High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28753/2019dismissed

Karambir Singh And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli13 pages

CWP No. 28753-2019 1

!!"#$#%& '()*#(+#%,-%.% -!( / ! # #%!($ 0!($1$ + !(2%%. -!($ / !$3%.!% $

(!$!% &4 5$#62((7.6" !( 5( -18!$987.6" !7( -!3! # #%!($ 5( %:1( 5# 87 ..8 .6" ! !%!(87 (2% 9# - 5(+1(*-5,7$$#$ % .6" !!%!(8(2%%. 5$'1$-8.!!3'1(5%"-%.7.6" !7 ( -!(!$3%.!% $ ;-! (!$#. 3(!$!%"! #$ *!#%, (!"(.!. -(1,- 6#.! "%!(!%"#%, $#%"! -! 3("!!.#%,$(!*!#%,"%.1" !.#%6#( 181( < -!"% (6!($2#%686!.#% -!) !( -%.(!686!$(1%. -! 338#"*#8# 2 +!" #% =;< #,- #( )3!%$ #% %. (%$3(!%"2 #% >%. "?1#$# #%7 !-*#8# #% %. !$! 8!)!% " 7

% -!" $ -!"$!9-!(!#% -!9(.1%.!($!" #%

-! >%."?1#$# #%" =9$%%1%"!.%

#!)(! -%#6! 2!($3(#( -!"))!%"!)!% -!"

=%.$ "% !%.!.*2 -!3! # #%!($7 -!3$$!$$#% -!8%.#%?1!$ #%#$% :!%*2 -!+ !-!)1% ")3!%$ #%-$*!!%(!"!#6!.*2 -! 3! # #%!($-!(!(!7%82,(1%.*$!.%9-#"- -!83$#%,"?1#$# #% 3("!!.#%,$ -$ *!!% "8#)!. #$ #%" #% % -! 3( -! + ! :! 3-2$#"83$$!$$#% -!8%.#%?1!$ #%

CWP No. 28753-2019 2 -! "% (6!($2 "(33!. 13 (1%. #% !(3(! #% +!" #% =;< "

9$ 31 (!$ *2 -! %$ # 1 #% !%"- -! %@*8!+13(!)!1( %.##%"$!

-!(!*282#%,.9%3(#%"#38!$ (.!"8(#%, -!"?1#$# #%.!!)!. -6!*!!%83$!.1%.!($!" #%=;< "

-! 3!A 1( -$ .#$"1$$!. #% .! #8 88 -! $3!" $ %!"!$$(2 %. (!8!6% ( #% !(3(! #%, $!" #% =;< "

7 -9!6!(( -!31(3$!.!"#.#%, -!) !( -%.7 -!(!!(!%"! -! "%"81.#%, 3(,(3- -! B1.,)!% 918. *! $1#"! %. $)! #$ (!3(.1"!.-!(!#%*!89&4 C/ ! "

# $#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

# $#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

! +

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

CWP No. 28753-2019 3 "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

! +

7 " ) "

& # $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& # $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

2) "

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ . -!!A3$# #%).!#% -!(!$#.B1.,)!% "%*!$1))(#D!.#% -! 889#%, )%%!( ( )(! "8(# 2 % -!3(#%"#38!$ 8#. .9% *2 -! %$ # 1 #%!%"-&4

CWP No. 28753-2019 4 ;< % 88 -$! "$!$ 9-!(!#% -! "?1#$# #% 3("!$$ -. *!!% #%# # !.*1 -!9(.-$% *!!%%%1%"!.1%.!($!" #%

-!" =7% -!. !"))!%"!)!% -!"

=7 -!(! #$ % 83$! 3("!!.#%,$ %. -! $)! 9#88 "% #%1!7 -9!6!(7 9# - -! (#.!( - -! ")3!%$ #%-$ *!.! !()#%!.1%.!( -!3(6#$#%$"

88 -$!"$!$9-!(!#% -!9(.1%.!($!" #%

-!" =-$*!!%%%1%"!.3(#( "))!%"!)!% -!"

7 -!3(6#$#%$ -!"

918.-6!% *!(#%, ( 338#" #% %. -! 3("!!.#%,$ 9#88 "% #%1! #% (!$3!" -$! "$!$7 $ #7 -! " = -$ % *!!% (!3!8!. ;*< -! 9(. C(@ 1$!. #% *! 9!!% -! * - -! "% #%,!%"#!$ $!" #%=;< -!"

