← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28652/2019dismissed

R D Sharma And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2024-12-17Mr. Justice Namit Kumar15 pages

 

    

 $ 

&   

%   ) % *  )      '      

 +  )

 (()        '      

 +  *

 (*     !

" #     '      

 + 



    #

   '      

 + 

,-./0 (

  "    '      

 + 

 1"

 2 % 

       / # / 53 1$ &3

  +   /  2 /  3 1?3

  / 9   3 1$ &3

 +  6 )   6  6 (

 

  /  +   " 3 1$

 / <  3 1$ &

 +  6 )   6 $ &3 3  (*



 

 @   3 

 

$ <  +    2 "

 + 

3  &   A  

<   &  $ $     5 5

2$  &  2 " 5 5    6 

 7      $ 

     B +   $ $ 5  <  ;

  &

 

 2

 "   +    1 & 8*

  

9  5 "3 A  "

   (  

,1:

  0 $  < &  & 

  +   

     $ &

  + + 

"

   &  1  2 ;&   "

  "

   &  $ & & 2



     + +  4 3  < < 

  2 

"

  & "  +   + +    +   "

 2  <  

&     

< +     2    2  $   =" 3 <   & A   2  ( @ 

&3  $ 2 +    +  3    +   < ++   >  = ="    +  *(8 *)    

+

 $

    

(

<

  +     + 

  $   ="     2       *   "

"

 2  2<  

 

(  <   <   $ &  < "  2

  &  1     $     $ &

   "

"  "

 +   2< <   

* 

 B $ &  + & 

 +      %    6 8   +  

  *)

* ) 

) 8 

;

 "  >= 

1 +   = 

1 "     "

     =

  )  

 1 "

 

 (

  1 "

 (

* (  

 / #  ( ?

2  @

 )

  < 



 *)

* ) 

  

(

 1 "





(  

"

(  *(

  *

 (

 1 "

 )

(  

;



 *(

* ) 

 * 

 1 "

 *

  1 "

 *

( 



 '  #     # 

  *)

* ) 

  

(

 1 "





(  



  *(

 ) 



 

 1 "

 

     1  

 

( 



* * #' 

)  *(

* ) 

* *  

 1 "

 

 (

  1 "

 (

* ( 



9 

 2 $  +   6   3 +    6  #   +   6 / 5 ;

#  

2  +  

 

(3  

)   

3 3 +& $

 "

  "     +   +

  2  

<$3  &  <  5 2  +     + + 3 

3 +    $ "   &   (

 "

  "    +    <  + 

)

< & $     + 3  +   ++ &  

 2 < <

 "  

 7     $ 

     

 *

 7 # '   $ 

         <  +   <  +



  

3 $      *

   *

3 3 <    &      &   "  &,0 B B   & 

 +    $ 2 ;& 2  +   $     

8(

 

 ,1:

 0 ) + +   2

 +  6  (  ) $ 2

 <   & 

 + +    2 ++   "    

1 &   *

 3 "

   & 

$ &  &

2

  " 

1 2      $ & &  2 &

  C &



  + 

   2    +   <

 " 2

 + 

   + 

  $   = =" 3  <$3  < " $  +     2  $ 

 ="     

< +    "

 2  3  

3  $ &   2  +     2 2 &

 

  + + 

"

1 2     &   < "

2 ;& 2  +  $  + "    

8(  

 ,1:

  0 

  3   &

  ++   &   2    &



  + 

 2  2  "   

1 &  *

  3 "

   & 

$ & & 2 5     <   &   "  & 

 +  

 "

1 2    $ &  

2

  +&  & +    ;

"



G2  + 

  

    %

  %

 ) 

%

   

   H

 

 23

%  

    * "

+

 ( ,

   -.  -/  $   @ & ;

"

  

   ,



"

 



 ## 0#/



 !

!

 



"

  ##$   " @& ;

"



  

 

,1 , 

 

 %

 #& '(&#& * 9 $   &



  +   +   &   B     + + +      <   $ $ &  2  +   & 2 &



 "

1 2

  @

 + & "

3  <

 2 $  " $  & 

 1 & < &  2  +  " 2   ?

$   :& 

+ < &   2  + $  1 & (

  

9  2 5  "    5 <  D

   $  $ & ,$   0 

3 E ,

   F  G0 

 

    <     " 2  

 "

1 &  + $   $ ?

$  $3    "

   & 

$ &

      +

 

3   " 2

 "

  &  1 &    

    

% 

4$ "

% !

    35  

 

 

  

  "



 3%         

           

    



 

 

    

 

   

  

 









           

  

 

 



   





 

   ! ""#  

  



 



 $% 



    

         

 

 





  

       





         

  

 

  

    

 

           ! ""#



   

   

          '( 

 

   ! 

 

 

  

  "



 3%         

  !         

    



 

 

  !  

 

   

  

 









     

    



 

     

 

       

 

         

*

 ! ""# 

  



 

  $% 



 



      

 

 





  

       





         

  

 

  

    

 

           ! ""#



   

   

      

 '( 

 

  

  

   '( 



 



 

  

   

 

) $*     

   

 6("



 3%  6 6    

     

  

 +  

     

  , 

 





-             

 

 , 

 



   

  



  

  

   .   

