Harbans Lal Gupta v. Union Of India And ORS
!"# $#%&'&()
!*+!('!,-."!
/..#,,!("
0#*'-'
(&( ($&!!($"1#*'
/#'.($#("'
)2 3435 3 2 35
!
!
#$ $% &$%'
! * ! + + ,!
) - ./
0 1 . ,
(+
!
!
'
#$44%%4% ! 5!+ %6 %& %77%
+
-/
8!+) %796 : ; ;< (
3 %& &$$7
&
!
+ ,
! ,
!
)
!
8!+) =
>
-/
(
%& $& &$%% )
)
+
3& 3 & &$%#
!) 9 ? &$%#
0 1 . ,
+
!
,+ %# $7 &$%#
' +
!
+ !
%744&
+
) - #/
,
)
+
%3 $9 &$%3
@
#$44%%4%
-'
3/
+
+
%?44&94& -& %6/ #$44%74& -6 $3/ #$44&$4% -3 %'/ #$44&&4% -% %6/ #$44% -& $%$/
! A
+
+
1 )
#$ $# &$%9
+)
(!
%$ $3 &$%9
(
!
1 )
&
#$44%%4%
!
!
0 ) 0 )
! +
!
& 7 &$%9
A
!
!
+
) (
+ > (,!
+
( !!
,!
(+ + ) !
!
!
()
'
#$44%%4% %6 %& %77%
%3 $9 &$%3
(
(!
A
+
> ) (+ !
+
(!
.! *
-3/
)
!
! 0 ) 0 )
A
!
>
31!*$! #6&0'3"!"# &1!*
3-.*#7#-*"8
8!
31!(7-9!7!($:"1#*'0'1# 3.#%&!, &'"*&%"#6#(-#
&%#*5!"&(!,&91;!<'= >:>5 53!6!*&7-"1-1#""&!*3"*##"5#$ &#,$'5&7+!"*#:
?
!($!("1#*5
@?>:5++!'0!91!($"1#*'0'1# 7.#"#("-"1*&"<3.,#6#(-#
&%#*5!"&(!,&91;!<'
3%1#7#'54!(%1&.-*!71&*-6!,,-* &'"*&%"'!"4!(%1&.-*!7!($ "1#*'
@
@ >
?
3!*-.3&(910'3"!"# !*<!(!!($"1#*'5$#%&$#$( ?
: @
B
()
'
#$44%%4%
%6 %& %77%
) +
) )
,
+
A
?
+
( +
)
+ ("
&
!
!
! +
(
,
!
!
#$44%%4% A )
) +
)
> () 2
+
3 & &$%# +
!
!)
,!
? ' &$%#
%3 $9 &$%3
! !
!
+ 3 & &$%#
%3 $9 &$%3
! (
2
+
3 & &$%# = 4
(
+
+
,
,+
!
+
!
>
:
&
#$44%%4% )
D
!
( 0 + !
7 7 &$%6
C
=
8) 1 0 ! 0
!
( A%%*$&(9 " !+6# &( "1&' 7!""#* "1# .*%#$-*# .!*"&"&( &' *!-$-,#(" ' .#* !;!*$ "1# !($ %B-&'&"&(
&%#*1!'.!&$%7.#('!"&(""1#%='1!*#*!'.#*'1!*# "1#!+6#%7.#('!"&(1!6&(9.!&$""1#%='1!*#*+<'!&$#6#(-#
&%#*1!'!,'&(%,-$#$"1#,!($ "1#6"%7.*&'#$&(41!'*!
CC
&(4-**!1 31!*+!('!,!($;!**!(" .''#''&( !($+<7-"!"&(1#;!'7!$#!';(#*&(.''#''&(("1&';!<&"&'
*!-$;&"1"1#6#*(7#("5'"1&'*#.*"&''-+7&""#$"<- *
-*"1#*(#%#''!*<!%"&(D @
%6 $7 &$%#
1 ?3'7'% %$ #
) &$%9
!
(
) &7 %$ &$%9 -A 7/
(
,
> ) (!
&7 %$ &$%9 -A 7/
7 7 &$%6 -A %$/
(
( 0
> +
+ (
& =
+ ! +
&# $% &$%'
@ +) +
&3 $% &$%'
)
-*"1#*"1#*#'.($#("7!<+# *#'"*!&(#$ *7.*%##$&(9' -*"1#*+< &(&"&!"&(9 3- " *#6&#;
.*%##$&(9' *#9!*$&(9 "1# .!*"&"&( *$#* .!''#$ +< "1# ''&'"!(" ,,#%"*= *!$# !*;!,!5 $!"#$ ?
;1#*#+< "1# &(!, .!*"&"&( 1!' +##( 7!$# !($ 3!(!$ 1!' +##( &''-#$D
!
() )
!
(+
-3/
)
+ !
> ) !!
+!
!
&$%9 +
+ )
+ ) &$%'
+ +
)
-3/
E= #.'&"!($.!<7#(" !7-(")= " EE EE EE
EE EE EE !(<$&'.-"#!*&'#'!'""1#!..*"&(7#("
"1#!7-("*!(<.!*""1#*# *"!(<.#*'(";17 "1#'!7#*!(<.!*""1#*# &'.!<!+,#5"1#%7.#"#("
!-"1*&"< '1!,, *# #* "1# $&'.-"# " "1# $#%&'&( "1# .*&(%&.!,%&6&,%-*" *&9&(!,F-*&'$&%"&(;&"1&("1#,&7&"'
;1'#F-*&'$&%"&("1#,!($&''&"-!"#$D
) +
+
) ! !
-3/
.! *
)
A
(
! * !
!
) +
(
) + A
) )
+
+ +
+ )
+
!
(!
-3/
+
, @
A
(
+,
,
( )
(!
+
+ !
!
! * !
,
!) +
1 #$$$$4
+ + 5 "( 8) 8!
! +
) ( 1! =
43 3
@ ,!4 F4
@ ( F4