High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3045/2016dismissed

Anil Kumar Singhal v. Surender Kumar Singhal And ORS.

2018-05-21Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages

"#$$%&'&() "* + , (&-./0"1&(23"- 44$--"(# 5$1'/'

/1$(6$1./0"1&(23"-#3$1'

$'4(6$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

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

6$$(6"(# !"(6(&-./0"1&(23"- 4-"&(#&!#8"'"(/(1$2&'#$1$6

&10 %('#&#/#$6 8&#3 #3$ 41&0$ =<$%# 6&7$1'&&%"#&( =/'&($'' "%#&7&#&$'#3$4"1#($1'+838$1$4"1#($1'&("(#3$1&10+("0$-*+ @' $1%/1* /==$1 &--'("4/=-&%"/%#&(3$-6"##3$&('#"(%$#3&'/1# &( 04"(* $#&#&( C C,+ #3$ &10 @' ''%&"#$' 4/1%3"'$6414$1#*0$"'/1&(2,;"("-' 0"1-"'+'&#/"#$6&(#3$1$7$(/$ $'#"#$5&--"2$"3"-2"13+$3'&-"(6&'#1&%#($4"#3$=&6"0/(# 8"'4"&6=*"(;&"'&(23"-+83&%38"'%(&10$6=*#3$/1#(

C,,&0&-"1-*+"2"&("4/=-&%"/%#&(8"'3$-6%(#&2//'-"(6# #3$"1$0$(#&($6-"(6+1+"'4$1#3$16$14"''$6&(04"(* $#&#&( CC+-"(60$"'/1&(2 ;"("-' 0"1-"'8"'4/##"/%#&(+ 83$1$&(#3$&108"'6$%-"1$63&23$'#=&66$13$ @#3"/%#&(0($*+&$+ + +>@:8"'4"&6=*#3$4-"&(#&(=$3"- @'''%&"#$'=* ="(;$1 %3$B/$ "7/1&(2 $(&1 /= /62$+ (&4"# 3$ 4''$''&(#3$414$1#*8"'8&#3#"#$"(;(6&""'"#$("(#&(%$ "(;&"''&(23"-%(#1&=/#$6"'/0

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

! "

"" "

"" # $%% & " "" &#'&(() "

* +',(+ "-$%% , " "

" "

-$%% #

-$% '

-$% / .

-$% +

-$% ) 0 1

3$"44$--"(#:4-"&(#&$D"0&($6/18&#($''$'"(6=1/23#( 1$%166%/0$(#'D

#D +D E@+D E@$#%+83$1$"'#3$ 6$$(6"(#'$D"0&($6E:

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

4"1#*3$21/(6(83&%3#3$F8$144$--"#$/1#"&-$6#"441$%&"#$ &'#3$6%/0$(#"1*$7&6$(%$(1$%1683&%3417$6#3"##3$%(#1&=/#&(

++-"%'66"0/(#8"'0"6$=*"(;&"'&(23"-"(64"*0$(# + +@: 8"' "-' 4"&6 =* ($ %3$B/$+ 83&%3 8"' %(#1&=/#$6 =* 6$$(6"(#' "(6"(6"(;&"'&(23"-$B/"--*3$4"*0$(#'"-$ %('&6$1"#&( +,>+@:8"'"-'6($&(#3$'"0$0"(($1 (#3&' 1$2"16+4-"%$6(1$%166%/0$(#'D

#D +D E@D

"(6 D #3$%$1#&&%"#$'&''/$6=*#3$3"1#$1$6%%/(#"(#%$1#&*&(2#3$'"-$ %('&6$1"#&(+,>+@:+83&%3%"0$10#3$"%%/(# @' $1%/1*

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

$$%#$61$2"16&(2#3$4/1%3"'$#3$414$1#*&(#3$("0$ @' ''%&"#$' 3$%$1#&&%"#$D

&''/$6=*'38"(&&(23"-"(6D '38$6#3$%(#1&=/#&(10#3$"%%/(# @' $1%/1* /==$1 &--'

7&6$ "* 16$1D +=/##3$/1#'=$-8"=6&%"#$6&(6$%-&(&(2#21"(# #3$1$-&$"''/23#1 DE @ &'#3$%$1#&&%"#$2&7$(=*"(;&"'&(23"- 3"7&(2 %(#1&=/#$6 ++@: 1 "%B/&'&#&( -"(6 "(6 =/&-6&(2' #3$1$("#"3"-2"13+"1*"("=* @'''%&"#$'+"4"1#($1'3&4%(%$1( 3&''(+/11$(6$1./0"1&(2"-"(66"/23#$1 1#3$1$"'('=$'# ;(8(+#3$/1#'=$-8&2(1$6#3$"1$0$(#&($66%/0$(#'+#3$1$1$+ #3$1$&'"=6&%"#&("(6&--$2"-&#*"(6+#3/'+/12$6#3&'/1#1'$##&(2:"'&6$

#3$&(6&(2'/(6$1%3"--$(2$ 3"7$3$"16 #3$-$"1($6$(&1/('$- 1#3$"44$--"(#+ "441"&'$6#3$4"4$1=;"(6#3$7&$8#3"##3$1$&'(1%$"(60$1&#&( #3$'/=0&''&('#3$-$"1($6%/('$-1#3$"44$--"(#(#3$--8&(2 21/(6'):

44$--"(#:4-"&(#&3"'0&'$1"=-*"&-$6#417$#31/23 "(* 6%/0$(#"1* $7&6$(%$ 1$$11$6 "=7$ #3"# "(;& "' &(23"-8"'$7$1#3$4"1#($1#3$&10H =!