#$ *!(!.$-.($-. 9-#"-)!%$ - $!!:83$#%, -!"?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$ * - -!"% #%,!%"#!$)1$ *!18#88!.5!%#%, -!(!*27 - # -! 3$$!$$#% -. *!!% :!% *1 -! ")3!%$ #% 9$ % (!"!#6!.7 -!(!918.*!%83$!+#)#8(827#")3!%$ #%-$ *!!%""!3 !.*1 -!3$$!$$#%-$% *!!% :!%7 -!(!918. *! % 83$#%, #!"

&&#$ ! 3( $ ;"< $ ( $ -! $3!" ")3!%$ #% ( -! 8%. "?1#(!. #$ "%"!(%!.7 -!%@*8!+13(!)!1( %.#-$" !,(#"882 *$!(6!. - -! !A3(!$$#% 3#. #% -! )#% 3( $!" #% =;< -! "

.!$ % #%"81.! .!3$# ")3!%$ #%#%"1( - #$(!?1#(!. *!3(6!.#$ - -! ")3!%$ #%)1% 9$ !%.!(!.9-#"--$*!!%!A38#%!.#%

CWP No. 28753-2019 5

& - -! !%.!(#%, -!)1% 918.)!% - -! )1% #$).!6#8*8! -!8%.9%!(%. - 918.*! .#$"-(,! -!*8#, #% ):! -!32)!% %.#% - !6!% $1"-3!($%"%% *!3!%8#D!.( -!.!18 #%):#%, -! 32)!% -#8!(!!((#%, $!" #% ;

<7 ;<7= -!"

=%.")3(#%, -!)9# - -!3() !(#3(6#$#%$#! $!" #% %. -!"

7 -!%@*8!3!A1( -$ "8(##!. - -! %82 "%$!?1!%"! %%432)!% ")3!%$ #%#$ ):! -!32)!% #% !(!$ $3!($!" #% = -! " = 6!% -! %@*8! +13(!)! 1( -$ 1( -!("8(##!. - %"! -!32)!% ")3!%$ #%-$*!!% !(!.E !%.!(!. 1%.!( $!" #% ;

<7 -! "?1#(#%, 1 -(# 2 "%% *!3!%8#D!.(%%432)!% $ -!)1% -$(!)#% 1%3#..1! (!1$8 ""!3 *2 -!8%.9%!("8(#2# 1( -!(7 -!%@*8!+-$1( -!(*$!(6!. - #8%.9%!( -$#8!. -!(!!(!%"!(-#,-!(")3!%$ #%-!"%% "8#) - -!9$% 3#. -!)1% ;.< -#8!(!.#%, -!3(6#$ $!" #%= -!"

*! 3( $!" #%=;< -!"

7 -!%@*8!+13(!)! 1( -$"8(##!. - #%"$!7 -!!((32)!% -$*!!% ).! *1 % .!3$# !.7 8#*#8# 2 32 )1% 8%, 9# - #% !(!$ $1*$#$ %.#% .!3$# !.()B(# 2-8.#%,$( #6!2!($()(!7")3!%$ #%1%.!( -!"

-$ *! 3#. -! 8%.9%!($ $ % -! . ! % ##" #% ( 8%. "?1#$# #% 1%.!( $!" #% = -! " = !,(.#%, -! .!3$# 7# -$*!!%"8(##!.#% -!B1.,)!% - ( -!-#,-!(")3!%$ #% 8897 -!)%!2$-18.% -6!

CWP No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

7%2#% !(#)(.!( $1*$#$ #%,#$ *!!A"81.!.9-#"-)!%$ - !(!A"81.#%, -! #% !(#)(.!(7 -!3(!4(!?1#$# !,33!(#.2!($#$% -!(!7 -!3(6#$#%$$!" #%=;<"%% *!#%6:!. ;,< -!%@*8!1( -$1( -!("8(##!. - # -!"?1#$# #% 8%.-.!(8#!(*!!%"-88!%,!.%. -!"?1#$# #%9$13-!8.7 9-#"- )!%$ -! 3("!!.#%, $ . "%"81.!.7 -! 1)*(!88 3( !" #%$!" #%=;< -!"

"%% *!#%6:! $# .!$% (!6#6!$ 8!%. #)!*((!."8#)$ ;-< % 3( 7 -! %@*8! 1( -$ ).! # "8!( - -! 3(6#$#% $!" #% =;< -! "

#$ )!% *! #%6:!.*2 -!*!%!#"#(#!$#!8%.9%!($9-9!(!(!"(.!. $ -! #)!#$$1%"!% ##" #%1%.!($!" #%= -!

