High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1607/2015allowed

Mukesh v. Baldev Singh

2025-09-04Mr. Justice Virinder Aggarwal10 pages

!"# $% &'&

() $* !$%$+%,-%).&'&

/ 0 1 &

2 31

! " #

! " # 2 31

$ %

&#

"

'" ()$(*($)

+" ,! , ''! -

.

/ -

' "$0(1*($0

,2,+3!

#

! #" # "

### ! - "4 ## '"! -

#5 6$0(7!- -#

!

% !+", ''%

!

89. +:! ( )

5 6$0$*$0$(! 5 )

5 6$0(1! %$!)6

5 6$0$*! $+)6

5 6$0(; # *$ < *($$! #

""

#

##:

- -

! "8 /+:

%

##" "! " ()$**($$ # ""

=

0$4

2*0:=$*:3#5 6$0(7

""# 8 :/4

!

### # 6"# -

#!-

4

" " - ""

" = %

## # " "= !#

-- " / ,! !

)

' " !

## #

!- " -

-

+",!, ''! '" ;

'"

/!

&# #

6"#-

!-

" < "

" # # #

>

" #"

! -

# - 5' ? !"

#

")$# 5' / "!$7$1 "$((/5/#" " '# / "#

!#

-

' "# ! "

"

# $

%

"& $

- - #'!4# -4 # @" #

" # "

.

/

<

/#

" "

# - 4 /"

! / " -

"""- -! # - =- 1$ . ! +", "" ! #"!

##

#

- ! "-""- " "

." / %

+", # "A "

"

, 1* ! " #=

" "

""

#"#

'

!- " -<-# #"

! ## +",!, ''!- /4

!

- '"# ,! ! @" #

##"

# #"

+",% +",! "

= ""

"

#

!

" # ""

!

! "#

$% & '( (

#

')

"' ( ')# ')

*( " ')

+

)#

,

)

,

(

-*" # #

&

# ) ( ')

./0-

')

"'

,,%1

( "# ./ %23./%&

,%1

#4

5 "

' #

./%3./%2&

#

4

5

$%

6)

7

5"

/ '

0'

8 -," 52

"9 $5

"

.

$ (

5

":$2

" $22

" (

02

0

# .

$0

"9 $0

"

$

":$

" $ 0

" (

5

"

506

0 #

./ %0 ;# (

" -* '

"#

5

#

2

2

&"

/

/

-*& (

# '

')

)

&

(

'(

( <( # '( (

" !

') ') #

(

= +

')

)(

%

-*#

./%0" (

(

##

/ )

-

'

#

'

# ) $$ @" #

/

### =" #5 6$0(7% A"

" "#8 :

" " -5 6$0(7$0(;!

#5 6$0(7 " #

29=5$3- A29=5)3 8 /+:

'"

9=5)% #! ,""

###

# 8 /+:- #

##:

$$$ % "# ," "

" # !B C!-=- $$* @" # 9=5D-

" +",!

E BC!- "" "!-=!

## " # C!- #BC: " % " 29=5D3 ##" "! "#"

-

"" $$0 ?# " ,:'"# " % : *((7*($$- =# ##" # ""##"

"<-

% !- ##"# /!"

"#"

!- " #"

# ""# ##"

$$) ?# " , "# " #9=5D # "" "! ##" #

85"":#" F -"#5 6$0$*!

#5 6$0$)!5"" -

5 6$0(1% #" -#""

4

! ##" #"#5 6$0(7 "

=

0$4 2*0:=$*:3

""

G/ ""# -

$$;

<-# - !

#5 6$0(;$0(D! "- ##"

#% / ," " ##" =""

!##" "- "

="?-! ##" "#"

" #5 6$0(7

## ""

0$ 4 8 /+: ""

&# $$D <# "

! C!

# " " " ##" #

% +" ,

### ## ,! " " - A!

"

##:"

$* <# ""# " #

## "

#

!

## #

" " "!- " -

-/4

!-

29= ;3-

"#

=

## % +",!

- "#! $*# ' &#-"

" #

&

##! "#"

8 /+:

9= ; $*$ ?-! #"

- # """- 9= ;!-"""

% "#"

"

# /+: -

"

!

+" , # " # /+:9= ;!- " -"

-

#

$** . !

" ##" !B C!- "" "29=5D3!5 6 $0(;!- " -

&#<" """!

# ""

# "" 0$4 #5 6$0(7

##% " "

""

#

##- 5 6$0(7-#"

0$4 E " #:

!

#- # #

##: <-

###" #

6$0(7-

!

- " "" <"

BC =

6$0(; - ""

#

6$0(; < """! #

6$0(7" "" ""

"" #

6$0(7 "

6$0(; $*0

""

! " -

"

,2,+3% +" , # - #

" 29=5D3! 29=5D3- """- -!""

""

"

, $0 <-"

## " ##" - "" "!

, - " "-" % # #"

+" ,

""

!

#

&#

-! '"

+",!, ''!

$0$

""

#' !

"""

" -

<="# - *0 #B)$# /5/! /# " ##"

"

##"

"" #

!- "

&#! " #

##""

" $0* % ,

"

##-""

F /""- %'# " !# " - "

##

% # , 2,+3! ! "# $00 % ,"

" ##" ""# "#5 6$0(7!-

##! 5 6 $0(;! -

&#

4

= ##" - - "" " $) " " "! "

"23!# ! #

2 31 .&'&

(+!("

$!$) Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No