'4$110:&''/$6=* $2&'#1"1 &10'+#3$&108"'

1$2&'#$1$6( /#"#&(&'"-'&(#3$("0$ @'

''%&"#$'+=/##3$1$&'(6$'%1&4#&(#3$4"1#($1'H %!

/1&(2#3$%/1'$3$"1&(2+ 1"&('/=0&##$6#3"#1"- 4"1#&#&(&'"-'4$10&''&=-$3$61"#"(6#3$%$1#&&%"#$+D

"(6D +%"((#%0$##3$1$'%/$#3$4-"&(#&+1+ $D%$4##3$'#"#$0$(#3"1#$1$6%%/(#"(#+(#3$11$%16 3"' =$$( 417$6 ( 1$%16 "' # 38 "(6 /(6$1 83"# %&1%/0'#"(%$'+ #3$ "0/(# 3"6 =$$( 8&#361"8( 10 @' $1%/1* /==$1 &--' "(;& "' &(23"- 8"' $7$1 #3$ 4"1#($1#3$&10+(#3&(241$7$(#$63&0#416/%$#3$="(; 1$%16%('&'#&(2#3$4"1#($1'3&483$#3$1&(#&0"#&(8"' '$(#2&7&(248$1#$&#3$1#3$4"1#($1'1#1"('"%#&(#3$ =/'&($''H 6!

/#"#&( D

&' &( 4/1'/"(%$ # #3$ 6$%1$$ /(6$1 %3"--$(2$3$6$%1$$%"0$#=$4"''$6&(&7&-/&#&-$6=* @' ''%&"#$' "2"&('# 0&# &(23"-+ 83$1$&( &# 8"' "--$2$6#3"##3$4"1#&$'3"6%0410&'$6&(1$'4$%##3$'/&#

. 414$1#*1$$11$6##3$1$&("(6#3$"1$0$(#&($64-"&(#8"' '&2($6=*.&(23"-=$&(2#3$4"1#($1#3$&10H $!

0 "1;"'331&*"+1"(%3 "("2$1+83=1/23##3$ 1$%16+'#"#$6#3"##3$"%%/(#8"'4$($6=*''%&"#$' (#31/23.&(23"-"(6(&"&(23"-=$&(2 4"1#($1'#3$&10"(6&(-&$/#3$1$+7&6$D

#3$0/#"#&( 8"'$$%#$6H $!

3$1$&'(1%$&(#3$'/=0&''&( 1"&(#10"( 4&(&(#3"##3$6$$64"1#($1'3&46"#$6 C,,%('&'#&(2 /1$(6$1./0"1&(23"-'("(;&"'&(23"-"(6 (&"&(23"-6"/23#$1/1$(6$1./0"1&(23"-8"'61"#$6 ("'#"044"4$1(="%;6"#$+1+10:'38$6#3"##3$ &108"'1$2&'#$1$6( 8&#3/1$(6$1./0"1&(23"- "(6(&"&(23"-"'#3$4"1#($1'H !

1 "-- &(#$(#' "(6 4/14'$'+ #3$ "44$--"(#:4-"&(#& 0&'$1"=-*"&-$6#6&'%3"12$#3$(/'&(417&(2#3"#"(;&"' &(23"-8"'$7$14"1#($1#3$&10H 2!

16/%#&(&(%0$#"D1$#/1('38&(21$%$&4##3$ 1$(##3$41$0&'$'8/-6(#%-#3$#3$'#"#/'8($1'3&4 /1$(6$1 ./0"1 &(23"- "' &# &' '$-:'$17&(2 &(10"#&( 417&6$6##3$&(%0$#"D6$4"1#0$(#H 3!

"--#0$(# -$##$1 &( 4/1'/"(%$ # #3$ "/%#&( 41%$$6&(2'3"6=$$(416/%$6(1$%16'38&(2#3$(/0=$1 "(64"1#&%/-"1'4"1#($1'+#3/'+#3$/1#3"6(%%"'&(=/# #6$%-&($#3$1$-&$

1#3$1$"'(''#"#$6"=7$+#3$&(6&(2'"%#"(6-"8+0/%3

/ -$'' #3$"12/0$(# -$"1($6%/('$- 1#3$ "44$--"(#6 (# 8"11"(# &(#$1$1$(%$1=1&(2&(2#3$%"'$8&#3&(#3$1$"-04$17$1'&#*#10" 6&$1$(#4&(&(#3"(#3$($"11&7$6"#21/(61&(#$1$1$(%$&'0"6$ /#

$'/-#"(#-*+#3$"44$"-&'6&'0&''$6

0-/ +*,&

123 ()45'

,363278 92

:29

,363 6;"

:29