CWP No. 28753-2019 7 " = %2 $1*$!?1!% 31("-$!(7 -8.!( ( -!(9#$!7"%% #%6:! -!3(6#$#%$$!" #%=;< -! "

= $ 3!( -! "$! 31 ( - *2 -! 3! # #%!($7 -!2 (! 9%!($ #% 3$$!$$#% -! 8%. ")3(#$#%, #% '-!9 E'- = EF7 51$ #8E'#88FEE=E ;

=<751$ #8E'#88

EE=E ;

4=<7=E E ;

F<7EEE ;

F<$9!88$'-!9 FE 7'- %#==%. '-$(FEE=E 7

EE=E 7=E E7EEE $# 1 !.#% -! !6!%1!$ ! -(31( 137 !-$#8 %. #$ (#" 1(1,() -! 3! # #%!($ -6! #%-!(# !. -!8%.#%?1!$ #%() -!#( -!(!+#%,- #$ -!"$! -! 3! # #%!( - -!2 -6! "%$ (1" !. -!#( -1$!$ %. !6!% (!8#,#1$ 38"!$% -!8%.#%?1!$ #%%.$)!()$3( +-#6"8%29-#"-#$ 1882.!6!83!.-!$#.8%.9$"?1#(!.*2 -!+ !(2%6#.! % ##" #%$ . !.

#$$1!. 1%.!( $!" #% = %. $!" #% F -! >%. "?1#$# #% " 7 =7 889!. *2 9(. . !.

( -!31*8#"31(3$!%)!827(.!6!83)!% %.1 #8#D #% 8%.$))!("#87%.1$ (#8(!+!" (4= 1(1,() #$ -! "$! -!3! # #%!($ - .!$3# !-6#%,"?1#(!. -!8%.#%?1!$ #%7 -! + !-$#8!. :!3$$!$$#% -!8%.%. #88. ! -!2(!#%" 18 3-2$#"83$$!$$#% -!8%.#%?1!$ #% 1( -!(# -$*!!%"% !%.!. - -! 3! # #%!($ -6! (!"!#6!. ")3!%$ #% )1% 9-#"- -!2 (! (!.2 .!3$# *": %. (! -1$7 $!!:#%, 83$#%, "?1#$# #% 3("!!.#%,$% -!,(1%.%%4 :#%,3-2$#"83$$!$$#% -!8%. #%?1!$ #%-!(!8#%"!-$8$*!!%38"!.% -!8! !(. !.

9(# !%*2.)#%#$ ( ( 3#% 1 9(.$ -!" $ - -!8%. -! 3! # #%!($ "%% *! 1 #8#D!. ( -! "?1#$# #% 31(3$! %. -!(!(!7 $)! )2 *! (!8!$!. ! -$ 38"!. (!8#%"! % -! B1.,)!%

CWP No. 28753-2019 8 . !. =

3$$!.*2 -#$1( #% $

77 7=

79-!(!#% -!#%$ % "?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$9!(!"-88!%,!.*2 -! -!(8%.9%!($!A"!3 -!3! # #%!($% -!(!$#..!"#$#%7 -#$1( !(% #"#%, -!" $ - -!8%.(9-#"- -!"?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$ 9!(!"-88!%,!."%$ # 1 !. -#":82*1#8 413(!%. - !6!% -1,- -! .#$3$$!$$#% -! 3! # #%!($ 9$ $ 2!. #% -! 2!(

7 -! + ! )"-#%!(2#8!. 3(!6!% 1%1 -(#D!."%$ (1" #%$.1(#%, -!3!%.!%"2 -!9(# 3! # #%$%.88 -!*$#")!%# #!$8#:!!8!" (#"# 279 !($133827 (.$ 9!(! !A !%.!. *2 -! 1 -(# #!$ -!)$!86!$7 -!(!(!7 :#%, 8!,8 %. !?1# *8! "%$#.!( #%$ -! .#(!" #%$ 9!(! ).! (!8!$! -! $ (1" 1(!$ -! 3! # #%!($ #% -$! 9(# 3! # #%$ () -! "?1#$# #% 3("!!.#%,$!%"!7 -!3! # #%!($-6!$1,- $#)#8((!8#!#% -!"$! -%.$9!88

!1 #%, -!"% !% #%$(#$!.*2 -!3! # #%!($75(%:1(5# 87 >. ..# #%8 .6" ! !%!(8 (2% 33!(#%, ( -! + ! (2% $1*)# $ - -! "% !% #% -! 3! # #%!($ *!#%, #% -! 3$$!$$#% -!8%.#%?1!$ #%#$.!6#.)!(# $ -!3$$!$$#% -! 8%. 9$ :!% *2 (!"(.#%, 3 D%)"- %

. !. F

%. $)! 9$ -%.!. 6!( -! *!%!#"#(2 .!3( )!% 1( -!(7 -! "% !%.$ - -!")3!%$ #%(8%.#%?1!$ #%9$.182 !%.!(!.#!7 9$).!6#8*8! -!3! # #%!($%.$)!.)# !.82$ %.$(!"!#6!. *2 -! 3! # #%!($ -!(!(!7 # #$ $1*)# !. - $#%"! %%! -! "% #%,!%"#!$)!% #%!.#%+!" #%=;< -!"

