#$**'5!&&!3#?!&'" '#$#&&!,9,"/#56!%'"%&,#'19*#'"!&"/#%,?'5,5#,"9/!&!$$#&& ""/#*!%'!"/0,!,!2 '"/#5,#5'2#,!'$#"/##)%2#'$#-"/#",%!6$0,",!*#2"/# 66?

# $

&! ' ( )

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

55#!,%'3'+#/!6"/# !55#66!'"=2##'2!'"& &0+*%""#2 "/!" "/# 4?#, 55#66!"# 0," /!& #,,'#0&69,#6%#205'"/#$'"#'"&"/#&!6#2##2-%#-&0+&#B0#'"&!6# 2##2F"+#%'$'"%'0!"%'&!6#2##2F /#,#?!&'&0$/ %'"#'"%' , ,#$%"!6 ?%"/ ,#3!,2 " "/# &#5!,!"# 5!&&!3# /# 4?#, 55#66!"#0,"/!&!%6#2"!55,#$%!"#"/!""/#/!+0",!&/?'%'"/#&%"# 56!'"/#2##'2!'"&?!&$'&",0$"#2!"#,"/#&!6#2##2-?/#,#!&%"?!&%' #F%&"#'$# *0$/ 5,%, " "/# &!

. $'$60&%)#695,)#2"/!""/#56!%'"%&?#,#'#%"/#,"/#6!?06?'#, ##" ?%2# 5,%)!"# 5!&&!3# ', /!2 !'9 6!?06 ,%3/" " 0&# "#, "/# #F#$0"%'"/#&!6#2##22!"#2F -"?"/#,&!6#2##2& F!'2F.?#,##F#$0"#2%'!)0,"/#56!%'"%&-%' ?/%$/%"?!&&5#$%%$!669*#'"%'#2"/!"5,5#,"9'',"/#,'&%2#?!&"/!" "/#56!%'"%&!'2"/#9/!)#',%3/""0&#"/#5!&&!3#%'B0#&"%'' &0$/$%,$0*&"!'$#&-"/##B0%"92%2'"6%#%'!)0,"/#56!%'"%& ' ,2#, " 6#'2 $,#2#'$#" "/# !,#*#'"%'#2 !,30*#'"- ,#6%!'$#/!&+##'6!%2""/#1023*#'""/#'D+6#05,#*#0,"%' / 012 03 3 455/ 02621

015,7.

.- "$'"#'2"/!"%'$!&#!5!,"9!%6&"&##:,#*)!6!' #'$,!$/*#'" " +# %' #F%&"#'$# , !6*&" .= 9#!,&- "/# 6!? !$B0%#&$#'$#?062!5569 "?!&0,"/#,5%'"#20""/!")%2#&!6#2##2&2!"#2

F A !'2. F < -"/#56!%'"%&/!2&62"/#6!'2"!6?!'" %'3/!'2!&?!'"%'3/-?/#,#-!&5#,"/#,#$%"!6-+0'2!,%#&"/#!,#! ?#,#*#'"%'#2!&(,"/(,#*!%'%'35,5#,"9*#!&0,%'3A&B9!,2& &#66#,& !'2 "/#,#!"#, %'20&",%!6 0'%" @& 0" '20&",%#&- 0"/( ,#*!%'%'35,5#,"9 2?' &#66#,!'2AH"?%2#$**'5!&&!3# /!)%'36#'3"/ "$''#$"%'3!"=5%'"""?%2#$**'5!&&!3# 6#!2%'3#6/%=!"/0,!&#,)%$#,!2-!&"( ,5#,"9+#!,%'3&0*! = @<!'2C#&"( ,5#,"9"/#,& '"/#,?,2&-%"

?!&&0+*%""#2"/!"/!2"/#,#+##'!5!&&!3#'"/#',"/#,'&%2#-%"?062 '"/!)#+##'*#'"%'#2"/!",#*!%'%'35,5#,"9A&B9!,2&/#,# ?062/!)#+##',#6#$"%'5!&&!3#!&%'2%$!"#2%'"/#&%"#56!'!'2!& ?#66!&%'"/#&!6#2##2F

8 !*!,!%2"/!""/#!,#*#'"%'#2!,30*#'"%&'"&0&"!%'!+6# !&,"/#!2102%$!"%'"/#6%&!'2,!55,#$%!"%'"/#!,30*#'", #/,!-%"?062+#%'"/#%"'#&&"/%'3&"#F",!$""/#,#6#)!'"5,"%'& "/#&!6#2##2&F 2!"#2-F2!"#2A .!'2F 2!"#2 ..-?/%$/,#!2"/0&(= ,-

./* -

)*"(0"00012- )* "00012 &"- 3

4 1-*)

- 5

/// /// /// 7

!82980 !

;-8 &

; .

3 9*%2<1$4 = ..>4) ?4& @; 8 )

*&!

' !

! *

'*0*A'* /// /// //// -

./* -

)*"(0"00012- )* "

&"- 3

4 1-*)

- 5

/// /// /// 7

!898 -

; -8 31 !

& ; .

00#*

*&!

! *

*%*AA(+ /// /// /// -

./* -

)*""00012- )*$"0012

8 - 3

4 " B /// /// /// 98-

;-8 31

& ; .

! !

31 !

& ;8) *+

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

?563 >4CD

*) 2

*+ /#5!,"%#&*!9"#66!6%#+0""/#2$0*#'"&!6?!9&,#6#$""/# ",0"/"%&!$6!&&%$!6$!&#?/#,#"/#2##'2!'"&!"#,/!)%'35,)%2#2! 5!&&!3#,!%&#2"/#//!+0",!'"/#&%2#"/#56!%'"%&/?'!&84 &0+&#B0#'" " "/#&!6#?/%$//!2 $!0&#2/%'2,!'$#!'2 "/#%'10'$"%'

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

,30*#'" "/# 6#!,'#2 $0'&#6 , "/# !55#66!'"= 2##'2!'"%&'"!+6#"+,%'3"/#$!&#?%"/%'"/#,#!6*5#,)#,&%"9",* !2%#,#'"5%'%'"/!'"/#'#!,,%)#2!"3,0'2,%'"#,#,#'$#%& *!2# 0"- *0$/ 6#&& %')6)#*#'" !'9 &0+&"!'"%!6 B0#&"%' 6!?

#&06"!'"69-"/#!55#!6%&2%&*%&&#2 96:,7 *)+%

651 '(;<& +1015=2 >5

?5>

+101 0:!

?5>