  





  '( 

 

 

  

 



  

 

& 

  

 

   

'( 

1 &

  "

 + $  

    < 

 "

1 &  +&  "

"

   &  $ &                 B :+  " $  

A 

D"

   &  $ & E

  + + 

"

1 &

 B      

 

     2  2



G2  + 

   &

%

) 

%

  

,

+0 <   4  @& ;

"

  

  ( 71 , 

"3 8 & ,;

  $ <0  2

$  2   " 

 "

 $ & & 2



   + + 

"

&

 " B   ;

"  2

< 2 

G2  +  

  * "

+

( ,8 & , +0 03 <    &   " $ 

 ;

"3   2    %  / 0      ,      . 

  

        

  

&   



  



 

  

 

 

   .

  



 





 





 

 



       

   1     . 

  

  

          

 

 

2

 



    34 +   +  5

  6 '+04 04 '

  

   

%7 

 8    

   &

 

   

  

&      

 

    







 

          ! 7   "9"  : ; "" 

     

   +  

0  



 

  



   <.

 =   4

  , 

   '

  

      >  "9    

       !" 9 "9! 

  

  4

  (

  +

     

  

 



 

!

     >  "9 '

 

   

 <.

=  4



   + (   ? 

     @  8    

    



 

   

%7 

 8 ,  ,  











  

    



     



 



   

            4 

  0 ( 



 ,   + ( 

$ A(  

 !%:%"9"

   *  (



  4

    

   +   *  @       

 



 

   

     

  @  @   4 

      

     





 (

3(

33    & 

  



 

< < ># 

 



# 

 < >< < #



 !   

  0  * (





 

   :%#%""    

      

  

      0  

     

  

 

   

     2  

      !%:%"9"



 

      





  

< >#

#   

     

  



  

< >< #      2  !B  

   

  

! 

   



 0  

  

 

     & 

     

 

  



    



   

    

#  !  

 

    

  

  



 

 



   !

!B 

  0

            

 





 <.

=    "9"9!

        

 

 .

          

   !         0  ,  , 

    +  (   



  &  2

A

 A  A 

 A  3    

  

   

          !%:%"9"  :%#%""

" 

  <.

 =   





  

 



 

 !  !"%%"9!             '

 





  



  (

    

    0 

  , ,    <.

=  



 

  A 0 (  



     +  4

    

 (

%33

 1 .

@   3

8  <

"C

$%

A'  

   

    <  <

     



     

 

  

<

 





 

      



  

 "9 "9! 

 

 

  

 

 



 

 



 



     !% :%"9":%#%""



 , , ,   + (  

 

 

     

       <

  <

 

  

 0 



     :%!

!%"C"     

  <.

 =    ,     '

  

        "9   

  



 0

  



& 

 

 

     '

   

     

  

   >   



 



   



    

  :

:          ,    2  < >      

  <

 >  <    



 



 

 

         

 

       

  

  



   

 

4

 <

 



  

     

     

 3      



      

   



  

  





  





 





 

0 

 + + (    



     

    



    

   0



      !"%%"9!      <.

 =     

   



 







  <.

 =        

       4



 + 

 4

 (

 

      '

  

    4

  (

 

   

  

 



   







  

    

 

   

 

 0      

 <.

=    

       

  

 

 



 ( 

 , 



 

 

  <.

 =    

           ,      

   !"%%"9!  





    





  



 

    

 

   

    !%:%"9"

" 

         :%#%"

""  0  

   ,  ,      +  ( 



  



   

  A !  3 

 

   9  

"

 #0:; #0<





    !

= 1 ,  >== 3

  ;.##  0.< <   %7 

 8 

  %

 %

 ,  

(

) 

% ?  

    

  





  

   



     



 



  







    

%  2

     '

   

   8 .



  

  

    

 

   

  

 "D: 

 E.



 

   

  

  

 !

 0 0

 

F

 F    

      







 

 



     

          "D:D! 

   

           . 

   

 

    

2  



   

   

  3 

 8      





   



 

     

  

 

    

 

       

    

  

      

2

 F"D: 

 F   F! 

 F 

   

 2

 F"D: 

 F   F! 

 F  + 

  

    

 

 

 

& 

  "D: 

  !

   

     

   

   



* 

       

   

 



     

D  

     

"D:D!  (   



     +

)

  

    

      

        .



 G

   

&    $   @& ;

"

  

    &

,



"  !

 



", +0

 C  " > "

 

 

, 1 , 8 & , +0 03   &   "  +   <    2;&3    %  /> * 



   

$%  0   

 

 

    

   D .% .%

D  

 

 





    

-  

  

 

     



 

 4 

   0   

 

 

 

  '  3

       

     D .%



    

  9D9  

  

 D!   

 

  &    

  

    

 

     '

 C ""!  4

   



 



  

   +

4  4

     '

 (



 4

 

   

     D . 

D   

   ? 





          

  

  

    



G

( 9 $ <

 2 $3  "

"   3 + +    2   

)  " ++ & ,03   ,0  + 

  



*  )   +5 "8  % !86

 + 2 % !86