(!18#88!.$ 3$$!$$#% -!8%.$ %.$.182 :!%%. -!*8#, #% -!+ ! 32 -! ")3!%$ #% $ %.$ .#$"-(,!. 9# - -! !%.!(E32)!% ")3!%$ #%G -!3(!$!% 3! # #%)!(# $.#$)#$$8

CWP No. 28753-2019 9 F $($ -!38! -!3! # #%!($$!!:#%,3(# 29# - -!(.!(. !.

3$$!. *2 -#$ 1( #%

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

($%$ "%% *! 3!()# !. :! #)3! 1$ % (.!( 3$$!. *2 -! "1( 7 -! *!-!$ % -!( )(! .#8#,!% 3!($% +#)#8( *$!(6 #%$ 9!(! ).! *2 -! %@*8! +13(!) 1( %.##%"$! ) ! # 7$87!%"!7# -$*!!%$1*)# !. - -!"8#) -! 3! # #%!($ #$ *((!. *2 .!82 %. 8 "-!$ %. % *!%!# "% *! ,(% !. -!)*$!.% -!B1.,)!% 3$$!.#%61($1"-8%.9%!($ 9--.33("-!.

9-!(!$ -!3! # #%!(-$ ( -!#($ #)!$$#8!. -!"?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$#%

#! !( 2!($%%1%"!)!% -!9(. % (.!( $!!: 83$#%, "?1#$# #% 3("!!.#%,$ 1%.!( +!" #% =;<"

7# #$#%"1)*!% % -!3! # #%!($ $-9 - * - -! "% #%,!%"#!$ 3(!$"(#*!. #% +!" #% =;< "

(! 18#88!. #! %!# -!( -!3$$!$$#% -!8%.#$ :!%*2 -!+ !%( -!")3!%$ #% #$3#. -!8%.9%!(;$<9-#"-)!%$!6!%#%! -!"% #%,!%"#!$#$

CWP No. 28753-2019 10 18#88!.7 -!(!918.*!%83$!"?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$$(!,(.$ -! 3$$!$$#% -! 8%. #% ?1!$ #%7 -1,- -! 3! # #%!($ -6! "% !%.!. - -!2(!#%" 183-2$#"83$$!$$#% -!8%.#%?1!$ #%7-9!6!(7 -! $#. 6!()!% #$ % !%*8! #%6#!9 -!#% !(3(! #% C

@ ).! *2 -! %@*8! 3!A 1( #% %.(! !6!83)!% 1 -(# 2;+13(<9-!(!#% -!%@*8!1( -$" !,(#"882-!8. - -! 9(. 3$$!$$#% 1$!. #% -! " = -$ $)! )!%#%, $ - 3-2$#"83$$!$$#%1$!.#%+!" #%=;<"

-!% -!+ ! 6!(%)!% "?1#(!$ -!8%.%..(9$)!)(%.1) :#%,3$$!$$#% 9-#"-#% -!3(!$!% "$!#$*2(!"(.#%, 3 D%)"-%

. !. F

7 - )1% $ :#%, -!3-2$#"83$$!$$#% -!8%.%. %"! -! 3$$!$$#% #$ :!%7 -!(! #$ *$81 ! 6!$ #%, -! 8%. #% -! + !-!(! !(!6!%# -!8%.9%!((! #%$ -!3$$!$$#% -!8%.7-! #$ (!$3$$!(7%.$1"-3$$!$$#% (!$3$$!(!%1(!$(-#$*!%!# %. % *!-8 -! 9%!( #! + ! +#%"! 3$$!$$#% -$ *!!% :!% *2 (!"(.#%, 3 D%)"- %

. !. F

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

8$ ,!$ %. -1$7 $ %%! -! "% #%,!%"#!$

CWP No. 28753-2019 11 3(!$"(#*!.#%$!" #%=;<"

#$18#88!.7 -!.!!)#%,#" #% 83$#%,3(6#.!.1%.!($!" #%=;<"

"%% *!#%6:!.$ ($ -!38! -!3! # #%!($ .!3$# *": -!")3!%$ #%)1% #$ "%"!(%!.79!(!#%,(!!)!% 9# - -!"% !% #% -!>.1%$!8( -!+ ! - -!(!#$%3(6#$#%#% -!"?1#$# #%" 7 .!3$# *": -! ")3!%$ #%%.-!%"!7 -!$#.38!#$8$(!B!" !.

!$#.!$7$!!:#%,83$#%, -!"?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$1%.!(+!" #% =;< -!"

-!3! # #%!($-6!38"!.(!8#%"!% -!B1.,)!% . !. =

3$$!.*2 -#$1( #%

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

" # $ && 9-!(!#% 9-#8! (!!((#%, " !%B1.,)!% $ -!%@*8!+13(!)1( 9!% % -8. - -! (!8#! * #%!. *2 $)! 3!($%$7 *2 33("-#%, -! 1( #))!.# !82 !( -!"$!" #%-$(#$!%7"%% *! -!*$#$( -!( 3!($%$9--6!*!8 !.82#8!. -!#(3! # #%7 :! -!*!%!# !(8#!( (!8#!3(6#.!.7( -!(!$% - 7$1"-3!($%$"%% *!3!()# !. :! #)3! 1$ % (.!( 3$$!. *2 -! 1( 7 -! *!-!$ % -!( )(! .#8#,!% 3!($% 3382#%, -! ( # -! $#. B1.,)!% 3$$!. % -!

CWP No. 28753-2019 12 " 18) (#A -!#%$ % "$!!$3!"#882#% -!8#,- -!(!8#!$*!#%, $1,- 79!-6!%-!$# #% -8. - -!3(6#$#%$+!" #%=;< -!"

.!$% ,#6!(!$-"1$!" #% -!8%.9%!( ,# !$)! -#%,%)!(# $($(!,(.$ -!3("!.1(8#((!,18(# #!$6#D $$#8 -!"?1#$# #%%)!(# $6!%#$)!8%.9%!($() -!$)! "?1#$# #%3("!!.#%,$-."-88!%,!. -!"?1#$# #%3(#( %%1%"#%, -!9(.9-#"-#%882")! *!.!"#.!.#% -!2!(

7 -!3! # #%!( "%% ,# !%2 -#%, -!( -%$!!:#%,83$#%,$.)# !.82 -!3! # #% -.*!!%#8!.#%6#!9 -!.!!)#%,#" #%83$#%,3(6#.!.*2 -!"

-1$7 -#$38!*!#%,(#$!.*!#%,9# -1 %2$1*$ %"!#$8#*8! *!(!B!" !.%. -!$)!#$""(.#%,82(!B!" !.

1( -!(7 $#%"!7 -! "?1#$# #% 3("!!.#%,$ ?1 -! 8%. #% ?1!$ #% "%"81.!.92*":#% -!2!(

%.$"% !%.!.*25(%:1(5# 87 -!8%.#%?1!$ #%#$6!(2)1"-!$$!% #8 "-#!6! -!31*8#"31(3$!$ 3!( -! .!6!83)!% 38%7 # "%% *! (!8!$!. () -! "?1#$# #% 3("!!.#%,$

$$!?1!8 -!*6!.#$"1$$#%%.#%6#!989$1))(#D!.#% 3(F%.(!!6!83)!% 1 -(# 2;$13(<7$3!"##"882 !(-6#%, (!"(.!. - #% -! "$! #% -%.7 -! 3-2$#"8 3$$!$$#% -! 8%. #% ?1!$ #% -6#%, *!!% :!%7 -! *8#, #% ( 32)!% ")3!%$ #% $ %.$.#$"-(,!.%.8$"%$#.!(#%, - -!8%.#%?1!$ #%#$6!(2)1"- !$$!% #8 "-#!6! -!31*8#"31(3$!79!-6!%-!$# #% -8. - #% -! #%$ % "$!7 -! $ ! -$ 1882 .#$"-(,!. # $ *8#, #% ?1 * - -! "% #%,!%"#!$""1((#%,#%$!" #%=;<

" %.# *!#%,$7 -! 3(!$!% 3! # #%)!(# $.#$)#$$8%.-!%"!7 -!#%$ % 3! # #%#$.#$)#$$!.

CWP No. 28753-2019 13

6#%, .#$)#$$!. -! )#% 9(# 3! # #%7 88 3!%.#%, 338#" #%$7#%28$)!! -!$)! !-!9(# 3! # #%#$.#$)#$$!. + 1$?1#%2$ %.$6" !. ;

0+' < + ;

>><

(6#%.!( -! -!($3!:#%,E(!$%!. !$E -! -!((!3( *8! !$E